High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/7310/2023dismissed

M/S Blue Stampings And Forgings Limited v. Rajiv Mandal And Another

2023-09-14Mr. Justice Harsh Bunger15 pages

#&'

%'*+,+($ -.". , /0'

1&#23+$4,

(54+$4, 6+2+&'% ......

'&+&+($'5 7'5,0, #8+9 #$%#/ #$(&:'5

......

',3($%'$&,

5','$& 5.

1#$8#;

#+$<

%9(*#&'

)(5 3'&+&+($'5.

. . .

'&+&+($'5

, /0'

1&#23+$4,

(54+$4, 6+2+&'% :#, )+/'% +$,&#$& =5+& 3'&+&+($ 0$%'5

5&+*/', ($,&+&0&+($ $%+# ,''>+$4 # =5+& +$ $#&05'

*'5&+(5#5+ )(5 ?0#,:+$4 +2304$'% (5%'5 ..

$$'@05'

< %+,2+,,+$4 #33/+*#&+($ )+/'% 3'&+&+($'5(23#$;

,''>+$4 ,'&&+$4 #,+%'

35(*''%+$4, .. #4#+$,& +&

3'&+&+($'5(23#$;

:'5'+$ ='// ?0#,:+$4

=#5%

$$'@05'

< 3#,,'% $%0,&5+#/ 5+A0$#/< 6#A(05 (05&<

#5+%#A#%

5',3($%'$&

:'5'+$.

& +, #33(,+&'

&( ,&#&'

:'5'

&:#& 9+%'

=#5% .. < 5')'5'$*'

=#, #$,='5'% +$ )#9(05 5',3($%'$& (.

=(5>2#$ :'5'+$ :'

=#, :'/% '$&+&/'% &( 5'+$,&#&'2'$& +$ ,'59+*'

=+&:

*($&+$0+&;

,'59+*'

=+&:

B A#*> =#4', 3'5 /#,& %5#=$ ,#/#5;.

5+')/;< 5',3($%'$& (.

=(5>2#$ :'5'+$ 5#+,'% #$ +$%0,&5+#/ %+,30&'

5'4#5%+$4 +//'4#/ &'52+$#&+($ :+, ,'59+*',< =:+*:

=#, 5')'55'% &( $%0,&5+#/ 5+A0$#/*026#A(05 (05&<

#5+%#A#%

:'5'+$#)&'5 5')'55'% &( C&:'

5+A0$#/ A'/(=C )(5 #%80%+*#&+($.

',3($%'$& (.

=(5>2#$ :'5'+$ )+/'% :+, */#+2 3'&+&+($ */#+2+$4 &:#& :'

=#, #33(+$&'% # 5',, #$ +$ ;'#5 - /#&'5 ($< :'

=#, #,>'% &( 3'5)(52 %0&+', (5+ #$ &:'5'#)&'5< :'

=#, %',+4$#&'% # #22'5 #$ :+, /#,& %5#=$ ,#/#5;

=#, ,.

< 3'5 2($&:.

, 3'5 5',3($%'$& (.

=(5>2#$ :'5'+$< :'

=#, :#9+$4 :+, 35(9+%'$& )0$% #**(0$& %0/;

,#$*&+($'% *($*'5$'% %'3#5&2'$& A'+$4 # 5'40/#5 '23/(;''

:+, =(5> *($%0*& =#, ,#&+,)#*&(5;

%05+$4 :+, ,'59+*'

&'$05'.

',3($%'$& (.

=(5>2#$ */#+2'% &:#& :+, ,'59+*', ='5'

&'52+$#&'% ($ . . =+&:(0& #$;

35+(5 $(&+*'

(5 +$&+2#&+($ +$ 9+(/#&+($ 1'*&+($

$%0,&5+#/ +,30&',

*&< "-

:'5'+$#)&'5 5')'55'% &( C"-

*&C

$'+&:'5 ($'

2($&:

$(&+*'

$(5 #$;

3#;

+$ /+'0 &:'5'() 5'&5'$*:2'$& *(23'$,#&+($ =#, 3#+% &( :+2 #& &+2'

&'52+$#&+($ :+, ,'59+*',.

**(5%+$4/;< 5',3($%'$& (.

=(5>2#$ 35#;'% &:#& :'

5'+$,&#&'% =+&:

*($&+$0+&;

,'59+*'

)0// A#*> =#4',.

3'&+&+($'5(23#$;

=#, 35(*''%'% #4#+$,& '@3#5&'< 9+%'

(5%'5 .. < 3#,,'% 5+A0$#/ A'/(=.

',3($%'$& (.

=(5>2#$ +$ ,033(5& :+, */#+2 A')(5'

/'#5$'% 5+A0$#/ A'/(=< '@#2+$'% :+2,'/) #/,( '@#2+$'% :+, *( =(5>'5,< $#2'/;< (3',:

#$%#/ #5*:#5#$ D02#5 .

1+$*'

'9+%'$*'

/'% 5',3($%'$& (.

=(5>2#$ :'5'+$

:#% 4($'

0$5'A0&&'% 0$*:#//'$4'%< #**(5%+$4/;< /'#5$'% 5+A0$#/ A'/(= 5'/+'% 03($ ,#2'

#$%< 9+%'

+2304$'%

=#5% ..

$$'@05'

< +& :'/% )(//(=,

!!"

# !#$

% $&

' (

) *# !!!+ , '

$!-

& #33'#5, &:#& ,0A,'?0'$&/;< 3'&+&+($'5(23#$;

:'5'+$ )+/'% #$ #33/+*#&+($ )(5 ,'&&+$4 #,+%'

35(*''%+$4, .. ='//

=#5% ..

$$'@05'

=:'5'+$ )(//(=+$4 #9'52'$&, ='5'

2#%'

/ #!0 !# ) (

' ) (

#"! !#' 1 ' %

/ ) (

#!0 !#

2 /

#!0 !#

) (

0 /

) (

#!0 !# " / #3# !# 4

% 65 %

#!0 !#) (

#!!, !# $ /

) (

+&:

#)(5',#+% #9'52'$&,< 3'&+&+($'5(23#$;

:'5'+$ ,(04:& ,'&&+$4 #,+%'

35(*''%+$4, .. ='//

=#5% ..

$$'@05'

/'#5$'% 5+A0$#/ A'/(=< 9+%'

+2304$'% (5%'5 ..

$$'@05'

< %+,2+,,'% #33/+*#&+($

$$'@05'

< ,''>+$4 ,'&&+$4 #,+%'

35(*''%+$4, #/,( #=#5%< :(/%+$4 0$%'5 ,

#!0 !#

#3# !#

)

#3# !#

#!0 !# /

#!0 !#

)

$ #)(5'2'$&+($'% *+5*02,&#$*',< 3'&+&+($'5(23#$;

:'5'+$ :#, )+/'% +$,&#$& =5+& 3'&+&+($ A')(5'

&:+, (05&.

6'#5$'% *(0$,'/ )(5 3'&+&+($'5(23#$;

:'5'+$ *($&'$%, &:#& +&

3'&+&+($'5(23#$;

:'5'+$ =#, =5($4/;

35(*''%'% #4#+$,& '@3#5&'< 9+%'

(5%'5 .. 35',02+$4 ,'59+*'

#)&'5 /#3,'

%#;,.

& +, ,0A2+&&'% &:#& /'#5$'% 5+A0$#/ A'/(= :#, )#+/'% &( #335'*+#&'

&:#& 3'&+&+($'5(23#$;

:'5'+$ :#% $'9'5 5'*'+9'% #$;

$(&+*'

,022($, )5(2 /'#5$'% 5+A0$#/ A'/(=.

**(5%+$4/;< +& +, 35#;'% &:#& +2304$'% (5%'5 ..

$$'@05'

='// +2304$'%

=#5% ..

$$'@05'

,'& #,+%'.

:#9'

:'#5% /'#5$'% *(0$,'/ )(5 3'&+&+($'5(23#$;

:#9'

3'50,'% 3#3'5 A((> =+&:

:+, #A/'

#,,+,&#$*'.

($*'%'%/;< 5',3($%'$& (.

=(5>2#$ :'5'+$ :#% 5#+,'% #$ +$%0,&5+#/ %+,30&'< =:+*:

=#, 5')'55'% &( /'#5$'% 5+A0$#/ A'/(= )(5 #%80%+*#&+($< =:'5'+$ $(&+*'

,022($, =#, ,'$& &( 3'&+&+($'5(23#$;

:'5'+$.

3'50,#/ +2304$'% (5%'5 ..

$$'@05'

=(0/% 5'9'#/ &:#& /'#5$'% 5+A0$#/ A'/(= :#% ,'$& $(&+*'

,022($, &( 3'&+&+($'5(23#$;

:'5'+$ )(5 #33'#5#$*'< 9+%'

5'4+,&'5'% 3(,&

(,&#/ 5'*'+3&

-. .

3'&+&+($'5(23#$;

:'5'+$ =#, 35(*''%'% #4#+$,& ($ .. /'#5$'% 5+A0$#/ A'/(= 3#,,+$4 )(//(=+$4 (5%'5 '*

#"! !#

)

9 $* 3:$;

0! 64 =

#,!" !#

:#9'

4($'

&:5(04:

*($&'$&, #33/+*#&+($

$$'@05'

< ,''>+$4 ,'&&+$4 #,+%'

(5%'5 .. =:'5'A;

3'&+&+($'5(23#$;

=#, 35(*''%'% ='// #=#5%.

3'50,#/ ,#2'

=(0/% 2#$+)',& &:#& ($/;

4'$'5#/ #9'52'$&, :#9'

A''$ 2#%'

&:'5'+$ #A(0& %#&'

($ =:+*:

3'&+&+($'5(23#$;

:'5'+$ *#2'

&( >$(= #A(0& #=#5%.

5(2 5'#%+$4 3#5# - #33/+*#&+($< '9'$ $#2'

3'5,($ =:( 9+,+&'% ())+*'

6#A(05 $,3'*&(5 ($ ". . < +, $(& )(5&:*(2+$4.

$)#*&< #33/+*#&+($ )+/'% 3'&+&+($'5 (23#$;

:'5'+$< ,''>+$4 ,'&&+$4 #,+%'

35(*''%+$4, #=#5%< =#, $(& '9'$ ,033(5&'% #))+%#9+& #0&:(5+E'% 3'5,($ 3'&+&+($'5(23#$;

:'5'+$.

'&+&+($'5(23#$;

:#, A5(04:& $(&:+$4 ($ 5'*(5% &:+, *#,'

&( ,:(= &:#& $(&+*'

,022($ +,,0'% 5+A0$#/ A'/(= =#, $'9'5 5'*'+9'% +&.

! " #$$<

($CA/'

1035'2'

(05& '@#2+$'% +,,0'

5'4#5%+$4 35',023&+($ ,'59+*'

/'&&'5 ,'$& 5'4+,&'5'% 3(,& 0$%'5 1'*&+($ '$'5#/ /#0,',

*&< " :'/% 0$%'5

>:8 ;

$ %&%"'( ) " *+, "

,-.#< ($CA/'

3'@ (05& (A,'59'% 0$%'5 ?@

##:#;

# :0;

;

( 9

1 ' A

/ 6

)

( )

9 $

6 /

)

> >

(

> >> >

> >

$ "" / !

% +001*$,

*" , .< ($CA/'

3'@ (05& :'/% &:#& 1'*&+($ '$'5#/ /#0,',

*&< " 1'*&+($ - F+//0,&5#&+($

)G 9+%'$*'

*&< 4+9'

5+,'

&( # 35',023&+($ &:#& ,'59+*'

# $(&+*'

:#, A''$ '))'*&'% =:'$ +& +, ,'$& &( *(55'*& #%%5',, 5'4+,&'5'% 3(,&.

& =#, :'/% 0$%'5

>#0'

% ##"

' :

;

/ % ##"

% ##"

1 ' &

% ##"

8 '

1 '

>+1% 2

3 !@ ' *

> >

>> > > >

#"%

> >

> > > >

EF G % =

% '*#33 %

#?!"C%

46)9:#33?;%

$ 0F *2 H 6% = ' !!":";* *:

;300D !!$:#;'

$,D: !!";,%

"I.

$ 9+'= #A(9'< +& =#, 5',3($,+A+/+&;

'&+&+($'5 (23#$;

&( 35(9'

#%%0*+$4 '9+%'$*'

())+*+#/ *($*'5$'% (,&

))+*'

&:#& ,#+% /'&&'5 :#% $(& A''$ %'/+9'5'% &( &:'2.

(='9'5< )(5 5'#,($, A',& >$(=$ &( '&+&+($'5(23#$;< ,0*:

#$ '@'5*+,'

:#, $(& A''$ 0$%'5&#>'$.

& :#, #/,( $(& ,:(=$ '&+&+($'5(23#$;

&:#& #%%5',, '&+&+($'5(23#$;

=#, =5($4/;

2'$&+($'% ($ 5'4+,&'5'% 3(,& (5 ())+*'

'&+&+($'5(23#$;

:#% ,:+)&'%.

$ #A,'$*'

#$;

2#&'5+#/ &( %+,/(%4'

35',023&+($ ,'59+*'

$(&+*'

,022($ 03($ '&+&+($'5(23#$;< (5%'5 .. =:'5'A;

'&+&+($'5(23#$;

=#, 35(*''%'% #4#+$,& *#$$(& A'

,'& #,+%'

($ 2'5'

#,,'5&+($ 3'&+&+($'5*(23#$;

&:#& +& $'9'5 5'*'+9'% $(&+*'

,022($.

1+$*'

'&+&+($'5(23#$;

:#, )#+/'% &( ,:(= &:#& 5+A0$#/ A'/(= =#, =5($4 +$ 35(*''%+$4 #4#+$,& +&< *($,'?0'$&/;

$( +$&'5)'5'$*'

+, 5'?0+5'% &( A'

2#%'

=#5% ..

$$'@05'

& +, 5'?0+5'% &( A'

$(&+*'% :'5'

&:#& '&+&+($'5(23#$;

:#, )+/'% #$ #33/+*#&+($

+$ +$,&#$& =5+& 3'&+&+($ )(5 3/#*+$4 ($ 5'*(5%

$$'@05', - &( -.

$$'@05', - &( #5'

&50'

*(3+', 2'2A'5 35()+/'

(5&#/< 1&#&0,<

(52"

=+&:%5#=#/<

(52 1 +&:%5#=#/< 2'2A'5 35()+/'

35(() 8(+$+$4

,,(*+#&'<

(52

5#$,)'5<

(52 )(5 6(#$< 23/(;'5 *'5&+)+*#&'< 5',3'*&+9'/;H 5'4#5%+$4 3'5,($ $#2'% #8',:

#8''9 #$%#/

$$'@05'

+, '3':*:#$ *#5% #8+9 #$%#/.

$$'@05'

+, # *#// /'&&'5 .. =5+&&'$ &( #8',:

#/+#, #8''9 #$%#/ ,'$& '&+&+($'5 (23#$;

:'5'+$ *#//+$4 03($ :+2 &( 8(+$ %0&;

$$'@05'

- +, # 3:(&(*(3;

5'4+,&'5'% 3(,&.

& +, (A,'59'% :'5'

&:#&

$$'@05', - &( ='5'

5'?0+5'% &( A'

35(%0*'% 35(9'% +$ #**(5%#$*'

=+&:

/#= 3'&+&+($'5(23#$;

+$ +&, '9+%'$*'

A')(5'

5+A0$#/ A'/(=< :(='9'5 3'&+&+($'5*(23#$;

)#+/'% &( #33'#5 A')(5'

5+A0$#/ A'/(= =#, 35(*''%'% #4#+$,& '@3#5&'.

05&:'5<

$$'@05'

=:+*:

+, # *#// /'&&'5 .. =5+&&'$ &( #8',:

#/+#, #8''9 #$%#/ ,'$& '&+&+($'5 (23#$;< *#//+$4 03($ :+2 &( 8(+$ %0&;H =(0/% ,:(= &:#& %05+$4 3'$%'$*;

#33/+*#&+($ ,''>+$4 ,'&&+$4 #,+%'

35(*''%+$4,

=#5% A')(5'

5+A0$#/ A'/(=< 3'&+&+($'5*(23#$;

:#% *#//'% 03($ 5',3($%'$&=(5>2#$ &( 8(+$ %0&;

+$ &'52,

=#5% ..

$$'@05'

$)#*& /'&&'5 .. =(0/% ,:(= &:#& 3'&+&+($'5*(23#$;

:#, #**'3&'%

=#5% ..

$$'@05'

:0,< #)(5',#+%

$$'@05', - &( - #/,( %( $(& #%9#$*'

*#,'

3'&+&+($'5(23#$;< #**(5%+$4/;

#33/+*#&+($

"" )(5 3/#*+$4 ($ 5'*(5%

$$'@05', - &( - +$ +$,&#$& =5+& 3'&+&+($ +, %+,2+,,'%.

$ 9+'= #A(9'

%+,*0,,+($< %( $(& )+$% #$;

2'5+& +$ +$,&#$& =5+& 3'&+&+($ ,#2'

+, %+,2+,,'%.

// 3'$%+$4 #33/+*#&+($ ,< +) #$;< ,:#// ,&#$% */(,'%.

-.".

,8>, :'&:'5 ,3'#>+$4 5'#,($'%

!',

( :'&:'5 5'3(5&#A/'

!',

(