← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/11942/2020dismissed

Ramphal v. State Of Haryana

2021-07-27Mr. Justice Arun Kumar Tyagi8 pages



     

!"#"

$%&'&'  

     

% () ' *

+      

 

 

+  ,- ).

 !

  

"

 

"

    

  

#$%

 &   &



 '()$ "



!

 *+, -.( '/0(/0'% "

   

#/0 /0' '/012  +  &  '%.0







3

,"4

5"  !

1 *+6 "

 

 ! , 37

4

 ",

+

8 

 &



5"+

, 37

 "   

   "

 

 *+, '% 0)0'/0')  

/)( $0#  +&





8

5"9*+, /0# '(0-/0')  

/)( $0#  +&





2 5" *+ , $'% /00#/0'. "

   

/)( $0#

 +&





5"&

5""



 :

  ! ;     , 1-'

<1%)0%    !

     



   +

 4 

 "

 *+

  /0'%  



  

  

"   

    

"



!  8  &  

!

    !

   

 

     

 

  !

1  

     " 1 

  

6  !& , 1-'

<1%)0'  

 !  4     

   

6 " !

 " 

 

  4  

 

 

 



 6



 

   " 

  

 

3

 

, 



!   



 ;   ,



 

 



7

 

5        

!   

1  8      &      !

   

6 = " :

 

:



 6



"6

 





>  16



 *+, '% 0)0'/0')



"6

   

4   

 

   

 "

 

"

/



  .000:1 )000:1 





 



6  

"

!

"

 4     

6   

   1

 8     "

 

   

" 1   !

  !

1

          

 

      + !  !     



 

  

      

" 



 

 

    !

 !

"  



6

 

   



?!   & 6 

  "&   

 6   "

    "

"       @

 !

"     6

   

    

 "! 



  0-0'/0') !

?!   &

  

          ! !"!#

 ! 6  !

6  

   "& " "

 



 

&   !   !

  6

 

  ;



 !

  +  

6 !, 37

   "   ,

  +

 &   8  



5"

 ! 6

  *+

 6 "

 

'/0(/0'%+ 6  

    

 

*+ "



    !      "  

"  6   "   "

 

  

4

6 &, 1-'

<1 %)0' !

6

!

     4 6  

! 





 

 6  >  

"6  

!  

    

    

  

      

  

  

    "

 "



       !

  ;

"  

+   " 1 6    

    6

  

A

  "

*+!



  

!



 

" 



" 





 "   16



  4 

 

 

 !



 

 B  

 





6

   

   

  





        

"       &       "



 B



  

 B 



    "

  





 &&





 



 

')$C'D &&    

     &   '/1 

   ) 0 *

1 2*   ! 

  6

 

    8 "

  E 

         B 

 



  !  

 

'.)C/D

 && "   ! 

 

(06  

 



! 6

   

   

 

 

  .06  

 



 



'.)C-D  && 





  6  

B

86

/$(    

 

 

 

    

F!  

! 6



-  

.

G!

 

:6 



 

 +

66 

      "

   !  

    "



3

6  "

      

 

 

$      %&  '     ( ( ! 

 +  )  ! '*((! +,   

   +

"G

6 

!

 ! !

  6+ 

  ( !  '*((!- 

E!   & ! 

 !    3



 ;     6

E!   & ! 

./ "/ 0!!

 

 "$!

'-((!

3

!

 

3

 

 

 

!  

   

 

   

  

 



 

6

!

 

      !





       6!



 

 



  ! 

"

   "

6   

  $!1

+,

 2! "

3 %! !

!! 2# !-  

6

!  !

E!   &     

                       

            

    

      

 

            !

 

   

             

 

 "            





  

           

 

  #     

   

"        " 

      

     

                

  

"                





       

         

      



 

      

  "                   

 $ 

  

 "      

$ %& '%

   



    

 



        

 (



 6

! & 

  

B 

   6   

#%/  && 

!  

 

 3



   "       &         

&  

 & 

! 

"



! 

 

  " 

 " 

 



   



 ,

+

 ! 

6  

 

6

  

 

   :

    

!



6



6

!    6

6  



"   6

6   ; 

"



! 

  

6



!

 6

" 

 !    &       

" 

&

!

  4

5 

       

 

      

 "

" 



 "

  

"

1 +   6       

   "

"  

 

  

"    "

   

 

  

"  

    

"  



0'0%/0/'9

@  !



   



    

!  





  9

D @    

! 

  



"  

"

  

:

   

!          

!  

 

 

4  

!   !  4

5  

 

  "



!   ''0%/0/'  &



5"  

 

 ;

 

 

   



    

 "

   

'..1  +&:

  

""

  

:

 ! 6 !



 

 !

:



  !6 

!    " 1   !



   

"6

 



 6

   

 &  

  !  : 

 !  ;

 

& :  !  "

   " !      "

 



"  

''0%/0/'     

 



  ! 

      ;

 &'&' C

+  D >

   @   

": 

 = :,

@    !   = :,