High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/15231/2022dismissed

Dushyant Gupta v. State Of Haryana And Another

2022-05-18Mr. Justice Deepak Sibal5 pages

!" #$%$&'( )%*+ &),

$$& - ! + &* %,&" &% ' ./ 0/

% &'

$"*)1"2# 1!* , $$& %* &)) 11 + 0 3 4 1 &$"2# 14$* )5 %*0$&"

61"2# 1!* #7,6 & 8888888 0/19 /:

#7,$6 $&!"#)7 &%!$6 "&; * 6!!* #7,6 &$&) "

+$%" "; 5 &&* #" *)3* * , % & , $$& !$6 " )&" #$& < ( * , $$& % 5% $6$& "

"< 3$% ")&" #$&%<=(1<>1 1 < > 6$# $&%7 $6 ;

"1$%$# 0))5%* ) ;*$ 0 &% 6 !$6 " #7,6 $& 4$* * ,6$# % , 4*$#* &

%* &"* , $$& * "37 $ "?$4 & &3 "7 3 ?&

( # 7&+4 %, !7 "? ! &"

+%!* # 7&+* , $$& .%!

* 6 ,*& "* #7,6 &.%!

* %5 "*$77 *$7! 5$&3 &3 7 &% ! * 7 3 &" * !)&#$&%? & = * &.%!

* 6&34$*& !*$% 6 $2 %17 * , $$& .%!

* ?* , $$& .%7* &"& &$6), 9& ,* 4!* , $$& .%!

* :4 6% , % & * ? ")$&3 * #)% ! %)#* 7 $&3 * , $$& .% ! * 6" * &.% !

* * ;) % # % @, # " ; %, & ;+ * &.%!

* &* ),#7$&34 ""$&3?&$6), 9* , $$& .%!

* .% & ,* 4:% $"* * +; 3$2 & %<6 5*%!,)#* % ! # 1 %< 6 5*%$&# %*

&* %<6 5*%!C 4 66 +D3$!% #?* #7,6 &.%!

* 4 %%*#5 "

%)#*" 7 &"% &"6 4 &$& " , %%$&?3 * #7,6 &.%!

* )!

*$%" , %%$&*$% 6 $2 % %%) "*$7!7& +* 6,?& ;*, $ % %*,, " * 7 4 66 %1* &"$3 *4* * , $$& .%%$% " 7 &" "* 3 # 7&$ %; * 6"$&!$2 % * 6%4* %* #7,6 &.%7* E) % "* , $$& .%!

7$6+*6"%)#*# 7&$ %$& %$7,6 7 &&

0))5%* ?%)#* E) %!* #7,6 &.%7* 4 %)& ""4&$& & &3+ & ?6 1;** , $ % %% 7;6 " C %17;

4* * , $$& .% 7$6+ $% "!)* " 7 &"%4$* 3 "3$2$&3!36"#$&% %6 5*%& # 7&$ %6$5 #?*$%%*#5 "* #7,6 &.%7* ;))&" , %%) %* 3 "7 %)#*" 7 &"%?6 5*%!), %4 3$2 &;+* #7,6 &.% * * , $$& .%!

7$6+$&# %*? ! % 6 5*%$&* #7,6 &.% 7 4 6%3$2 &4*$#*$%6+$&34$** , $$& .%! 7$6+?&" 7 &"%7 " 1& "$!! &!)&#$&%D## %$&%* #7,6 &.%!

* 3 2 36"C 4 66 + &"* @, &%$2 3$!%* , $$& &"*$%!

7$6+7 7; %?* , $$& &"*$%!

7$6+ 7 7; % 6%" 7 &" " &"56 5*%!), %,)#* % 6)@)+# ;) !

## ,$&3* 7& +* +"$"&,)#* % &+# &"5 ,* 7& +?* $&3 # 7&+4 %* 6"$& !$2 % * 6$&* &"$3 *$&4*$#*1&" 7 &"1 " %$3& #*1 6 2 &36"#$&% &"& "$ 7&"%6$ $ $&34 3$2 &* , $$& ?

& * 7 3 !* #7,6 & &"* , $$& 4 %, !7 "$&

&* !$2 % * 6$&* &"$3 *$&4*$#*1&" 7 &"1C 4 66 + &"* $ 7%

6%# %*4 3$2 &;+* #7,6 &.%!

7$6+* , $$& .%!

7$6+?& * , $$& .% 7* 5 * C 4 66 + 4*$#* 4 % , ! * &.%

&"5 ,* % 7 $&* 6#5 ?& 1&* , $$& .%;$*"

+1* #7,6 &.%!

* 3 2 *$7 &* 36"#* $&1 % 1D $&# %* &"#6* % #4*$#*4 %& ,, #$ ";+* , $$& %* % 7 4 !)&"; 6 %% * & @, # "?&% 2 6## %$&%* , $$& 3 2 ;

$&3% & %)64* !%* * ")&" 3 + 7 & 4 6+

A B &%$) * &"$3 *?* , $$& 6%,)66 "* * $ & @ &* * % # 7 )!7$%2 +%!4*$#*%* 6%* " 5 7 "$# 6 7 & &"*

$& #; 11& ##)&!;

$&3%3$2 &;+* , $$& * #7,6 &1 %* 4 5 &* *%,$ 6;+* ,6$# & * ;

%$% ! * ! % $" #7,6 $& * $& E) %$& 4 3$% "$&4*$#** , $$& % 5% $6 / & "#)&% 6!* , $$& #& &"%* * , $$& * %; & 6% 6+$7,6$# "$&*$%# % & ##)&! 7 $7&$ 6"$%#"; 4 &* , $$& &"* #7,6 &?* 66 3 $&!3$2$&3;

$&3%;+* , $$& & &.% + &<$%!

6%$!$ "!7* !

#* & ;* * , $$& &"* #7,6 &4 2 # $&$&33 * $&*$76 ?* 66 3 $& !,)66$&3!* #7,6 &.%* $;+$%%;+* , $$& $% 6%$&# # %*

%& ##)&! "$% % 4*$#** #7,6 &4 %%)!! $&3!7?&> $4 %* #7,6 &4** "3$2 &;

$&3%* , $$& &"*$%$%% !6 # "

$&* , $$& .%/ ?&" 7 &"! &+"4+4 %7 " ;+* , $$& *$% 7$6+7 7; %?* , +7 &!* 7 3 # 7&$ %4 %$&!

#;& ;+* , $$& .%!

7$6+4*$#*$%% !6 # "$&* ;$66%!* %, #$2 * 6% &"* , $$& $% 6% "+ &"4$66$&3C$& &"#, 4$** $&2 %$3 $& / & " #)&% 6 6%6 & "% &$#)&% 6 ,, $&3!* & ,,% * 3 &! + ;

$6 * , $$& ;+ ! $&3 7 "$# 6 # $!$# "

" % 6% ,*3 ,* ! * & ! * % 7 "

*)3* 4*$#* $% %*4& & $&C)+ ; 64 * &.%6 ! + # )% ";+* , $$& ! &# $% 6%7 " 7 "$# # $!$# "

"(< %, 4*$#** #7,6 &4 %; $&3 "!,)66$&3 !* * $!7$%2 +%;+* , $$& &$&!*$%)$% 6%" 4& &.%/ "

"F %, 4*$#*%* # $2 " %7 &+ %!$2 $&C)$ %&* , %& * * &"%!* , $$& ! "$&3* 66 3 $&%7 "

;+* , $$& $&, (!*$%, $$&4* $&* * %% "* * , $$& &"

A<B &4 &&,6 %) $,% !7<=1

C,) & &"*$76 !7 F #1*$%)$% %*4& # $!$# !* , $$& "

"=*)3*4*$#** , $$& * ; &"$ 3&% "; -=,%$$2 %*4$&3* !

6%$+$&* # % % ),;+* , $$& ; ! *$%) 6%*$%7 &$,)6 $2 & ) 6 ,*&$##&2 % $& 66 3 "6+; 4 &* #7,6 & &"* * 4 6%,")# " &"* ";+*$%)")$&3* #)% !4*$#** , $$& 3 2 7 #$6 %%;

$&3%* #7,6 & 6%*)6 " * * #*$# % ! ;)% %

6$ &# $% 6%,6 # "&* ,;+* ,6$# 4*$#*4

#* " * ,6+!$6 ";+* ,6$# ,,% * , $$& .% $6; ! * %%$&%) 0))5%* %, 4*$#** , $$& &"*$%# ##)% "* "& #, "4$** $&2 %$3 $& &" * ! # $,!&$# %!7* ,6$# C$&* $&2 %$3 $&* +* ", "* $;

&56#5 %7$% ,,,$ &.%C 4 66 + G$*$&& + !* $7 3 * 6 %* ,$%" %;)3* &* #";+* #7,6 &*)3*4*$#*%* 66 3 %7 #$6 %%;

$&3%* ;+* , $$& * % $&#6)" &$&C)+C)%)&" * 6 ! + 1,)66$&3!* * $ !7* $2 +% &"& $&#$" &4* %* * % # $2 " %7 &+ %!$2 $&C)$ % 4*$#*$&#6)" 4#&)%$&% * #7,6 &* %!)* 6$ "&* #"$&3! 6 ,*&$# #&2 % $&$&4*$#** , $$& $%* "*)6$&3* #*$# %! ;)% % & 6%%6 ,,$&3D*$$&3* * &* * 66 3 $&%!" 7 &" # $,;+* , $$& &"

*$%# ##)% "3$!%D# %*DC 4 66 +4*2 # !), % ;2 66$%* % &"!* 4$* 3 "* , $$& &"*$% # ##)% "* 2$&3&#, "4$** $&2 %$3 $& &" * 1 ! * 2$&3; & ,)&$# !* 6"3$&3!* 1!* 2$&3 5 &% ,%7$% ,,,$

A B &.%C 4 66 +4*$#*4 %, !*

5$&3 #)7)6 $2 & !* ;2 1*$%)$%"$%$&#6$& "3

$6 * , $$& &" %)6 &6+" % " &+ *$7* %)3* #&# %%$& $%7$%% " $%#6 $!$ "* * ;2 ;% 2 $&%* 2 ; &7 " &6+!* 6$7$ ",),% !" #$"$&3* , % & $6 ,,6$# $& &"* % 4)6"&; #&%) "; & @, %%$&!,$&$&&* 7 $%!* # % ( A 0/B %* 7%* G* * %, 5$&3D %& "

%D G* * , ;6 ' %D