High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/6903/2024disposed of

Satwinder Singh And Others v. State Of Punjab And Others

2024-03-21Mr. Justice Aman Chaudhary6 pages

!"#"$"

%"" ""$"

'()*+,-*./0/+1 22 3()4/1-*53/167(1-+)7*50 222*)/)/+1*50 8*5090 3)()*+,91:(;(1-+)7*50 222<*0=+1-*1)0

">? @#A> B!

C">""

% 5*0*1) 52379;D(5E(1F9E(5GH-I+.()*,+5)7*=*)/)/+1*502 JJJ ">""

%!BK

"AL 2 M7* =5(N*5 /1 )7* =5*0*1) /I/O 5/) *)/)/+10 ,/O*- 91-*5 H5)/.O* P +, )7* +10)/)9)/+1 +, Q1-/(G /0 )+ /009* ( 45/) /1 )7* 1()95* +, E(1-(E90 -/5*.)/16 )7* 5*0=+1-*1)0 )+ 65(1) =(N 0.(O* +, <02& P )+ )7* =*)/)/+1*50 42*2,222R2 2 S*(51*- .+910*O 4+9O- 09;E/) )7() )7* =*)/)/+1*50 47+ (5* 4+5D/16 (0 ()4(5/ /1 )7* <*I*19* '*=(5)E*1) 4*5* 65(1)*- O+4*5 =(N0.(O* )7(1 <02& P 42*2,2 22R ;(0*- +1 1+)/,/.()/+1 -()*- &2 2 I/-* 47/.7 )7* =+0) +, ()4(5/0 0)++- 0=O/) /1)+ )4+ =(5)0 /2*2 :91/+5 (1- 0*1/+5 =()4(5/0G )7() 7(0 0/1.* ;**1 T9(07*- ;N )7/0 +95) I/-* :9-6E*1) -()*- 2R2 =(00*- /1 ( ;().

7 +, =*)/)/+10G 4/)7 O*(-/16 &R G #UVWXYZ[\ CXY]^ UYZ _`^[\a baB C`U`[ _c dYWUe UYZ _`^[\a 2 * )790 =5(N*- )7() )7* /10)(1) =*)/)/+1 E(N ;* -/0=+0*- +, /1 )7*0(E*)*5E0G5*O*I(1)=(5(0+,47/.75*(-)790 f2 M7* 91:(; <*I*19* ()4(5/0 O(00 QQQ 3*5I/.* <9O*0G <*I*19* '*=(5)E*1) O(N0 -+41 )7* <9O*0 +, 3*O*.)/+1 (1- H==+/1)E*1) +, ()4(5/02 M7*5* /0 1+ ;/,95.()/+1 /1 )7* <9O*0 +, ()4(5/0 /1)+ 3*1/+5 (1- g91/+5 ()4(5/02 M7* E*)7+- +, (==+/1)E*1) /0 0(E* ,+5 (OO ()4(5/02 M7* 0*1/+5/)N /1)*5 0* E*E;*50 +, )7* 0*5I/.* (0 =*5 <9O* & /0 E(/1)(/1*- -/0)5/.)4/0* (1- /0 )+ ;* -*)*5E/1*- ;N )7* O*16)7 +, .+1)/19+90 0*5I/.

*2 <9O* & +, 0*1/+5/)N (1- <9O* 5*6(5-/16 =(N (5* T9+)*- 7*5* (0 91-*5 f&2 3*1/+5/)N2 M7* 0*1/+5/)N /1)*5 0* +, E*E;*50 +, )7* 3*5I/.* /1 *(.7 .(-5* 07(OO ;* E(/1)(/1*- -/0)5/.)

! "# $" %"% $ " '"

$ "&

$ "# ("

''"

" )

#""(

$ ''"

" $ " *

''"

" " " ''"

# *

$ "#

''"

" " # )

$$"

! "

"# %$

''"

( $ ( '

$ "#

''"

# ## $ )

$$"

" ' '

# $ & "

(" ( ( !

"# '

& "% ''"

)

"# ' ( "

! "# $

" ''"

! "# %$ $

" ) "

" "%! + ," + -

% " '' " ' " ''"

" '% '

"& " '

' .% !+ ," + / $ "#

(" '

" "# '

" "

0 %

% ) "# ''"

'% '" "#

% " & #

" 0 '

" "# '

" "

0+ + + -

"# $ " %$ $ "# '

$% '$ ' )

)

1"&

+ - $ "# ' '

'$ "# '$ '" &

2'' 023 )" %+4 + 5$ & " $ "& (

$" " "# ' "

#$ ' $ "# (

#% $ " #"

" ( ' $"

" ( #"

$+ - $" " "#

'" (

" &"

! "

#"% " "% + /# ! "

) ("% '' " (

+ "(& ) (

' $"

" "( )

+ - ' $ "

(

+ 7% " $$"% "# $! "# ' $ "# 89 (

"# :+;

8) $$ ##$ "$$%

" $ "& "%! ' $ %

' $"

" # ") ( ## $ ( ' $ "# (

+ (" ## ' $ " '

"& " 89 (

" " 89 (

(" <% +

# $# % & "! &!

# '(

# )

&$ %

%% # %&+ $% & #

&, , - & , . //0

*#%

( ,

# "

# %1# &

% "

# 2(

& 3 !

& 3 % $!"

% %

* 4"

& 5* %(

$!"%3

(

( %6 *6 3" *

6 $%% 6

(

# #

$!"% #%

% 6 *

6 &$

( & $

7#(

# 2(

2(1 ( $

# # 1

&& &

# *

# 6

% & $# $

# " # $(% * "!

6 &&

# 6

% *$ &

# 6 "

% &

# " % & +

8&% "

# $!!

# 9( 6 !!

"$ &

# 6 &

# "

" *% # !%

6 &$ , ( $ " &

* $ &

6 "%

# &

# - & ,

$# $ # !%

6 &$ "&!1 && ! (

$!"

# $# $ +

8&%

# !"(1 $ &

# :!

$% %6

* 6

#( %

&+ $% & #

; , )

& (5

# ) <$

% )

# +"3 (

( 7# "$"% & 2( % 6

&( !

% &!(%

6 "%$6 *6

# )

# 1%!"

! * &( + $% = +

!* ,< &

& , 7# + $% &

& ,

# )

(

% *%1

(

$ % " 1 5(

$ % $!$

"% $ % *6

% !!>1 !

6 2( %

$(1

# 1#

& %%#

*6 " 1 &

(

"""

& %&

*6 "! 1 $!$

# 4

$ 1

#*6 &

# )

! $!$ *&

#% 61

# ( & 5(

&61

! %

# )

"$ %%6

# $$(!

$ # *

# $%

1(" & "

# )

)$ <$

* 1

! " #"

$ % &

' ((

' ( ))

)(

" "!# )!

% !

' & "

% +!

&& #& ' ) , - ! &

' &

' &&

' % & #!

! & #!

( ) % , " / *

" $ & )(

' '!#

)

% ) $

, "'

! & #!

#* &&

& ( ) % +!

#, ) *

& '

$' .!

( % # & (

! ( '

$' & ( ) % $

#, " / *

' % .!

' +% .!

)

! #

' "

' ! ' % !

(

' !

$ &&

)

) $# #, 2'!*

' # !( %

(( % ' & & ' (

, ! / " &

' &$

$ ! " &

' # # (

' $' ! " &! +!

' /

)

( & 3, * * 4

' $!

! & #!

$ '$ # %

' /

)

' ) /

' "

% '

" ( "'

% '

' $ "

' )

' ( / ! ( /

- "#, #

# ,,6*

) ! & /

) " ' $ #

! & #!

( , 7! ' *

)(!$ # # ,, # /

% .!' #

' ' $!

' ( #

)(

' ! &

! +!

, 2' ) !#

'/ ( #

$ ((

& '

' # )( ,8 , 9!# /

$' ' /, & !

+% / # :, - & 6* # # # %

' ;

/ < ' -,,6*

! " =)

' )

! #

( & & ! 9# 00 "' % 6> &

' ! " / ( & 3,- "'

' )

$ 6> " $

$# & 6 ", ,& ,,-

' % &

& #

' / ! ( * '

! '' #!

# ? , ' $! # % , ,1, " * # !

' % '

' # " )$)

(

' ),

! "# $ # & ' # % ( ) # ( ) " *+ ' $&

' & , - # .+ - & /#! " -0 + ) ' 1

"*# 1

' "/ '! .#'

# -#2 % "/ '+ 0 # - #

& '# &'

' # & % "/ & % 12 # # , '

& # # & )# # $# # # " & 4% / $& 514 '# # # , ' # & # # # #' # # *# /

/ & 6'

7 &&' "7 # & # #+ ) 1 1 & 8"*# "7 ' & ' # $1#

" & *"/ 1 #$ # & $/# $ # #

' * # #+: 66 66 66 + )# '# #' # & $7! "# '! 1 & 1 *! * & ' # * # " *! */ $' "# # / & 1 $7! 1 $ & ' '

*#' 1 */ & 1 # & ; & # / & 1 + , # 1# "# */ ! #6 1 ' *

+ -# / $ # 7 #'

# & 7 ' "# */

" # / # '' # & # "# $ # "* 7 # 6" + 0 "/ & '

1 '## $ 1 $ '# # ' ' '

*#' # $ / % $ * # # &

# & "/ ' "# # ' ' '

*#' # $ / % $ * # # &

# & "/ ' "# # + 66 66 66 + ,""/ # & & # "# ' " # && '# # 1# + 0 & $/ # & $/ # ' # # # & ' #

+ + 2 ' & ' ' & ' # #

' * # # $1# * / "' "# # 7 , ' & # # & )# * / "' "# 7 $# ' &

&&#/ 1 $ # #/ $ + 0 # & ' # ! $ / # '' / # 6# &

1 #1' # # # 1 &&#"/'+ +,'' /!1 " #1 + + , " # 1 7 $ "' "/ ' & $#

7# -# 1 # "/ & 6 # $

# '' / 1 # " & & *#+0$ # &7 +:

!" $%& % '( ) '%*& + ,& $ - .& )!

. / %!) 0 ' ! ./ %1% $ / )!

0 0% ( $

0! 1 !)! % 0 -$0# %

* % %*/ ( 2 1( %! 0& )%! ) ! 0!)!0 % -$0# ) !!0 4 56789:;<=4>9:?@4

!$)% A4BCBD4EFBGHFBIJ4K4 LMNOPNLOLQ4 RGHST4 !" %!) " #U% ! 0 V!U %%)% ./ V!U