← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/14370/2024allowed

Gurinder Singh And Others v. Ut Of Chandigarh And Another

2024-04-23Mr. Justice Sumeet Goel6 pages

           





"#$#%&

' '





  (

  ( )*$ (        (  ( &  +, '

(  ( ,  



     

       

"     "

# $$$$$ ( ,

- '

% &'( '    )!*

!

  +,-  "

./.     #0%%#.#%       0.1  02/3    ,  ! 

   %45  6 7 

* 

! !      %8.##.#069 3#7(    (  # :#..;#.#0

(! (   



  

    

 

!!  

 !  

"

  " #

 #

#$

% &  "     '  ( %  

  ) '  !%  %'  *%% 





 # !  & % *%%

  % %& )

'  

! $  



+ # !  & %,%

"# 

%





     "  "  !! $ "

-  

!!

#  !  .!!

 



/%/0%,/,0 + 

 #+ !  .!!

 ( 





$!!

  "!

  "

 " % $ 

 "

' !  .!!

 ( 

 !!  !   

  "  " %  !!#    !  .!!

 ( 

 

  

#++  !

#+      

 "     #+       .!!

 ( 

%  

  # #+$ +   '

!!#!+     #+  

!' #1  

  

 2   !  .!!

 ( 

"

          

     "  ""

  #+  $ $ !# "      3

%



        "   ""

'    ""

.    !!  

    

  

 # ". .

 

$  



# !+ #+

 

!% !!# #1 

     .!!

 ( 

%   !! 

     

  "

'     !    .!!

 

 !! #" #

 



 $ !! 

      "  

   $     "

      #  !  " 

$  # +       !  .!!

 ( 

 !!

 !! $     "  2 '

-   4 +        

    4 +     "!

.

 

+   

    4 +    

 #  !

 

!

" 2 5  # #"#  #   

%%,6%/0%,/,0%7

;

     #;.0#.#0  < 

! ,

   ( )

  

   

( 3  +   ,/%/6%,/,0

#+8 9#!8   

# 8

+

'

 ( 06:/ ,/,0

!

;< ) =2

% > %)  

  ;' $

  #  !  '$ $

    #"

"#  

+

'  $ +       !

"   '  $   ' !

$  +    '$  

 ! + 

   $  "

+  "

. "!

      % ,%  

 8 9#!8  ' < ) 

    

+

 & %?/ ,0%%,/,'   )

0/@'0A?

  4 " !) ')

:'*%%

%8

 !

 !

"  %& $$

  $!!  $ 

'   ""

  #! 

'  +  

" #!+ !  $ "!

<!

B   C%/,%,/,0    + 

" D %%    "   

 #    $      '   !

+  $  +    %8 + # !%

 

.

"%8  "   D %%8

+ 

  %6%   B

    

+

 & %?/ ,0%%,/,'

  ) 0/@'0A?

  4 " !) ')

:'*%%

%)

 !

 !

"  & $  $        $!!  $ 

'   ""

  

 #!  

%  )  

" #!+  !     $    "!

<!

B  "  C%/,%,/,0    + 

" D %%

 $      '   !

+    $   +        %) + # !%  

.

 %)  "   " D %% )

+ 

  % 0% < ") 

 >    

$

  !!

$

  #   

 

+

 & %?/ ,0%%,/,'   ) 0/@'0A?

  4 "

!) ')

:'*%%

%8

 !

 !

"  %& $$  $!!$ 

' ""

  #!

'+ " #!+ !   $     "!

  <!

 B     "       C%/,%,/,0    + 

" D %%

# $   ' !

$  +   %8 + # !%  

.

"%8  "   " D %% 8

+ 

  % C% ' "!

<!

B   

"!+< ) ' B < ")  #

  %?/ ,0%%,/, )

0/@ 0A?

   4 " !) ) :'

% & $  $        $!!  $ 

'   ""

  

 #!



" #!+ ! $ 

"!+< ) ' B < ") 

 C%/,%,/,0%

 $      '   !

!+    $   +       % )  "      "     C%/,%,/,0    + 

" D %%)

 #1        

      

 #  

% @%))) '3! %,A@,.

  

 

 #+)824 "  !

) :'

 





 ,/%/6%,/,0#   %  !+

 "!

"!+<!

B 

%

    

"!+  <  ) '    B < ") $  #

 %     %2%



%

 

  ! + 

)) :'

% :%) "



#+ 

$  "!

$  +

'    " '$

 #1  $ 

    

         #

  '  ' "  "!'  ' !   +  !

$%  '  #" +    !9

!%7 0 = 

   "

#     !        +,- 

! *    *

 8 

'  

       +,-*

    69 3#7 1 ,   

      

'



!    4 

 > ? 9

   '

(  9 

   0/#  

*

 ! 3 

          



 !"



#$%   &     

&  

''

!($"

  

'(

)$ 

    * +   !"

'' !($"

 !($ ,))$ -./  

0 

 /  )(  "    

( !    '> ? 9

 

 

$ .

0?, %% $ "  $  

#+) 6,/  % #  8 $ '$  $    %    !  !$!  $       #        

    

  E  "  #$    

   

 $ 

   $!" !+   "

!+    !  

  !   "" ! 



      "

"

!

 "!+  %   

 $  #



 !         " !  

+   !"

'  +%

 

  

 

  "  +%   ) 0?, %%

+ 8   

   1 

$!!%     +

 8  '  ! 8  $ !   

     )  6/:  " !+  #      "   %8  

   1 

'  $    1  ! 

 !.! 

 # +.

  $

    %   )   8  $ !# 

#! !+    !!   

  !.



"    !%)  

  #  

    $!"

 !!  %   4!



 "  #!   $

  

 '8    

    '  

$  $

# $ 

"

 "!

    % / )!(      

        9

  @0/#   *

+,-  3 

            $!! #    

!+    

 =  $!!   !+      # !1 %    !!

"

!+   

 %  

 " %             "

    #  !

+ 

 %   "!

."                $  ! 2

*  ' 

(+,-"

./. #0%%#.#%

 0.102/3 , ! 

   %45 6 7 

 * 

! !   

  %8.##.#069 3#7 '*

*

   %. !    67 '

   

.( ,/

  #;#.#0

A )!@  B@"

A  B@"