Bimla Gupta v. Mohan Gupta And Others

    

     





 

  !" #$%$!&'
((

  )

  * $$!& + , +%-%



  .  *( %/!&0 &%

!+ 1' !&234  +(-%$# (.(5 4$ + % &'

+(

&!6.7 +-/8. &$!+0,!#  7$9

+(&:$.7 +-/80,!#  8 +(!%  -/ 80,!# &0

%(

+$1 !0$80,!#  "!+9 / $$!& +7$9/ $$!& + $&/ +%!&(

+( 6 ,& &080,!#  "!++ %/!&0 &!%(
7$9 + %/!&0 &!($&/ +%!& 4!&;7$99$%0 -;9 +$&4 7

%(.7 $ -/ 7$" !".9(

&$%9 -/ ( !& "!++ %/!&0 &!((

+(9 & &6 < $ 480,!#  "!++ %/!&0 &!(=(

+(.

#9$& $&80,!#   0$ !+ ( >>> (.(5 4$ 8( + ?@ -+%- & ! !+0 + 0  0 A(
(

8 4 +& 0 0$ !+ 9 "$4 0 % 4 1 & ;+ 1 &B#!1/+!1$%  0  0 
((

 & + 0 $&! 3 7 & 9  / $$!& + &0 + %/!&0 & !( ; 0 AC &0 C < +% + %/ #$, 4<(9 % 1 $% : &!&+ #!+0( ?
@

+( !9 & -/  + %/!&0 & !(  $% /+ % & $& !-+

4!&; 7$99$%#!-&% 4 +(  6 , & &08 0,!# 4%! %( .7 $

-/ 7$" !".9(

&$%9 -/ 8%  03< +( 6 ,& &080,!# !3 0 -;9 +$&4 7!"+ %/!&0 &!(( ?@ -+$&;9 +$&;8!&D- +<7$9+ ;

+0! 1$# 34 % 4 1 &

!"9 0$%/- 3 "!+ 9 4 +& 0 0$ !+8 +( !9 & -/ + %/!&0 & !(  E/+ %% 0# + $&1$%;$,$&;%7$9+ ;

+0!9$%1 ++$ 04$" !, +9  / %  < +% 3- #!&#4-0 0 3< % $&; 9 49!-;9 9  9 0 "

# 0 & -&/4 % &1 ++$ 04$" "!+< +%8< 9 9 0"-444!,  &0 "" #$!&"!+ 9 #9$40+ & &0$&9 #$+#-1% &# %89 9 0 ;+ 0!9 #!1/+!1$%  + " ++ 0! 3!, ( ?=@ 06!-+& 0!A((

( ?F@ & +$1!+0 +!#!&$&- 8$&9 1 &$1 8$449 & E0  ( ?@ 9$%% ; 8 +( !9 & -/ + %/!&0 &!( + D- %% "!+  D-$ -% ! 3  ;$, & ! 9  1  + 3< ## /$&; 9  % 4 1 &

;+ 1 &B#!1/+!1$% 0  0
((

 & + 0$&!3 7 &9 / +$ % 3 "!+ 9  0$ $!& &0 !&#$4$ $!& &+ 

#9 0!9$% !-+( ?@ 9  / +$ % $( ( / $$!& +8 .1( $14 -/  7$"  !" .9(

!9 & -/ %7 44 %+ %/!&0 &!($( (.9( !9 & -/ %B!) .9(G-&0 &) 4 -/ ; 0AC &0C< +%+ %/ #$, 4< %7 44 %9 $+ +& 0 #!-&% 4 %   9  9  % 4 1 & ;+ 1 & B #!1/+!1$%  0  0 
((

9 %3 & ++$, 0 !-!"9  +& %0 %$+  &0"+ 7$44!" 9 / +$ %89 + "!+ $% ## / 34 !9 1(/ +"+!19 % 4 1 &

;+ 1 &B#!1/+!1$%  0  0 
((

 9 ,$&; 3 & %$;& 0 3< 9  / +$ %89 % 1 3 +%9 %$;& -+ %!".9(

&0 / -/ 8;+ &0%!&!" 9  / +$ %8 %( +-1$ -/  7$"  !" .9(

&0 / -/ 8 +( !% 

-/ 80,!#  "!+9 / $$!& +8 %(.7 $ -/ 7$" !" +(

&$%9

-/ #4 $1 0!3 0 -;9 +$&4 7!".9( !9 & -/ H+ %/!&0 & !( 8 &0.9( 6 ,& &080,!#  "!++ %/!&0 &!((9 / +$ %

%7 44 %9 $+#!-&% 4/+ <9 9 $&% &/ $$!&3 0$%/!% 0!"$&9  4$;9 !" #!1/+!1$%  B % 4 1 & 3 7 & 9  / +$ % 0  0 
((

 & + 0$&!3 7 &9 / +$ %3 "!+ 9 1 0$ $!& &0#!&#$4$ $!&!"

9$%#!-+( ?A@  & ,$ 7 !" 9  /!%$$!& &! 0 3!, 8 9  $&% & / $$!& $% 0$%/!% 0!"$& +1%!"#!1/+!1$% B% 4 1 &0  0
((

 & + 0 $&! 3 7 & 9  / +$ % 3 "!+  9  1 0$ $!& &0 #!&#$4$ $!& # &+ 

#9 0 ! 9$% #!-+( !& &% !" 9  #!1/+!1$%   % 4 1 & 0  0 
((

3 + 0 &$& ;+ 4/ +!"9$%!+0 +( +$ % + 0$+ # 0! &%-+  09 + &#  ! 9   +1% &0 #!&0$$!&% !" 9  #!1/+!1$%  % 4 1 &0  0
((

8$&$1 3!-&01 && + %$&0$#  09 + $&( ?A@

$,$4 + ,$%$!& / $$!& % &0% 0$%/!% 0 !" $& 9 

"!+ 1 &$!& 0 +1%(
















 




((