High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/24070/2015allowed

Vijay Pal v. State Of Haryana And ANR.

2015-10-09Mr Justice Rakesh Kumar Jain4 pages

!"#

#$%&% '( $"

)#* +,

!"#

#$%&% '( $"

)#* +,

!"#

#$%&% '( $"

)#* +,

!"#

#$%&% '( $"

)#* +,

-%.!/ !0 11111111#"%"% '#* -#*&2& 3"!"#

!*/!'! !'4 !'

111111#&6 '4#'"& ( ( ( ( 7 8 31 3 3

7 8 31 3 3

*#&#'"

*#&#'"( *1 "20 !4!9, $!"#

* "5# 6#"%"% '#*1 &1 %:60# !%',

!*/!'!1 *1 !.#&5 ;2:!*, $!"#

* *#&6 '4#'" 11 <<<< <<<< <<<< <<<<

, #"%"% '#* 5!& %0#4 "5%& 6#"%"% ' 2'4#* 3#$"% ' =

"5# 4#

*%:%'!0 * $#42*#, +>

* ?2!&5%'@

1> 4!"#4 1=1 >, 2'4#* 3#$"% '& , +, , , =, ,

"5# '4%!' #'!0 4#, = 77

* &5 *", *#@%&"#*#4 !" 0%$# 3"!"% ' ;5!%4A% !20!, 2*@!

' !'4 !00 '&#?2#'"%!0 6* $##4%'@& !*%&%'@ "5#*# :

' "5# )!&%&

:%&#1 8#!*'#4 $ 2'&#0

* "5# 6#"%"% '#* !& B#00 !& 0#!*'#4 2'&#0

* *#&6 '4#'" 1 5!9# &2):%""#4 "5!" 6!*"%#& 5!9# !:%$!)0/ &#""0#4 "5#%* 4%&62"#1 -%4# *4#* 4!"#4 11

, "*%!0 2*"C *#!

!@%&"*!"# B!& 4%*#$"#4 "

*#$ *4 "5# &"!"#:#'"&

"5# 6!*"%#& !'4 &#'4 %"& *#6 *" B%"5 *#@!*4 "

@#'2%'#'#&&

:%&# #

#$"#4 )#"B##' "5# 6!*"%#&1

' 62*&2!'$# "

"5# &!%4 *4#*, "5# !@%&"*!"# !

"#* *#$ *4%'@ "5# &"!"#:#'"&

"5# 6!*"%#& 5!& *#6 *"#4 "5!" "5# :%&# %& @#'2%'#, 9 02'"!*%0/ !'4 B%"5 2" !'/ "5*#!", #*$% ' !'4 6*#&&2*#1

& 6#* "5# 200 #'$5 .24@:#'"

"5%& 2*" %'

;20B%'4#* 3%'@5 !'4 "5#*& 9&1 3"!"#

2'.!), > ;20B%'4#* 3%'@5 !'4 "5#*& 9&1 3"!"#

2'.!), > *%:%'!0 , *%:%'!0 , *%:%'!0 , *%:%'!0 , %@5 2*" 5!& 6 B#* 2'4#* 3#$"% ' = *111 "

!00 B "5# $ :6 2'4%'@

'$ :6 2'4!)0#

#'$# !'4 ?2!&5 "5# 6* &#$2"% ' B5#*# "5# %@5 2*"

#0" "5!" "5# &!:# B!& *#?2%*#4 "

6*#9#'" "5# !)2&#

"5# 6* $#&&

!'/ 2*"

* "

"5#*B%&# &#$2*# "5# #'4&

.2&"%$#1 5%& 6 B#*

?2!&5%'@ %& '

" $ '

%'#4 "

:!"*%:

'%!0 4%&62"#& !0 '#1 '7)0# "5# 6#D 2*" %' "5# $!&#

%!' 3%'@5 9&1 %!' 3%'@5 9&1 %!' 3%'@5 9&1 %!' 3%'@5 9&1 3"!"#

2'.!) !'4 !'

3"!"#

2'.!) !'4 !'

3"!"#

2'.!) !'4 !'

3"!"#

2'.!) !'4 !'

"5#* *01 > *01 > *01 > *01 >, 5!& 5#04 !& 2'4#*( 1 5# 6 &%"% ' "5!" #:#*@#& : "5# !) 9# 4%&$2&&% ' $!' )# &2::!*%&#4 "52&( "5# 6 B#*

%@5 2*" %' ?2!&5%'@ ! $*%:%'!0 6* $##4%'@ *

* $ :60!%'" %' #D#*$%&#

%"& %'5#*#'" .2*%&4%$"% ' %& 4%&"%'$" !'4 4%

#*#'"

: "5# 6 B#* @%9#' "

$*%:%'!0 $ 2*"

* $ :6 2'4%'@ "5#

#'$#& 2'4#* 3#$"% ' >

"5# 4#1 '5#*#'" 6 B#* %&

B%4# 60#'%"24# B%"5 '

&"!"2"

*/ 0%:%"!"% ' )2" %" 5!& "

)# #D#*$%&#4 %' !$$ *4 B%"5 "5# @2%4#0%'# #'@*!

"#4 %'

&2$5 6 B#* 9%FG % "

&#$2*# "5# #'4&

.2&"%$# * %% "

6*#9#'" !)2&#

"5# 6* $#&&

!'/ 2*"1 ' B5!"

$!&#& 6 B#* "

?2!&5 "5# $*%:%'!0 6* $##4%'@ :60!%'"

* 11 :!/ )# #D#*$%&#4 B5#*# "5#

#'4#* !'4 9%$"%: 5!9# &#""0#4 "5#%* 4%&62"# B 4#6#'4 ' "5# !$"& !'4 $%*$2:&"!'$#&

#!$5 $!&# !'4 '

$!"#@ */ $!' )# 6*#&$*%)#41 B#9#*, )#

*# #D#*$%&#

&2$5 6 B#*, "5# %@5 2*" :2&" 5!9#

> 42# *#@!*4 "

"5# '!"2*# !'4 @*!9%"/

"5# $*%:#1 #%'

2& !'4 &#*% 2&

#'$#&

:#'"!0 4#6*!9%"/

#'$#& 0%A# :2*4#*, *!6#, 4!$ %"/, #"$1 $!''

" )#

%""%'@0/ ?2!&5#4 #9#' "5 2@5 "5# 9%$"%:

* 9%$"%:H&

!:%0/ !'4 "5#

#'4#* 5!9# &#""0#4 "5# 4%&62"#1 32$5

#'$#& !*# '

" 6*%9!"# %' '!"2*# !'4 5!9# &#*% 2& %:6!$"

' & $%#"/1 3%:%0!*0/, !'/ $ :%&# )#"B##' "5# 9%$"%: !'4

#'4#* %' *#0!"% ' "

#'$#& 2'4#* &6#$%!0 &"!"2"#& 0%A# *#9#'"% '

**26"% '

* "5#

#'$#& $ ::%""#4 )/ 62)0%$ &#*9!'"& B5%0# B *A%'@ %' "5!" $!6!$%"/ #"$G $!''

6* 9%4#

* !'/ )!&%&

* ?2!&5%'@ $*%:%'!0 6* $##4%'@& %'9 09%'@ &2$5

#'$#&1 2" "5# $*%:%'!0 $!&#& 5!9%'@ 9#*B5#0:%'@0/ !'4 6*#4 :%'!"%'@0/ $%9%0 0!9 2* &"!'4 ' 4%

#*#'"

"%'@

* "5# 62*6 &#&

?2!&5%'@, 6!*"%$20!*0/ "5#

#'$#& !*%&%'@ : $ ::#*$%!0, %'!'$%!0, :#*$!'"%0#, $%9%0, 6!*"'#*&5%6 * &2$5 0%A# "*!'&!$"% '& * "5#

#'$#& !*%&%'@ 2"

:!"*%:

'/ *#0!"%'@ "

B*/, #"$1 !:%0/ 4%&62"#& B5#*# "5# B* '@ %& )!&%$!00/ 6*%9!"# * 6#*& '!0 %' '!"2*# !'4 "5# 6!*"%#& 5!9# *#& 09#4 "5#%* #'"%*# 4%&62"#1 ' "5%& $!"#@ */

$!&#&, %@5 2*" :!/ ?2!&5 $*%:%'!0 6* $##4%'@& %

%' %"& 9%#B, )#$!2&#

"5# $ :%&# )#"B##' "5#

#'4#* !'4 9%$"%:, "5# 6 &&%)%0%"/

'9%$"% ' %& *#:

"# !'4 )0#!A !'4 $ '"%'2!"% '

$*%:%'!0 $!&# 204 62" !$$2&#4 "

@*#!"

66*#&&% ' !'4 6*#.24%$# !'4 #D"*#:# %'.2&"%$# B 204 )# $!2&#4 "

5%: )/ '

?2!&5%'@ "5# $*%:%'!0 $!&# 4#&6%"# 200 !'4 $ :60#"# &#""0#:#'" !'4 $ :%&# B%"5 "5# 9%$"%:1 '

*4&, "5# %@5 2*" :2&" $ '&%4#* B5#"5#* %"

204 )# 2'

!%* * $ '"*!*/ "

"5# %'"#*#&"

.2&"%$# "

'"%'2# B%"5 "5# $*%:%'!0 6* $##4%'@ '"%'2!"% '

"5# $*%:%'!0 6* $##4%'@ B "!'"!:

2'" "

!)2&#

6* $#&&

0!B 4#&6%"# &#""0#:#'" !'4 $ :%&# )#"B##' "5# 9%$"%: !'4 B* '@4 #* !'4 B5#"5#* "

&#$2*# "5# #'4&

.2&"%$#,

%" %& !66* 6*%!"# "5!" $*%:%'!0 $!&# %& 62" "

!' #'4 !'4 % "5# !'&B#* "

"5# !) 9# ?2#&"% '& %& %'

%*:!"%9#, "5# %@5 2*" &5!00 )# B#00 B%"5%' %"& .2*%&4%$"% ' "

?2!&5 "5# $*%:%'!0 6* $##4%'@1I 3%'$# "5# 6!*"%#& 5!9# !**%9#4 !" ! $ :%&# !'4 5!9# 4#$%4#4 "

0%9# %' 6#!$#, '

2&# 20 62*6 &# B 204 )# &#*9#4 %' !00 B%'@ "5# $*%:%'!0 6* $##4%'@& "

'"%'2#1

$$ *4%'@0/, "5%& 6#"%"% ' %& !00 B#41 1> 4!"#4 1=1 >, 2'4#* 3#$"% '& , +, , , =, , , *#@%&"#*#4 !" 0%$# 3"!"% ' ;5!%4A% !20!, 2*@!

' !'4 !00 "5# $ '&#?2#'"%!0 6* $##4%'@&, !*%&%'@ "5#*# :, !*# ?2!&5#41 3

)#* +,

:!5!9%*