← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/11952/2020disposed of

Ishu Grover @ Isha @ Golu v. Union Territory, Chandigarh And Another

2020-03-30Mr. Justice Harnaresh Singh Gill5 pages



      

 !"#$# %&'('( $)* +,-$)*- .*  //(

# %, 0,$*$

((1) ), /(( $4 %2% $  

    

,$% & ,(5) 8#%3)12+ "

1! , )4 # %,(   

 $ ) $ 5%

9% *4 ! , ) ,#%3 ), *3) +#2  " %!,%"#%3(

6, #% ) 4,$%  4 # % !#.2 *%2, 8"

# % :; ,( ((#$! ,#$$* %" ! 44, 4,#

2#,"

# %$ )$*5 ,2#%

7*2#"# . ) ,# #$ ) . "

.

# % ! , 5

" ,2#%

= ,9 "" ,2#%3 )3*#2.#%$#$$*256  %>5.8*4,< *, )#$ *, (  #$ )"

$ ! )4 # %,

#%   (:'2

:(( ,3#$ ,2 *%2, 8"

# %$ '?@:  1

.#"

# %18"

,'1) ,)1)= $3, 2,3*.

,5 #.56 22# # % .#$ *231) ,) %(((8 #..!*, ),1 #% ), "

$ 5 ,#%3    ( ? 2

2 (( ,3#$ ,2 *%2, 8"

# % '?  

  .#" 8

# % 8 ,1 A) ,1 # %,= $3, 2,3*.

,5 #. %'('(56 )8$$# %$



*23188 ,( #$1) =+,1$

)$ #2 ,2,$) + %# ),5%*4.

22% ," 4#$ ), !) +5%4, +#22 # %,( #$1 )*$14.

22

#%*

,#3% , %" ! ) ,2,$ 3, #%3,3*.

,5 )4 # %, %2+ ,# *$3*#2.#%$#$$*2 56 )  %>5. 8*4,<  *, 1 ) 4 # %, ) $ % 1 #.. 2

1 5% ,.

$2 % 5 #.( % )#$ 5 "93, *%21 ) 4 # %, ) 5$#2$1< 9#%34, 6,! ,)#$,.

$ %5 #.1) .$ 4, 62! , #$$* %" !+ ,# *$ ),2#,"

# %$#(( #$$* ,.# 5.") %%. ," %

%*<5,@< #.$ 5!.

$)2 %2"#,"*.

< %3 3%, . 4*5.#"B  *42

) " %

$ ! *2#"# . !!#",$ % 2* 6 % ,$4"

#+ 2 6$ . %3 =# ) )#, " %

 %*<5,$@<

22,$$$  % ) !!#"# .=5$#  ! )" %",%2#$ B 94 )=5$# $ !. "

.

%2$*5 ,2#%

7*2#"# ,6 *4 2

 =# ) ) ,"%  2+. 4<% $ .#9 *42

#%3 "

$ $

*$1 %C  5*$#%$$ 2

%2 *4.

2#%3 , ) %2#%3 +, ,2,$4 $$25! , , % )2

1 ). "92 =%= %% *%"2(

"(  #"#$% 5#%3#$$*2 ),$4 %2% $8

$1! ,

) , $ %

) 2#,"

# %$ 4, 62 ! , 56 ) 4 # %, 3%, .#%%

*,2* ). "92 =% )"*,!=#<4 $2#%

)= 9 ! ) * 9 ! +#2( )4 # %,) $$ *3) )#$ .3 .,2,$$ % "" *% ! %  5#%3 ,.

$2 % 5 #. 2$4#  ) +#%3 5% 3, 2 ,3*.

#. 56 )  *,

 ) %2 88  ,(  *,#%3 " *,$ !) ,#%31.

,%2" *%$.! , )4 # %,) $2, =%

# % ! ) *, = ,2$ )% #"*4.

22 % )=5$# ! )88 ,1=)#")= *.2, $*%2,&

'

D $ ,3% % #!#"

# %2

2('(( $ 4, 2#,"

# %$ !  %>5. #$ %2 8$$# %$ *23188  ,1 ) !!#",$ %2 $

!! 2#,"

2 %

%2 " *,  #% +#= ! ,$ # %$ #<4 $2 #% "*,!=( .. 2* 6 !!#",$ #%".*2#%3 2$

%2 3#$

$=#..= ,9!, <) <( ,$)!#.#%3#$ ". $2$ #! %6$

6<

, ,5 44(#$,"#+2

2* 6 !!#",>$ ) *$ )@$) < 6 4 $$ 44, 4,#

,2, "" ,2#%3.61 #% ) <

,(  $$  5

9% *4=((!('@' '@'@1#!%

9%*46 2* "*,!=1=#..5

9%*4 %2=)% %6,.

#%"*,!== *.253#+% , $4,!*, ),2#,"

# %$ !, <  %>5. #3)  *, ( !!#",$@$

!! = *.2 5 #%! ,<2 "" ,2#%3.6(%"

$ ! %6<,3%"6 %6 !!#", , )#,$

!!< 6" %

8*42 @@@ E2.(#$ %28$$# %*23188 , ) .#(F  =+,1 ), #$ %  2

#. ! .4) % %*<5,$

%2 < #.$1 ! ) 8*42 @@ @ E2.( #$ %2 8$$# % *23188 , ) .# ) !!#",$ %2* #$( A4#%3 #% +#= ) 4,+ #.#%3 $#

# % #% ) " *% ,6 % "" *%  ! ) * 9 !

%2<#"  +#21 %2 !*, ),

9#%3 #%  " %$#2,

) 3*#2.#%$ #$$*2 56 )  %>5. 8*4,< *, ),562#,"

#%3 )$

" %$#2,,.

$#%3 $ <4,#$ %,$ %4 , . ,2*" +,", =2#%3#%4,#$ %$12< 44, 4,#

2#,"

)8*5 ,2#%

 *, $#% )8

$ !

*%7 51 ,6 ((1) ,.

$ ""*$21=)  + ., 26 5% 3, 2 5 #. # ), 56 )#$  *,  , 56 8*5 ,2#%

  *, $1 % 5 #. % !*,%#$)#%3 )#, 4,$ % . 5 %2$ =# ) *  %! ,"#%3 ) " %2# # % ! $*, 6 5 %2$@5 #. 5 %2$( !  *,$1 " %2# # %"

%5.

#22 =%

=)% )$#

*,%$

 5 % ,< .1 ""*$2 = *.2 5 5 *%2  !*,%#$) $*, 6 5 %2$@5 #. 5 %2$( % $*")  4, "$$1 ) #$   8$$# %$ *23$ #% ) 8

$ ! *%7 51  ,6 ((1 ) ,)1 $) .. #$$* 44, 4,#

 2#,"

# %$ ) 4 .#" ) 7

) ,# #$(E#9=#$1 )#,"

,$%, . ! ,#$ %$ )

:

8*4,#% %2% $ ! ),8

.$ 2#,"

" <4.6 =# ) )2#,"

#+$#$$*256 ) *, $(  =+,1# #$< 2".

%6 ""*$2!, < )7 $) .. %.6 5 ,.

$2 !

, " <4.6#%3 =# )

#+ #%$ ,*"

# %$@3*#2.#%$#$$*2#%+#= ! ) * 9 ! +#21 #%".*2#%3< #%

#%#%3 !$ "# .2#$

%" %24,+% #%3" <<*%# 6

%$<#$$# %( #.. !*, ),1 ) #$   8$$# %$ *23$ #%

$ ! *%7 51  ,6 ((1 ) ,)1 $) .. < 9 <") %#$<1".

,.64, +#2#%3 % )#, !!#"# .=5$# $1 )" %

%*<5,$ %2 < #.$ ! ) $@* 6  3#$

$ , ), *2#"# . !!#",$ % 2* #$ $ 

) " <4.# %" ! ) ,2,$ 3, #%35 #." *.25< 2()6 .$ 2#,"

*4.

2 ,2,$4 $$256 ) *, $#% )#,,$4"

#+8$$# %$#+#$# %$1 5! , , % )2

 !. "92 =%( =+,1=)#.2 #%3$ 1 ), $) .. 5 $  " <4.# %" ! ) 4,"

# % ,6 < $*,$ "#,"*.

256 )#$ *, #% )= 9 !

%2<#" +#2(  " 46 ! )#$ ,2, 5 "#,"*.

< %3$ #$ 8$$# %$*23$1#% )8

$ ! *%7 51 ,6

((1 ) ) #,"

,$ %, . ! .#"1 #,"

,$ %, . ! ,#$ %$1 )  #. 8*4,#% %2% $1 ! ),

$ ! *%7 51  ,6 ((1 ) ,)1 ! , $ " <4.# %"( #$4 $2 !( '('(    

2$ !  G) ),84 9#%3@

$ %2& $@  G) ), 4 ,

5.& $@ 

 

      

  

      !"" # $%&"' (    ) )'  *+ ",   "  ,", *"- "    .

 .

    "," '"' ( ""'   ( *)  *"   /0 + '"/","","&","1)"   "",   !2)& 3+  $%& "'& " ,,   "1) &.

 .

"*""  4  "   ( *)  *"   /0 + '"   /"," ",  "&  ( *)  *"   5("05+* ", +","67()+ "",85"/') "(+","1)" "",85" "5!2)&3+$%&"'

 

 

    !