Dharminder Singh v. State Of Punjab

 

  
     
  


  

 





   

  

  
  ! 

 


  !

 

        

  



  !"

 #!$ %&'%( )*+,-.

!



#

  %&'

( )   *+*'

 ,  (

-., ) +++/

 *' +' *+ 0

   *  *1 )
  1&0  '+2 .
"

 &/+  *0 $   % -     
      3 " $  4
5
 6 

 

-.,

7


    


   



! "#   $ %  !  %  &'     ( )  &( *  +))'  *, -'

-,! **./0 1 222(*'
 03*!

' 

'

& '
40



&

 '

5%4! ""  $
 2

& 6  

*'  2 *  04  (  7  #2  ' 8((9

2 *  04  :

 $  #2  8((9 '  %(  0  ; *) 4' )22;;#4   *  ) 0 ))(2*2!
:< 0 )2!&* "#   $'

( ) 4-2= 2) *2(0*04 *-)>> 3*        *  +*  :*)).*  % 4'

842 *8&0 &

 '&((2 0 ""

 " 04

"28 - "2

 2 = 24 22(2  4/4* * >

* > -22 *  :

%  = 2  *2  0.  80  244  (   2 = 4/4*0"?

(2*2)20*@*42 *2 ( (*20*'

  ))*. 4=/'

 = 20(*04 22 0*:* ) *(  )20*4%

= 2  2  80  02  ).'     = 2  .) 2   (  :

*  0))=*.  42  =  /  ! 2(*A 1 2 B1 16.2 '2)"

 ? 
* '#  2+* '# .

;*? ')/

44**? 
2 *C+(?  09 :*  4,*. +'4,8+ * 7  2*2 = *) *      %  0?4** /*2 */000*22 

*      *  %  +4 )  D9 4* *  (  4()  (  0    -/?4**  1   2  B1 1  6.  * - *  .2  *  4   () 2  - (/  )223*00*22 

*E '0'F2).:*2 .

G '

*/.%/.'*/) / 0%-1&( *( .-% 2%.'.'*/%3 8   

   +& 6 7  $6 

 

 

  

 :

 

 

 2 +' *+*  $  $  6 .       +% + *+**  $

    $ +' + *+*%  **   +'

   

+'

  ;$  $ 6   

 6 # 

/ 0%-1&( *( .-%

.1.% 3      

      6

 

# 

< #

$ 

 

   



   <     7  

 

  :

 

% /1&4)') (

$6 

  

+ 6 +& $ +/

6  

   

 -.,   +& 6 7  $6 

 

 

   :

 

 

 2 +' *+*  $  $  6  

 

 

$    +% + *+**  $

    $ +' + *+*%  **   +'

   

+'

  ;$  

 

  

 #   

   

 

,   



$ ;

 

=
 

  

   

 

   



  

 $

; ,  

$





7 80* 4* )(2) 04* ),2(*2 (24(*0***'4 **.-  (2*2 -)/-****)0*.)=/' *2 *2*4* )) == /2*2 2-* () * * 2=.

242(000*2 - 2 *4  *2* 04 0* 4* )  (2)   *  2(  0    00*2  E

*4( *0 04* ),2(*2 . *0- )2.* )) *(*. (2** , )    *   (2*    *   *  4  =/ 9(22*  *  4   =2    2  2  *  9(* 3*0* )'2402- 2(*()2 ((  / -*)22.0=2) 4 *4(2*2

-*.*   *0)*.(2%22*  *.4* ),2(*2 "%2*- . ** )0- )2*) 2*0,.*2*.  2-/*2' 920, )2* 2-*42--

) .*4-02*2*-2+ *- /.+**E' 2* ))2

*22*2(=**.- ) * 2 (2*  2    .  *.      *    0 2  *  *   42 *20  2

@)2*2(*.' 4*.0 2 *- *2  2  =    2  = 2  2  *.

*/2.

*2  =*     (2*  ( (2   2    -2 ((*     4(  =    /*    *0)*

  =*222  :0    */2.

*.  00  2  *  0*   *22  2 * 2(2**.*/2.

*2'

2*. 22)-4 0() *. (2** , )2 0  .220)4) )'2 4( * 2 *= 2= 2( ( *.

**/2.

*22 20 *0*/2.

*.

00  *  = 2  *  -2**.    *  (( *.  =* F-*/2.

*.00)'0 * 22 **.04*/2.

*.002*. 24.** *9(220 0-*./42'=) -   0       ,.  =)  *    *2  * 

(((    2  :  2  )2  *22   0    ,.   *2= 22 02?400* -* 2000*2 *02'* 02 00*2 *2.* )*%(/ 4*.*2 20 * 22 )2 *94) 4( *0  */* ) 4* 2

**0- *( *. *D9() *2* "

0+0 +4* )  '  7B"  8*  F ))  20  ((    *  *   2  -*  

*  -   ) 4*  -  *2*.

2* "

8*+0+4* )' 7B" $%(2)' 4 * 2F-

(- ,.'=) )*.= * (() *0 4 **. 22( * 2(2*()2   , )  2  %    2/ )   2*2  0  2 *)*.  4 * **.    .*  0  *  2  (2*'

=2/( (2*4.-'F4*20 8)   0    +*2*  *    0        2 *42 /=*. *  (2*2' ) *.  2 ) * (-)42 2*-2+*:*?:*4 +**2* "1 2*2'  B ++4* ) 

!

 B$ *8(9I.4*28I  1!  B  ++

$1

%2 )- .*0(/2*0- ) -*) - ) *))9() ** *2* )/*
 2%  * /3**0:* '  B  " +8<D 7.*.-  20# .* + 

5 :*     2*'  0*  = 2  4     -

2  *. -- / 0*, -' 71  ++$ $*=2 -2/ = 2)= - *
.* /6*.?

D4('  8:  7

 + )     - )  2  *    - =)  2   (*24*  0*  = 2  )2  4    D4(/*2*'8: 7" 8)) - "$ =* = 2-2/ . *0- )2) *02 )2 9(*%(/2*0- )20 .?) * )- )*( *(/2*0- )2 )42

*)'.*.- )* ) 2 B=/'=2)*-*24 * - ) 2)-. **/ 2%. *02 )0- ) 2 *) =*  2*  0   ,.  *.    *. 2*2*0'42- 92  ,2)  *  *   4 *  4 **  * 4( 22* )8)2'**20. *0- ). *-22 2-* ( -)04() *'-

*.. *0- )))2G !  

  

 

 $       

  

 

  

   " .

!    

  

$  ;

=!

"



 #$ !

 %& 

'

 (

(

(

   



 7 

7      #

      6 $

     

   $     $ 

   6  

$

 

    

  

 

",77*01 %7*+**  )'* 

+   %, 

 *-  

+* +' *+*'        " .

  

     $     #



 $

:

6    



  #

  



   



 

 .  6    

    6  >  

  6  



 

!



. 

   $  

6

     $    6    > 6   

. 7

$ 

6 

<

$  6       ;  $ 

#   !$  



 * 4
.

@2(

*. 2* E2
 @( -) E2