High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/297/1999disposed of

New India Ins. Co. Ltd. v. Jasvir Kaur And Others

2018-12-11Mr. Justice Satpal6 pages

!"!

#!$% &$'()!%* !) #%!

)+ ,-

. /0 ,+1+23+45, 3366+ 71 '+89+1+,/ %3,

&- )3+:;1<,8++, +9/++<,8+ /+3366+ );%+,/+0+<,8+ 3, +,= //#13+<,8+ 3,+,> >

/,/+66,3 +066+

6,43, +,

1+23+4/+ 6,/+33+6/+66??+0+,,+,

.3+,4,6+2+ 1+6<&++6+ @ 1+6A / < / / /+,< /+8 6+2+=<:?/+2 /23++0+,, /24/6+, 1+6+1 ,+/ (+60,;?/+ 28/6+,

/ 6+2+< 0/ + 0 +, / ,+,< 6, + 31,; /7/6<:?23+ +1 ,+/ (+60,;?/,118,+28/6 +, 0// : 36+

0+ 36+,, /+ ,+, 0+ ?? 766+? 9/++

/ +? &(

)

0/+6:+1/A?+?2B/61?</ 0+ 660,4//+/+;?/+,%++/+,0/0 + 3++ &(

0+ +, /+ (+60, ;?/ 0+,8?//6 /+,,++2+63,(/+,

+/+ +, B/ / +/, + 766+? 5/++ 9+21< ++ ;?/ 3, +2 2 / , + 1: &

>. + 84 +/+,?6?2+++/?/3,B/160?+4/</1: /1:+?// (+60,;?/<0/,,+/3 /+ 3, 33, / 1: +0+4 2 / +, +, +2 / 36+ 1+,,6,/+2+,

,+:/1,/ /3+6 + +/+ B/ / 6+ /+ / ,+, /+, +6+,4 ,,< / 633, 2/36+8?/1:/, %C ,+,

0+ ?, + &6 ;+ ;+,+< +/+< +?+ 3, 0+ 36+,,/+/,+,+/2 /,+/0+0:?++6: / ?+ )3+2< ?? %>.= 3 2/ 23+ 0+< /1<3+4, 5+, 1+661,,/,+, 4+6,+/ 2 /,+/+,+,/2+%>

32/),1 =,0+

,0+,3+6D31636

0++336, /1<+6,3,40++,+%C<

/ 12 %

+,C

0++0+,,0+, 1+6D3+,6 +3864/12 %C

0++0+,,0+,6 12 /1</6+2+0/6,6,++623+ %C<.

< 0// 0+ 1,, %C<.

+6? 0/ E

F3+12 2/,+ 6? 6+2366+6+

1+23+40+/6,6+63+4/23+

??8, / 2< / 3 +33+6 /+

1+23+4 5+,16 /+3366+= 1+23+48/264 +?1/+/+6++/ 2+,, /364<+/ ,8

,?1:,,/+88+6,,8?6+/2 / +,< +1/G? /2 ,8 /

,? 8/6 1: +? ?+&

>. / /+/+/,8?6/6, 4/20+ +6?/+38/6+, +/+84+38/6 +1:5+,16 /+2 %B !+,;?/<'1 +< )

< &++6+ +, 12 /+ + 3 / 4 + ; >> =% ,+, . < ,8? 6 / 3,=,8 0+ 0, / 6?/ +3 8/6 / 3, 2 . . /80 /2+<12,/+/6+,1+6 /+ , 61,? /+ 3,=,8 0+ /6,? +

8 +, 8+6,,8?6+/2 +, 5+,16 /0+,,8

,?8/6 1/+,+820/612?/++8+6,,8?60/+ ,2 /,8?+1/G,,8++38/638, , /13+4,/+/+33+6,2, 5+,16 /=6+2+12/+ + 2 +1 11 33 /+ +

,, 8< 2+? 23+ /+ +0+,, 1, / 8+6 /+,< 0// , /+, + 3 / 1,?2 / !A6 ;132 1 +?2+ #+6 1+ 23+4 5, 7 +1 %+2 +6+ /1/1 %+2 +, /< 86 33+6 C.

. ,,,

. < /1< 3+4, /+ +660, +, 23++0+,,/6+2+/+,

/+8/+,6+,16 /3++,/+8?/1?/ /,0//+6++

+ 2+ , /+ / 6 /6, 4 / 3,=,8++,2 /,8?+1/G,,8 /+84 +3 8/6 /6, /0< 264 / +2 %B !+, ;?/ /

/+ / 4 /

+ ; >> =% 2? 1 , +4 2+ / 4 3+ 0+6 / ,8?6 2 . . ?+660+1,+ 34.,+,

!08<,3+?/?+6 616,3,1, / 1+6+0+2,4%B < /+/+2/+,,+2+?,/ 6,0///+,1,/4+

%B /++,2,/+/+1? 20, 5 7 /4 /?+; >> +,/+1?0++6,4/

/ ?+6 ,8? 6< 0// 0+ +8+6+6 / 36 6

/+66+ C ,+,

6, ;+ 7 ++ ;?/ 3,? / 1 ;)'<+/+0+,164122, 3 +6648,4/ 6+, 1+6/+/?+66+066+ ,34/ "D% +?+664 6/+/60+1, /+84+38/6+ 066 1/2< %B ;/+ 5+6< '1 +< ) < &++6+ , ,/?+6,8?6 /3,=,8/122,

6;/+5+6<%B ,/+/+,60+33+,4/20/ / 0+ 3, + '1 + /

) < &++6+ ! +6 , ,/?+1 //) <&++6+8/?+66 3 +664,,4%B/+/+,60+1,64 5 7+, / 0, @! 7A 0 , 1H164 8< ;/ ;?/< %B< 0

,?8/6<3 +664 ,/+3,=,80+

/6,? + 8+6, ,8? 6< 8, 0// / 0+ +1/G, ,8 /+84 +38/6+066!+,+?,,88/+8?+1, +4 +, +6 %B 1/ +, /+ / 1: 0+ ?16+64 1, 0/ / 1+ 23+4 +, +/ 2 / 1: 0+ 1,< ,8? 6 / 3,=,8 0+ 3,1, / 23+4

+6 0

,?8/66+64D,,1++,+1 ?+?? / 8 / ,8 / < :3? 80 / + +, 12+2,+8<61,,/+/6+, 1+6/+ ?/64,,,/1,? /6+, 1+6/+3,=,8 0+/6,?+ 8+6, ,8? 6<13/6, 1+23+4+ +68, 6+64,2 4/1,/+ / 3 /+ 1?, 4 6+, 16 /

1+23+4 5+,16 /+3366+1+631+4?1, 0/+8 /231?,+0+,+/+ / 1+ 23+4

3/36+ /+2 23++0+,, /6+2+<,31/+/,+,+?,+1 4+0+ 8? + ++6 &+0+ / ?+ )3+2 / ;+ &1+< 8?++6+4 % = 32/ 80 /1,?2 !A6 /;1321++6 1+23+45,7&++4;/+, /<

>%% 86

<C F+2/++

,, +1 11 33 ),1 =, /+ ?/64

, 1636

/+?/64+336, 80 /1,?2 !A6/ ;1321/+ +?2+#+6 1+23+45, 13+< 6+2+=3, +, + 6, + 12 %>

+/ 0+, 31+6 +, 3++6 12 3864 / 6+2+ +

,,6,+12 % C<

+/+, %C

+0+,,0+, 6 ++, 1+6D3 3366++</1<6,23+<0// 0:, +1,-

2 >

32<C <>

3+12 +6 2 + +,, + / + C F +1 11 33 <>

IC<

DC F J C<

2 + ,,1 =, +1 3+6D3

KC<

= JC <>

> +6 ,3,4 + +3364? + 21636

J.<C<.

C 5 +

1+6D3

5 126+2+E >

<%.

D .

<<.

/ +21 23+ +6+,4 +0+,, / 6+2+< ,6 +4< /+66 +, ,,1, 2 / +21 +616+, + +8 6+2+ /+66 6, + / + CF 3 +12 / /+,+21 2/,+ 6? /366+6G+ B/ / +8+, 2, + / +0+, ,+,

.< + ,3, +, / +33+6 1+ 23+4,2,

/0+ B//3+:?=+,- *= B//3+6- *=