High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/2487/1995dismissed

(O&M) Ramesh Kumar v. Karnail Singh & ANR.

2015-05-19Mr. Justice M.S. Sullar11 pages

!"#$ % &

$% ()*+" *,(" %!

( , -)!)*./ 0 ("1'

%+$ ,20. "%)%&)*,)*+"1,&- ( 1 %(" *( * %(" % !3*, *(! 5

''6 "%) *7)&$3( 1,&- ( 1 %(" *(! "%) $% 2" 71,&- ( %% !3*, *( 5'

''6

+$4 % -*,33 4!

*,'

% 2 )*+ , -), ,20(")!-*7$,+ *( !("

-(! *,(" 4 8)*&4& ,(" % )*

% (" !

,7$,)- ()* (" ! % +$4 %! -*, 4!20-* 7$,+ *( )! 4! * - !!

%0 % -4 %)(0 (" (( % *, % 2 (( % -3% " *!)*%-*& *) *- 1

-(!"

& 2 *( 9 * %

)* !"#$ %1, *(1% !3*, *(" % )*158" !+)& *$3&), %, %, ( ,:

68 !8* % 4 !$%)*+ * 4 %4 2 )*+: ;

("!"

% ! ;("!"

% (" (( 44 *,!)($ ( , )* &)44 + ,4 1 "!)4 "

* !

%1 )!(%)-( #$%$9!" (% 1 , ( )4 , , !-%)2 ,)*(" 7

*,) %(" 0 <' 4!)*(" 34 )*(1 " % )*

( % *()* , !(" !$)(4 *, "

,!4,(" !

),!$)(4 *,( !"#$ %1, *( 1 *(" % )*1&), % +)!( % ,!

4 , , , ( ,

% -*!), % ()* !1''';< 4*+ 8)(" 44 %)+"(!

33$%( * *(((" 4 *,4

# %* )4)*+"1% !3*, *( 1-4 ))*+ !$3 %)%%)+"( 8* %!")3"

, )4 , !$)(! 9)*+, -% 208 0 3% < 3()* :

*( "

,-*( !( ,(" !$)(((" *,* )4(8 -4 ) ,("

(!)*- (" 4 *,8 ! ((" () !

4 *,"

, 2 *% <-4 ) ,20(" & *, <, *(1 *(" % )*1)(8 !*(3% < 3()24 ( 8 ! -4 ) , ("

( (" 34

1% !3*, *( 18 ! *( *()(4 , % , -% 3% < 3()*(8 !-4 ) ,("

(!1''';<"

, 2 *!3 *(20(" & *, *% -4 ))*+(" 4 *," !$)(8 !-*( !( , 4 ))*+(" 3%)- (" 4 *,("

& 2 * )= ,)*+,

)(" -($ ),1 =)!( *- - $! -()*8 !, *) , )!)!!

4 (" !$)(8 !$+"( *% 34)- ()*1 %4) % !! %()*!)*(" 34 )*(8 % % )( % ( ,20 (" 34

*(" 34 ,)*+! (" 3 %() !1 448)*+)!!$ !8 % ! ((4 ,

% ,7$,)- ()*20(" 48 %-$%(*

6 >" (" %34

2 )*+ % %)*(" 9" 8 (-3%)!)*+ (" !$)( 4 *, "

! +( !$3 %)% %)+"( 3% < 3()*1

44 + ,? 6 >" (" %!1''';<(" !

4 3%)- !$)(4 *,8 )= ,)* +,

)(" -($ 4403 ),20& *, !"#$ %(

)* !"#$ %& *, ?

:6 )!!$ )!*(3%& ,1(" *8"

(8 !(" 3% & )4)*+

%9 (3%)- (" !$)(4 *,? %() !

6 >" (" %(" 34

!+( *4-$! !( *,)( )4 ("

!$)(?

6 >" (" %(" !$)()!*( )*( )* 24 44 + ,?

>" (" %(" ;("3% < 3()* $*("

!*(2 *, 3!)( , 2034

6 >" (" %(" !$)()!() 2 %% ,?

6 >" (" %34

)! !(33 ,20")!8* -( *,-*,$-(

% )4)*+(" !$)(?

6 >" (" %(" !$)()! * )1) !)(!

-(?

'6>" (" %)*(" & *( , -% !$)(1, *( )!

*()(4 ,(% -& %0 !1''';< 44 + ,40!3 *(*

-()*+ )3%& *( & % (" !$)( 4 *, ! 8 44 ! !( 3 % +)!(% ()*-"

%+ ! %(" 34

6 4) @ A), %, %, ( , 1 448)*+ ,,)()* 4)!!$ !"

4!2 * % ,20(" 48 %-$%(.<

<6>" (" %, *( "

!2 - 8* % (" !$)( 3%3 %(0208 0 ,& %! 3!! !!)*?

<6>" (" %!$)()!2 , %3 %() 43% < 3()*?

<6>" (" %34

!+(*- $! -()*?

( %% - )&)*+% 4 !8 44 !,-$ *( %0 &), *- %("

%() !1"

%)*+(-$*! 4 %(" 3 %() !8 4!3%&), ," %

( % "4,)*+(" % !3*, *(<34

(2 % %1)!!$ 8 !, -), ,)*

&$% (" 34

B)!!$ ! *,:8 % , -), , + )*!((" 34

)!!$ ! 11@1 1 *,8 % , -), ,)*

&$% (" 34

!!$ 8 !3 %(40, -), ,)*

&$% (" , *(!!$ !

<8 % , -), ,)*

&$% (" 34

C$ 4401(" !$)( ("

%3!! !!)*208 0 3% < 3()*8 !, -% , + )*!(("

, *(*3 0 *( !

4 3%)- !1''';< 4*+8)("!( 3 (" % -"

%+ ! *()* , )* (" , -% 8)(")* * *(" (" % %1 3!! !!)* (" !$)(4 *,8 !(2 , 4)& % ,((" 34

$,+ *(

*,, -% 8 !3 !! ,*:'

33 43% %% ,20(" & *, < , *( + )*!( (" !

), 7$,+ *( *, , -% 8 ! ,)!)!! , *

' 20,,)()* 4 )!(%)-($,+ 1#$%$9!" (% " , -% "

448 ,

")!, -% (" )%!( ( -$%()!$*, %-"

44 *+ )*("

3% ! *(% +$4 %! -*, 4 (-4 ) ,("

((" -$%(!2 48* )(" %

33% -) ( ,("

-(!*%(" 4 8 *,, !3)( ("

-(("

((" 4 *,)! *,("$!8 !*(3% < 3()24 1, -% 8 !3 !! , + )*!((" & *, < , *("

44 *+)*+ )*,)*+!*)!!$ (" 48 %-$%(1

)% , 20(" )%!( ( -$%(1)()!-4 ) ,("

((" *(8 !)*3!! !!)* (" 4 ,& %! 40((" & *,%(")!9*84 ,+ %(" 4 !( 2$('

%! *,(" !$)(8 !-44$!)& ((" )*!( *- & *,%<% !3*, *( ))4 %401 )*,)*+!*)!!$ !@( 4!

<8 % -"

44 *+ , ()! 4!34 , ,("

(%)+"((3% < 3()**(" 2 !)! -< !"

% %!")3"

,2 *)(( ,20(" 4 +)!4 ($% &), -( ' % *- "

!2 * , ( *,)*+-()* -()* (" $*7 2% < 3()*-(1 ()!-4 ) ,("

( *, *(- 8" *(" 48 3 *,)*+ *,%)+"( 3% < 3()*2 )*+3)% ()- 4* 42 )*+ -*()*$ ()* (" !$)(1)(8 !4) 24 (2 ,)!)!! ,()! 4!-4 ) ,("

( (" 4 *,!(,3 %()()* ,$-"3%)%((" , ( !

4 *,("$!%)+"(

3% < 3()* 8 ! & * (" %8)! * % !$2!)!()*+ )*

&$% ("

% !3*, *(<34

% 0 % %% & %!

4 (" )3$+* ,7$,+ *(! , -% (" -$%(!2 48208 0 -- 3( *- (" 48 ,

)!-*- %* ,1(" 4 *,(" % )* ! &)44 + # $4 3$%1 "!)4"

* %!

%1 )!(%)-(#$%$9!" (% A *,%< , *("

24)*+"1, *(@"

,!4, 0(" !$)(4 &), !

4 , , , ( ,

( , *(! ( % !

-*!), % ()* ! 1@1';< 4

( *(# $%1% !3*, *( " % )*1"

, !$+"( 3!! !!)* (" !$)( 4 *, 208 0 3% < 3()* -4 ))*+" %! 4 (2 % %)*(" 9" 8 (

" , *(!"

,-*( !( ,(" !$)(((" *,* )4 !3)( (" )%-*( !(1-4 ) (" 34

8 $*, %)( , *,8 -- 3( , $)(8 !, -% ,*@ 33 4 + )*!((" !

8 !,)!)!! ,

134 !( 9 *)*

& 4!2 *( 9 *

$%)*+(" -$%! %+$ *(!1 *(!)*2("(" 4!

& $%+ ,("

(%)+"( 3% < 3()**(" 2 !)! % %!")3)!* % =)!( *( *,%)+"( 3% < 3()*2 )*+3)% ()- 4%)+"(1- !( * *,

$%(" %2 *$%+ ,("

((" & *, !8"8 % (" ! 4& !

-<!"

% %!)*(" 4 *,("$!*%)+"( 3% < 3()**(" 2 !)! -< !"

% %!")3)*

&$% (" 34

!!$2!)!(!("

$%(" %2 *-*( *, , ("

((" 4 *,8 ! *,("$!8 !*( & *(" %8)! 3% < 3( 24

"$+"** % , %(" % !3*, *(!

( %

)* (")! 41 "8 & %1 -$*! 4 % -*( !()*+ % !3*, *( )* '

!-$*( % ,(" %+$ *(! (" *(! ()!

-4 ) ,("

(, -% "

&)*+2 *3 !! ,20(" 48 %-$%()*

&$% ("

% !3*, *(<34

!*(8)("!( *,)*+(" *, *()*(" -( 24)!")*+ %)+"( 3% < 3()* -<!"

% %1 !()44 *$% ! %(" 2 * )( ("

*,(" *, *(- **(3 % ( % (%!3 -()& 40 ()! $%(" % $%+ ,("

((" 4 *,8 !-$4()& 24 *,8 !*( *,("$!8 3% < 3()24 ( ($! (" & *, <, *(! !-<!"

% %!1 !"

!2 * -4 ) , 20 (" 1 "

! 2 * , *) , ( (" $%+)*+ ("

( %)+"( ("

% !3*, *(<34

!)!)*,

!)24 *,"

!(2 3%( -( ,

@ )+"( 3% < 3()*)! 3)% ()- 4%)+"( *,- *2 ,

( ,20

444 +)() ( *!1)! 3%3!)()* 4 88")-")! *,)!3$( *"

* )*+" *,(" %!& *,$ *,(" %!1

D 561)(8 !" 4,("

( (" 3% < 3()*4 8)! % 4)- $, 4)! *,-% ( ! -4+*(" %)+"(

(" 8* %(

4) * ( ")!3%3 %(0( 3 %!* ")!-")- *,("$!)!

@ & %08 9%)+"((8 $%(" %" 4,("

() (8&) 8! % 3!!)24 )* 3% < 3()*- ! 1(" * 8")-",

(!(" %)+"( 3% < 3()*)!(2

-- 3( ,

!! %()* (" & *, < *()!("

((" 4 *,8 ! *,("$!8 !*(3% < 3()24 ("

!2 * =34 )* ,("

((" 4 !% -4 ) ,20(" *( %4) %()(1)(8 !*(!$27 -(( -$4()& ()*>" *(")!34 (" & *, )! = )* ,*("

-($ 4 (%)= (" - ! 1)((% *!3)% !("

(3!! !!)* !3 -) )-3 %( 9"

!% :

;

68 !, 4)& % ,((" , *(" % )!-4 %40 (03+% 3")- 4 %%% )*, !-%)3()* (" 4 *,*(" 8%)(( *!( ( *(19"

!% $2 % ("

*,)!::

<7)*(% ,)*+

*,) %(" 0 < 5=

%(" 0 <'5= 6% & 4!("

(9"

!% :: 5 ;

6)!

8 & %1-30 3% 3 % ,*: ' '

5= :6% & 4!("

(!3 -) )-3 %( 9"

!% :: )*3!! !!)* & *,%

)* !"#$ %)!% -%, , !

!* ($% (" 4 *,)!

-*- %* ,1-%3! *,

% !"8*("

& 2 *"

%& !( ,

(8$4,2 % 4 & *(( *()*" % ("

((" !

4 )*,)!3$( (934 - *

B2 % (" !

4 (934 - 1+)%, %)5= :61 *()- , %4) %1% -%,!(" !$)(4 *,(2 -"

") !*: ' ' ' ()!(% *!3 % *(40-4 %("

((" !$)(4 ((" () !

(" !

,*% % )* ,(2 *,% (" %)("

, 4% ,0 2 *% -4 ) ,20(" & *,% )* !"#$ %3%)%((" !

4 % 4 ( !()*0 !" #$ % *(1 8" % , % (" -$%(2 48 > 1("

(

( %(" !

4 (" 4 *,)(8 % -4 ) , *,8 , -$4()& 24 1)! * & )42 - $! ,-$ *( %0 &), *- )* (( %!&$-" ,20% & *$ % -%,)!(( 9 3% - , *- & % % 4 &), *- $*( % 4 &), *- )* -*(% ,)-()* 8)(" ("

,-$ *( %0 &), *- )!(2 ( 9 *)*(-*!), % ()*$*4 !!(" % )!

3%3 % =34 * ()*-)*+ %(" %(" !

$*! 4 % (" *(<, *( ! 9)*+ !$33%( % *)* *,) &/9!"$)4, %! *,)* *-) %!D(,*,(" %! (-1

'1% %%)*+( -()* (" *,) *&), *- -(1"

!$%+ , ("

( ,)!!)*20 3 %(0)!!$2!( *()& &), *-

-( ,)(( ,20

%(0 -(! (" - ! )*"

% *()% 40,)

% *(4 ,)!!)*"

*(2 * , 20(" & *, < *( + )*!(")!8*)*( % !(2$()()!

! 4 <!(04 , ,)!!)*)*")!8*

&$%8")-"- **(2 -( ,$3* + )*!( (" & %8" 4)*+% & *$ % -%,3 % ()*+ + )*!((" & *, <, *( : !$

% % 3 ()()*1 % & *$ % -%, -4 %40 % & 4! ("

( % -4

()* (" 4 *,8 , 20(" & *,%$-" %4) %((" !

(" 4 *,("$! ((" () !

4 1)(8 !*% 4 *0

$%(" % !(" !

,2 *3$((-$4()& ()* *,"

,2 - 4 8" % $3*-%3 -"

%)"

,+%8* *,8 !"

%& !( , ()! -*- , ,

-(("

()*( %! -()*526 (" -(1

& *, )!+)& *%)+"( 3% < 3()**40)*% !3 -( 4 8")-"" 0"

& % -4 ) ,

( %)(8 !!4,(")*!"%(1* ($%

*,(2 , ( %)* ()& )!(2 ! * ((" () !

4 )*- (" !$)(4

4% ,0!(,% -4 ) ,3%)%((" !

4 )*

&$% (" & *, < *(1 (")!34 (" *( + )*!(3% !! ,4 +)() ( -4 ) 3% < 3()*

+)( ( ,20(" % !3*, *(<34

1)!*(( * 24 >" *(" % !3*, *(<34

)!% -%, , !-<!"

% %)*("

!$)(4 4*+8)("& *,% )* !"#$ *,7

*,) %(" 0 <

<'1=! :% !3 -()& 401 *) !(!(" 34

-<!"

% %)*(" !$)(4 *,1")!%)+"( 3% < 3()*- **(2 ,

( , @ 3 %( %(" % & *$ % -%,1(" % )!*( & * 8")!3 %

, *08" % 20 !"#$ > (("

-(("

((" % !3*, *(<

8 !*( % %)*(" !$)(4 *, %$!

4 !

4 , ,=

$%(" %% & 4!("

((" !

4 )! !"

% 4 -*!), % ()* !1''';<)! 4!!"8*("

& 2 * ),)*+,

)("()!-4 %("

((" !$)(4 *,8 !!4, %!1''';<1

8")-"* 08 -($ 4403 ), *,)(8 !(" %9 (& 4$ (" !

$%)*+(" 3 *, *-0 (" !$)(1 *, *()*(" -("

,4 ( (" -<!"

% %!")+" *,,%08" *(" )%%)+"( 3% < 3()*+% *( ,$*, % (" -(8 2%+ ( ,")!-*(%& %!0"

!% -" , & *((" *E24 3 =$%()*"0 $*, % *(" %& #$ *(" %1''

5:65)&)46 8" % )*)(8 !" 4,("

((" *, *(!)*(" $*7 % < 3()*-(1 :1 *, ,* 120 %0 * *, *( -(1 )!3%!3 -()& )** ($% *,"

!*% (%!3 -()& 334)- ()** @ 5F/65 %, 4)*+" *,(" %!&#)%$ (" %!61 % *, %)*+ , -)!)* *

'1 (")! $%( )* ($* 8)(" ("

7$,+ *( (" *E24 $3% $%( 4!C$()*+ =( *!)& 40 % "0 $*, % *(" %E!- ! 5!$3% 61-4 %40" 4, !$*, %.<

! "# # $

% &

'()*+ '(

'( ) # , " # - " .

/ )

, ()! -*- , ,

-(("

((" , -% %(" 48 %-$%()*

&$% (" % !3*, *(<34

)* (" 3% ! *( - ! 8 ! , * :'

1) 13%)%((" , ( *, *()*(" -( :' $%(" %34 (" *()!("

(" 8 !)*3!! !!)* ("

!$)(4 %(" 4 !( <'0 %!")! !! %()* (" *(<, *( )!*(-%%2% ( ,20 *0% & *$ % -%, !! !!)* (" & *,% )!

*) !( %(" % & *$ % -%,)*(" !"

3 7

*,)! *,(" -%3 )*!3 -()*% 3%( + %,)*+3!! !!)* (" *(<& *, ;, *(1 (" 48 %-$%(8 !%)+"()*-)*+( )% )*,)*+C$ (")! !3 -( :

" ( -$%("

4! *,%! ,(" )*,)*+ (" 48 % -$%(*(")!-$*(

: * < ) (" (" !

4 -*!), % ()*8 !(2 , 3!)( , !3% < 3()* $*(*%2 % : !3 %(% !$%0-"

*1!

), * 08 !, 3!)( ,)*(" (% !$%0* " % )!("$!*, 4 0)* -34) *- 8)("(" %, %! (" -$%(" % 8 !+%$*, !(33 4 )!!$ !* *,+& %*)*+ !(33 4 *,(% *!

-()*2 )*+2 * )1 & * (")! ,7$,)- ()*)!(2 + )*!((" , *(!8""

,% )! ,(")!34

2 - $! (" 0-$4,*(!$2!( *() ( (" !

8)("(" )% &), *- :: ))4 %401* )(" %(" % )! *0 ( %) 4*% &), *- ( 9 $(

- ! 3 %() 43% < 3()*" , *("

!*(2 * 24 (3%,$-

*0 &), *- (!"8("

((" !$)("

,2 * )4 ,20 3! $,*0 C$ 4401 *(*40(" 34

2 )*+ % %"

,4-$!!( *,)( )4 (" !$)(2$("

-$4, 4! )*( )* *,3%! -$( (" !

)*,)*+!% ($%* ,20("

%* ,48 %-$%(* 44(" )!!$ !

)% ,20(" )%!( ( -$%( ,*(!$

% *0

-($ 4%4 + 4 %%% : C$ 4401!$2!( *() 4C$ !()* 4 8E !(8" (" % *, *( 2%$+"()*(" $*7 2% < 3()*-(1 :&), -( ' 8)("

-( % 2%+ ()*+(" %)+"( 3% < 3()**(" 2 !)! -< !"

% %!")3E)! *!8 % ,(("

-(("

((" !

8)44"

& *403%!3 -()&

-( : *(" %!$2!( *() 4C$ !()* 4 81E !(8" (" %(" 4 *,)* 4)()+ ()*)! *,("$!)!$( (" 3$%&) 8 3% < 3()*E1 "

4% ,02 *" 4, %4) %1)! *!8 % ,(("

-(("

((" !

)!*( 2 !(" !

4% ,0!(,% -4 ) ,20(" & *, 2 % *( %)*+)*(3!! !!)*(" % :@

(1* *(" %)!!$ )! !(8" (" %& *, )! 4! -< !"

% %)*(" 7)*(9" 8 (8" % %)+"( 3% < 3()*!$2!)!(!1& *, < , *(! -$4, *( !( 24)!" (" ! 4& ! ( 2 -<!"

% %! 8)(" ("

% !3*, *(<34

)!-*- %* ,1 $* 9)*+"

!* "

+8 * )*+" )! % -%, , ! -<!"

% % 4*+ 8)(" & *,%

24)*+")*9" 8 ( *,)*( %! 7

*,) %(" 0 %

< : ), $* 9)*+""

,(% *!

%% ,4 *,$( ")!!"

% )*9" 8 ( *, ( ( *( # $% ("%$+" -)&)4 -$%( , -%

()! 4! &), *( %$( ()*@@5=6" % )!% ( !()*0 ( *(# $% !> ("

( & * %4) %((")!, -% 1!"

% %<!"

% % $* 9)*+" 4*+8)("( *(# $% "

,2 * 9)*+ 334)- ()*2 % (" !!)!( *(44 -(%)%!(% , 1 "

* !

%3 %()()* 9" 8 ( *,4

("$!)!3%& ,( 2 % %)*3!! !!)*)*3%()* (" !$)(4 *, :

!!( *, , *(! (:("

((" 08 % -< !"

% %! 3%)% ( (" !

4 *, ("$! (" )% !

4 8 ! *( 3% < 3( 24 )!

-*- %* ,1(" % % )& , *(!)* 44

*(! (: % !"8* (2 -<!"

% %!)*(" % & *$ % -%,2$(, *(!* *,- (2 !% -%, ,*40

( %7$,+ *( *,, -% , ( ,@: ' : & *("$+", -% , ( ,@: ')*

&$% , *(!

*,)!2 ! ,*

)40! ((4 *(1)(, !*(+)& 0 )44)3(("

- $! , *(! *,2 - $!

( %("

)40! ((4 *(13 %()()* 3%- ,)*+!-$4,"

& !( %( , -% )! @: ' C$ 4401$( )& & *, !1("% , *(! % -<!"

% %!8" % (8 % *( *(")!

!)($ ()*1 -*( *()* -$*! 4 % (" , *(! )! ("

( & *, - * 4 +)() ( 40,

((" 3% < 3()& %)+"(20 44 *!

*(!* 2 - -<8* %! (" 34

)*(" !$)(4 *,*40,$%)*+3 *, *-0

(" !$)( ' " , -% , ( ,@: '- **(2 % 4 ( ,2 -9(("

)40 ! ((4 *( 3% &)$! , ( 2 - $! (" % )! * &), *- $-" 4 !!

-% ,)24 -- 3( 24 *("

(-$*( ! ( & *, <, *(!8

%4) %-<8* %2$(% !( (" 8 % *(!1(" * & *(" & *, !8"

% -<!"

% %!4! 2 - $! (" 7)*)*+ **-<!"

% %! % *- 2 , ( %)2)*+"& %* )*+"1

D '@56

C$ 4401, -% != :( @3 !! ,*@: '1) 1,$%)*+ (" 3 *, *-0 (" !$)(- **("

& *0

-("$!1 )*,)*+% ($%* ,20

(" )%!( ( -$%((("

-(("

(, *(! (:8"8 %

4% ,0-<!"

% %!)*(" !$)(4 % )( ,(" )%%)+"((% !)!(3% < 3()& %)+"( (" 34

207)*)*+, *(! F 4*+8)("(" )*("

7)*(!

4 1)!$3" 4,

)% , ! % !$4( (" 2& ,)!-$!!)*!12("(" ! 4!

% --%,)*+40,)!)!! ,

0 1 + ) 2)

3 1 + 2)

4 1

$ 2)