← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/357/2002disposed of

Nishan Singh v. Hy.State

2015-09-09Mr. Justice Sanjay Kishan Kaul17 pages



   

  

 





 

!  "  "#  $%"

  " # 

$ %

 &  "' 

$ #' (")



*  

$ * +

)  "' 

 "&



,

      &   "       )

 )  

-.-./-0 "  --/-0  1#+   "     .         &   

 

  )2 -  " " ! 

 ") "  &   )"     "  

  "       &     ,) "

%

 " )4'

 )4 )

 

! 

 "

)

  ")   )

&)  )  ,) "  %

  

)4'

 )4&

" 

     )

  ) "   

 -./-0   "  --/-0  1#+

5 " ) "3)"  """"/    "

""  

 6)"  718  %   &    '

       ")) "%

 " )4'

 )4 9) " 

 :

&

 ")  )    -.1#+ "  ") "  )        '     "            !

/, " ")    )) "  )             :   "  

 /"   " ) "   ")  '   

"     &  ""          

    )   '

      ")   & &' 9) "



 '"       '     "      

 "

  &    

) ) """0  

"  +)

(  "  )  

     )  2 -       , ) " 

 & %  

()

 "% ) ; &  ) "     "%  

   

,

 "  )4'

 %

 "

 ) "   : & < &"

&    

)

 && &  " "  

, , &

 ) ",%

))    :  " & "  

& " 4  

 &  

4 &  &

4 " ' &  

4&4  

 & "    

 "

 

    " "   &    &) "  )    

    <

)"   "

  < &"

 

"   &' &

< &"

'

& 

! 

# " "

&& 4"

      

    <

) "     "     

&') "   " " 

&    ')

   ,

)

 " ! 

#  "   

 ! 

& "  &   

= ! 

")   &  ) 

 

"&  ")  ) %

&    " )4'

&     

 "  

&) ")! 

  <

" " 

)  &      !  

      "

    )  ! 

 

"& &   "& &"

  =   

%

'& & '  "

'   & & )4'

'& &

  ""! 

  

  "  , )

"%  

 % ) ; "  

) " &   &     '&

1 3)",! 

  &     '"    +)      +  *)     &    &  "    *'        % 

&'    )  "   & 4  !3 "   # 

>)  )     )9$"  ? +)   + *) 

'

 &  

&  

")  ) 3)"'

 "+ '

   % 

 +4

1'

   3)""

 4 !3 "   #  "



""    !3 "      &    "  " "

3)"  4    ,

)

& "" 

&  >1! 0"" )  

-./--/-01#+ .  &  "#    *) 

) "

)  '     ) ",%

  &   "    0    "    '" 

) ", )4'

&  " 2   "

 '" :

&  "  -  "



 "

 )  '") @< #- &    "  ' "

A     '      ) "

  .-+ # + & ) "



 "

&,) "

 :  &   "  +)

&     "'& "

&   "" )   "  "

 

)    )  < "



 & 

#=    

 ;   $"   ?   +))  + *)    "" , 

< "

% ) ;      ") "  3)  

 & & &

 " "

 )3



   "   -   )9 #      *)   "

  3)",!  

   "*     % 

#=    6 & " 

  6)   ! "   >

$"  *'  $"  +

 #  " "   -  " ,



< "! 

 ") "

& 

 

, B

$)     "  &)  

(  )    - <  -     "   

"  " &  

>  "

&  "'

"C, 

)  "@  ) 



!""

    -    <       

 ""

 

-

!""

    -  <       

)   4

!""

 ) <.'   "4    ""

"'

"C, 



&

0<0  "  0 ' &  "

 &  "'

"C,  6 &

)   "   "-&  &   0 "4) "  ' 

 # ")   & &  0)

% "& ) " 3)  &  &  &

 ) 



#=-  $ 3  %)  !",%    $"   +

  ;)"    ")"    "

 "  



#=0 1# %)   " 



'   

 &  '    "       ) "

  .-+ # +

#=  +  !

   ""   ' "   

  "' @< #+

#=G  + 3   %)  

   ""   ' "   

 "' @< #

#=.

1 ) 

" "  )9 @< #@)+

 !3 

""

>1!@< #@/

#=2 ) " 

          

 "

 &  ) "4   

" ") ' &  

") "

) ! 



#=  !3  #   ;     + 4  $  +)  *)    "  @< # "

)"   

,



#=+

  

" ""

""'   1

9$ *)  

#=! 

&" '"  ) "'  #=2 ) "

 

 "")  '"   " ) 9) 

") )     &4" 

>)) ")  '    ) ) 

) " " &4

#=  ;

     '"   "

, @< #%& ""  

) #=-1

!3 %)& " "

1/ ?#    *)   -    "  "  "

#=0  +

   H  

  " "    

G - & 3 " 

1'

  '   

       )   '     

,



)""

 )  @< #; ") )  '") @< #-  "@< #0 " ' " @< # "   @< #

#=

1*)  

   ")  ) ", )4'

" 

   "  '    @<  #  ' "   @< #6  ) )       "

 )     @<  #

)"  

#=G  +

     

   "" 

' "   "' @< #

#=.    ( ( %44  " "  )    , "



 + '

   %   

19

 0     "   " ) 

19

 )9@< #? #    "

,"

 3)"



 "   " )   19

   "  @< #>/"      @< #>

#=2

1  '

 " " )   ' )

 4   ")  '    

* #=    !

% %)   )  )   $+     ;)"       "           G     

3)",!  

  &  " "       

    &

) 

 )

&   @  ) &")

  .

    3) 5@!" 

   &"  

  " : 3)"&

"   )

"    3) 

1 " $"  1

 )  '""

"

@< #C ) " 3)""      ")

= < " )    --+ # + 

 ) "" "

 

'

"

 :  ""  

    

"

        &

) & #) 3#  "'

 

%     )     6

 

        '

/ & )

 )"

! 

 "  % )  ;   '"    "       &   "



       

  #      (&     

) 1&



"

,

&  )   & 

      

    #) 3  # 

>)

 "  ) " )  )  : 3)" "  &  

  ) "#  ?

 ! 

  &    ' " &        &  

+!

"'*)  " & & &4   ) 

+)     +   *)   "   

'  &    "   

  "     &  "  &  ! 

" "  ' 3)     

) " )

" ) "< "= 

 =%) & 

 "=-+$ 



:  +)   ")

   " )' " ) "    '

      $"   ?   "  " "  )

  ! 

 

  

  ) "  )  3)  9) "%



)4'

,) " 

  : 

& &' ' ")   -.1#+  & ) "' " ")  ) &   ! 

  " ")   

)  

"

&  " ) "    "      "'

'

  "   "  )

          )' "  ) &   

   +) 

&  )"      " ")    )   "     "    3)", !  

      "       )     3)", ! 

 '

  

1 )

++ ) )      , )

 && < "  )  #=2  ")  ! 

  "  

 :       ") "  3)", ! 

& )  < " #=  "

! 



   ") "

    ") ")  ' &' ) 

'

         '  )  '      :         ,

)

#=2 "

#=")

" #= 6 &

&" , 

< " 3)"   -  !3 "     #      )   )   &   

 ")    "&)  )  -< -  "  "  " &      @' "      "    )    "      )   

 )    "  



 '

   

 

  - 

" )""

 )  @< #;) ) &  '") @< #-   "@< #0  '  "@< # "  @< #

"

 " &

"

"   " >1! &) "&& 

+ 

 ) & & '4   )2 -     '

 % '

  

 ) 

 & 4 +)   + *) &#=  

; )9@< # /#    *) )  '  3)" " "*      % 

 1  )     "   

3)"  &  )     &   4    *       %  

"& 4 *'  $"  +

 #    &    &  " , 

 < "    #=  6 &

   -  #=2

1'

     "  )9 +)  + *) ""! G " " +)   + *) +4  )

'

 4 !3 "    #  ) ""*     % 

"

    " !3 "      #   &  '"     @< #? ") & 3)"

&  4  ?

 3)"& " ")  

1  ' 

  ""     @<  #@      

)

  :  "   "

            "      

  >1!    0  ""

 &  " #     *) - - 

   !  &       )  +

   

+

  &   &   '"      )   '

 6)"  

$ *) G     " *     

  "& "  & ' 

" >1!

 ='

  "  )"

   < "  ) 

: "    )  " 

"  )  "4    

'

  /     &   )   &   #) 3#  "'

  % )  6



& ' ) 

 )"

! 

 "% ) ;  '"

 &'"

#=  6 &

&"" , 

< " 3)", ! 

   -  *'  $" 

+

#   ")   & & 

0)

:  &

&  )   "

 & ) "4    ) -   1  

&) " '  '"      -          &

"

"   & '"  

  '

/  :     < """   "

     4      "      , ")  % ) ;  

%  

 ;

"()

 &'  

&  

+'  )  : &&'"

&  , )

" " 

! 

&  " 

,



$' 9)  & '&     )  ) "< "  

9)  ' " &  " 9)  

!"

    )    &         "   '"

#=! 

" " " &

 " 

   ") " 

 )



+  '& ) "' 

" 

 ! 

    " &

! 

 # '

&&

)   < " ) )"   



     &   "    "  "    <       &"

&  

   ""'  &

 , )

 " ! 

& "

   "&  )  

  

  &     " 

: 

  "         

      

  <

"    "      "  )   &      !  

    

"

"

)



+ '

 &   &) "&&        #=   !

% %)

   "   3)", !  

  &  " "   $+       ;)"    

 G   "& ) ") 

 )

  & < " @  ) &")  

.

               3)  5@!  "   

   &"  

  " : 3)"&

"    <   

1 " $" 

 )   )" " 3)" '

  ")

1 

,<       " 3)"& " "  4* & ")   *

(3&   "&' & "  )

'

&  

    ""    

%  )4   $  )    &  ")"5@! 

 " "

"  &    " 3)" ""

1 " $" 

 )  3)  " "" '  "

'

1 ) &  *

(3&&""

)  3)" " & 

%  )4 $ )   &" ")"5@!  " " '   < "  )  )     "

 < """  3  &  "&

#= !

% %) ")   ")"

+( @  ) "5@! "  

%  )4 :)    ")  

")    " 



" '

/ 

  "  ) 



 ' )  '

' &' )  ) "&  ) "3)"  '   

"   +)

"

  &    ")



    "

       )     



) "    " ) "  )



 ) "    &     "&   <"

:   

& ) "   

 ' '"

   1  

 & " &  &  





  +)

' 4

" " 3)"&   4

  " )     " 

 3)" '

   

:4     

"            )       +)       

""  ' &    

  '     ")  

     " @ 3)  &) "  ") 

+

 ' 

  )   !

/,  ") 

 "

 " !

/,  

 3)"

'

  

! )       '       

 ) "

   -.  1#+   ) )   '           ")"    '       )

   ' 

:)    " !

 /,    !

 /,   "   ")          



) " )    I 

:  )   " "  

 "

 

 

: "

"

 " , "-    ./0!*& !+

 3 ,