High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/875/1995dismissed

Bhag Singh v. Haryana Agriculturl University

2026-02-19Mr. Justice Namit Kumar12 pages

!"#$% & '

('

'(') '

!$%$*%+#$% & ('

'(') ,

-.$/##$%0123 40 & ('

'(')

6101!$%.7$-!/04"-/!0$8019*#:;%04 -!$%$*%+#$!8*..9*#:;%04 -!$%$*%+# & *..

1#./7<48/%7<$801-!$%$*%+;%0$88*.. 9*#:;%0</%#!/ $% 01!$8 & $0/--.4+/3.

& =>

?

!" # $

!" %& $ ''''

?

<

(

%

) $$

* + " ,- (( (../

0

* 1

$

) $ + " ,( 2, (../

% * " $ 3 $$

$

" $ $

$+ % * ,

4 $ $

% *

'

6

$$$

$$ 89+ $

2( (2 (.:/; < 1 7 (, (.-= $ $1$ > $ " $

$?"

* " " 6 1 $

$ 3

; $ $ " $$;#4 <,- 2- (.-= "

$@ *"" ! $$$ ?

?

! 4 1 "

1 " 1 1 ""1"$A89$ ?"

* %" 1B

?B

C$$ 1 B

2= (.-:$ $

$$ 1 B

1

* B $ ?B

C$$ 1

25 (.-:

0" $$ (= (.-:

6 " (= (.-: $$ 1 6$ " B

"

B

1 $ ?B

6

1

,

! "#

$% $$ $&'( # ) # ### %* *+ $&', # !

# # #- #

# $% $$ '( . / /

%$ $ (= (.-:1 "

(= 2A (.-:

4 $ $@ "8 "

9

* $ !

% $ $$

,2 2= (.-:1

7 " $ "

(= 2A (.-:1

"<

"

&40 $ $$ 1

1 B $ $ $$

" "1

$$

2A 2= (.-:$

0 $$ $

11

+ "

,( 2, (../ 1

(= 2A (.-: 1 $ $ $$1

$@ "

,2 2= (.-:1

(= 2A (.-:1

5 " $ 1

$$1

1 $

(.-: " 1 $ $$ 1 1$ 1 B $

$

1 11 1 1

1

B " $$ "$ 1 " 1 %+ "

,( 2, (../

1

7

$

1 1

0

* + "

,- (( (../1

+ " $ 1 " $ 3 $$7

1

$

" $ $

$ 7+

@$ 1$ $0

*

$$ 8 9 $

" 1

$ B "52 (.-: $ $ $ 7+$

=

D $

" % *

) $$8 9 1$$$ "52 (.-: 1 1

1

$ B " $ $ 52 (.-: $ 7+ 61$

"

+ "

0

* 1

+ " $ % * 1" $ 3 $$

$

" $ $

$ +

$11 6

$ $

) $$

+ "$E "*

:

0 $ 7

""

+ " $0

* $ $ $$1 + + "$ % * 1

1

B " + 1$ $1E1 E$ "

$ -

6

$

.

$$7+ $

2( (2 (.:/; < 1 7 25 (, (.-=$ 1$ > $ " $

$?"

* " "

) 61$

$3 7

"

; $$ " $$;#4 <,- 2- (.-=

" $ @ *"" ! $$$ ?

?

! 4 1" 1 1

1" "" 1 $A89$?"

*

%" 1B

?B

C$$ 1$ B

$ $

$$1 B

1 B "

* B $ ?B

C$$ 1

25 (.-:

0 " $$

(= (.-: 1 1 "

(= 2A (.-:

4 $ $@ "8 "

9

* $!

%

1 B " $

,2 2= (.-: 1

"<

"&40$ $$1

6 $ $

$$ 1 $"

(= (.-:

6 $ " B

"

B

1

1 " C

" 11$ $$$

(= (.-:

(2 61$

$$

1$ (= (.-:1$ "

"1 1 $

"

"

4 $ $@ "8 "

9 "

(= 2A (.-:1 "

* $! "

%$

$$$ 1

1

(= 2A (.-: 1 $ $ $$1

$@ "

,2 2= (.-:1

(= 2A (.-:1" $ 1 $$1

1 $ 52 (.-: "

1 $ $$1 1 $ 1 B $

$

1 11

1

1 1

" $$"$ 1 " 1 D % * 1 "$ $$ + "$ *

!"!#$ %!& '

()*!+$! + %$'$,!),$-%)$ & $,%.

/0-121 $ +& 1

@11

*

6 $B $ $ $$ "

"1

B + " ,( 2, (../

1

7

$

0

* + " ,- (( (../

" $ + " $ 3 $$7

$

" $ $

$ 7+ 6 $ $$7

",2 (( ,22.

(( %B 1

$$1 1

$

1 " $ $ " $ $ 52 (.-: $ 7 +

% * (,

$ "

$ "

* $ $ (= (.-:1 $$1

+ ?

1 $ $$ "1 " (= (.-:

6$ "B

"

B

1 1 B

1 BB

1 B

$ 7B

$1

"

$ " "

1

$ $$

$ (= (.-: " 1 1 " $ $ $ " $ "

3 $ " 1 "

"" ; 1

1 "

< 1

"

$ " 0 $$1 ?"

*

""

1 $$

7 1 1

$ $ 7

1

" $$

+ " $ $$1 1 7+

"

( $ 52 (.-:

61$"

$$ 8

9 1

$

B 1 " $ "

$ $ 52 (.-: $ 7+

(5 F $ $ 0

$"

$

$@ " $ * $ 1

1$ $1 1

*

!

"!#$ * %!# %$ + "1

@ $ *

$ D4 F (2=5$(..211 ,= (2 (..21 1 $ 1$ " $ $ % $

+ "

+ 1# # # 2 3

#

4 5 ##

# # ! # # 7

8 85 9 # 5 4 1# 5 4

#

4

!# / (5

%

$

+ "$

* %!# 1

$

+ "1

$ "$ + " G " $E1 E

1 "

11 1

$ $$ H1 $$

7B

1

"

(/ ! 1 $1 : $ " $ $$7

I $

"I $ E 1 E

,= (2 (..2

@

!"!#$ * % !# * $ " $ "

"

+ "

0

* %$

$

1 $

$

* (A

" "

+ " $$ "

$$ 8

9 1

$ 1

" $ $ " $ $

52 (.-: $ 7+

)5'''(' (=

$

'

"

$

) $$1

1

(:

$

) $$

" $

$

1 $

('

'(') 8 ?

)"

J )

K)F J

K)F