High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/24529/2016dismissed

M/S Akshay Enterprises & ORS v. M/S Amarnath Alloys Motia Khan

2016-07-26Mrs. Justice Manjari Nehru Kaul5 pages

!"#$%&'& "%!&

(%%& )& *

+"&"%!,,# %"-!" '%

!"#$%&'& "%!&

(%%& )& *

+"&"%!,,# %"-!" '% .

!"#$%&'& "%!&

(%%& )& *

+"&"%!,,# %"-!" '%

!"#$%&'& "%!&

(%%& )& *

+"&"%!,,# %"-!" '%

(& % &/" *,0!"&+"12"% &%!'%%& 3!"&+%*&'%% "&454#6"# ++&&"

%!%&2& #2,2%! '%% +,"& "%*&"%! '*%!"

"& 4%6%! "+'"&% 762&1& 21%!"% !"24%" &+

3!'%%& !"2,%!'& %'%%*&0%

&( 58*"

!5%!+',"%%%,"

!"#$%&$'()) *"

+%"," !" -"($* &'+%.%/"+" +'0 , *& 0% . %! /5%"4, 9 %&*+% %1 !&"%& +% "

%! % !",,5!"

", 4,"%%!&&"% '"

4#,"& :*","5 %&"% % ,"

1+,!6!&4#%!'%%& !"24 &&%4 *++%"%&",*&0%.%!% ;&,# %"%1%!+',"%%%,"

!"#$%&$'()) *"

+%","!"-"($* &'+%.%/"+"+'06"

,4&,"&%&",*&%4#

%! & '% +',""% *& 0% . %! % "5" % %! '%%& ",,55%!&%!"%%!'%%& / ".!"2"''&"! %!& '% +',""%4!",'%%&/&'*&!" & " %,+"%&",&%4"

3!'%%& '*&!"

%!+"%&", %!&*5!2"&* 4,, "

+%'"&"/.%!'%%

'&%!+',"%1""+*% 1.1 . *% %"5 "&2&"4,%6"& %!'%%& 3!'%%&/ *,%"% 6%!'%%&/.6%!"26% !"&5"+ !%! %"5 '"&%",,5",,"4,%#"4%1

*"!8*/ .

"% &""+*% ," &"6(*<"4/"%",;" 1;&"!" =45"&! 762&1 %! " 4" & %! '%%& &%*& %! "& " !8* 6%! ++ "% % %! 4" & %! & '% +',""%6%!%!&+"& > *%* ? 3!'%%& 6& *++4#,"&"5 %&"%2 &&"% %"%&",*&0%.%!%3!* 14#6"# %!'& %'%%1%!'%%& !"2!",,5%!+',"%"

6,, "

%! *++5&&'"

4#,"&"5 %&"% @"& * , & %! '%%& !"

"&5* %!"% %! +",*

" +"," %! & '% +',""% " 4 %"4, ! &+ %! "% %!"% %! !8* 8* % 6"

* % !"&5,5",,"4,%#&%!+"%&",6!!%!'%%&

!"'*&!"

&+%!+',""%762&1'&* ",'"&"/.%!

'%%,"&,# %"4, ! %!"%%!4,, 16!!%!+',""%!"

",,5

%!"%%!'%%& !"2'*&!"

+"%&",%!&*5!&&16&

1. 1 ". 762&1%!!8* 8* %6"

!*& 4&

*"%! 4,, @"&* ,&%!'%%& !"

*&%!&%%!"% %!!8*!"

4 !*&1&"

"4,4*

+"6*,

,,%!+"%&",%""*,%&9%"%4'& *+%!"%%!& '% +',""%6,, ,,%!+"%&",%%!& '% 6!!"2%'"%! "+*%3!!8*8* %6"

1"%1+ *%, 4#%!& '% +',""%16!!6"

%!&6 52%%!& '%,#&4*

'*&' 3!'%%& !"2",&"#'"%!"+*% 1.

% %!& '%&%!'*&!"

&" %,+"%&",762&1%! " +"%&",6"

% *'',4#%!& '%%%!'%%& A!%! '%%& +" %! +# 4" 1 *& +',"% 1 ,*5 %! '& %16&,4#%!& '%&""+*% 1

1 4# &55 "4,, "4#+"'*,"%5%!"+*% 9!"2!"&,"&* ,&%!'%%& 9%!"

!"1%!+',"%6"

, . " %!&"%&1 *++5&&6"

4#,"&"5 %&"% !",,5%%!+',"%"

6,,"

*++5&&"%&+&%!"

2#"& "%4'&+%%/ *!+"%&",&5"&5%! %"5 %&",!"

4',"&&&2&1%!'& %'%% %!&6 %+"%""4,"

%!+',"%"

16! *++5&&!"

4 '"

4#,"&"5 %&"%1%!'%%& !"2%!&+#&2

"5" %%! *++5&&14*%%!#!"2%2 %! "&+# 926%!"421%! *&% %"#+&%%! '& %'%% "%! "+"&1"&5,#1 +

(!%'# %! && 4 '," %! , %!& %"

B"5*%% A!%!& '" 5 &"

B / A!%!&'&%"4, B /