High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/250/1998allowed

(O&M) National Insurance Co. Ltd v. Gulabo Devi & ORS.

2016-02-12Mrs Justice Daya Chaudhary7 pages

!" #$% "&'(")(*! "(+ ,-"(#.&/ 0-- ))"(& *!*

,&!)" 1'"(/&2 * 0

(&* 3 4 5.3

(& 3

"672"(("$/1+"& &2 "-- ))"(& 3 3",)'$/1+"& (& 3 "2!)8"&*$/1+"& (&*"(/9

3 $ #:"#&2'*"-- ")$&2 ,-"(#2"**!;2&

# ';2&*"**"')'(;&2 ":" //"& /<()#&&2 (& 2)/'(; '& 6'(&)# "(/ * "))# )'") & ,"> &2 -"#, (& (*"&'( '

"+&* "

&2"& ( $ (& :2') / '1'(; 2'* ! :2

) " '(; 44?%% '( " "*2 "(/ ;)';

(& ,"(( *& !+> &2 +#+)'*& '(;2 ", # +,'(; , &2 --*'& /'

+&'("&')"*-! "/ '(;2 ", ))/:( '1'(; ,!)&'-) '(6! '

* "(/ *!++!, / & &2 *", ( &2 *-&$

) "1'(; 2'(/ 2'* :' ")( "* " / - (&$ (& *@&$2'*+2')/ ( '(;:

))* &&) /:

(&/ - (&!-( 2', '*:'/:"*"*) ) ;")?("&! ")2 ' ') /"+)"',- &'&'( !(/

+&'( %% &2 3& 8 +& +)"','(; )"+* "* (*"&'(";"'(*&&2 "&2 '(;2 ",

(&*"(/9$/ '1 "(/:( &2 " *"'/ "* :

)) "* &2 "-- ))"(& +(& *& / &2 +)"', - &'&'(

(&*"(/6'(&)#-) "/ /&2"& '(;2 ",$ '(;"()/ - *($ )) ( 2'* :( , 2'* '4+#+) ( &2 "/ "(/ '1 '(6! '

*2 ' 1 :"*( '(1)1 /'(&2 " *"'/"++'/ (&

(&9$&">'(;&2 *',')" *&"(/$-) "/ /&2"&'&:"*(&)'") & ,"> "(# -"#, (& +,- (*"&'($ "* / '1 (/'(; :"*(&2)/'(;"1")'/"(/ +&'1 (*! "(+ ,-"(# ;& 1 ''

/ &2 / '1'(; )'+ = , &2 .'+ (+'(; !&2 '&#$ 2',)""(/!(/'&& ""> 1'/ - &$= &:"* *- +''+"))# - & /&2"&&2 $= :"*(&'**!

/'(&2 (", !)*2 2,"/ *( 32/ 2" ' # .'+ (*'(; !&2 '&#$

2',)"2 ) / '!(")&2!;2* /&2"&- ',""+'

/ '1'(; )'+ (&:"*"> $!&

!"#$$! #%% 2 ) / '!(")$&">'(;'(&+(*'/ "&'(&2 ";

/ '(;2 ","*<# " *, (&'( /'(&2 -*&, & , - &

9 = "(/2'*'(+, "&<$?4- "((!, ,"; '+!)&! ")-! *!'&*$ "& / /!+&'(; 2'* - *(") =- (* * "(/ +(*'/ '(; &2"& &2 / / 2"/ ) & ()# 2'(/ 2'* :'/:$ "--)'

/ &2 ,!)&'-)'

$ +")+!)"& /&2 +,- (*"&'(",!(&9<$?4!&&">'(;"'/&2 +(/ *+2 /!)

+&'( %94 &2 +& ; "(& / $?4 "* (*"&'( -)!* $?4 &:" /* !( ") =- (* *$ )** +(* &'!, "(/ )** *&"& &&"))'(; $?4 "* +,- (*"&'( ",!(&$ :2'+2 '* !(/ / & %$?4 1'/ ',-!;( / ":" / /"& /< .

/ +!(* ) &2 "-- ))"(& " ;!

/ &2"& / '1'(; )'+ (&:"*!(/"> 1'/ - &= $ ) / '!(") !;2& & 2"1 =( "& / &2 )'"')'&# &2 (*! "(+ ,-"(# "&) "*& # ';2&*2!)/2"1

(;'1 ( &'&$& &2 ":" / /+,- (*"&'(",!(& ,&2 '(*!

/ (*!-- &2'*" ;!, (&*$2 )'

/!-(&2 (&!6" "& ';2! &'( :(/'"**! "(+ .&/1"!2"' ! *2&&",2"' " '6"("(/&2 *$@ ( &2 &2 2"(/$ ) / +!(* ) &2 :( (/'(;1 " ;!

/&2"&&2 '*(& =- +& /&;&&2

(& 1 '#'(; &2 ;

(!'( ** &2 / '1'(; )'+ :'&2 &2 )'+ (+'(;"!&2 '&# 2"* ()# & *"&'*# 2',* ) &2"& &2 / '1 *

,-)# /2"*"1")'// '1'(;)'+ "(/2"*+,- & (&&/ '1 2 ) / '!(") 2"* ';2&)# (& =( "& / &2 )'"')'&# (*! "(+ ,-"(#$ = :"*1 #,!+2*

(& 94:( "(/ '(/'(; '& & - '," "+'

;

(!'( $ 2

@ "--'(& (& "* / '1 :"* (& A!'

/ & / "(#&2'(;, &2"('&(*!-- &2'*" ;!, (&*$) /+!(* ) &2 )'

/!-("/ +'*'(/"& /@@'( B3?*&)"*(*& !+&'( "A '/""/1."2 '(;2"(/&2 *C .

/ +!(* ) &2 +)"',"(& " ;!

/ &2"& &2!;2 2'* + **6 +&'(*2"1 (&

()'*& /:'&2&2'*"-- ")$!&*&'))&2'*! & +"( (2"(+ +,- (*"&'("*&2 -- ))"& ! &+"(-"**"(# / $ ' &2

'* ( "-- ")$ !(/ / @ !) 99 (*"&'(A!"+(* &'!,$)** *&"& &+2"1

(; "(& /# '!(")&&2 :'/:&2 / $&2 ',-!;( /":" / ,"# ,/''

/&&2"& (&(*!-- &2'*" ;!, (&*$2 -)"+

)'"(+ !-(&2 (&*

/'( "(6"(" ">"*2"(/&2 *1 '1'*'(")3"(";

"(/"(&2 @$"&'(")(*! "(+ .&/17,")D *9%$ '

(&")(*! "(+ ,-"(#.&/ 1! / 1 '(;2"(/&2 *B@C .

9$3"(";'(;'

+& $",') "/! &"& "(* -(.&/1.">*2,"("(D &2 *$ 8',")7"(:" "(/&2 *17'*2 "("(/&2 *9B9C 9 2

'*"+"& ; '+'(/'(;&2 ) / '!(")&2"&"* - - &$= $/ '1'(;)'+ &2 / '1 = :"*!(/"> &2"*

(+(& /#) /+!(* ) &2 ,-"(#&2"&

+"* B*!- "C2"*") "/#

(1 !) #&2 - =! & 2 "+&* "(/ +' +!,*&"(+ *

+"* B*!- "C"

(&'/ (&'+")&&2 - (&+"* (&2"& +"* $:( &2 & !+>2"// -* /'(&2 :'&( **=&2"&"&&2

&', "--'(&'(;/ '1 ."2 '(;2!-(2'*/!,- $2 2"/*

(2'* / '1'(; )'+ "(/ *"&'*'

/ 2',* ) &2"& '& :"* " '(; *&",- & (&"!&2 '&'

*2 :"*2"1'(;-2&; "-2* ."2 '(;22'* 1'/ '*,'**'(;'(&2'*+"* $ (& 9( (&

/'(&&2 :'&( **="(// -* /&&2 "1 *"'/

+&2 ) / '!("):"*) &:'&2() ;#&2 &2 (/'(; 1 &2"& :2 "& "(# -'(& &', 2 2"/ *"&'*'

2',* )"!&&2 ;

(!'( **&2 (& ( &2 +' +!,*&"(+ *$ &2 ) / '!(") :2 ( 2"* *- +''+"))#2 )/&2"&/ '1'(;)'+ = :"*"> $'&!;2&&2"1 ;'1 ( # ';2&*&&2 ,-"(#:2') '='(;6'(&"(/ "))'"')'&#&2 "(// '1 2

'*(/'*-!& :'&2&2 * 1"&'(*&2 - =! & &2"&:2 (:( 2"*&*"&'*#&2"&&2 / '1 2"/1")'// '1'(;)'+ "(/ +,- & (+# & / '1 $ 2 '* (& =- +& / & ; & &2 (& '#'(; &2 ;

(!'( ** &2 / '1'(; )'+ :'&2 &2 .'+ (+'(; !&2 '&#*!+2"/ '1 +"!* *"++'/ (&$&2 ('(*!

"(/(&&2 '(*!

/:')) )'") :

$&2 *"&'*"+&'(&2 "!&&2 / '1'(;)'+ = '*,'**'(;'(&2'*+"* (&2 (&

"/ "(*- & - "&'(1"&'(")(*! "(+ ,-"(#$

- & /"*9B@C B'1')C<9$&2

2"/) 1'/ '!(")&2"&&2 #2"/"--'(& /&2 / '1 ' ,") '(;2'(@ 2

"& $2 2"/

(;'1 (- - & "'('(; ,&2 / '1'(;*+2)"&

"&'")""(/$&2!*$2"1'(;&"> ( "*(") *& -*'(1 '#'(;&2 / '1'(; )'+ "(/$ &2

"& 2"1'(; & "'( / &2 / '1 # &2 ,-)#

% 2',* ) ( &2 +' +!,*&"(+ *$ '& :"* 2 )/ &2"& &2 (*! "(+ ,-"(# :"* )'") 2

:"* ( "+2 "(# +(/'&'( # &2 '(*!

/ ( ! B9C B'1')C@@$'&2"*

(2 )/#&2 - =! &&2"&:( "1 '*!(/&,"> "*(") (A!' #$:2 / '1 2"/"1")'/)'+ " "*/ '1'(;)'+ "- **'(")/ '1 '* +(+ /$ &2 :( 1 $ / *-'& &">'(; "*(") +"

$ ,';2&2"1 (&

(") &'(/!&"*&:2 )'+ :"*"> ( (&2 '*(& =- +& /&1 '#&2 ;

(!'( **&2

,&2 & "(*- &'+ :

$&2 "+&*&2'*+"* "

(&'/ (&'+")& "+&*&2 - (&+"* $ 2"*(& !;2&"(#

1'/ (&2 + /&2"&2 ,"/ "*(") (A!' #"!& ;

(!'( **&2 (&"(/"**!+2$ " *"'/6!/;, (&*"

(&"--)'+") ( &2 - (& +"* $ &2

:"* ( )** & &2 *&"& $

"))2'*+2')/ (' (&*@&:

")*'(+2" ;

&2 ' *&"& 2 # &2 ,* )1 * :

+!)&'1"&'(; )"(/ "(/ &2 /"!;2& *&2 /"

")*," '

/2 /:"*, &2"( < # " * ";

:"* (& ,!+2 2 )-!) '( !)'))'(; 2'* *+'") )';"&'(2 (&

/'("

#$%

+"* B*!- "C'* (&"--)'+") &&2 "+&*&2 - (&+"* $ '(&2"&+"* / /2"*) & 2'(/&2 #!(;:'/:@# " *"(/&2 /"!;2& # " *$:2

"*$'(&2 '(*&"(&+"* $ (&#&2'*&', ,!*& 2"1 " !(/ # " * & # " * # &2 &', $ &2 (*"&'(:!)/ /'*! * /$*2 :!)/(& '("+(/'&'(&

+;('* 2 +2')/ (:

$'("))+' +!,*&"(+ *$&2 /:"* "))'(")) 2'*:'/:(*'/ '(;1 "))"+&*"(/+' +!,*&"(+ *$ ":" /! &2 "*!,&'(''')* ++,

(1'

:&2 " *"'//'*+!**'($&2 - (&"-- ")'* -" &)#")):

/2 ,-"(#'*2 )/ (&'&) /& ",!(& +,- (*"&'( , &2 :( "(/ / '1 (/'(;

(& '* 2 )/ (&'&) / & ! &2 +,- (*"&'( ",!(&&'(''')* + -.

!" #$% ", (/ ""'(C 7 !/;