Raj Kumar v. Parduman Sood And Another




  
  


 






  

  

!!

" #$$" $%  

!  

  !
 
"#$%&!
$# &!

'#(%

& '   %(")$* +$', (")$* +$% 

'# , (")$*

$

$- $)*+*
'),-
"
%,! ,!   +,

" ./  0*  !

1, 2

%

$+*$

'$$**,"

 ,! (. 4  "$!5% 67+$% , ! !++ "./%,, $$) %,*

3,%',*.

, 2 2,!,$  $ 089008:;9 4   " $ 5%  $++

2 %,*

67$3

"",)

./ " #$$"0

$9 ! " 3,% 

$ -0 3
", !!  $ / <" 3!$!

"! "$ !.

, /  ,* (3%$%!

$3 1

 )$ /  ,

 ),"

 $"

 " " -=8:-888 4>

0=7 - !

$+* (, ., +(,!%$ 8:8-9??:.$ 8;9; ( %  3!   2 +$ "/ $  %,! !*$$  .

, 2 2,!,$ $0890'0@-;@($ 3%,*%%,!*$

2 ' ,#, 2% 3!,

,"

% !*$$ 3!%,./% $++

2) %,*

(3%,*% 3! .

2 ",)

 ./ 

$ 9( ,   !% 

,2





,) "2, )$!, ! "3!1

$,), $!, ( *%1 ./' ,#, 2%+ +,!,"% 3! "$# *$9=(

 $!, 4$)

' ,0# *, / $!, 7( % ",2%( +$ 3%  %  3!  " $ 
( % ",2%!% 3!, *,,* *$ ",,$ 

"",


+$8:8-9??:$-88-9??:+$.$9;"/! , *

! $+
-8(888A0 $   ",*,

!  " $ ,$ (
;888A0 $ *$ / (
98(888A0$ ! *, ", "
@888A0!! /,"$



"*$ +,

"$.

")

+ ",!*%2 +$ %$!, (% 1 $ ),!,, 2 
 B, "$ ,$ !+$ $) $+ , 2 "+$+  

 %! !$!++ "-8C ,/! ",!., ,/* 097,!! .$"  %  , ! %) !

" , $!! $+ %,! +  )

! $+ $$,$  *

$!,*$!!0

2(! "$3 1+$ 2",$

0., 2, 2$+%,!"

! "*,$ $+%,!*%, "

3! !$ ") !

/++ " @ %  ,.  

" *$

 $+
@9(888A0 $ (3%,*%3!*$ "!+$

$3!&0
  

  4,7 $3"!, "!++ 2
;888 4,,7 $3"!! *, ",
98888
9=888 4,,,7 <$!!$+:@"/!.!,*! /! %"$

) +$ -;="/!$$+3%,*%:@"/!

) 3!

"$ +

! /   
D
%) "

"*$

+$% , !( !

 0.$$1 *$"$+% 3,%% ,!!,! ;  $"

 $ $)  % *  %! !++ " ",!., ,/ $+

-8C(* >,

E09#.%!%% (

1, $++,* $+,), #2 (3%$%!! "%* !++ "-;C4!,*-8C7 ,/! ",!., ,/* 097,!! .$"    ,2( 3%$ 3!  .

 $+   .$" %

>,

" *   " ,!! " ",!., ,/ *  4> 097(  "! E0D "%!! "%" $%,!",!., ,/* 3,

%) ",++,* /, !,, 2(! 2 "3 1, 2 "/+

, B, ",*,

!+$% ! % ++ *$+, !3,

+$3%$

,+ = <

" *$

 +$ %  

 %! 2 " % % %! $

/*$

+$% ",!., ,/!++ ./ *  $  %  2$ " % , 3! $   

 ",!., ,/  ,2(3%$ "! E0D(%!* 2$,*

/! "% ++ *$+%,!",!., ,/3,

%$2%$ ,+ (3%,*%!%$3! % %,! ,!   

 ",!., ,/( %$2%   .$" %! *$, $ 3%,

$ 

2 %,! +* ,  ",!., ,/ : <

" *$

 +$ 

$ - %! 2 " % ,/ !   ",!., ,/ *  4> 097 3! $  

,/( ! !*%( %  ,.  %! *$, $ $ 3%,

2$2 /*$

%,!!*$ F %  ,.  ,! "/ .$ " $ $$1 , $ % ),"

$"* "$ *$"3%,

$3, 2! !$ .

*$

(, ",

/+ %

(3!1

$,), $!, (

*%1 

$'#(# *$9=(% ",2%+$3% 3! "$ 
(% ",2%% ",*$

2 $4> 09:7$+ !%$3!%, !$+* 3 .

2 ".

$$"3! *$, 2$$+$%

"", 
(% ",2%+$

 .$ 98 "/! ,  +$ 998-9??: $ -88-9??:  %  3! +* $+

++  ! .$

!

",!*%2 +$

$3  *" 4> 0:7  !  

! ,  %  ",!*%2  *" 4>

0:7(*

"  

$ .

(9??:3%

%,! +*  .$

  "  !   ",!., ,/ *  4> 097( 3!%), 2, !,++

!!$+

+%,$, 
(",!., ,/,! $

"! 

",!., ,/.

,23%,

 , 2! E0D%!! "% ++ *$+, / 3,

,+ 2   !$ ( 3%$ !++ ! +*  , / $+

+ ( $!

* %" $   $  .

" +$  B, 2 ,  3! *$ $!

/ "),!

"  ! $ 

( 9??: ,

+ +$$ %!$+**,"

)

,+(",!., ,/!++ "./* 3! $"

"! 

",!., ,/./% .$"!,

, %",*$  +$ $+"/./* 3%$3! .

$+ ",!*, / +$*   %,! %!  !$ ++ " %,! +  $! *! $+ $$,$  

,

/ ,  %  /  -888( *  %" $  / +$ )$ / ,

),"

 ,*,$ 0D73% !., % "  $ ",!., ,/ !++ " ./ %, %  ,! $ ,   $!,,$  $ +$%,!"/  %,! B !(% 3!

,

3 + @998-888 ? 1, 2 

 %  .$)  +*! , $ **$ (
  $+ % *$ !,"

"$, %% %!*$, "2) $3%,

$

$3, 2*$

 % *$

"!, +$% ,/!++ "./* G$3"!+

!G $!! $+ $$,$  )

!G

! $+ 

G  "  !$,$ *%2 !1, 2, $**$ .$) ",!*!!

"+*$!(* ,!

"$*$

!+$

$3!&0

 
  

  4,7 $3"!, "!++ 2
-;888 4,,7



!
-8888 4,,,7 <$!!$+! /!!!

!!


9=888 4,)7 $3"! ,,$!A! *, ", !

98888 4)7 <$!!$+$$,$ )

!
988888 4),7 

*%2 !
98888 4),,7 $

**$ $+ ,/
988888   .
98 ), 3$+/.$) ",!*!!,$ (%,! %! , ,!** "3"$+% ,!$",+, *$

"$* ,!

% "+$
@9(888A0$
-(F9(888A0% $ $+*$

3,

*/,

!H:;C 

+$  "  $+ +, 2 $+ %  * ,  ,,$  ,

 * ,I,$

$-.

2, ! $+% $++

2) %,*

3,

/% $ $+*$

$* /*)*0

-















$# &!

'#(%
1

















"#'!