Shangara Singh v. Piara Singh
!
#$%&%&'
()
#* #$#+$, - $)%&%&'
./#("
#$0%&%&'
0 12 %
3 42
!" #
!$ !" # 3 42
% The appellant has invoked the jurisdiction of this Court through the present Regular Second Appeal (for short, 'RSA'), assailing the judgment and decree dated 13.12.1994 rendered by the learned District Judge, Hoshiarpur, whereby the judgment and decree dated 29.09.1992 passed by the learned Sub-Judge Ist Class, Hoshiarpur, stood reversed in appeal. The impugned appellate judgment, which unsettled the findings of the trial Court, has been challenged on the grounds of legal infirmity, misappreciation of evidence, and erroneous application of settled principles of law, thereby necessitating scrutiny under &#& !
" '
(&&)*.
+ ""
" "
, ## - " # ." # ./0%%%012 " . 340 5 # " 6 # # ! ₹ # . .# " # 3 ///7 " # .#6" # .8 .
# 9 .## 6" # +2/%%011 +% 8 ## ## .# " " "/2/%%011" #
# 6" #%0/%%011: ! # # ";
+2/%%011
## .### "# 9 #6 # .# 8 ##". !
## "# /</+%011 #
++ 8 " " ## ## !
!
"
"# " .# 9
.6" " ## !# 8 ##" " # . # " " .#" %='"*# " # " 3.
5 " " # " ! ! # #
##)" . . ! 6"
" ! 6" 8#. /1%%%012 : "# .. "" . ## "".
" " ! "> # "
- . " : 5 # %%// . 5. " # ## >" .! "8# " # ## '?. *
- ".
## " ". " " "
"# . #! # ##:! .- .
".
" "
. . . " - @ 5" ! # 6 !" " 8 ## # .
9 !" "! >" ! . " . . .
" . . # " . " 8 !. # . ".
! ## . # ##) !
"##"" @% "" 6 !" # ! - . "
# " !
& . !" B !" ! 9
> 5 # " "
> " > "
" !
. . & "" # .# # .
! "
# $
%
# &
'
(
$ ) '***+,
& ) 3 5 9 # .
# # ## # # ..
"
" ! ". !
" " ! "" " A ".
# !
" # - 6 ! " > ! # " " "
#.
!"$ &
" >."
3%
! > 7#
#
8 C
& ".
!
##". 6
"9 ! >."
D ".#
" 3+ 8
"& # - > " # .! #. " "" 5 "- 9 # #" "" # ! .
!
" & !
! " # # !
"
= # # > !
#
# . . !
! !-> " # & A " #
.#"
" # " & #
## " " 9 . ##> . &9 . .
# =+ 5# " # " #
" " . !
"
# # . 8 )" ".. " . . #
# #
& "# # "
=< 8 !.
" B ## 9
# .
# !" .
& =@
"
# 6" > " ! ! # ".
! " " .
#9
"
' * " # & ... " "# & 2 . # >
5! "# " ! "" . # 6 .
!" "6 # . -# " # ". !
"" "" # "
& 2% 8 " # & " B . "" " 6 ! # # >." 6 > " # . # ! .
#!
"#" . # " & 6 "
#
> " 1
" #"
# >: "
#
" @%#>& " %0%1 " %//&&# " ".
>.# .& "#
# >. "# ! "
# $
%
"& $ # >. 9 # 9 # . 0 . # > " .
"#
" C
& ! . " " >.# D ! .
">" 5
. # " #! 6" . #! # ## ! . . # . " " 0+ 8 !" 7# . " "
# " " .
!
"" "" .8 C
& >.
! .
. ">" ! - 9 !".
!
" ! 6" # . ##) " # . 0< 5 #! .
! C
& !
# "# " # " &
" # #
#!
"" 6 #"> # " %/ .# ".
!" " "# >.#
"D : . " " # " "".
!
# #!
" " 5 # .
"D# # #" #". 6#" " 6 #
# " & %/% ? " C
& ! & )>. & # > ! ". ! " " 6" # . #
## # . "#"!
"#" "
&9 .
# # & . " #"
#
"- . ! .
%% 8
"D " # . 6" " "
. # ". .# "
9 "" F# " " " #".
.
: . - " " . " '*"" 9 E #)! " #
& !
& !
!
""
## " " " #"
. .
!. -!# .
" "
# . "
. .#6" 8
"D !" " " .#
!#"
#.
. "%/</. - ! 1,0. " . ?. %%% 5 "
7 ##9 !"
!6" # .6.
"
E% -! " %<+ /0%%%012 . ?. - 6" # . #! #
##5 7#
%%+ E C
& ! ".
"# 6" # . 9 "" !
" " " ".# 9 " ## ".
" """ " " 5 "#" # " "
"
6" # . #! # ## . "# " %%< C . " 7# . -# .$ : "## ## "".
!.
" ! ! # /1%%%012F ! 7# # 6.
#.!
" ! 6 6.
" .5 #.
" C
& . G6% 6" 7# ! .
" "
. # " # !# "
9"#! !
. " # .! " . " .. F" " "
## "" # %%@ " 9"#" ! 9 " %0=3# .# ₹ ₹ + <// # +3 " # 3 ///". "6##.
.
. !
" " F " " 9 .
# " # .6"/0%%%012
%%3 8
"D#
" .
" #.
#"6" # .5 ₹ "
7 ## .# 3 /// 7#
"# 9 !" .
# 6" . /0%%%012"
.#.
"6 # 9"#" .. "" ! # .8 ."" !
! " . #"
E%-!
. ?. - 7# # " .
!
" .5!
## # "
"D 8 D 5 & : 7# 6" . #! # ## . # . " " . " # ."# ./0%%%012 "# # &9
F
>. "
" D : >." # D5& : 8 # ## " .#" D5& :
%+ &9 "" !> #
"
. .
" " "
# "" " #" 5!
# .
"" 9
"#"
" "". ".
" ! ## "9"
3 42 %&%&'
(+ (!
# #) Whether reasoned / speaking?
Yes / No Whether reportable?
Yes / No