High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/676/1995allowed

(O&M) Baldev Singh Etc. v. Balbir Singh And ORS.

2018-04-24Mr. Justice Girish Agnihotri10 pages

!""#$%$&'()$*+,-+./

! "

" 000 ' 12

3 4 5555

)"%"&!'

$ "% & '

() $"% $ (+$ "% & " ,$"% $ " ". //// 6"76")6 8 &- '

%" !+ ** % 0 , % 12 2$ & !+ "3

% 4 $5 $ * %"

!+ ""

!4 $) $" " 0 , % 67 2 !+ #"

"* *

% & !+ *!+ ***"

""!+&+"* %*% ,%"* !+"

%% ""*$ &%

1 8"

("*%"%$

! *

" !*"

9 % . 8% ""*%""* :

*** %*% ,%"* "* 6 62 77 ;<'= % "* %

"*"" $>) **$00 ,, % * ", "*? + , "&% "*"

6 62 77$00, , " "*"* & ** %" " ," "* .$ 66= , "* 12$ 66= &

% !+00 , , ,"+

,," & "! ,"*<% ""* !*"

00,, " , " % "= *"

"* ** * % % ,!

% % " " <% ,"* "*;<'= **$ & + & " ,

"* %"

% ?"& $ ,, +* $* 00,,

& ","

" % > ** * % *"

, 0 % " @ *9":

$&;6:% << = &9!6")%@ ," "*4 +$ 77 #"

"*"

!4 $5 $*"

* 00,"

" " +"

"<% **> % &

+* 2 > **" ""( % **"

"( *"*%*% ,%"* "*$

" *% $ &" ! " %" ,"+!+, "* 00,,"& ,3 A ,$ * "

%",*"

& " <% $ %$ !*"

9 %

3* ".%" $

( + % * ",00, ,*"

,"*.7$666= 61 77> &**% " "* 6162 77

;<3= * -" " .$ + & "

& "* + +& , 0 % "*!+

** * ".$ <%

"6162 77& ("&"* ** * 00,,&"

%", "<% +

"6 62 77; % ;<'=1<% *"

**!+* 00,,!" "*%" "3* ".%, , "! """* 3* -" * &

, " ( , (!+* ". + !, >#"

9 %

*""&

& "

B C %00,D, " " ** *"

%" " % "* . 66= % 12$ 66= "& ,"+ <% % E '' 1 C ** +& " ,

"*%"

% E '' . C !

1. #'#E

'3 2 C * "2 !"*

& "

% ! "! % %E '3

C !*"

"0" "*% +

E '3 C %" ! & ** * "6E '3 * 7 "

&"% , +% F

4 $* %" , %! "*$%9 -"$12*" **

* %"%&!+

"9 -".$

$ , & " & *"

"* ** %"A +$ "* ** *"

%*% ,% "* "*;<'&% 0 , % 67 2 > * *

!*"

$%" , % !" *$ *&%% $ *"

0 , % !+ #"

% %$ %"!*"

6 9 %" *"

F %" *"

** %"

, , % !" *>,%"

" +& " "*

"* 6 62 77 ;<'=*"

** 6162 77 ;<3=*"

"** . 1 %" *"

$ ;<'= + "" * ,&% !!+ 3C G#4$?& 8 '

'C2& <,$ &" " ,! , " "* "

" ;<'= % ;<'=1 "

;<'C2= ;<'C2= #"+"* # -"..= 77 @ *9":$&;6 :% << ="!#@& "" %"

;<'2 %"+"* &

, * % ;<'

!"* "% , $ #"

9 %

* "*;<'=*"

**& +<%

,"+& ,"* <% " "

%" % % , % . >" %"

+$ "* ;< 3= 12 77*"

"** ".&%

+ %"

"% , !+

4 $;<3=

" " ,&, " "!12 77> ;<3=1*"

"** ".&<% "

1 77" !"** "* .6 77

;<3.>*% * ! ;<3=&"

<% * , *% !%", +"

!+ *

& & "* %"

!+ #"

% 2 F %" *"

*& "

-"61"* 0 , !+

"$ $;<3=1" "

* "+ > 612 77&

3C %$ * %"

!+ *

! "! **! % %!+ #"

% F %" * -" ". %" , 0 % " ;<'2&*!+ **"1 77$ " " $ **%" * " * %*% ,%"* "*"+$ !

& 1 7 & %*% ,% &* "&% "*"

"** "." 77 C +" " $ #

$ "

%" ** & %" " $;<' & "! <% "" "

!%,"& & "

!%","& $ *** %*%

,%"* '

" $ *** % , 0 % "&&&

"* , 0 % " " *

00,,&"

& "

" "

<% *"

" " "* , "* $;<'= ,"* $ *""& !

A ""* & *"

, "!+ #"

%" B

C * %"

!+ *

0 , % 67 2

0 , % "* #"

"" $!% , "* , , % ""*%E 7 ?%" !,",!+ %"

"* %"

"* %$ #"

"* %" & $ % ,

" " %"

" +!"

"* "* 2 77

;< '= "* 12 77 ;< 3= 9*$ "* ;<3=$$ 12 77 ( "!%"

" !"*%$ 2 77 ;<'= <% *"

**%"

! "! " *%! " ** $ %$

**!! " !" *$" !"*"

&"% , +%$ *% $ ;<'=&

<% " 2 77 ;<3= 12 77& ,&<% %"%"** -"

".* 00,,$0 "*

"* ** "& "

$ ;< '= <% !+," +*"

**> "*

;<'=! + "" * , "*'C.$ $&""!*"

00, , %"

"* * -" " $ "*$;<'*"

,"*.$ 66= ,"* 12$ 66=& "00,, ,"+

,$ % $;<'=1& +<% > $;< '=$&<% "

% "("** 00, , ,!, ( %

$$ **& +& " ,

% & & +>"% , ! + "" * , "*'C2$G#4$ ?& 8 '

&" !,

<, "% , %", ,!, ( > & + "*"

**$ "* % , 0 % " " "

$ 00,,&"

"* , *"

"*","

" +&

>*"* * ! *

("& !"

<% ""* $ ;<'= *"

16 F #"

%%*% ""

* "* ;<3=$+<% "12 77& > " , =%& %" "*"

%"*

, &, ""

"$ ,& % ".. 77$!

,& "

H" ,+> ,

%" "

" % "& !+

, & " > ,"+ "* 3C1$ 3"$ "% &"

!*"

" 0 ,

& &

& % & " *% ""*) , %!*"

% "216$2$27$2169'# 1 "

"$ %$ &" *"

"** ".>*

;<3=$ 12 77$ <% ""*&% * %";<3=. .6 779 %" $;<3=.$ " * %

<% ""* $;<3=; $;< 3=1$ ", " <% ""* $;<3= 11 *% % + ! "*$;< 3=&"

+<% $ ,& *!

% "* **;"

&$ "*$ ;<'=! +<% "" * ,! , " ! +%", "" *

, "*'C2$ G#4$?& 8 '

>#"

%%*% "*"

* " " &%! !+ *

& "

+0 * " "

" 1. 9&"* !"$ %" %% 0 , % 12 2 !+ "3

% 4 $5 0 , % 67 2"* ""

!4 $)

+$ *!+ ***"

""!+&+"* %*% ,%"* % 12 > %" "& !"

, >3 4?

()$*+,-+./ ",