High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/7378/2020dismissed

Som Dutt v. Union Of India And Others

2021-03-24Mr. Justice Anil Kshetarpal15 pages

!

"#$ $%&'&() *

+, -## $#&#&($.

/$.'-'

(&( (0&""(0#1$.'

$'2(0$(#'

)34 + 45+ .$'$(#) . 61&'1$7+$#1&8 09%"#$

.#1$2$#&#&($. .1&#/$.,"8 09%"#$8

..$'2(0$(#(#*

! "

## $ !$% #

&# &

#'

! "

# $ ! % #$!& ' ()*

#

+, -

. . / %/ & 0! ,

$ ! % #$!&

1

+

2

# 34

#$!5

2 , &

#

%' " )& 5

6

$ 7 $#

%' " 8&, & 9

2 #$! "

"

6

%

6

$ 7 $ #

, " 8&

, &

2 #$!

"

"

6

+9" , & 2 #$! "

"

6

6

$ 7 $#

," 8,:

!

"

#

$%&''%%'(

)

*

+

(

,

-

.#+/0

(

1

0#!""

,

$%&''%%'

0#!" 0

(

" 2

"

, '%&$ 0#!"

* 3

0#!"

(

'%&$

3 $%%4'%&5

#67 '%&&$ '%&$

0#!" - #

1

3 &8&''%&4 97 &48& '%&5 1

9 "

:

7

" # (

! #

#

.

1

&;&''%&; #6 7 <$8 '%&;

1

#

(

1

+

.

97 &'&4 '%&;=

1

>

,

%4%8'%&?

(

0#!" (

#

@

# ##

:

# #

( #

#

#

) ! &

& & )

&

# ) #

& & &

*

# # &

#

#

& & +##

&, -

+## .,

##

#

#

&

/. & &

&

& # #

& &

$

# & &

$

# & & # ,

@

0, )12

,# &

# !2

;

'

"

% *

) )+

3

3 "%

/

"%

7 7

A> B

+

! )

/ 9

"%

* "

B

AB

/ + 0

+ A*

C

/

/

A

" A

@ (

D0D D D*3+

7 ''A&)E"A60)+AB $%+ '%%' ,

,

2

,

0#!"

,

3 %4%8'%&?

,

1

&&

(

# & $4 5$

)3/

# # 6 ! , 7

/8!

# 89 !

33/8

# #/

# &

#

( # 5

#

#/

# & '

;<

(

(

6 5 ' ' 1

+

2 ()%*&5=>5.!%9 & 2% & ((! (==>

<

6

" (

#$!"

'

:

#

83/9 .3 #

: #

& #

/ &

# &

# &#

#.3 &

# #89

+;<6 /9,

#

&

0

#

& &

,

#

##

#

&

<

/)

&

& & < #

#

#

# # &

5 = & #

(& :,

4 //) #/)

<

"65 &>

#<

%

)/< (&

6

? =, 0 /9/ #/">

#<

, (@ %

/9// A

6

? (& 2 ?

>

#<

/./.2

)/./. =," %4 /8).) #/.",

@ >

#< %

= ,

# & (& ! , !& ,

&

(&

#

# (& # & #

5 & 5#

& #

( # 5

&

5

0# &

& # # ?

( A # & # #

#

& &

# #/

#

/

( &

& 0

0 9)

B #<

7 #6# #

<

(

6 5 &$ " % # & # &

#

##

!

&

& #

&

# &

## #

#

> !

&

#

& B +

& # & #

& #

&

&

#

> !

& # !

<

#

# C

<# # #

<

#

#

/

(& #

#

(& !

$

!"#$$

%&< # (& # &D& 65 &$ " % )/

#

!

(& =,0 ? /9// (& #!

$ " %

&

#? < $ " %

& #

#7 < 3./

#=& 0 = +##

= < B

<

#

#6 B

#,

#, 7

# # #//

#

#) #

< #

&# 0

7 0

C $0$ $?$

$ $ #

&

& #

(&

&# !& #4 & ?

:

# !

$

# & #

'

!"#!!$ %

& &

&

'

& (

'

) &

&

*+ % , - &

'&

. /.000000000 1- & 2 3 00000000 '

0000000000 00000000001 3

00000000000 1

0000000000000 &3

(

'

&'

4

&

'

%5

6 #6 76 6

'

1 7

3( '8

4 &(

$ % - &2

'

& (

('

9 % '

.

&

'

&

%

&

'

(

4

:

'&

(

,

(

&

'8

' &

$ % ;4 <

#!=#!!$ !"#!!$

'&

4

&

'

& '

( &'

'

)

< &

> ?

( ?@

? ' ( ' ; 4

&

9 @ &

? #

(& 6

?

=,04 /9/ #/ &

#6

?

(& " %

#

# # #

# &#

*

# <

# ## &

#

(

#

& ##

#

C #

##

#

4 #

& & C

#

E

# !

$ # #7 " %

# #

5

& #

&

C 5 C

#

5

#

& 5 &

# A

# A

# & &

# # # #

#

5 B

&

#

# 5 &

& &

: <

(&

'( )$ *+

"$$,- !

.# /"0 @ & #

#

# !

*#1".%18

45+ 4 (#

1$#1$.'2$"7&(=>.$"'($0 )!+> 1$#1$..$2.#"6?$ )!+>