M/S Anil Agro Industries And ANR v. M/S Bhoday Steel Rolling Mills
-1-
!
"# $% %
&'
(
'
'
)
** "
+!
, +!-!
&'
'
( ((
(('
** !.
"/ " $01 2
'
(
** "
+
, +!-!
&'
'
( ((
(('
** !.
"/ "
# 3( % '
'
'
Ms. Ishika Jain, Advocate for the petitioner(s).
'
'
%
!" # # $%$&'#$('& ) * + , ) -./" !" # #%012$#$('3 / , )-./" 4 5!" # #$%$&'#$('& 55 55 $
/ 32$! !
6 5 '(&# $3 (3 $('%
7 #'
/ '%2 *5 '22'
-2- 55 $3 '( $('%
7#% .! 8 ' ! 5 9 4 / (0 (2 $('3
7 #$ 6 5 %
5 5 ) . 5 5 ) 5 '
. 5
: '$ ; 5 5 )
. 5 : '$ ; 5 . " '&((((()#
!6 %'0$101(% (2 $(''5 " 1((((()# !6 &<$2(' (2 (2 $('' 5 " 2((((()# = 5 5 5 ) 9/5 5
> 5 %'
(% $('$ 5 " '(13$&()# 5 . 5 %'
'$ $('$ 5 " ''1(<%%)# ?
6 (3%303 (2 ('
$('% 5 " ''&(((()# @ - * -
5 ) / . 6/ . 5 6 A 5 5
-3- 5
6 5 6 6 6 * 5. 5 . 6 5
5 / '%2 *5 5 $3 (3 $('% .5
7 7#' 5 ) 5 55
55 / '%2 *5 . 55 $3 '( $('% 7 7#%
(0 (2 $('3 . 7 7#$
5 5 55 6 &
5 . 5 6 "-* . ) 7 7#3)
/ !" # #%012$# $('3 5 .
-4- ) 5 # ) !?'#- / !@ -* - #75 6 ) 5 ) 6 5 6 (& (< $('3
7 #& A B7 6 6 *
!" # #$%$&'#$('& 6 / '%25 ?
/ !" # #%012$#$('3 .5 $ /
/ 5 ) * 5 5
. )5 . ''
'$ $('& !" # #$%$&'#$('& $#/ ' 5 $ / 5/ !" # # %012$#$('3
. . 6 . / 5 6 . . / / $ ' 7 / . '0 (0 '<<& 5 6 5 @ -* ./ . 7
-5- 7"$)'
6 6 . 5 5 ) 6 5 7 . ) 55. / 32$ ! !
6 9 5 6 ) / !" # #%012$#$('3
* 5 5
5 6 6 5 . 5 7
7#&
/ /
.6 . . . 6 . / . . / 4 5 . 6 5 .7 6 # . C 6 5.
/ 21* "-* " . 6 . 5. 55 / . 5 5 . ./ 6
-6- *. 6 5 5 . 6 5 * 5 5
6 // !" # #%012$#$('3 ) * '
/ 6 A 7. .
)5 5.5 6 * 5 6 5 5 5 / / # . C 6 5 / .
7 "$)'
5 56 . 5 / '%2 *5 < * '( - 5 75
# '
"
5
78
"!+-9 "!4 + /!
!
-"/ +#
-7-
!
"
"
"
" "
"
#
$
%"
"
"
"
'
"
0
5
78
"!+-9 "!4 + /!
!
-"/ +#
&
" '("
) !
!
'
"
5
78
"!+-9 "!4 + /!
!
-"/ +#
!
"
! "
"
*
-8- '+",-".( /'0
'
"
1
5
78
"!+-9 "!4 + /!
!
-"/ +#
!"
#
"
"
" "
"
"
*
!"
# %"
"
1
3 4
"
34
" "
"
"# %
34
" "
"
& 5
"
''
> 5 A ! AD /5! .
-9- # *$ % $ % $ &' (()!* +,- E F EF # 76!6 55
"-*
/G '(&3<)$('< AD /5! />.H5, /@+
> 5# 6!
"
789 (/+'+/+" -
:
; 8
9 7 " 3'++'4 / <;; =(6 5 > ?5 ;
>?! @ A ?! "'++6;
>@=..+ .; -
1$ B789
2 ?<< !"'++6 1$BC :
3
"
4 5
D " 3 4 3
4"
B -9
"
'
/+
<$ /+ 343 4
1$ 34
$ ; < 3;<4;
" $ "
-10-
;< 3 4 9
E9;7 " $E9;7 " 3
4
; F
B /+9; 8
9 3
4"F D!
;
789;
//
B
*B B
B"
=,
;2;"/-+. ! ((
/-0( 9 F D <
;
" *
"
" /'
-" "
; < 3;<4
E9;7 " C $E9;7 " 3
4
; F !
B""9
'
8
" "
D
-11- "
B
B
D
! D
3 4 G
;<$'+/+
789 :
3
" 4
D " 3 4
3
4 "
9
"
'
" $
"
'
*
"
" /=! .6
C9!
1$ B.6&
$!
"
!
$! "
"
*
'+",-".( /'0B /,9
"9
/0>
5 > ?5 ;
>?! @ A ?! "'++6;79>@=..+9 "
7//"++"+++:$
/
"
7("++"+++:$ 0"++"+++:$
-12-
" 3 // 4"
; 8
9 H
B
B E
" /=.
C9!9
.
*"
" < .6
!
''
* "
"
" /(5
$
'
< .6
!
F
"
"
" "
< .6
! IIII IIII IIII '0
9
-13-
;
< ,.';
2;" /-6=
"
.6
C9 !" "
;
"
" 9
5 *./0 % $ -1
(!)"* 232 )3
* !!( ! 6 55
> 5# //!
"9
" /0,'+++ /0-'+++
< .6
C 9 ! 1 B.6&
$!
"
IIIIIIIIB /' < .6
C 9 !
"
;
"
-14-
/=.
C 9 !
9
"
"
/=9
"9
/=.
C 9 !
;
&/:/ /:'"
5 * $ 2
% +
2
!445,2) *5 5 5 . ! 5 .
7 . 5 &> 5# 0
&
F
D> D
& "999 & H //" =(6"2 0-. 0--1$ B0-.!
! $
"
"
"
B B0--9 3 " "
$ 4
" $
-15- "
$ "
$
"
" " "
$
$
"
"
" "
" "
" "
B ( 9
9 .6
C 9 !
< .6
1$ B!
"
B 9
!
""9
"
""
" < "
"
9
9
9
-16-
9
!
69 " " "
" "
"
! " < 3< .64
"
!
" "
. &
9
"
"
9
9
F " "
9
"
"
-9
" "
"
9
-17-
D
"
;
9
" "
.6
C 9 ! /+
"
G
" "
1 <E A
;
8
E
<" 3/.(/$(=4 - E
9 !
/ /632;49 9 "
"
" "
9
&>
"
"
* F
D>
& 999& "H //2 (''" =6-1$ B! "
"
"
"
B
9 "
9
-18-
D-D $
9
;
"
9
"
"
9
" "
9
.6
C 9 ! "
"
;
9"F J "3/.'.4/=+&7/+=/"
1$ B
D
8
"
B
;< 2 AA A " !97 /-=0 7
/=/ 9
"
"
"
"
F "
"
"
" 9
9
;
7
-19-
5 *261
% ./7 8 (()* 232 )3
* 9! AD /5 ! . / '%2 *5 5. .>
.. 5.
* % : % 8 ; < )((* ! $33 4 5 6 6 AD /5! A ! .5 6 # 6 . 5 * - ' % $ ' (! $33 =6 > ) 6
.
55 . . 5 . # ) ! 5 65 .)
7 2?? % %; (!$33=6 . ">5 * ..83 6 ' % .
3
)*6 ' )((*!$33"> 6 . . . 5 5 6 / 32$! !
.
*@ $ % .1 ; )(!4*>$33!4
-20- 6 . 5 5 / '%< *5 .
6 .
* 6
* + 3 .
6 ' % . 6 6 )!444*>$339"AD /5!6 5 ./ '%2 *5 '$ !5 5 65 . 55 /
. )# 5
!
/ !6
7 #3 5 . 5 5 5"-* $$ ($ $('(
7#3)
. / 21 *5 6 5 5 5 ./
5 5 5 76
5 "-* / 21 *5 . 5 5 6 5 . 7)65./ 4 / $1 *5 / .
-21- 7 /
6 .6 6 5 . 5 5
/ 21 *5 "-* . 6 5 5 7 5 .65 5 4 . 6 5 5 .6 5 5 = 5 5 .!?'#-> / !@ -* #75 .7 .5 .6 * 5. 5 > 5 6 . )5 "-* !
$$ ($ $('(
7 #3)
5 . . $('( !
*6 (2 ('
$('%
7# . 5 5 5 . * / 5 ) * / .) 6 5 / 5. C . 6
-22- 5 55 6 66 '% H
5 ! 5 '(&# $3 (3 $('%
7#'
55 $3 '( $('%
7#% (0 (2 $('3
7#$ 6 5 .66 $% % :'
'
;
? )# I) ?" #
I)