High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/17564/2022allowed

Jasbir Singh @ Kala v. State Of Punjab

2023-09-12Mr. Justice Aman Chaudhary6 pages

!"#$"

%"" ""&"

'()*+,-*./0/+1 2

3(04/56/1789:(;( 2222*)/)/+1*5 <*50=0 6)()*+,=1>(4 222*0?+1-*1)

"@A B#C@ D!

E"@""

% FFFFF 5*0*1) 52=8(1/8(-8(GH-I+.()*G,+5)8*?*)/)/+1*52 52(1/?(;6/178H)J(;G'HKG=1>(42 LLLLL "@""

%M!D 2 5(N*5 /1 )8* ?5*0*1) ?*)/)/+1 ,/;*- =1-*5 6*.)/+1

5222 /0 ,+5 )8* 75(1) +, 5*7=;(5 4(/; )+ )8* ?*)/)/+1*5 /1 .(0* OP Q+2 G -()*-

G 5*7/0)*5*- =1-*5 6*.)/+10 G

G G +, Q'6 H.)G G () +;/.* 6)()/+1 R(;J(1-/8(=-85/(1G'/0)5/.):(?=5)8(;(2

2 S*(51*- .+=10*; .+1)*1-0 )8() )8* ?*)/)/+1*5 /0 /1 .=0)+-N ,+5

N*(5 (1- (4+=)

T+1)802 R8* ?*)/)/+1*5 J(0 1*/)8*5 )8* -5/I*5 1+5 +J1*5 +, )8* )5=.UG ,5+T J8/.8 )8* (;;*7*- .+1)5(4(1- J(0 5*.+I*5*-2 * ,=5)8*5 0=4T/)0 )8()

?+;N)8*1* 4(70 .+1)(/1/17 ?+??N 8=0U J*5* (;;*7*-;N 5*.+I*5*- ,5+T )8* 0*.5*) .(I/)N +, )8* )5=.UG 8+J*I*5G )8*N J*5* (;; *T?)/*- +1 ( )(5?(=;/1 (1- )8*5*(,)*5 )5(10,*55*- /1)+

?;(0)/. 4(70 *(.8 J*/78/17 U702 (1- )8*5*(,)*5 0(T?;*0 J*5* 0*?(5()*- ,5+T )8*0* 4(70G )8=0 0=.8 0(T?;*0 .(11+) 4* .+10/-*5*- (0 5*?5*0*1)()/I* 0(T?;*0 +, )8* .+1)*1)0 +, (,+5*0)()*-

?+;N)8*1* 4(70G +5/7/1(;;N 0)()*- )+ 8(I* 5*.+I*5*- ,5+T )8* 4+-N +, )8* )5=.U2 * 5*;/*0 =?+1

#"$%&

'()"*

+*,

- )./0".*

'/!0)/&

12)% 2

3 456 78895 :;6

3 = ;

6 ;9==> ?4 4 ?

@ @9> A 49 4594 A9 5 AB @ > ;4 ;44 9

9<4 =>;B ;<

B94 9

;@>3 D@; D9> 95>; 9 59A;44 9 9 AB @ ;D4 ;< @ 4=E ; 49>8;4

>9=E> ;< A9>9 =6 F4@4 45 9=

> ; ;44 49 A9 5 ; @ > 594 4;

G//!

H%+"

I /

+*,

J0 0%

G2!L M 89>>

;

6 6

3 99 > D@ =@ ?N O45P Q R9 4B :;6 S

< 5 AB @ ?9 ;< 9A3 D9> > >> ;44 9

6 @94> D4 <49 ; 6 6

6 :; ; ;< 84;>= ; >>> @9> A T9 6 U ; ;4 =9> D9> 4 >4 99 > @ 8 ;43 D@4 4=;C4B D9> 5>> @9 =;4= 95 9 @ D9> =;C = 9 >= ; @ 84 ; 9549B 4;6 U 9;@4 =9>3 @ @9> A

85 =9 A9> ; >=5;>4 >93 @;DC43 ; 4=;C4B @9> A <<= <4; @ 3 A @

> ; ; A9 56 5 > ; @ ;< ;V A5 W@ ?84 ;4

X 2& !

X/($,

") I *( $"

+*, J0 0% /K Y,G, !$ /0(%)*

O P? 6

6 W@ =>;B =4 < =9 9 6 6

@9> A < 5 AB 594 ?9 =;>56 7> 84 @ >93 @ 8 ;4

> A@ A94> <;4

B943

;@> 9 9B>6 6 N94 ?9 =;>5 ;88;>> @ A9 5 ; @ 4; @9 @ =;4= 95 Z9 B ;< =;49A9 D9> 4=;C4 <4; @ 8 ;43 D@; D9> 9884@ 9 @ >8; 95; @ D; ;@4 =;9==>6

> @;DC4 9A5 ; =;4;C4 @ >A >> ;> @ 494 ; >9 ;< @ =9> 9 @ >9> ;< ;@4 =9>>6 6 946

! " # "

$%& '( )*+,*-*(( )./01(( 2345( ( 6*7/*04( 8& %9

: "

%"; <=& & >: ? "

#@ "; ! ? "

%&#& ' $ #!#% %"$:"&; "

$%#! ' "

&$: &:" $%" A$": B "

C :&; #" #& "

"? ' "

" " '#: " "

' "

%$$ &: # "

$%& # #$

%& $ % @: %: "

$# $ !&"%$& & $ %& &&###"?''#@%C%?' !"

A #&:#$"#'"

""$D #& " #( E..-*3(( FGH4(( 6*.(( H71(( IJ*JG(( .K(( E+-L*M( %&&: #

@ %": %# " "

"#"# %'" $ &":? ' % " ?% %: !"

& ? "%N#@ #" $&#: %"# "

:@!" #( 23*-4( ( O40G,(( P/547( 8& %9 %: & >#@ "

%" # ! $> : ' !

%@& ' ! % > #$ "

%" C#@ :

N@ @ %!& C%&

" # % $ :

! %: "

%'" ; "

&%!& C $$": %: "

!#Q"

C%& !%:

!@ &; ' ! "

&"%"#> &%!& C $$":; #&"%: ' : %C#@ &%! # :

#$%" ' ! %$ %$N%@R $"%# # $%& ' &#S ' ! "

% %$N%@R$"%# %& >#:: # % % ' "

"%:#@ T : UR :%":

; #&& : ? UV

&; %&

: # =!%# W#: #& 8& %9; "

#@#% &%$"#"? ' "

$%& "? # #:#>#:

% ?"

%@& C%& &"

X %@%#&" "

&%#: : C%& :#&!#&&:

! " # "

$%& '( F/GG5*L(( Y+3*5(( I/+Z,*(( H71(( [/G(( IJ*JG(( .K(( \JJ*5(( E5*0G7/](

X 8 #!#%9 U R

:$#::

& >: "

%" # % $%& ' @ $ &":? #:; #>>#@ ^ %"#"? $> : " ' $!! $#% %"

; "

" #% #& ?" " $!!$; "

@ $ % @&

%: ' %!:; "

$:#"# '

$"#

' U_ =$" $% :#&&: C#"

#!#% ?; # "

$%& ' ( I/*54K+,(( `7,*3(( a(( I*54K(( H71(( [/G(( IJ*JG(( .K(( bG7J(( cG-d*,(

X 8 9 U R

; :$#::

;

! " ' B:#% @ %": %# " "

!! " #$

%&'

& !) & ) %( "*")&

!" " )

$$+ , )

- ./0123425-- 6738/-- 9:;- - <=5>?@7>-- A?3@5?B-- .052=0-

C"+D ' ) E F ) ) $ % & G) (& )( %" %G ()

& " ($& $& H "

) $ ,& & ( I

JEI + K) $ )

- .=B5=L-- 6738/-- 9:;-- 6@=@2-- ?M-- N03L=O-

' & && + +

)

""G& ) & $! "& &G % P %" K) I$! $ ,& & (& %" ) ) ) )& $&( "

$ & & !) + , )

- Q03=:7-- Q=:7/-- 9:;-- 6@=@2-- ?M-- N03L=OR-

' & &&

' ) $ (& %"

! G)!

!! " #$

%& )& % & & "

$ S ) % T!&' % % ( ) G &" & "' ) ( I

JEI

% &"$& T & )

% (& %"' *( !& ) ()

& " (& $& H "

) $ ,&+ + U( G ) & V$&(! &

)

' $" ) )

$ &

!) & & W

)( G

!& + +

W $ " $ G

' ) % T!&

W ) " "*" *

&%" !' )$

$) ) G$"& % " ) () )& $& H "

) $ ,& & ) ( I

JEI

% &"$& %( !& ) ()

& "' )$ ' ) ( ($"%"& %""G&+

!" ! "#$ % !

!" ! "$$

" & $ " ' &! &()

! * ! ! ' &!+ , &" $

!*) !" "*

! " +- , '! )" ) $ $ &()

! "

&! ' .!$! ,"

)% !

!" &!$&,

*""#! ')" $!

!" /!0 % !

!" #! "

1 #!

2!$ ) $! '

! /!!0 % !

!" #! "

!3+ !

!1!$

") !" #!

/!!!0 % !

!" #! &*"

! " " ) $ 2, $ *!4$ ! 41 $ &, )!*!)"$"*" /!20 % !

!" "

)"11!

"** ) !1!

"** ) "* # !)

! ))$ " *" )"11!!" "*# !) !) $"* /20 % !

!" "

$!) , " ! $!) , )") ! $)

" "1!

" , " ).!

$ #!

*) "*

) "

" $!$

!1+ *"1 $!)"! ' ) *)

" "

" , "!) "**!) "

1 #!

2!$ ) ! , 1 /2!0 % !

!" "

! , 1 1!

! !& , /2!!0 % !

!" * !

! $$ $ 1"&! 1&

%! " *"

$ "

) '

)" )!" "*

! $ ! ) *" , "

!" 5

" ) ' , "*

*"!$

1 & $" " , #!

!" !

!1 !"

$ %! "

! '

" *"

1 /2!!!0 % !

!" "

)" , #!

" !"1!!" "*

!" /!40 %

! " +- , '! 1, !1" , "

)" $!

$1$ "! # ! ! '

!" ! 1$ & $ , )

! )

! , &) "*

"" # "# $

"" #" &

' #$ ( ( ) *+

#* , ",

'-' '

' & +-"

- '

" +-" ' '

#* ( .

/0102.3405640789.

:56;<.

=>?@A?>@>B.

DEFGHC I '% &J

KJL I ' #"

KJL