M/S Jullundur Engg. Company v. Commissioner Of Income Tax

  

 
 

 



   !"

#$

%

""

 & !!  
! '$

%

 %

(" 

   
!
   
" 
 #$%$&'



#() *''+(,-./+'$ #'0$+11$((+&'

#"*.$) $'0*, $&*# '+&-*&23&%$( #'0$$.$&3$  )

*++
,$ 0$+%%$%%$$*%*&+11$+(3&-$# $/'*& 4  '0$
&/5$ +6/', 8 #%0#', '0$/'

9+2+*&%''0$#-$#-+'$-  

1+%%$- :;'0$
&/5$+611$((+'$#*:3&+(,5#*'%+#$&/0,5#*'%+#8 #%0#',

'0$  #*:3&+( 9  1+#'(;  +((<*&2  '0$  +11$+(    '0$  #$.$&3$  ((<*&2 %3:%'+&'*+(=3$%'*&% (+<0+.$:$$&/(+*5$-*&'0$+11$+(

>8*9 !0$'0$#*&'0$ +/'%+&-/*#/35%'+&/$% '0$/+%$,'0$ #-$#%&&$63#$%?

+&-?@+#$($2+((;%3%'+*&+:($A 8**9 !0$'0$#*&'0$ +/'%+&-/*#/35%'+&/$% '0$/+%$,'0$
&/5$+611$((+'$#*:3&+(<+%#*20'*&%3%'+*&*&2+& +--*'*& % B?8<#&2(;';1$-+%+--*'*& %3%'+*&$-*% %

B?9&+//3&' -*%/#$1+&/;

 :$'<$$&'0$%'/)%+%1$#:)% +//3&'+&-+%1$# :+&)#$/#-%A 8***9 !0$'0$#*&'0$ +/'%+&-/*#/35%'+&/$% '0$/+%$,'0$
  <+%  #*20'  *&  %3%'+*&*&2  '0$  +--*'*&  

% B?*&.*$< '0$%'+'$5$&'%2*.$&:;'0$ :+&)

*/*+(%'0+''0$%'/)%%'+'$5$&'+% 3#&*%0$-& @ 7  /&'*&3$-  '  :$  #$ ($/'$-  *&  '0$*#  +//3&'% :$*&231' D 7A 8*.9 !0$'0$#*&'0$ +/'%+&-/*#/35%'+&/$% '0$/+%$,'0$
  <+%  #*20'  *&  %3%'+*&*&2  '0$  +--*'*&  

% B?& +//3&'  -*%/#$1+&/;:$'<$$& '0$ %'/)%#$ ($/'$-*&'0$:)% +//3&'+&-+%1$#:+&) #$/#-%  %1$/*+((;  <0$&  '0$  -*%/#$1+&/;  <+%  &(;  +% #$2+#-%'0$$&'#;5+-$*&'0$$2*%'$#+&-<*'0'0$ *& *#5*';,-$ $/'#-*%/#$1+&/;+%'0$#<*%$1#$%$&'*&'0$ :)% +//3&'% '0$+%%$%%$$?+11$((+&'A 8.9 !0$'0$#*&'0$ +/'%+&-/*#/35%'+&/$% '0$/+%$,'0$
  <+%  #*20'  *&  %3%'+*&*&2  '0$  +--*'*&  

% B?,'0$%+5$:$*&25+-$<*'03'+&;:+%*% *2&#*&2  '0$  /2$&'  +&-  5+'$#*+(  $.*-$&/$  1(+/$-  & #$/#-  :;  '0$  +%%$%%$$?+11$((+&'  %0<*&2  '  '0$ /&'#+#;AE 0$&$/$%%+#; +/'%+#$'0+''0$+%%$%%$$&@

77 *($- #$'3#& #'0$+%%$%%5$&';$+# 77?7 ,-$/(+#*&2*&/5$ 
7F,D B? 3#*&2  '0$  +%%$%%5$&'  1#/$$-*&2%,  -*%/#$1+&/;    %'/)  *&  '$#5%  

=3+&'*'+'*.$+%<$((+%.+(3$#$ ($/'$-*&'0$:)% +//3&'+&- 3#&*%0$-

@ ''0$:+&) #0;1'0$/+'*&+&-1($-2$<+%&'*/$-:;'0$%%*%'+&' 55*%%*&$# 
&/5$+6*#/($ 8 9,+(+&-0+#80$#$*&+ '$#-$%/#*:$- +% '0$%%$%%*&2

*/$# 9 0</+3%$&'*/$<+%*%%3$-%'+'*&2'0+'*&'0$ :)% +//3&''0$.+(3$+%& D 7 /(%*&2%'/)*%%0<&+%
C,74, @B?,  <0$#$+%  +%  1$#    $2*%'$#  <*'0  '0$  :+&),  *'  <+%
D7,C

4B?0$+%%$%%$$#$?/+%'$-'0$'#+-*&2+//3&'+&-%0<$-'0$ .+(3$ /(%*&2%'/)+%& D 7 ,@7, F4B?0$-*

$#$&/$<+% $61(+*&$-3&-$#'0#$$0$+-%0$$61(+&+'*&<*'0#$2+#-'
,F@,

B?

<+%+//$1'$-:;'0$%%$%%*&2

*/$#%#$2+#-%' 
B?,'0$ +%%$%%$$+.$##$-'0+''0$%'/)<+%1($-2$- #5'0$+(#$+-;0;1'0$/+'$- %'/)#'0$#$5+*&*&2-*

$#$&/$ 
@,DD,

B?,*'<+%%'+'$-'0+''0$ %'/)<+%':$#$/$*.$-+&-1($-2$-0$%%$%%*&2

*/$##$G$/'$-:'0 '0$/&'$&'*&%+&-.*-$#-$#-+'$- 4@ 77 ,+1+#' #5'0$#+--*'*&% 5+-$+--*'*& C,@ ,C@ B?&+//3&' %'/)-*

$#$&/$11$+(<+%

*($-+&-'0$55*%%*&$# 
&/5$+6811$+(%9,+(+&-0+#

#%0#',

'0$
89 .*-$#-$#-+'$- 4  77@+((<$-'0$+11$+(0$+11$+(

*($-:;'0$#$.$&3$:$ #$'0$#*:3&+(<+%1+#'(;+((<$-&  

0$$61(+&+'*&<*'0#$2+#-' 
@,DD,

B? #-*

$#$&/$*&%'/)<+% +//$1'$-  +&-  '0$  +--*'*&  '  '0$  '3&$  

B?  &  +//3&'  

-*%/#$1+&/;*&%'/)<+%%3%'+*&$-,0$&/$'0$1#$%$&'+11$+( $+#&$-/3&%$( #'0$+%%$%%$$+#23$-'0+''0$#*:3&+($##$- *&%3%'+*&*&2'0$+--*'*&,+%+/$#'* */+'$ #5'0$:+&)<+%1#-3/$-''0$ $

$/''0+'&%'+'$5$&' %'/)+%& D 7<+% *($-:;'0$+%%$%%$$ $%3:5*''$-'0+' *23#$+%&@ 7 %'/).+(3$ ,DD, 4B?

<+%#$1#-3/$-:;'0$:+&)&'$&'*&*%'0+' #5'0$0;1'0$/+'$- %'/),1($-2$ %'/)<#'0
B?<+%5+-$

D 0$/&'$&'*&%#+*%$--&'<+##+&'+&;*&'$# $#$&/$*&'0$ #-$# '0$#*:3&+(0$+%%$%%$$:$ #$'0$%%$%%*&2

*/$# +*($-' 1#-3/$+&;$.*-$&/$<#'0#$(*+&/$,$61(+*&*&2'0$-*

$#$&/$ %'/) 0$:)% +//3&' '0$+%%$%%$$<$#$#$G$/'$-+&-$%'*5+'$1# *'& +//3&' '#+-*&2<+%/+(/3(+'$-0$%%$%%*&2

*/$#$6+5*&$-'0$:+&) 

*/*+(+&--3#*&20*%/#%%?$6+5*&+'*&,*''#+&%1*#$-'0+''0$1#$.*3%

*23#$2*.$&:;'0$+%%$%%$$<+%#$1$+'$-3&($%%'0$#$<+%/0+&2$*&%'/) 1%*'*& $+&*&2'0$#$:; #5@ 7' D 7'0$+%%$%%$$&$.$# *& #5$-'0$:+&)'0+''0$%'/)0+-#$-3/$- 0$+#235$&''0+'&%'/)%'+'$5$&'+%& D 7<+% *($- :;'0$+%%$%%$$-$%&'$&0+&/$*'%/+%$,#+'0$#'0$1%*'*&/5$%''0+' '0$%'+&- '0$+%%$%%$$<*'0'0$:+&)<+%'0+'0;1'0$/+'$-%'/)<#'0
,DD, 4B?+%*'$6*%'$-&@ 7/&'*&3$-'*(( D 70$%'/) 1%*'*&+%1$#'0$$2*%'$#+%& D 7*%'+:3(+'$-:$(<

>*9;1'0$/+'*&B/% ,DD, 4B?

**9($-2$B/% ,F@,

B?

***9($-2$B/% B?

*.9:$1($-2$-%@,DD,

B?

???????????????????????

%D7,C

4B?

???????????????????????E 0$*%%3$#+*%$-*%&(;<*'0#$2+#-'1($-2$ B? 0$/&'$&'*& *%'0+''0$ %'/)<+% #5'0$0;1'0$/+'$-%'/)

B?--%3:%'+&'*+'$'0$%+*-/(+*5,&$.*-$&/$<+%1#-3/$- :$ #$'0$+3'0#*'*$%0$:+&)<+%&$.$#*& #5$-'0+''0$0;1'0$/+'$- %'/)<+%#$-3/$-+&-3''0+'

B?-- %'/)<+%1($-2$-0$ +%%$%%$$ +*($-'-*%/0+#2$'0$&3% $61(+*&*&2'0$-*%/#$1+&/;

C 0$5+''$#/+&:$.*$<$- #5+&'0$#+&2($,*$,+%+&-<0$& '0$#$<+%+--*'*&+(%'/) 
@,DD,

B?,'0$+%%$%%$$+11#+/0$-'0$:+&) '%0<'0+''0$%'/)0+-*&/#$+%$-0$%+*-%'/)<+%1($-2$-<*'0'0$ :+&)  &  7D 7  +&-  '0$#$+ '$#  -#+<*&2  1<$#  <+%  $&0+&/$-  :;

,@@,4

B?+&-+//#-*&2(;'0$.+(3$ %'/)<+%/0+&2$-:;'0$:+&) 0$.+(3$ 0;1'0$/+'$-%'/)+%&@ 7<+%#$1$+'$-%3:%$=3$&'(;

& 4D 7+&- D 7+%'0$#$<+%&/0+&2$ .+(3$ %'/)+&- '0$%+5$<+%&'*& #5$-''0$:+&) 0$+%%$%%$$ +*($-'1#.$*&/##$/'&$%% $&'#*$%  $2*%'$# 0$$.*-$&/$<+%-3(;/&%*-$#$-:;'0$#*:3&+(+&-1+#'*+( #$(*$ <+%2#+&'$- $####*(($2+(*';*%%0<&*&'0$ #-$# '0$#*:3&+( %3%'+*&*&2  +--*'*&  

B?    =3$%'*&    (+<  53/0  ($%% %3:%'+&'*+(=3$%'*& (+<+#*%$%,#+'0$#'0$/&'$&'*&%+#$13#$(; +/'3+( 0$+11$+(*%-*%5*%%$- -)

*++
,.

-/ 0(
.

1 1

@

5) !0$'0$#%1$+)*&2B#$+%&$-

$%B !0$'0$##$1#'+:($

$%B