Vikram Pal And Otehrs v. State Of Haryana And Others
!""#$%$&'()
' *+
, -,-
*+
,,, .....
! "
#
$%&'
(
!
$) .....
-,-
/
+
( !
( *( + ! %,-.'-'- /
0( )1 ( 2 0 + 345 ! + (6( 77 ( ! !
+ ! ! '-'-'%
( ! !
!( !! ! ! ! ! '-%8'- 2
$%
' ! $%:7-)7'-%3:"9 %,-.'-'-
! ( 77 6( # 7#
!
;
(! 9 !
+ (
< # < "( #((+
< " (+ =>> ! ! '-'-'% 9 ( # ! (
! ,-5
2 +
9
6+ $;;
#'-'-
$;;
'-'-
+,-5
2+ (
6+$;;
#'-'-
$;;
'-'-9
( ',5
2 /9 !1!
""7"!( ! 7
!(
?(
# 7#
! 7 ( !
+ (
# <
< / < 1
,5?(
2
(2 !
2 ! 2 !! ! + 2 ! '-%: 2
@$ ;
+2 !( ;
! A
69#( ( 9 ( ! (
! ,-5
2
(
B !+
+,-5
2
(
+ !+ 9 ( ;C !+
2 # $! ',-''-%8 9
+ *( $;;
# '-'- 0
( +2 ! ( ( ?(
,-5
9
?( 9
+
( ! ! %,-.'-'-
)( 2 !
+
!
2( #6( '-'-'%
0 ( ''' 2
)< %%%
9
?(
2 ! %%% ?( !! + (?( %-5 ;C ',59 ! '-5 ! 6 %:5 "6 %%5 "6"
,5 C"
! ! ?( 345
%)5 2 !
7+ !+ 9 +
2( ( 2
+ ! ,0 1"&%!$!2!$& ! 3 ,! !" 42! %" !% ! 3 %" !% 5 $3 63" 0"&"0 37 8"& !"90: ;< %
#9 %%% ') ' # ! 6
+ %' ' C D ( D ) # ! 6
+ %% % $ /$(1 . 6 + '' 3 0 &=! 3 ;)( ; 9 (
+ 2 ( ! ! '-%8'-
',5 !
,5 2
2 ! 4-5 7+ !+ ! + ! (! (
,0 $ 9
$ B ?(
$ B 2 # 7B 6+/%)51 %
#9 %%' 43 ' # ! 6
+ C D ( D %% 4 ) # ! 6
+ $ /$(1 %% 4 . 6 + '' %, 0 &=! 3 ;)( ;
( ! + ! 2 + 345 7+ !+ 2 !
(! %-4 / ( ! ! '-%8 '-1)% !( ! ! '-'-'% ! !( !
!!,-5
(+ ! 2(!
6( ! (+ 6 ! + -%-,'-'-
+
!"
#$"% &
'
! "## $ %&&
(
'
)*+)!)!
,!!+)!)!
) "
-
"
&
.!"
/0
1
2
!"
&%
%
2
4,
. 5
%
,.
3
% &
%
%
6
!5! )!)!
7
8 % 3 39%
%
.
)
,4:
; <
( (
% &
+= ! )!)!%
>
! !
%
' -,-,'-%- !
-%-,'-'- 2 6( 0
! ! + +
2( /
0(
)1
! 6
6 + " < ! !
0 ! 7 (
2(
6
! (2 2 9 ( 6 (2 -.-,'-'-
0 + ! !( 7 !
6
! 0 + ( 6( ! ! '-'-'% (
22
+ ! E%
2(
2 !
!! + '-5 ! 6 %:5 "! 6
%%5 "! 6 "
2 ! 2 + (
!
%:/.16 9
(
2! 99 ! ( ',5 2
!
! ""7" 9 ( ! 9 9 ! ! ! (
!+ ! ""7" ( !
!! + 9 (
2 F
!!+ 999 + C ! 2 A2 ( 6( E9
< 9
G /%88'1 ( ) 66 '%4
! %,-4'-%.
2 F
!+ 9
!(
(2 # $! ',-''-%8/
0( 9
0( '1 ;! !
C ! # 7# ;
(! 9 # 9
H C '8-%'-%8 /
0()1 %-5 #6(;C!+ ( 2
2
( + !2 !( 2 ! !
+ ( 2
! + 67 7B"6 !+ (! (! (
E; 6 ;
(! 9
(
6 (/61! ' ! '--: ! ( 2
2
( + !2 !( !( ( 2 2 0!
+ 2 + + ;C ( 2 (! 2 ! !+ ! ! ! + ! + ! +( !2
! '-%8 !
( + 2 ! !
+ ! !
! 2( !
( + !
2 ! !
! !
(! (! ! ! 2 2+
+
! ! '-%8'- 26 ;
(! 9 (
(2>! ! +(
2 ;C
( 2
! + 67 7B"6!+
2 (! G
!(
(2 " # ( 69 %3.'-%8/
0( .1
-'%''-%8 /
0( ,1 #
!
+ ( 0 + ! 6
+
! !'-'-'% %-5 ;C !
! #
! 7 6( '8-%'-'- # ( ! 7 !( %-5 ;C !
! 6( ! 9
!! + ! ! # " # ( 6 ':-''-'-
(2*( B -)-)'-'-/
0( :1 ! 6( !
'8-.'-'- /
0( 41 69 !
!
H C ! %-(
;C!+/-:
#9
-. "
#6 1 2 ! !!!
!!9 ( ! 7 ( !;C 2 + (
# ,0 1" &%!$!2!$& 0 &#> %" !% 90 &!"= 2&="0 , % "
#6 D ( D /6 ( ! 1 % ' "
#6 D ( D /H ! ! 1 % ) "
#6 D ( D / +1 % . "
#6 D ( D / +1 % ,
"
#9 / !1 % :
"
#9 /6 ( ! 1 % 4
"
#9 /"! 1 % 3
"
#9 / +1 % 8
"
#9 / ! +1 % %-
"
#9 / +1 % 99
!! + 2 ! (
;C *(
2
;C ! !(79 !
2 69 '8-.'-'- (2>! 7 ! 2
H C # B9
(!
2 ! 2 ( !+ !
+ !+ 3
!(
(2
! 0 2 2( 77 !( (
2
+ ! !"90:
"0#"&! 9"
"1 0?% ! 6 '-5
! "! %:5
! "! %%5
"
!
C -,5 F
!+ ',5 9 !
2 + F
! !+ !
! ""7" 9 ( !
2 A2 ( 6( 9
)%--,'-%4 I $%,3:8'-%4 I
$4:' '-%4 ;C*(
2
;C ! !(79 !
269
'8-.'-'- (2>! 7 ! 2
H C # B9
(!
2 ! 2 (!+ !
+ !+ 8
!(
(2 2 ! 2
2( (
2(
,0 1"&%!$!2!$&% ! 3 ," !% 8"& !"90: < , ;(< ;;< %
" #9 %%% ,8 '' %3 %' ' "
#6 C %' 4 ' ' % D (D ) D #6 $ $( %% : ' ' % . 6
+ /# '' %' . . '
1 ! 3," !% %,: 3. )- ': %: -,5 C (
2 F
!!+ ',59 ! (
2 F
!!+ ;C *(
2
;C ! !! !(7 # 9
&H C
;C ! ! (
2 ! ;C # B
!
69 !%-;C
( +
+ !( ! 2! (!(( 2
$%&' $8 ,-,'-'- ! (! ( I !( + 2
$%&'
) ( 6(
(
2( + 8 /(1 2 (
+ !(
+( I !( + 2
( 2 2! (!((
(!
-,-
,, ()