Surinder Singh Matharoo v. Ut Of Chandigarh
! "#$#%& ' ( )*#%! *#%+,- , *.,,#%!
// 00 % 1 *$)$ , %!#+ *, $/%! % -& 23-
!"
!"
# $% &' 4 %
& &&' &(
') '( *+&, ' &' -*+ ""
*"!&" " & &' .
& $"& /0" % ' &' &( &(
& + + &
1 &
+( & ' &' &( &( & &2 ( %*& " " "& &(
') '( " 34 &" + *+5 6 & 7 ( &"
&' 5 - &' 6 , '!
&' * 8 & ,
&'
- ( "
+ "&"&(, 9 - &'
* &" - -& &" + "&( &- "&! & &' & & ( & !&' & (&&
& & "&'- !&
'7 : $% &' (:"
#5
+ & ( &!&' " &( & &" + 9 * &
78 * & * ; ( ""
!&'* "9" "
* '
&
( & #5 - -
&"& - & ( & &' . & "" - ! &" "& 0 " &' &( * " & " '& # <4&" # < &" 4&" ""
' &
+ & * "& " # < &"4&" 6#0 &- - &(&&' - "
""!+ *
(6#0 &- 9 ""
& +*)"&&& "&" "&&
"""
' !&" " ""
- " "4 "9'4 & ( -
& +
9 & "
* '- "!4 & '(4 & (- (
&
&"*2( &&'" +- 9 & &*2 " " &&' (
( &&'" +- -& 67 - 9& &" &5& :
- "
&!&' &% (
" "
+ ""
-&- "*+5 & :
*5 " 64 *&&' ( - !&&" & &2&
(
" + ' ( &-&64
' & "&' ( "
& -&
&' &
"&!&' =: "(
&" +&!&' & ""
- "
"& /0"> 4 "((& ""
- " ' -& " "& / "&"0 ' +" &" * "" ?/ -&"
'
& + "
&(& 5
&" "
&2 (&97 ( , "&&&" 4&" @ A * B @ A * - 7 ( @ 6,
&' @;A * ,
&'@ A56 &7 ( @ A5 9-&&' @CA , 9 &' @/A5& :
@?A5 " *&&' @ 6 '*&&'0 &- @
- 5 - &'- '&!
" + % ( ""
"& - "6
&""
' &(
&" &6-! & +!&"&" &' * &""
-
" ""
'&' '!&" " & "!&" " ""
1
&"
;
= &' ''&! ' &) '( "!&"& " *+ & &
*& *+ ""
1
% ""
1
+ ' + C( / + * &!";+ &(& &'
&" & &" -&"-
- *+& ? : " + &!&-( + * 9 ' D ("&( *+& 4 "
+
1 ""
) '("!&"& " *+& 5 ! '
( " & !"
+' '"" % "
&" &
+ !*+ (
"
&%& -&) '("!&"&%
' ) '( "!&"& & "" & &(&-& -
-&D (" ""
&&' .& & * -
* -&& (& +6& (& + "&&-& -(&"& %
'+ ""&(& & (
+ ""
"(( -&"('
"&+ & * -&& (& +5
*& &) &"
) &"& "
+ &" )&
( & ( & &"&+ %
&(& ""&* & "6&&! !& +=5 7 &'&!&- " && *"& (& +-
! -
*2 + &'
( "&( &( - ""
&*+ * " & + ' 4 ""&'
+ 6-! "&& "*+
1* & -&&-(( "& "&&" + ""
&&' .& & * * & 6&* & *
&" ' 5&( "
& " ( && & -&&&
&
*( !* &(& -& +&" 5 6 )+)$ '4 ! & @ 9&'1 B1 @ * B1