Indian Federation Of Trade Unions (Iftu) v. State Of Haryana And Others




   
   


!"#$#%&'&()*+ 
($&!( #$#-!"&(-!$# (&('    . #"&"&(#-  /#-'0' 1"!"#!-2!(!!($"3#-'  #'4($#("'
 


  
 
 


 

  

-#'#(") -1!(5&6708!-!$!69$6%!"#9-"3#4#"&"&(#- -##4!:!;2!(9$$;$6%!"##(#-!;9!-2!(!9 -"3#-#'4($#("'  <<<<   
 

3# 4#"&"&( 3!' =##( "!:#( 04 - 3#!-&(> "3-0>3 6&$# %(#-#(%&(> 3&'4#"&"&(3!'=##(&;#$=2"3#
($&!( #$#-!"&(-!$#

(&('  4-!2&(>-4-6&$&(>$9'3#;"#-!($8(#"!-2=#(#&"'" ,*, 8&>-!(" ;!=0- &( &'"-&%" !(&4!" !-2!(!  ( "3# '"-#(>"3  "3# -$#-' &''0#$ =2 "3# 1"!"# 6#-(8#(" $!"#$ + 9 + 9  9+ !($ ((#?0-#' *9 *,9 *@9 *+ !($ *A  -#'4#%"&6#;29 &''0#$ 40-'0!(" " "3# $&-#%"&(' &''0#$ =2 "3# 6#-(8#("
($&!$!"#$+ ((#?0-# *  
"&''0=8&""#$=2"3#4#"&"&(#-"3!"!'4#-"3#$&-#%"&('"3# 6#-(8#(" 
($&! !($ "3# %('#B0#(" -$#-' &''0#$ =2 "3# 1"!"#  !-2!(!9 "3# 1"!"# 6#-(8#(" &' -#B0&-#$ " 4-6&$# $9 '3#;"#- !($ 8(#"!-2 -#;&#' " "3# 8&>-!(" ;!=0-
" &' '0=8&""#$ "3!" &('4&"#  -#4#!"#$-#4-#'#("!"&('9"3#!0"3-&"&#'3!6#("8&"&>!"#$"3#>-&#6!(%#' ,*,8&>-!(";!=0-9C3!-#&;;&"#-!"

#  " "3# 0"'#"9 ( ! B0#-2 =#&(> 8!$# =2 "3# 0-"9 ;#!-(#$ %0('#;!44#!-&(>-"3#4#"&"&(#-3!'!$8&""#$"3!""3#4#"&"&(#-
 &' ("!-#>&'"#-#$0(&((-&'&"!-#%>(&D#$0(&(-!-#4-#'#("!"&6#0(&( 0($#- "3# ;!C -#;!"&(> " "-!$# 0(&(' - ;!=0- ;!C' 44!-#(";29 "3# 4#"&"&(#- 0(&( 3!' ( 50-&'"&% #("&"2 1&>(&&%!(";29 "3# 4#"&"&( 3!'

 &;#$(;2(=#3!;
 !($("3#-&($&6&$0!;9C3&'!;;#>#$"=# !>>-&#6#$93!'=##(&84;#!$#$!'4#"&"&(#- ,

!%#$C&"3"3&'9;#!-(#$%0('#;-"3#4#"&"&(#-'0=8&"'"3!" "3# 4#"&"&( ( =#3!;  "3# 0(&( 8!2 (" =# #("#-"!&(#$ =0" "3# &''0# -!&'#$ =#&(>  40=;&% &84-"!(%# "3&' 0-" 8!2 "!:# 04 "3# 8!""#- '08"0 E !6&(>3#!-$;#!-(#$%0('#;-"3#4#"&"&(#-!($&(6&#C "3# !$8&""#$ !%" -#>!-$&(> "3# '"!"0' 
  C# !-#  "3# %('&$#-#$ 4&(&("3!""3#4#"&"&(&;#$(=#3!;
 %!(("=##("#-"!&(#$!-  3!'(50-&'"&%'"!"0'(-&'!;#>!;#("&"230'9"3#4#"&"&(&;#$=2"3# 4#"&"&(#-&'$&'8&''#$ C#6#-9C#!%%#4""3#'0=8&''&(;#!-(#$%0('#;-"3# 4#"&"&(#-!($"!:#04"3#&''0#-!&'#$&("3&'4#"&"&('08"0!($4-%##$ !%%-$&(>;2 @

4(!$6!(%#%42"3#4#"&"&(3!6&(>=##('#-6#$("3# 1"!"#9!'3-"-#4;23!'=##(&;#$(&"'=#3!; +
(4!-!>-!43"3#-#4;2'0=8&""#$=2"3#1"!"#9&"&''"!"#$ "3!""3#-#4-#'#("!"&('$!"#$  !($* -4-6&$&(>$9 '3#;"#-#"%""3#8&>-!(";!=0-C#-##?!8&(#$=2"3#$!; &%#-'!"

!(&4!"9C34'"%($0%"&(>"3#(#%#''!-2#?#-%&'#!($$0#6#-&&%!"&(' "3#&($&6&$0!;'3!6#4-6&$#$"3#=!'&%!%&;&"&#'&#$9'3#;"#-#"%!'4#- "3#6#-(8#("&('"-0%"&('
"&'0-"3#-'"!"#$"3!""3#;&'""3#4#-'('9 C3C#-#("4-6&$#$$9'3#;"#-#"%98!$#!6!&;!=;#""3#!0"3-&"&#'9 3!'!;'=##(%('&$#-#$!($#;&>&=;#4#-'('3!6#=##(>-!("#$"3#=!'&% (#%#''!-2!%&;&"&#' A
(4!-!>-!43"3#-#4;29"3#1"!"#!-2!(!3!''"!"#$"3!" "3#23!6#("&&#$3#;4;&(#(08=#-6&D**

(C3&%3(;&(#-#>&'"-!"&( -8'%!(=#0-(&'3#$=2"3#0(->!(&D#$;!=0--&(!(%&!;!''&'"!(%#&#

'*

4#-C##:-!4#-&$(#8("3
"&''"!"#$"3!"!'8!(2!' E ;!=0-#-' >" "3#8'#;6#' -#>&'"#-#$ !($ !"#- 6#-&&%!"&( **A 4#-'('9C3C#-#0($#;&>&=;#93!6#=##(>-!("#$"3#=#(#&"0($#-"3# >6#-(8#(" '%3#8#
( 4!-!>-!43,9 &" 3!' 0-"3#- =##( '"!"#$ "3!" "C

3#;4;&(#(08=#-' *A @*AEE!($ *A @AAE 3!6#!;'=##(("&&#$9 (C3&%3!(24#-'(%!('##:"3#-#B0&-#$!''&'"!(%# 
( 4!-!>-!43E9 "3# 1"!"#  !-2!(! 3!' '0=8&""#$ "3!" "3#2 3!6# ("&&#$ "3-## $!; &%#-'9 (!8#;29 &  88&''&(#-9 0(&%&4!; -4-!"&(9 !(&4!"9 && 10=&6&'&(!;!>&'"-!"#9 !(&4!"!($ &&& 10= &6&'&(!; !>&'"-!"#9 1!8!;:3!9 " 8(&"- "3# !&- $&'"-&=0"&(  $-2 -!"&(F%:#$$!($"4-6&$#"3#-!''&'"!(%#""3#8&>-!(";!=0-&( &'"-&%" !(&4!"
( 4!-!>-!43@9 "3# 1"!"#  !-2!(! 3!' '"!"#$ "3!" ( *@ 9++4#-'('C#-#-#'&$&(>&("3#* '3#;"#-38#'#'"!=;&'3#$&( "3#&'"-&%" !(&4!" 3#1"!"#3!'!;''"!"#$"3!"!;;"3#;!($C(#-'F;!($;-$'3!6# =##( $&-#%"#$ (" " $#8!($ !(2 -#(" -8 "3# ;!

=0-#-' !($ C-:#-' C-:&(>&(6!-&0'0(&"'F%84!(&#'F&%#'#"%-!4#-&$(#8("3&( !%%-$!(%# C&"3 "3# $&-#%"&(' &''0#$ (   =2 "3# 1"!"# 6#-(8#(" ((#?0-# *A  * 
("3##($9;#!-(#$$$&"&(!;$6%!"##(#-!;9!-2!(!3!' -#&"#-!"#$"3#'"!($"!:#(=2"3#8&("3#-#4;2!($3!'!;'0($#-"!:#("3!" !(24#-'(&((##$!''&'"!(%##6#("$!2%!(!44-!%3"3#-#'4($#("' C&"3 3&' >-&#6!(%#' !($ "3# '!8# '3!;; =# %('&$#-#$ =2 "3# -#'4($#(" !0"3-&"&#'&88#$&!"#;2&(!%%-$!(%#C&"3"3#$&-#%"&('&''0#$=2"3#1"!"# 6#-(8#(" # 0-"3#- '0=8&"' "3!" "3# 1"!"# 6#-(8#(" &' "!:&(> !;; 4''&=;#'"#4'"4-6&$#$9'3#;"#-!($8(#"!-2!''&'"!(%#""3'#C3 !-##;&>&=;#0($#-"3#'%3#8# ** #!-(#$%0('#;-"3#4#"&"&(#-9C3C!'-#B0#'"#$"!''

&'" "3&'0-"&('4&"#$&'8&''!;"3#4#"&"&(9'0=8&"'"3!""3#-#!-#'#6#-!; "3#- 4#-'(' C3 3!6# (" =##( !=;# " !6!&;  "3# =#(#&"' 0($#- "3# >6#-(8#(" -$#-' # 0-"3#- '0=8&"' "3!" &( 6&#C  "3# -#'4('# '0=8&""#$=2"3#1"!"#!-2!(!9!(2>-&#6!(%#'0-6&6&(>-!(24#-'(&( (##$  !''&'"!(%# 0($#- "3# >6#-(8#(" -$#-' C0;$ !44-!%3 "3# !0"3-&"&#' # '0=8&"' "3!" !' !($ C3#( '0%3 4#-'(' !44-!%3 "3# !0"3-&"&#'"3#28!2=#$&-#%"#$""!:#(#%#''!-2'"#4'"4-6&$#!''&'"!(%# !'4#-"3#-$#-'&''0#$=2"3#1"!"#!-2!(!((#?

 * #!-(#$$$&"&(!;$6%!"##(#-!;-"3#1"!"#!-2!(! '0=8&"'"3!""3#2!-#=0($"4-6&$#(#%#''!-2!''&'"!(%#&("3#'#$&&%0;" "&8#' " !(2 4#-'( &( (##$ C3 !44-!%3#' "3#8 !($ "3#2 C0;$ "!:# &88#$&!"#(#%#''!-2'"#4'"4-6&$#"3#(#%#''!-2!''&'"!(%#&(!%%-$!(%# C&"3"3#6#-(8#("'%3#8#""3#4#-'('C3!-##;&>&=;#-"3#'!8# #'0=8&"'"3!""3#1"!"#6#-(8#("&'"!:&(>!;;4''&=;#'"#4'"4-6&$# (#%#''!-2 !''&'"!(%# !($ '3!;; %("&(0# " $ ' # '0=8&"' "3!" "3# -#'4('# >&6#( =2 "3# 1"!"#  !-2!(! &($&%!"#' "3!" !$#B0!"# (#%#''!-2 ##%"&6#'"#4'3!6#!;-#!$2=##("!:#(=2"3#1"!"#6#-(8#(""4-6&$# (#%#''!-23#;4""3##;&>&=;#4#-'('#0($#-"!:#'"%("&(0#"$' !($!;'"8&"&>!"#"3#>-&#6!(%#'!(24#-'('C3!44-!

%3#'"3#$!; &%#-'("&&#$-"3#&'"-&%" !(&4!"-'##:'!''&'"!(%#"3-0>33#;4;&(# (08=#-'("&&#$=2"3#1"!"#!-2!(! * !6&(>3#!-$"3#;#!-(#$%0('#;-"3#4!-"&#'9&"&'#6&$#(" "3!""3#1"!"#3!'!($&'"!:&(>'"#4'"4-6&$#"3#(#%#''!-2-#;&#""3'# C3(##$"3#'!8#
("3#%&-%08'"!(%#'9=2"!:&(>(-#%-$"3#!-#'!&$ '"!"#8#(" !($ 0($#-"!:&(> >&6#( =2 "3# ;#!-(#$ $$&"&(!; $6%!"# #(#-!; - "3# 1"!"#  !-2!(!9 "3# 4#"&"&( '"!($' $&'4'#$  C&"3 ! $&-#%"&(""3#1"!"#!-2!(!&("#-8'"3#-#"&88#$&!"#;2#?!8&(# !($ 4-6&$# $9 '3#;"#- !' !;' "3# (#%#''!-2 !''&'"!(%# " "3# #;&>&=;# 8&>-!(";!=0--4#-'('C3!44-!%3"3#$!; &%#-'4#-'(!;;2-( "3#3#;4;&(#(08=#-'40-'0!("""3#>6#-(8#("'%3#8#'9&"3#23!

6#(" $(#'!;-#!$2-&'8#4#-'('3!

/
17    
  1




 
   *+

 

 !  " #!    $% #!