← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/15142/2023dismissed

Kxxx v. State Of Haryana And Others

2024-03-05Mrs. Justice Manisha Batra10 pages



IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATES OF PUNJAB AND

HARYANA AT CHANDIGARH

   



 ! " #  $ %  & 

'  ( $ )*+,- #

./#01- ()1#$( +(0( 



     

    



  

 ! "   #

 $ %! 

 ! &  

 % '    $ (

()1#$( +(0(2 .

 )

*    +     ,-. /  / +   #          0   10 *! 



  + !          !  0 

1' $ ..,  23 2- .2.. 0   4.- 435   1/      ,2 0!

.

6        ! 1' # 0   # !  +! +  7!  8&9  

 

00    "

 .2..   0  60   0 #  !  ! 0!      !   ' # #             

 0!    #

: ..

.2..      0!   !     0! # #  0  60  #  + 

 !             #    !   ;   #    0 : .4 .2..         + 2<22 

   #    ! *  #  4.

    =   0 !  0     ! 6      0   #     !0 #      0    ; !0  #  0 >>     # 0 =        # # 0  0 !   #    ! 00  ! ;0 +  !!0 #0  #  :         +      =  +!0 !      #  

0       0   0  

 0   1' 0 0 #  *         ,4- /  /  0    + +  ! # !    2< 2< .2..  +    "0 ?

*/@ 0!

*       +  / +0   #+    .< 2< .2..   #     /!!    0! #            A /!!     0  !  !    0  

  #   +  00 0    1'  ).

).

.2.. +

  0  0 0   00  !       #    +  +0 

0   ! 

 0 00 #   0   

    7!         0 !   1*      0   !

,

      0    #  ! 9 !       .4 .2..  !0  ! ;0 + + !;0  !   

#   #    #  00 0 ;       +  0 !  

# !     #  ! #   *         /!!     .< 2- .2.. 00               0   0 *     !    +  /   0!  !0  00  0    1' # # ;  .4 2< .2..   0      !  #   00 0    !    

0  = !0  #    !  !!        #      0 0   !   )5, /  / *  0 !   +  /!!    0 +     B  0  00  1   +!       /   ..

2< .2.. A/ C # 0    0 +       0 

 

 ).

.2.. 0  0  +   +  /  !  #       0  

    !

(

       0   0   !   +      !

!   !     0 + !     *   0!       

    

     !" # 9+  ! /        0             0  

1      #  0 ;     !    !       / #      0       0      +   00 0

 

          0!  + 9+  ! /  #$$%&'&( #

)%$ % %$*+ , %



 *%$ =  ?/

@ $ ),)  .2.2   )5 2< .2.2 #   +    #  /     0   +      + !  0 #       0  +              

             - .&.

 % %$*+/&,  %

*%$    

 (

 01  (2  % %$*+3 



*%$  " 

 (

  4"0  ( ,  2   %

 (&  

  *%$    % %$  *+ '



% 

*%$   !  !  

&  (  % %$

#*+1$    "     0   00 0    #         !

 0   !     

    0  0    0    0 +     

        +

    $ (7  0   

   +   +    +   /  0     ! 0 A0 0   #

  !  # 0  0 C        #   0  ! 6 # 0 *    +   #    #     0 +  #  0 +    //*% 0    #   #        !  !  #    * !  0  ! ;!    # 434-    

0  !

;         0   + +    #  !   # 0 *       !!     0 #    ! 9 +    ! ! 0     # .,,-     #  ! 

1   +!     0 +  /  0   ! #   A /!!    C #             +    0

    0     #    

0 

 +  !  0 0 0  +     

   +    # 0    B  +    !

    

3 0     )5 ).

.2..  +  "

1/ 0!    + 0 +            #  

        !   # #    0     +   + !

1            0 0  !    

-

*  #  !    ! 1'  

0   #   +  !       .4 .2..  !0 ! 07;0 +   + !;0  !   

*   

0            ! 0   !    0  0     0  +  + !     $#  B   +  /    #  0  +         !     0         D 6 #0  B  #  +        0     E+

  0  +  !  00 0     0     +#    

  +  !  # 0 +      +       0     !  0 '   ;  + !  2*+'  ,$ 

 &6$

%$ $ %*+2* )$0-10 *&%  7* $0  $

0          8 #     #

+     00    0 + 1* 

4 /61    +    !   +      !   # 0               0       00 0 +

#0 !     0             

   0  #  0      + 7+

<

$#    0 #   ! B  /             0  +       

  #     !   !    )5)  #

 )5, #   ! ;! #        0!   #        + ! * //*% 0   ! 

  ! 6 #      !   # #    * 0          +#     !  #           * !         #   !   0   + #       0 #   A /!!    0!

*     #  +         #

   # 0 * !    #   0  # 0  0    0    0     .4 .2..    !     !    +   

   !  4.   ! 6 #    # !   *  #    /  

5 #    # !     0 # # 0   +   !     B        0  # +    #     +!           !     !  7 !  +  0

;            !   ! B   + # 0   #

0

 0  !   

 

0     !; ! ;0 +     ! 6   !0  !       #   

  ; !0 #  //*% 0   ! 6     !  # 0   +   

  C     ;  +  0 !      !  #       + # 0  !

* ;     !    ! 0 0  #  #  + ! ! *  #   ;    !     #   !!  0   +   !  C   !   #          + !

*   

0        .4 .2.. #  !   )(      !     23 2- .2..

*   !  0    #   !  ! 0! #  60         #  +    #  !  ! 0!    0!  24 2- .2.. 

C  !   !  # 0 #       ! 

6  * 

     + 0     #  0        

0   !   0 0      

 

)2

*     !   !    0       00 0        = !0 # # ;0 +#     #

 0   +# !

#   0    #    +    *         = !0       #  +# !  42 .2..  ; .    # #      !  !  # !

#  

0   #  +   C  !  +        #   #  * !

0   !         0  ! 

  !   +   +     

#      #      0 0  +  +        0      /          A /!!    #  #  0 #       

    ! 1       

   )5 ).

.2..  !     +       +  1

B 0 0  

  #  ..

.2.4       !   !        #     !  1*      0

  ))

1 #     ! +    !          0

     !

05.03.2024 (MANISHA BATRA) 

JUDGE Whether speaking/reasoned Yes Whether reportable Yes