M/S Ram Gopal Brij Bhushan And ANR. v. Gurpratap Singh











  

!"#
 #$%&%'
(  

)&
!*
+!,
-%.
/0&/!'
!'1
!'"/#- #"%"%'#-& 2#-&0& 0-+-!"!+
3%'4/ 
#&+'1#'"

 (






5 6
3
27 
 8 





  



 


  


 



  


 27 
 8 69





!

"

 #
 
 

 


 
$% &$ '$''

(
)&"
 
*

+



+
,

-  "




-
.




/


 
*

) 







(

))
/ 0 

(
)'"

 

1
&%2&3245)
/ 
 
*


)

 

)

6
   (
)4"
/ 
 
*

 
 


 



 
1 
(
)%"
/ 
 
*




 


 




/
  
*
 




 

 






 









-



 
. 
.

)6'

7 
8

)64 




(

))

&9 $4 '$'&

. 

.

)6'
/ 
*:

)(



'& $;

'$'&

'4 $;

'$'&


 

)(



. 
.

)6'

 )



(
)2"

  





)(

))

#


(
)3"
 
 
/ 
 





 /

*


 




 
$'

$3 '$&%

1
<$$$$$5) / 


 

.


/ 



/ 




)64

=
/ 



*
 



(
 

1 4$$$$$5)

1 <$$$$$5)
/


 

.





1 4$$$$$5)

1 <$$$$$5)
/




#

/ 

/



 


 


/ 
 



 


 
 =



 




  8 



)


* 
 



+


0



>
* 
 

 

  

!
?@===
1 
%


+

+

&;$9
 
A++B"

 



 
*
*
* 

>
 * 
 


)(



7 
8

)64
/ 

 



/ 
/

/




* 


 
)(

>
* 
 


/ 
*
 
 


)(


7

)64


0
/ 
*  



=




 





%-!,%

&/:%'
#4!'1/%
2&
!;!'"%,!,
'<#&"*#'"&
!'1
'-
8 /
C
-
=- D
'&9%4&;
!'4!'4!
+#-!"%<#
0&%'4
3$%#";
6"1
2&
2!&!'"% !.!'!'
#-0-=!-

  >
%<%,
?9
!"&%;!
!'1
-&
2&

!*4<%'1
!'1
-&


!1/;!
-!1#&/
 9
/#
3"!"#


!'%+0-
#+-#&#'"#1
;
"/#
3#$-#"!-;
*#9
<#-'*#'"

!'%+0-9 *+/!,
!'1
-&
2&
3/-%

/%@!
3%'4/9

AA 
A > 

 




*   









 


>
* 
 


/




)(


*
.

)6
'
 


 1
<$$$$$5)
/ 



 

/ 

 




) 64






/ 

/

/



)




>
* 
 


/ 

 * 
 



+


 




/



/ 


0




) =



 


 




 


* 

 
 
*
 
*
 
 

)




>/ 





(














 







 





 0


&42


= 
E 

&92'
 
 (

))
)(



)(

=


   
/ 


/


*
 


+



) (




 


)(



/

! 

 

)(


/ 
 

)(


 

>/ 

 

( =

 

!-#&/
--!
2&
30-%'1#-
70*!-
1#$#!&#1 "/-04/
/%&
6&



#'"

+) 

 
 



 

 


(

))
 
* 


  




 



=
/ 


>  
!
?@===
1 
%
++



 


 

7 *

 
 

 

 
*
 

>/   


 
*
 

#
+) 

 



0 


>
+
/ 
 


   ) A
'
*;
<%#:9
0+'
"/#
#B+%-;

-#&+'1#'")-%4%'!,C ,!'1,-1
30-%'1#-
70*!-9
-#&+'1#'"
'%<
%&
#'"%",#1
"
&##=
#<%$"%'


"/#
+#"%"%'#-
%'
/#-
:'
@#/!, 9
#&+#$%!,,;
%'
<%#:

"/#
!$"
"/!"
"/# -%4%'!,
,!'1,-1
/!1
!,-#!1;
%&&0#1
#'#-!,
:#-
 ""-'#;
%'
/#-

!<0-9
!'1
/!1
!&&#-"#1
"/#
-#D0%-#*#'"

-#&+'1#'"

%<
%'
-#&+#$"

"/#
1#*%&#1
+-#*%&#&
%'
"/#
%-&"
%'&"!'$#
%"&#, 

"
/!&
!,&
$*#
'

-#$-1
"/!"
!,,
"/#
"/#-
,#4!,
/#%-&

"/#
-%4%'!,
,!'1,-1)-#&+'1#'"& /#-#%'9
!1*%"
"/#
'##1

"/#
&!%1
-#&+'1#'"
'%<
!'1
!1*%"
"/!"
&/# -#D0%-#&
"/#
1#*%&#1
+-#*%&#&
"
+#'
/#-
@0"%D0#
%'
<%#:

"/#
!$"

"/!"
&/#
%&
:%1:
!'1
/!&
":
;0'4
$/%,1-#'
"
@-%'4
0+
-#<#-9 -%4%'!,
,!'1,-1
/!1
!,-#!1;
4%<#'

%'
!<0-

-#&+'1#'"
'
%< %'
/%&
,% #"%*#
"
+0-&0#
"/#
#.#$"*#'"
+#"%"%'
'
"/%&
-#4!-19
&0++-" *!;
@#
1-!:'
-*
.014*#'"&
-#'1#-#1
@;
<!-%0&
%4/
0-"&
%'

!'4!'4!
+#-!"%<#
0&%'4
3$%#";
6"19
0*@!%
<
2!&!'"% !.!'!'
#-0=!-9
6!:
%'1#-
$
1
E


?

AF
!.#&/
2!-*!
<

*%'#B
,1%'4&
!'1
'<#&"*#'"&9
6!:
%'1#-
$
1
E

>F
!'1 !4/@%-
3%'4/
<
!-<#&/
70*!-9
6!:
%'1#-
$
1
E
>?

 ?9
:/#-#%'

%"
/!&
@##'
%'"#-C!,%!9
/#,1
"/!"
'$#9
!'
G<%1#'$#

%1!<%"H
%&
%,#19
!'1 "/#
#B!*%'!"%'C%'C$/%#

"/#
1#+'#'"
/!&
@#40'9
"/#-#
%&
' %*+#1%*#'"
!'1
%"
*!;
@#
+#-*%&&%@,#
-
"/#
1#+'#'"
"
%,#
!
0-"/#- !

%1!<%"
&%'$#
-1#-
A9
0,#
>

1#&
'"
,%*%"
%"&#,
"
!
&%'4,# !

%1!<%"F
!'1
"/!"
"/#-#
:!&
'"/%'4
%'
"/#
!*#'1#1
9
:/%$/ +-#$,01#&
"/#
0-"
-*
-#$-1%'4
0-"/#-
#B!*%'!"%'C%'C$/%#

"/# +,!%'"%



'
$!&#

!4/@%-
3%'4/
&0+-!9
"/%&
0-"
/!&
/#,1
!&

,,:&( I 

10@"
"/!"
"/#
,!'1,-1
/%*&#,
/!1
'"
!++#!-#1
%'

"/#
:%"'#&&
@B
%'
&0++-"

/%&
$!&#
"/!"
"/#
1#*%&#1 +-#*%&#&
%&
-#D0%-#1
-
"/#
@'!
%1#
-#D0%-#*#'"

/%&
&'

@0"
"/#
&'

"/#
,!'1,-19
'!*#,;9
0-*##"
3%'4/9
/!1 !++#!-#1
!&
8
-
/%*&#,
!'1
!&
3+#$%!,
:#-


""-'#;

/%&
!"/#-
!'1
/!&
&"!"#1
"/!"
/%&
!"/#-
%&
!'
,1 *!'
!'1
/#
%&
:#,,
$'<#-&!'"
:%"/
"/#
!$"&

"/#
+#"%"%'

/#
&!%1
&/+
:!&
-#D0%-#1
@;
/%*
-
/%&
+#-&'!,
0&#
#
%& *!"-%$0,!"#9
/!'1%$!++#19
/!<%'4
1# #$"
%'
/%&
,# "
#;#
!'1 ,# "
,#4
!'1
%"
%&
1%

%$0,"
-
/%*
"
1
"/#-
@0&%'#&&
#B$#+"

-
-0''%'4
!
&/+
#
/!&
$!"#4-%$!,,;
!<#--#1
"/!"
/# -#D0%-#1
"/#
&/+
-
/%&
:'
$$0+!"%'
!'1
%&
'#%"/#- $$0+;%'4
'-
<!$!"#1
!';
&0$/
&/+
%'
"/#
0-@!'
!-#!


0'%$%+!,
0'$%,9
7/!-!-
:%"/0"
!';
&0

%$%#'"
$!0&#
!

"#- "/#
$**#'$#*#'"

"/#
$" 
'
"/#
+-#&#'"
$!&#
!,&9
8
/!&
$!"#4-%$!,,;
&"!"#1
"/!" /%&
!"/#-
%&
!'
,1
+#-&'
!'1
%&
1%'4
'"/%'4
#
%&
:#,, $'<#-&!'"
:%"/
"/#
!$"&

"/#
$!&#
:/%$/
*#!'&
"/!"
/#
%& *!'!4%'4
"/#
!

!%-&

"/#
!*%,;9
"/#-# -#9
"/#
!-40*#'"

-!%&#1
@;
$0'&#,
-
"/#
"#'!'"
"/!"
"/#
,!'1,-1
&/0,1
/!<# #'"#-#1
%'"
"/#
:%"'#&&
@B
!&
/%&
:'
:%"'#&&
%'&"#!1 !++#!-%'4
"/-04/
/%&
3+#$%!,
:#-
 ""-'#;
"
+-<#
/%& @'!
%1#
'#$#&&%";
:0,1
'"
@#

!';
$'&#D0#'$#
@#$!0&# "/#
@'!
%1#
'#$#&&%";
%&
!,&
'"
',;

"/#
,!'1,-1
@0"

!,&

/%&
&'9
!&
+,#!1#1
%'
"/#
+#"%"%'
!'1
!,&
%'
"/# !

%1!<%"
B8) 9
"#'1#-#1
%'
#B!*%'!"%'C%'C$/%#

"/# &'

"/#
,!'1,-19
:/
/!&
$!"#4-%$!,,;
!,,#4#1
"/!"
"/#-# %&
'
"/#-
&/+
%'
/%&
$$0+!"%'
'-
/!&
<!$!"#1
!';
&0$/ &/+
%'
"/#
0-@!'
!-#!
$'$#-'#1
:%"/0"
!';
&0

%$%#'"

$!0&#
!

"#-
"/#
$**#'$#*#'"

"/#
$"J 



/
/ 
 
*

 *

>
+


 
%-!,%
&/:%'
#4!'1/%
!'1
!'4!'4!
+#-!"%<#
0&%'4
3$%#";

6"1
&0+-!



 
>
+


 

!"&%;!
!'1
-& &0+-!

1 


 



 








*
*
.

)6'

7

)64

 
*  





(



1 4$$$$$5)
/


 
. 
.

+


. 
.


 


) (


 



1
<$$$$$5)
/ 



 

/ 

 

 





/ 
 

 


)(



.

)6'

!
 
/ 
*

  /

0


 
 
 )


 



)





 





/ 



 









/

 
 
)(





 




#

/ 
/ 

*
 
 / /

 

#
) 
/ 


: 


)(





 
  


C

/ 
*




 

/  
* 

  
*





0

 
*
  
*





 

0
 
 

 
 # 
*

=


 


/



*

)







 



/

#
 

 
$% &$ '$''
(
)&"
 
*
 +



+
,

-  "



-
.








*

)



 
 


*
/



(

))


/

#






/ 
*
*0






 1 '$$$$5)


)



27 
 8 6









 

 



  6
 5  57 6
 * 57