Mohinder Singh And ANR. v. State Of Haryana
# $$%% & '('
#"# )"*"
+ $ + ),%+-. ++- $ '
# (/ #0 "
1 & "2 34"# '2 "55 "
# +"
(0"(#"/2 34"# 2 "55 "
# 0"("3"
'"202)"*"
" 666
55 "
#'
05"1 " "' ( "3 #
' "55 " "!"
'# # 7( !/ # "# 8 "
4 "# 9 5"'' :* # 4(# " " ''
'-( ! 21"
"2;
:*# *; 4 4# ( 4# $"# " ;
4# $2 "
'
4 # ( ! !('
/5 ' #(* "'"
#5"*
<2= "4
"(## (# ( ! !(' /5 ' ##;/ '
4"' # 5' 4(# ' :"' (5 '#"# / >?$@ /" :* " 3 >$A@2 # "
( +"/ >$A8@
9 '#"# / #2'
" ! # "## "'##;* "'2 '#' 1(/";"' /5* ;
"44('
"#
'": & #;B"5 ":(# / ' 4( #
"##
' (# ' ( #
''"
" "'! #:
!/ )" ;" "# "*2 9 "#":(# $2"55 "
#'
"44('
05"1 " "' (4"/ ## ('
#44('
"'B 1"/"1(/"> (':"
#@"'#;
*
'' 1(/";"' #4/
! (#*2 ( #;
';B;"''(
!1"/"1(/"'#"# # "#
''
$"B"'
1(/";"' #
!; "
*;( ' ## #
"44( #'
;
'##
'2"44('
!#"
* ) 4"(!
"
5 '' # 4B1"/"1(/";
C"
;
# 4"(!
# 1"/"1(/""
'#"# !
:;'
'2;
## # '4( (':"
1"/" 1(/"2"44(' 05"1 " "' (5('
";"*"
"#
##
"
' ""/2;
"##"4#
:( >$A<@"
1(/"2;
'4( 1"/"1(/"/#
4(#4 '# "44(' # "44(' "
";"*;
?#
!# "#'
##
#5"#* #"B
!4" 1"/"1(/"2 ;"'(
" 4# /"*: #"B "!"
'## #'
"44(' # 4
!# " '"
'#"# / #2 "
(+"/ /"
' / #>?$=@"
'
#(D"## $ 4 #"# 2 :"'
;
/"+>?$=@;"' 4 "# 2 "
(+"/ "4 5"4 44( 4 25 5"
D( '#54
!'>?$-@"
(!
'
# 5"
# 5"4 44( 4 >?$1@2 4 #
'#"# / #'# ;
'' '"
'
## " : *1"/"1(/"# )'5 #"21"
"25'#/# / ?"/
23 "55 4"# >?$)= @ (#
3 '# !"# # 4"' ;"' 3 #$("
'5 4#= )>$A@2;
4 # '(55 / #"*'#"# / #' 4/5"
* ;
'' ' 1(/" /5"
'(55 / #"*'#"# / #2'#"# # "#;
"44('
05"1 ; (
!";"*/#
'5#2"44(' & "+"
"'B # /#
(' "
'
;( 5(#"4B(#'
:"'
'#
''#"# / #2 4 '( 4# $; " 9 2"# "44(' ;"'
" '#
'4"' '"/ "*2# 4"' 55 #*;"' 5'
# ;
) 4" '
# 5"
5"4 44( 4 ;"'!#5 5" / '#": +"/ ;"'>$A9@ # 4/5 #
3 '# !"# 2# 4 ""
;"' "!
( 4# " ;
4# $;"'"/ "!"
'#"44('
"
05" 1 >"55 "
#'
@2 "
4
"44(' & "+"
;"'4 "! '
# ( 4# $#
"44(' #5 " !( #*"
4"
/ # " < '(55# #' 4"' 2 # 5' 4(# ?"/
3
;
'' '
$A $ +"7 ) " '#": 2 $A '#": (
1(/"2$A ("#1"
# 2$A9 '#": +"/ ;"'2$A )";
+"/"
$A '#": &
" # /";
'' ' 8 $A >4/5"
#@2;
';
# 4 "' 2 # "# # 3 '
2"''#"# :*
'#"# / #>?$@2 ;
;"'/" :* 9 9 $A<
:( #
#2 '# * ;
''# 44( 4 (*'(55# # 5' 4(# 3 '
$A 1"BB"2;
" !;
#;# 4#'2 4 (4# "(#5'* " : * 4 "' 1"/"1(/"253 #
5'#/# / 5## 4 "' "'?$) '#"# # "#"# 4 5# 5# %>?$@"
5#$"# !* 5"#/ #>?$0@2
'"44/5"
*
!#; 4#'2 "55 4"# 5 >?$)@3 5
>?$)=@5
"## 5''
:
#* "# ( # 4"
4'
4B4( #: ( (# $A8 "
(+"/ 2;
4 (4# #
"
3 '# !"# 4"' 253 '#"# / ##
#>?$@2
' / #
'"/ >?$=@2/"+>?$= @2
D( '#54
!'>?$-@2 (!
'
# 5"
5"4 44( 4 >?$1@"
"55 4"#
>?$)= @3 ;
" : * 4 "' 1"/"1(/";"''
## )'5 #"21"
"25'#/# / ?"/
$A $("
'5 4#2 ;
4 (4# # (#
3 '# !"# # 4"' 2 "' '(55# # 4"' # 5' 4(#
!"
!"
! 4 '( 4# ' $2 :"'
'(55 / #"*'#"# / #'4/5"
2"
* ;
'' '
1(/"2 4 :*
/) (# '#"# ":(# " '#"44(' & "+"
"'53 # # 4(/ #'5 5" :*
/ (
3 '# !"#
'#"# / #' 4 ( 4# $2"#
"44('
4
! 3
4 "55 "
! "!"
'# # / "
5 " #
4 4 *#B# 5 "# "#1"/"1(/" (
"#(" "# * "3 :
"' * /5 4"#
'4"' #!":#
/ *
<
4 2# "44(' ?"/
+"/$"2A" 2 (:-"
2 1"
"2"'A2;
5 (4 # !
'# !"
!# 3 #';
; "; #/ ## 7"
/"# ' # "
! " $(: 4$' 4(#"
" 4( ' 2"
4
!# 3
4 "3"
": 4 2;
*
(5 / 4" 3
4 2;
53 # "#5''
:
#* "# 1"/" 1(/" ( #4" !
4'
4B4( #: ( (#C"
'#"# / #' 4/5"
"'; "' * ;
'' C"
#
4 2 # # " 4(# 4 4# "
'
4 # "55 "
#'2 "'
'#5""# 7( !/ #); 3 2"44(' & "+"
;"'"4D( ## # 4 "! 2;
:' 3
!# "#3 '
4/5"
"#"44(' & "+"
4"/ '5#"
":( #
"55 "
#';
*; (
!";"*"# 4// ##
!# 4 / '"
/53 / #2"'# 3
4 4 # "#"44(' & "+"
" # B ; ! # "# # "55 "
#' " 4// ## # 4 4(5": / #"/(
!#/( < "3 " " 4( ' # #'"
"
''
'#"
# 34"# 0 "2)"*"
"2"
"3 5 (' # 4 #
4"' % " 4( ' # #'4 "#"44
!# 5'
$A 1"BB"2"## / 4 (4#
!5'# /# / ?"/
" : *1"/"1(/"2 /"B' ?# "
7( '; '
': *## / #"B
!(#'
#/ : *# 4 "' 2 #;"' #
"# 4
2;
'4 #"*# 5'
$A4/5"
2;
'#"# # "#'
#
(':"
1"/"1(/";"'# :*# #'
'4 #"
4#
;'# "##
# "55
/"
2"' ""# :*#
5' 4(# ;
4 "# ' (:#
5' 4(# 4"' '2"'5 #
5#$"# !* 5"#/ #>?$0@2# 4 "' ;"''(
!/
"# ' "' ) (# 4 "# # ;"' /# 3 #
"55 "
#'#B 1"/"1(/"2"'# *; # "3
!5 3 (' #* ;
/ " 3" (' '4 5"
' "
/53 / #'
'#"# / #'# 5' 4(# ;
'' '$A4/5"
# '# "#"55 "
# 4"(!
1"/"1(/"/# 4B2 #'#"# !
! '#"
:;'#
/ #"*##
'2 $A< 5' # "#"55 "
# " 4"(!
# "# 1"/"1(/"2;
;"'*
! : 2"
# ;"'!
! '# :;'#
/44(' & "+"
;"'
# (4 :*4/5"
"# :*/"B
!"'(55 / #"*'#"# / #2"
# "' 2
'(:'#"
4
5' 4(# '#*2'
;"'"4D( ## :* # "4(# 8 !" ## D("
#(/'
4 2 " 4( ' #
"55 "
#'"!( # "## #'" ";":
!4 "3
4
" 4 # 4
"4"' 2 ?4 5## 5 '
# '5
"!"
'## / *" "4
!5#"4# # "/ # <* "' * " (
/ #
2 4 4#
"55 "
#' ' (5 2 "
# 3 ; : #"B ;
4
! #
/5(!
'
4 5"'' :*# " # "4(# 9
'4"' #B5"4
* "
:"4B!( 4"' '# "## "'##;* "'2$"B"'
1(/"'
#;"';B
!"## ": #;B"55 "
#2"
"5 ":(# / ;"' #"##
' (#*;
(#"
*
/"# #"55 "
# "*
#2 9 2#
"55 "
#' ;
# # # (' # 4/5"
# " 3
(':"
1"/"1(/"#B ;# "'
' 1(/" # "##
' (#*2"'# ": #;B:('
''"55 "
;"'
'(
!/# ":3 5' 4(# '#*2 ' 3
## "#: !
## (' #
#2:# #' " / ' "# 4// #"
*4
""4## '"' 3
#/# '#"# / #$A 4/5"
"# ' 1(/" " #5"*'/ / *## #'"
# "# "' (':"
1"/"1(/" "''( # /# "# ;( ' ## #
"44( #';
'#
/"## ' B
# "
4 4" (*2 #
* 4 4('
;
4"
: ";
'# "# 4 "' 1"/"1(/"/ #: "
"#5"#
#"
/"* "3 ( #
"#"
/ #2: 4"(' "'5 #
5# $"# !* 5"#/ # >?$0@2 5 '
#"# 3 / 4' 4# ?"/
/ #" "' "#'
; 4 ! '4
4 '4
"# ' "' #""
4 "*"# ' '
; / "# # /"B '4# 44 ! '(## "# (4B# #'#B# /# (' #
#"
(':"
1"/"1(/"#B ;#
"'
' 1(/" #"##
' (#*"
"/
"# 4"# #B5"4 2 (
!;
#'/ "3 !
"5('
'/ :;'#1"/"1(/"2;
'(#
# ?"!! "#
"# "
/ # "
! #
' "# (!
* /"* # : 4#* '5 : # "# 1"/"1(/"2:(#4"
# '4"5 #
"## :(#
' "# 2
4 5
'4(#2 /5(!
7( !/ #4 4#
!# #'( 4# $"# " ;
4# $ ' # D( "
*
# 4 .
'5(# *2 :# "55 "
#' "3 4
" :"4B !( " #"4
!4
"54
!'
*# 4"' 2 ?4 5##
5 '
# A
!
!## (' #
#"
(':"
1"/"1(/"> 4 "' @2"' '4('' ":3 2# *; "3
/ ' "
# #
#"
*4
""4# #*5 ('"#
# 4(#* "#
9 2;
:*'
4 :# #';"''('5 :*#
4(#2 3 "' # "# # * "3 " " * ( ! / ' "4#(" 4 */ "3 " '/ / ''
"' *" "4
5#"4# # "# "'#":(#<* "'
!"# ' "4#'2 "/# 5
"## '7('# 4 ;( : / # #
'
4
/5 ' ' (4 ## 5 " " *( ! 2:* 4#
!# # /"B 5"*/ # '/ 4/5 '"# # # : "3 "/ * 44
!*2
3 ;# "4#'"
4 4(/'#"
4 '#
'#"
#4"' 2:#
"55 "
#' " 4# # /"B 5"*/ # < "4' "4 "'
4/5 '"# ##
#2;
';
; 4 "' 1"/"1(/"2 ;
"5 #;/ '/# "# 5 ( 4 / ##
7( !/ #2"
!;
'#"
#"55 "'
"'#"
'/ ''
' D( #*2# "55 " '5' ;
/ 4"#
/5(!
'
4 2 # # ?# # # "# # '
4
/5 ' #";" ## #':*# # "4(# ' (4 ##
5 " " *( ! 2'(:7 4###
/"B
!5"*/ #<"4'
"4 "'4/5 '"# #4/5"
# " 3 >;
; 4 "'
1"/" 1(/"@ ;
" 5 #; / ' / # "# 5 ( 4 / ##
'7( !/ # !"#!$%!& '
( )
'5 "B
!= "'
F '
+ 5#": F '