← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/497/1995dismissed

Faridabad Complex Admn. v. Ram Chand Etc.

2018-05-29Mr. Justice Alok Singh29 pages

 



     

   !"#"$%&%'()*)*+ ," -%# . # /01"2#/%'%&!- !%'

00"11 '!

3"-&4&

/ , '# &%'$"#"$" &"#!,-45,6 & '#!,"-&  "&0'#"'!&

( 76       

 





  

      







 

 

%!4 ,-%8



  

!  "" ## #$$% 

  '

 ( )   !

    * +    , ,-  

!   #. /0 #$$1   ( 2 3 )    &  *  



!

 * +

 - +    , -    ! #/% 4 $  

 566    '

 )     !

* 

!     !

 & 

3  

)  !  3!! 5 +  -

#$0#    & 



& 566

 !   

 

9   !!   



 & ! 

  

 ! )   3! +  '!-

#$:#   566

  &



)   3!;

!



 !   

& 566  ;

2    !!!

 ;   < =>#:$.

 #1 /# #$:"

!

   566



9  

   #1 /# #$:"

  3!! 5

#$0#   

)   3!;

 '!

#$:# !  #. /# #$:"

7 & ?&   3!! 5

#.

#$:%  

3  

    

9    % ?&   !



#$:"

      

? @   +-    ! 



     #1  3!! 5 + 

'!-

#$0#  .# )   3!;

+  '!-

2        ."

?&  

#$:1  A/ 33

!  2  



 (!  & #$A%*A.

2 !

 566

 ;

    !

  & !

 ! )!

      &

 !   3* # B 



    C D'

"

   3 

     ! 

     &



   

!  #$ /" #$$"

 < #  



 

 !  "1 /1 #$$"* # B

C D " B 

   ;

  

 

 C D 1 B

!   

 !C D'

% B

   C D'

. B

  > ."

  3!!



#$:1 A/ 33C D'

0 B

! C D'

: B 

!

4!

&  E 8

& C D A B

*   *   &  C D'

$  

  

;!



!

4! 8 

& +B*#- D 

 

;!

 

   'B*# 

  



3

  

    #1 /# #$:"

; !





! &



 

)   3!;

!     &

; !



!  

?& 8E '!

  566  ; !

 

 

)   3!;

!

 ?    #1  3!! 5



  

; !

   

! &

3    +-

 

)   3!;

!

 

 

!    &

)   3!;



   3

 





6     !   )   3!;

!



   #1 +- #1 + -  3!! 5

!

 ?&

!!

< $ #$$"

   #% /# #$$"

!

    !

  3 2 8  ;



 &     ?           ; !



         

 < #  

 



  ! =; "

8   566

 #$1$*%/ ! < #.

!

+  < #- ?  BE  

110#>""/11

  ?

 < "

!& 



 )  =; 1

!  (!  & #$%%*%.

! < 1$  ! 

=; "

=; %

& (!  & #$1$*%/

BE  

!

? 

  



 

!

 



=; . =; 0 =; : =; A =; $  (!  & #$1$*%/ #$%%*%. #$.0*.: #$0/*0# #$0%*

:

0.

 &

   

(!  & #$0:*0A =; #/

!

?  BE 

! '



!

 ! < $

 ,   ,

  &

6     5 

   

&    

)  &

! < .



    &

  & 3! < $  

!

?   



    &  

& & 

 6      

(! 

& #$0$*:/ =; ##



=; #"

& (!  & #$:%*:.

 & ! )   3!;

!

 

!



=

     

 

!  =; #1 *#%   ! 

!   & #$:$*A/ #$A%*A.

 !

!

 !

 

 + -    =; #.

& (!  & #$0:*0A

 &

!

 

    

7  

   

!   &

   





!



 !  !  =; #0 =; #:

       #A.%  #$.:

=; "# 

 

 

   #$1$*%/

!

?  

 ! 

=; #$ & ! < #.

  #. /0 #$%.



!

?

=; "/ & !   #1 /% #$".

 BE ?  

 !

    

  !

 !   !

* * 

  

!

 #$./

  % +1- +

-  3!! 5

   

  !  #"

&  &!  &!  ;       

 + -  # "

%

 

 

;

  & #$./ ?  

 )  "

+-  3!! 5

* 



'



    

  !  "#  $!!  

%!& #$01 35( ./:

    

 *   &  

    

  ; !

    #1 /# #$:"

=; #A

)3

    #. /# #$:"

 ! 



+ &

&

!!

   

9

  #1 /# #$:"

=; #A 

9  ; !

  

 &

   )3



 & 2

  

  

!  

  % ?&   3!!



(& #$A/  



@ !&

 9 ! #/% 4 $    6

    3  &

 9 ! #%/ 4 $  

     +-

 ! =; "

=; 1

& 





= 

    )3

+'B*#-

  

 =; " =; 1 =; "# ?

   ; =; "#

*;!

 



!

?

& 



  

     

 #$:"



)   3!;

!



?

!



(!  & #$1$* %/

!

?  * 



 

6 ,@,    ;!

 =      ;!



5  

    &  ;  "

+- +

-

= 



  

   2 

 

;

  & #$./ 

!  



! 

"# %  ' !   (  ) #$::

5( #./    * !

" "%  +

  ! , !!

%&"'$

&"' %!& "/#"

+1-

+3 - "%: ("

  % ! % - %!& 3B < "1.A$ "/## +  /A /" "/#1-   !.

$% %/0% &  , !!

%&  "1     %!& "/#% +"- 5( #0" %   '  !  2%  $ % &  "/  $% %/0%     $%0 %   %& "/#% +"- #A. 21 !3!.  %%/  % /,40* "!

 / % +

 %!& #$:0 5( 01# 

 , ' %! !  #% %!& #$::

5( %.1  /  ! % "1& #$$"

5( 0$1 . / '  !2%. $ %  &"1

 %& 3B < .:%.

#$A0

& &  

!   

 !

            



    

!

=; "

8   566    

 

  #$1$*%/

110#>""/11



) 

* (!  & #$%%*%.

=; 1 ! < 1$ BE  

!

+  < #- ?   



 

!

 





(!  & #$1$*%/ #$%%*%. #$.0*.: #$0/*0# #$0%*0. =; .

=; $

   

(!  & #$0:*0A =; #/

! < $

     !

        



   "

+- +

-  3!! 5

D

   



! 

$%!1  % !2%  5 //'%+    %& #$A# 5( 1//G .'

% '

%! !$ % &,!/

 -/

'!&"1 %!& +#$A$- #

 ?& 0%G   &/ !$%  ' %!& +"//%- #"

! 3 ### ) ! , !!

%& #$

& # %!& "/#.

33 D5  F?

%#//

) &



!  ) 

"1( %! ! % -  %& "/#:

+"- 5

0/. 

&  

,(!  6 6, ,(! 6 B '

 ?9

E ?



9 ,   

  3 >3 )  ;

3!;

   3

#$$%  

#$:1    & 

    &! ! !  

 

 )   3!;

 

   (!    %% 



! 

   !

 (! 

D  

  

&

; !

   "

+- +

-  3!! 5

=

(! 

  



     

    !



 9  

   , =; "

8   566 (!  & #$%%*%.

=; 1

   



&  ,

   =; "





 & #$1$*%/

!

 ! ?  BE

 !



!



   ! 



 110#>""/11

 &

(!  & #$%%*%.

=; 1

!

 !

!

?  BE

! 

2

! 

 #>%

 ?6

 !

#>%

?  !

!   

  

)

 99:;))*99



   

  'B*#   ! =; "

=; 1

' ;!

 * *



  

)   3!;



 D

 

" 

#

 +!&-

  #$:"

*;!

 



 &  (!  & #$1$*%/



?    

(!  & #$./*.# #$.0*.:

 

 *;!

 'B*# 

 (!  & #$1$*%/ =; % ?

&    #$:"

)   3!;

!  ?   (!  & #$1$*%/ =; % ! BE  

!

? 

 

 

   ! =; "

$ =; "

(!  =; 1 ? &    !

=; "

=; 1 

=; . =; 0 =; : =; A =; $

(!  & #$1$*%/ #$%%*%. #$.0*.: #$0/*0# #$0%*0.

 &  

?

! &

        

!  

, 

   #$1$*%/  #$0%*0.

  (!   





110#>""/11

 

     %%  5

9

  #AA: ! 

   

(!  ? 

3

&  * * 

  ,   ,

!

6    

!  #"

&  #$./ =



  

9  

 (! 



& ; !

 



   "

+- +

-  3!! 5 +  -

#$0#

 (! 

& #$0:*0A =; #/  ! 



        6       ! 

  

3 

  

(!  

!

?  "   & & 

 6    

  

(!  & #$0$*:/ =; ##  =; "#



  + - 

  & #$1$*%/

!

?    < "



 !  

=; "/

& !   #1 /% #$".

 BE ?  

 !

    

    !

 ! 

    ?    

% +1- +

-  3!! 5 +  -

#$0#    

 

    !!!  !  #"

& 

!!!  &!  &!  ;       

 + -  #  "

%

% +1- +

-

 * I%

3"&!%'5-%5,!&%' '$, < ! '#''=0-0-%"!-&      +#- <  &

&  

&   !



& !

! !

 &   &    &   

 

* +-



 !

 

&



  !

   !!!



  

   

  

 







  

  + -



    



  *   !!!  !

  !





* 

+"-

&



  !

   !





+1- <

 

 +-  * +#-

 +"-    ! 

 G* + - ;

 

   

 & 

    !

   

'

     !    

 9 G +

-  

   !

   !   & #J !! &  !!!



K  &!  &!  ;  &   # +

-  ! !



!

 "0

(& #$./ L  

&          



  !

=; "

=; "#

    

 &!  6

!     

   



*   &      !

   !



'



 

 2%!

/)' !"#$!!& #$01 5

#/%1

; 

  * 

! 

  

2

   * I#.

     +

-  "

+-



! 8 3

+ ##-

  



&    !



   





 

 

 !  *  *  &  

2

& ! 

 *  !  * 





  

!  *    9 !  +

-     2

 &,    *    9  

 

 

; 

   

! ! !  !  !& 

  !

  



;

:

   *       

  

   %# 4 #1 

   

   



!& 





     "

+- + - +

-

     !

 '

 "+-

   

& L

'



!    

 * !

" "%6!

 +-   

 

   ;   

 + - + ;- "

+-

 

   

  

   "0 /# #$./  &  

 &  !

 & 

!    

"# %  '6!

 +-

     



!  & #$%%*%.



    

 *   =; "

(!  & #$%%*%.

=; 1 * 

  &!

   %

# 2 ! < $



,    ,

&  

6 

!  

   

?  #$./

   !  #"

&    & "

+- + - + ;-



!    

("



 % ! % - %!& 3B < "1.A$ "/## +  /A /" "/#1- '





 ; 4

8

  &>  3!!





!  & #$#"*#1        

&   

 ( 



 4

8

 9&

 4

8

'



 !   3!! 5 +  -

#$.1

! 

& ?

   '()

 !!!  3!! 5 +  -

#$0#   

(!  & #$0/*0#    ( 

   

 I ' L

&   ! < ."$#  #. #/ #$$/ I ! ' L

( 

 !& 

 " 



 

  

!

 ( 

   &

 4

8 @ !&   !   '



       =

!  &

 

  



 &!   #$1$*%/ *  "  

) 

!   

+ 

    !  .  $% %/0% &  , !!

%& "1 %!& "/#% +"- 5( #0"

% ' !2%$ % & "/$% %/0%   !$%0 %   %& "/#% +"- 5( #A.

      

   

  

$ 

 # "

+-

 

#"

&  #$./

. / '  !2%.

$ %  &"1  %& 3B < .:%.

#$A0 +  "/ #" "/#" '



   

! 



       

 D 



  

 ! 

 

) &



!    

7

 ,0/%8 

 !

 & #$$$ +"-

+3 - %.#

      )   3!;

!

   !



  

  

 

; "

+-  3!! 5 +  -

#$0#  &   

  * 



     

  B*%

!



    !

   

 

  

= 

 

   

! 

 &        

   

 " 

#  * 

 #$1$*%/

$   =; "

!  & #$%%*%.

=; 1

!  =; 1 

 

 110#>""/11

 

!  !

#$1$*%/ #$0%*0.

=; .

=; $ 

!    

!

6     =  "     & & 

   ?

& ;  #$0#

      

 

  



 

     

 &! 

  % +"- 

?,  !

  &/6!

 +-

  

 * 

   "0 /# #$./    ;  "

+-  3!!

)* 5 +  -

#$0#



 

 .

!

* I.

B

     !

  !  

!



       

   "0 /# #$./



I L  

"

+-

 ;  

  





 

=;  +

- "

+- 

     

   "0 /# #$./



 I L

)    ;  +

- "

+-



   *   "0 /# #$./ 

 ; !

 I L



 



 '& '





 & 



   "0 /# #$./ 

  



 *"!

    

    

     





!

   & &  !



!  & & #$#%*#.

 

!

 

3   

    



    

&  9& @ !   &    

) 

!  39&  !

 L



.'

% '6!

 +- '



 

      

  

$

!   



  +-  &! 

 

 &  '

 3  ?   )  '



)6!

 +-

;!



!  *    

2

  

   



  

  

!  *   

 2 

3 3!!

 

&

   

  

      

 * 

  &  ;

D  +- *   

 

  ;  "

+- % +1- +

-

   &  !

 

 

$%!16!

 +-

3



 &

      *

I:

    

  

  !

 '

 "+- +1-

 

I  

 !

        

))  !! &   !!   L

!  

 









I    +    !



  !! &   !!  

 

  ) 

!



  '()   ,-  )

.  " %/$"  (/ %  ' %!&

+.9 :

D 9   ) 

  6

3*   & 2!!  / 

- '+  //'%)   %  //'%)

:9+ ;<& 

 ;   !! &   !!  

 * +1-  +-  "

 :



   * +1-  +-  "



3*   & 2!!  !

  ?!

 ,  +-    &  &     2

   ; I  !! &  L   & 

  !     &

 

 & 

 !  & !    !

 

!! &   L

) 

     " 7%/$"  " %/$" !(/ %  ' %!& #$::

5( ":0

  +1- +.- "

+-  3!! 5 +  -

#$0#

* I

  * +1- +.- "

+- &   





         - ' '

 





  





   /  !  &  

)9   

&

    !! &   !!      / ! 



  &

 !! 

9    

#$0#

    ! 

 ' 

 

 !

     

  

 &  &    &  !  !  & !  2          - '

 



    



 2   

3*   & 2!!  !

 

!

 ,  +-

    

 

 

   !  !!   !! &  

     







      

   L ) 

  ?,  !

!=5 1(

 !7#"/-!! %! +#$:0- 33

1.

= 

#A:" ! 

   !

 3  ! 6   

9 &

 

!   & &        #% #.

!

  * I#%

2

 

   &      ! 6   

9 &

   !   & &

)     

 !&  





    &

   &

 6

! &  &

) &  ! 

      &  #.

/. - & #>.#41-?, ' +#$0%- :

3

A//

"/ @ 

# #$.#  9   

 

 

9

   

  #1.0 )

 !!

 

 

' @ !%>-% /8 +#$0A- # 3

0#:

    



  !6  9 &  ! &

      &

 



B

  !

  ! !  





      

  

  8       566 =; "

(!  =; % =; ## 



  " !

9  2

 *      ! !  !      &

? ! 

    

3 

  *    &! 

& 

 +  &! - 6

=

)

     

  !!  &

 



?

!     +-  &

 

 9

 

  )   3! +  '!-

#$:# !

     #. /# #$:"   566

  &



)   3!;

!



 & !&     

 * 



566

    '



3!" 

%! ! % - %!& 3B < 1.":

"/#:

+  "" /A "/#:-     #A #" "/#.

    '

 8  & ! < 1"%$

 ! 1:#:

4 /#   

   3  8

'



   "/ /1 "/#"



  3  8!

& 8    ;



 3

 !

 9

 

  3  &

 ' !2% , !!

%& #$

& # %!& 3B < #0..% "/#/ +  /A ## "/#1- '



     

   #1 #$0#

!



' & 

):





  

!     3  ! 2





   

 ;

   !  

 3!! 5 +  -

#$0#

3



 &



     

2 

  



 



 



&     

!     

   



"1(6!

 +- !  5 

)  (    9 * +#-B ) 

!

I1% %!  %! ! % -> #$:$ 5( "0"

 #$:%

 

   

 %%

!! 3  C +"-B &  

(!  6 6  

  3 >3 )   3!;

 #$$% > #$:1

C +1-B    & 

(!  6 6  &! ! !  

  "+- +0- #$0#

#$$% #$:1

   !



?1

 '  % "1  %>

#$0:

3 A.0C +%-B   #$$%

#$:1

  

!!   

  3 >3 )   3!; ! !& 9  

) &! ! C +.-B &  &   #$$% #$:1

 &! ! 

  C +0-B 1//

3  2   &C

+:-B :

+%- #$$%

 "

+""- 0# + - #$:1

"+- +0- #$0#



 C 2

! !  



 

  3   3!!

  

   ;







 !    !  & ! !     !& 6   

!

  "$0 3  2 2





"#A * I  @">"-8  @,"-"  !,"  1 '#&  -"  %#"'!%% .1"  .<  !%!1"8 &"/.1 '$"@'"-&,%0->"&!%'5!%!1" 0-0-%"!-!!," "2!"'!,%&&, -".<@ < #$4/"'!-.<@ <-">"'4" -"$-#&;A / . '#%&8!,"@'"-8&%#"'!%%"#8&, 11.""'!%!1"#- $/0"'& !%' &0"-,%&"'!%!1"/"'! "&%#"&8%!,"1 '#&$/" @%!,%'!,""2$14&%' -<$1 4&"&"$!%') 5!,"3 6$!:8 !,"@'"-&4$,1 '#&@41#.""'!%!1"#-$/0"'& !%'!%&8 ,@">"-8/ #"$1" -!, !!,"'4&!0->"!,"-%5,!@'"-&,%08 &"/.1 '$"@'"-&,%08>"&!%'5!%!1"-!, !%!$/"&@%!,%'!," "2$14&%' -<$1 4&"&"$!%') 5!,"3 6$!:&, 11."'

!,"0"-&'&$1 %/%'58@,%$,,"$ '"&! .1%&,'!,". &%&-">"'4" -"$-#&;A / . '#%&-!,"-/ !"-% 1&,"-">"'4"-"$-#&!@,%$, 0-"&4/0!%'!-4!,%& !! $,"#@41#8,@">"-8."&4.A"$!! -".4!! 1B

,""'!-%"&%'!,"-">"'4"-"$-#&$ --< 0-"&4/0!%' !-4!,8@,%$,8,@">"-8 -"-".4!! .1" '#$ '."&,@'!."@-'5 .<!,"-/ !"-% 1 &'-"$-#,""'!-%"&8,@">"-8%'$ &". &"# '- 4#-/ '%041 !%'-">"'4"-"$-#&8!,"& /"@41#'! $'"- '<-%5,!-!%!1"'!,"0"-&'&"'!"-"# &@'"-%'!,"

)+ -"$-#&BL

        

   +

 -

       !& BE  

!

+  < #- ?

   #$1$*%/ ) 

!

"1(6!

 +- 



  3  )       !

 

! 



& (      0  1"&     

& &

? !!    

 "

+ - "1

3 

#$%A

            ! ;  !

   +

 -

    

  &!     +- +- 

"#A

! 

"1(6!

 +- 2

  !

 ! 

   

 &   

!

!

  *

&  

3 

     

 !

* 

)

 <

 & !

  &



!

! 



 

 

 

&  !   

!



  "$ /. "/#A       6 >

 M><    M><