Jagir Singh And ORS. v. Dalip Singh
!" !# #"
$$%% &"' %$ !# #"'!# # (
$
)"
"
*" #"+, -
"
"'% #"+, - " # $$%%
"
".* !#, - " "$ / -
)"!"$# )!
1#%%! # $" $$%
"!'+ .#% # $$%%
"!'+ .#% "$ / -
2
%4 ! 3 22
$$% '5 3 '% 1)1 23
)% #- % # $" $$% ! # '"" ! 1#%%! # $" $$% # *'!+ " 2 3 # "% 1'" - 7## # ' % .4 #
$%5$$%% " %" # # #4 7" 7" $ # ' % # . + 1#%%! % # *'!+ " # 8" $$%% 1'" 3 - 7## # $$% % .4 # $" $$%%5$% # % . +
(" '% " # $$%% # '.+ # #' !# # '% # 7 '+"" 9 '.+ # # $" $$%%5$% " # # ."#" #' !# ' %- % ' # # # $$%%5$% : " # #' !#, # #' !# # ;' <%% 6
-'" # $" $$%%5$% 9 '.+ # # $$%%5$% # ;+ .# # ! 7 # <%% )< )<2 # 7 7 # $"- ' ;' # <%% .' # "% 1'" 7%% # 8" $$%% 1'" +"' # - # 7 7 9 '.+ # - # "4 $'.% # . ;+ )< 9 '.+ # # ' # $% +""' # + #'% #- . " # <%% -'" # $% #'% #- . '$#% # *'!+ # "% 1'" 7%% # 8" $$%% 1'" " . +"! - "- .
!
(" '% " # "$ / -, #
2 #" #, # '.+ # .# # %%! ! 7 )<
)<2 # #" ";+ $%%4 + # #' !# # $' # #'+. +$" # <%% #" $" #', #" 7 +$% 2 # 9 ' , . # # ! 7 # $"- ' ;' # <%% 9 '.+ # # "% 1'" 7%% # 8" $$%% 1'" # : " # " - # '""%4 ' # # <%% 7 '%4 ;' 7 % '""' .4 '$' "'+ # ! #" $"-" " ! %7 "- . '$#%
=# 1'" # #" %" '% " # $$%% %" '% " "$ / - # $"' # $$"
.: 7%% # "" # "% 1'" # $ # # $" $$% +"% "- . + # *'!+ # "% 1'" # 8" $$%% 1'" " " 7# %7 "- . '$#% " # " 7## " % #""
=# $" $$%%5$% # % ' " %" # # #4 7" 7" $ # % +'"! 2 :% +$" :#" / 535 3, 3525
>, 5
6 535
> ' &%%! =%7 # !#, =#% " +"", " # " # 4"
9 7 # # $%, 7# 7" # * !#, # # ."#" * !#, #' !# 7 # 7" # ' $"$"4 # #' !# # ;' <%% 6
3 #" -'"
9 7 # # $% # # <%% 6
7 '%4 ;' .4 # # ' $! + ' '"% %- 9 7 '"#" $% # + $% # # $% - % # $'"# % +'"! 7 :% "+ #' !# " % " ₹ , 5
=# , 7# 7 # ."#" # #' !# 7 % # $"$"4 #' !# # . '"% ', # # 7" + # # # #' !# 7## # . + # $%
7 7"!, # #' !# #
9 7 '"#"
# # #' !# # -" ;' 4 <%% # #' !# 7 %" $" 7# ' ! '+ #', # ?' $'! #'+. +$" # %%! <%% " 9 7 # # $% 7" #" 7" " $ # ' $"$"4
>
=# "% 1'" # "+ # %%7! '
!"##
!"#$
%
!"#$
&
!
"#$
'
(
!
"
( ) *
9' / 7 ! # $%$$%% # "% 1'" 7#% ! # ' : " # - %% # 7 %'! # )<2@%- !# 7# # $ # #' !# # %- " "$%$ !# # #" 7 $ " ;%' # "$5 %$ !# "+ # <%% =# "% 1'" % :
" # # # $% # $'"# $"$"4 "+ #' !# " " , 5 7## #7 # #' !# #- 4 $% %- " # $% # # % # $"$"4 " -%'.% ", - $" # '$ .4 # $% 9 7 # # <%% 7 $"- " 7# # $"- 2 # 9 ' A" 9' / 3, 7 ' # # ' 7 +.% # $%$$%% 7" "?'" % ' " $ +$%" ' " %" B- # # '" ' / 7 ' .
# 7" +
.4 # $%5$$%% # $%
# . # !, # ' % .4 # $$%% 7 +
$$% % .4 # $%$$%% 7 + - *'!+ 3 7#% +! # $$%, # 8" $$%% 1'" # ";+ # " - ' # .# # ! 7 , @%- !#)<2 )< C'"#" !#, - # + #" ";+ # #' !# #
$' # #'+. +$" #" $" 9 7 '"#" # )< C'"#" !# # # # :7 #' !# $"%%4
=# - )</"4 )'.% # # # <%% ." #'+. +$" # 7 ! 7, 7#" $"'% # <%% #7 # # 7 7 # #'+. +": # <%% 7 % : " =# # #" 7 $ .7 # !'" @%- !# 7#" # #! D! 7E # . 4$ 7 % ' . '$' =# # # " <%% 7 4$, 7#" + # 7 7" #7" #" " 7" " $! # # ! 7 7" $" # + 7# # %%! <%% 7 4$ 9 7 ."- # # + "", +" , - )<2 # #' !# 7 +'" %! .' # # ! # <%% "!" # +"%4 #'+.
+": # <%% 7#" # #" '+ , % 7" ! .4 #+ 9 7 ' # #" # <%% 7 #7 . '%4 ;' <%% " '$' "'+ "' # <%% 7" $%% #', 7 ."- # '% . # # <%% $"$' .4 # $% 7 # % !' <%% #' !
=# 1'" # % ;+ # " ""
$"'% # %%! <%% 6
7'% #7 # # + '"!" <%% # " <%% # . 4$ - # + # $" , #' !#, 7# . # ;', 4$ .' # + 7 #- . 4$ #" !$ .7 # #! D! 7E 7#" # !'" # ! 7 " $" 8'"#" $"'% # <%% #7 #
6 # .4 # <%%, # . + # # ;'#' !# # ! #'+. +": # <%% 7#" + # # <%% # . ! %4 ." #'+.+": 7## %%! . # #' !# =# # <%% " #', % / " # . !- # <%% ;%' %$ !# 7# # ."#" # #' !# 7# $" # -, 7## # . ' #"", 7 %:! " # 9 # <%%, # . # #" 7" 7 ! 7 , @%- !#)<2 C'"#" !#, -)<
2
)<2 # # ";+ $%%4 # # <%% 7 4$ # $" # #' !# # #'+. +": # <%% # $" # , # #' !# # #'+. +": 4 '+ # $" 9 7 '"#"
+ .4 # 7 # # # %- 7# %$ !# , , 4 $" # %%! <%%, #! # . !- %$ !# 7# 7 ' # $"$"4 '"% '" .! % '"--! #"
9 '"#" ";+, # @%- !# # # # "++." # + # ! 7 # '% - 4 7# #' !# # =# "' "% # "%- $" - )<2@%- !# "$"' #".%7 # "% # . .4 # ="% @"# # 1'" # %+ ,
--.
> /, 01
2.
3 .1
,4
. 5.1
6
6
$
3
. 78 $
.0 3
-
* =#', "+ # -, . # <%% # . '%4 ;', "#", #" 7" -"% '$' "'+ 7## #- . 7"
3
+%"%4, $"'% # - )< C'"#" !#, 7# % . # ! 7, 7'% #7 # # " ;+ # # # # :7 #' !# $"%%4 #', # '% #- $.%4 !- - # # #' !# # ;' # <%% =# )< # % # # <%% 7 ."'!# " # . 4$ #' !# # #'+. +":
4 '+ # $" =# "' "% # "%- $" - )< C'"#" !# "$"' #".%7 # "% # . .4 # ="% @"# # 1'" #
9 ,
:::
. 4 + . +
!
" !
.
+
#
!
" ! #
+
6
$
; < 01 .
" !
-
*
". # $" # . ;+ )<, 7# # /"4 )'.%, # # ";+ # # :7 7# #' !# # # # 7 -! "+ 7# # #' !#
2 # 9 ' , " '"
$% & !
' = 2
2> ?2 2
@
1
2
B.
1
2
2
#
!
(
* 6
9 +" % %7 # !" # #- . + "" $"- # ;' <%% =# !" "?'" '" 2 # 9 ' , " - "+%4 '%%% .# # ! 7 # # " ; # #'+. +$" # . + .4 #+ #" "$- ";+
"-", #" - #7 # #4 # "- $"% :7%!+ "+ # " ?' # +":! # #'+. +$" # " # <%% =#', ' ;' # <%% # - . "+%4 $"-
>
# #" #, 7 # # '%%4 $"- # # # %- 7# # %$ !# 7 %$ !# 7# 7 %:! " #
<%$ !# (% !# 7# 7 ; +." # )#4 # $%%4 # - # # #
7 %$ !# 7# 7 %:! " # 9 7 '"#" .4 #+ # #' !# 7 %" $" '% " 7$$" #', # ?' #' !# %4 #'+.+":! # <%% !! # <%% % " '. 9 # '"#" + # - %$ !# # #' !# 7 7%% " $" -"% 4 $"" # # #', # ?' ;'! '"!" <%% 6
, #" 4 $"" # # 7## : $%
% #!#%4 '$' /#!
# . $ ' .#% # $$%% ." # 1'" "+ # ";+ %! # - # 7
+%"%4, <2%$ !# "% !# 7# 7
+." )#4, # % "" # # #' !# # %% %- " # ."#"%$ !# 9 7 # %$ !# ' : " # 9 7 '"#" "" # # %$ !# 7 7%% " -"% 4 $"" # # # 7 7 !#.'" # #' !# =# "' "% # "%- $" - <2%$ !# "$"' #".%7 # "% # . .4 # ="% @"# # 1'" $ %$ C8 CD 6
$ 2"3 23 &' 232
) .1
E E E
2 $ 2 2
3
"
*'+,
6
2
!
-
* /#! # . $ ' .#% # $$%% ." # 1'" "+ # ";+ # .- 7 %! # - # 7
< 7%% <3 % '%%4 '$$" # # =#', "+ # .- -, $$" # # 7 %" # ! -"' '+ %'! # % 7## # . $"' .4 # $%$$%% 7%% # "$ 7## # . "% '$ .4 # $%$$%% 7# "$ $4+ +4 %#'!#, # .4 # <%%, # . + # # + ! #'+. +": .4 ;' #' !# .' $"'% # <%% #7 # + # . ! .4 # ;' 9 $ #" .! '".' - # # # %- " # %$ !# 4 " # . !- # <%% ;%' #+, %#'!# # %$ !# 7 # % #" 7# 7 % # $"$"4 #" .! <%%
2
F$! -7 # .- "'+, $$" # # ! # "% 1'" 7%% $$%% 1'" " . # - '+ "" + " #" $"-" " %%!% # $" $$%% #- . .% ."! #" 7# # $"+" 3 # )'*. 1'" , > " # 1'" "" # $" !'%" $$%
"!%4, # *'!+ # "% 1'" 7%% 8" $$%% 1'" " '$#% # $$% % .4 # $" $$%% +
9 7'% . "%- # # $%$$%% # % $$% " % - ."! /
1 '"
"" 3 '% 6 1)1 " 7# 1)1 " !"!
$"+ +$" # #'+. +$" # # <%% 7# # # # % =# $$% # . $$ .4 # "$ # . ' #".-, # "% 1'" 7%% # 8" $$%% 1'" #- !- -"% " " "! # <%%, %'! $" ' ;' # <%%, 7## " #- . ' . -% #- . '$#% .4 # 1'" 9 # "'+, # 1'" # $ # # $" $$% +"%
"-", . # # $% # +- # $" $$% 7# ' %!, +'# , '"! # '" "%, 7 $ # $%$$%% #- +$" # #'+. +$" # '.+ "$" % ;+ ;$", 7## ;$" 7'% #- # . ";+ .4 # '% " # 9 4 '# - 7 %, #, - # '% #- % - #'+. +$" ;$" %%7! # $"
3 $$% 7'% "'% "$! # +" $ # # # $$% # . % 7#' ' %! 9 7'% % . "%- # -7 # ! !- .4 # 1'", # 1'" # $ # # $$% 7'% 4 74 #%$ %%4 $"$"%4 *'! # +", #', # $$% " % - +
# !, %" '% " # $$%% # '.+ # # "!% % # . ;#. .4 # $%$$%% B;
<3 9 '.+ # # $%$$%% . $"+ : .: # "!% # %
9 4 '# "?' + .4 # $$%% ." # !"4 # 1'", #, # "?' 7'% . % .4 # !"4 " 7# # $"'" "'% 7## " $$%.%
%% # $! +%%' $$%, 4, #%% $ -7 # .- ""
"#""$
#C# %&'(&')*+',-./01)',*2/'3!
'*12 %&'(&'))'+2)(,45'!
'*12