P.S.E.B. v. M/S Rupinder Sotne Crusher

  

       


 



   ! "! !#  



   $ "! !#

%    $ "! !#  %    %

 %%

&

'

  

      

  (%

       )%  
 



!"#$ ! % &&  '" ($"" )



# """

"**+,*,- .....

     )%*  

 '
)& $" & (% &"( 

&&  "%"

 

)/")0 ""$"

",-*1 2  "  (    & " ""

&    $  3")!  

!  4(  

&%"( " &

%%4  &  &&4"!( 0"

% )/")0 ""$"

"*,*    "( & "

""

& (3")!
/ !"

0  ) %"$& % &"( " &

%%



5 6%$# $!   &&(%" 0%  (%& "

&7

!  , '% $4 $  0 #(8 " %

"/"

%$   &

%%!9
 "7 )  ! "% &"  (%& """

&  (3")!
/ %!:

&7;%"$& ! 4 $

 " &

%% "( $ 

&& ) <)  $ 12 "4 $0 %&$  & "( 

&&  "%"

9= " "(0 ))&  0% &$  $0" ,

'  0   )  4   $""  0&  (    3  >) % &&  "%"

 " )&   "#( "! "0 %" &

%% "/ %% $%  &&  "%"

!% )   $  ,, ?4 &&)"  &%&$  $$ % " &

%%  4  $!      $$   4   4)& $$",**1 @@!%&&4"(  &"

", *1 @@

)

"0 "%
21!@-*,  & % &&)"%%  "%+* 0!
-, 9 4 "$%0!
2+!-@*9 % ""

&$  
!-,9 $ )%$   ,+ ?4 % &&)" $   "("&

 &&" 0  A  " & " ( (0 "! )

  $ "& "%*=B!  "( ) & -*=B!( )   &&) %%"!  ((0 " "

$$ " "#&  %%$" ( !

  (&&'!( % %

"% $!

+ &

%% "% &" %"$& /$  ,2 C $!"%"

!/ ( >&$  = "

! ")$& "$" ( %

4  0!4  4  " 3 >) # " 0 & %%$"

)0 ) "4 

 "$$60 , 5! 4 (0 " # "&"

", *1 @@!

"0 "%
+!12, "( "!4 $ 04 &# " ( %%5& )A "%= "!4 $" 0     ,**1 @@      $  %   "   )!

 )9 # % &

%%!4 "  )"  $$6 )  ,-  $ ! 4 %" 7= &% DEB040  )!' &4(6 ) )! &% 7'$ 0(40  )!  $&& ! > &4 %"

(6! "DEB04 %"" "!(  (&

%%%)  ,1 $$"

)& !  &  % 
21!@-*, 4 0"%

 "%0& $$6 )"

", * @-?4 %& ""

&)  8 D $  4  &&"! 4 %""

$$"

" %$ &!& ) $ )%
!-,9 % 80  = " $  
-, 9 4 $ )"4 "$%0
2+!-@*9 4 &# " ""

&$   0%$00$

&$ $& 2@9@ ! % 0%0 &$  !  4 $ %%

" ,@ ?4 % &&)" % $ & )4$$" 40!4 $ &$ "% "4 &

(&($ )"

 &   '  DEB  0  4   0#"      $  %    # "&$  $$ 4  )& "

$$"  4 0 "  ("

0 " , 50& )%  !%&&4 4 % 0"( & "

&7






  







 

 !"##


 $ % 
!"#& '



 





!"#& (



 



%
!"## ) *

 + , * ?%&

%%;# "$!$&%&

%% (%& "

&78 "
 " )! % 9
 " 7! E

"$&"# "$' $  !$&%"%"

8 "6

 )!
!

"$&" # "$ ,

 '& """

& (3")!
/ ! ( % $

%# "$&"(   !"

0 " %&

%%# "/")0 ""$"

"*,*    , , )



"/")0 ""$"

"*,*   ! &

%%%"  &(%& """

&  $3")!



%!:5 && 7;'& """

  $  3")!  

!  %   )  & "  $&  %      !

 #"/")0%& "

&7 " &  &&4"

&( &"

)  $%"0 ""

", *1 @@ "(  "!$&

)
+!12, !4 4)!& 4%& &&) &!   "    0 &  

"  %0 "

$$ )   &$  & % && %  0%"

" 0 % 
+!12, 4   "$%& 4!# "/")0 "$"

",-*1 2 , + )) #" )



"/")0"

",-*1 2 "

(    & "  5  &&   7!    &&  "%"

  #

 $" 7$ &&) ) 0 

 % %% + < "$&% &&   $"" 

0)"/")0 ""$"

",-*1 2 "( & "

&& 7 &) && 

(&! & %# & %  $ &%  &/ $4 #

" &

 "$ ( $ ""
 & ) +

? &($"" & "

&7& $6"

/ "

$ # 4%&"& 4 "$ % $(  & (& $"

!4 $ $ (&  )" +, ?    %  )"       0)"  /")0    

 $0&! %

& $" &4   $

"( &%% &&  ""#"

$!0$& #! $ ) & % )%% % &$   $"" (   & "

&7( %(6 " 0" & " 0

# ++ ? &$"" & "5 && 7 %

&" $ "  ( )  %  "

"  *- @  0"

) 7& ++%?"

>&$  $& )%%) !4 8& 0 "

$$ 4  $! "4 $4   &&)" (  &

%%  $&" # ( )" 
! 

&& 74)&  0"/ "

$  $  &$ ( #&6 "    # !$  &"

 $ &%   +2 ? % )" & "5 && 7& "

/")0% 7  ,-./01/123241564617/58!

%,896/-/  /-8  /-1925 # &9:/-6  ;,</5*  
+  ,-./0   /57/-/
=F4#!

"/")04  "( B;(& 07  6>63??2/3! =@
=/56&6-A,1@%

+=@
+ *8246828-
" +
= + '!    4    "       &  (  &&4"  "  

0)"/")0 ""$"

",-*1 2 "( & "

""

&    $  3")!  

!  (    "  "    4&&  "

/")0%& "

&7("

  2 '"  & #($""

)

 
  
 # " "  "

" **+,*,- "      

$( &%%"   

 ) (#(0  %& "$&%

&&  %) )) $"!    

= & "

&7 "% 0" , " ,


 $ % 
! "#& - ?$   "!0 %"9
 "7  4$$6"(  && G / ( >&$  = "!

! "%/ (  >&$  = "!

!4 )8 ( " >8

(%& "



&7' "$" "

,-*
.
$
/-0

1,.2(-,.' 
(3
' -),45 678




0 #9/2()' . 0 :'''




 ((:$9' ) 0$;


 ,9$.
 .22 (<  ,49 
 . 2,92=  3
 8
>5?.

4*?.. 2,92=  3
 8
 
 %   
@?.*?.
  

> 9
,$;$9 

 3

 A ?

3 


 

3


= 
>
$9
 % 



 
38
 3
3 

 

 3
 


 


 


 9


3



  3 
 
     
 
  3  

 

 3 
/

' ,49
 

 . 2,92=  
 @?.*?.>3


   3
 8
 "

 '

$  
 @?.*?.3

%  

 3
 8
  3
3 
 

 3     3
 8
 

3
  + 1 50 (#!  # "  4 $ %%% &$  9) '

"4 0 " $% "  )! )9 #%$0 @ ?7& ++%?"

>&$  $! 0""# "  % "

" *- @ ! A #$ && # "  $ % %%) ! $&"

)4 & %" 0"0  )! &$  & %$00 ("

$$"%4 4 

   $'

"# ( )$& !0   "( )!

7% "  $% 0  A 0%  $  ?  $ !$ &&) %%4"

(  $  )(6 "0  ) & 

%$ &0! $ %"%"

 = " "

$$ ) &$  & 4  $4  $&  $ $4 

$&  "!%!$ (0" &&) & (   

* '  B;(&  0  7  %  ?"

 ,-./0  1/12 3241564617  /58 # &9:/-6  ;,</5!  1  + 
7
 # &  21!

"$ ""$#  4$ # &74&"(/ % " 

)  ") /$  "%?4 &" / ( >&$  = ";$  :B $ %7" %7 # &$"! *@!# " $ # &7 &&  && %

# & !(/$$

 / "

$ !& $) $

 8& ( $   0& ( "! 4 %&" $  4&"(0

(&
! / ( >&$ = ";$  :B! 4 &"( B;(&07%?"

!( $   0& !$) $%$ # &$  ( 8$&""

  $A$!$ # &7 &&(/ % " 

)  ") "$& 4 "

$ )   #

&0" # """?"

>&$   & $  $  "( = "  ( &%%0 0 0!  " (#

, >#B;(&B )7% D !  ;25/3/1/12 3241564617  /58*  52?52&2-128  07  24521/57  /-8  1925& #   &?61/3*  />236BB/5/*  52?52&2-128  07  5    96336?*  /-/A6-A /51-25 1++%,***!"$ "",+

,*

!&"  / "

$ %$ # &7 ( " $  #&# 00 " (    >&$   = "  "    >&$  $!  4  %%    0"

  #

(& )) #"  

+  # 44 & 6(  7 ;/?1/-6-A9 #,06>6&6-/3 @@6425*/B&96-/57/-//-81925&
 *- %,* +!"$ "",**,,* 

2 ?& )%"

$ (#! 7% "  & "5 && 7 $"" % )/")0 " ?
 +/ (B 1 :B!(! "

$"

(#!B;(&07%?"

 "

"/")0!

"# %"

% 0)"/")0 "#

" 4$!

"/")0 ( )# &! "$A& !



0)"/")0 ""$"

",-*1 2 "( & "

""

&  $ 3")!

! (  "! " 0 $"( )# &

 $$"

)& ! & &&4"! "/")0

""$"

"*,*    "( & """

& ( 3")!
/ ! &"9 %% 0"! $ # &7 / "

$  $ 

- "

)0 $&&  & ! %  ! && & "%    % $*! !#      )%

-616-    E ) I E
 (& I