High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/17011/2025allowed

Angrej Singh v. State Of Punjab

2025-08-12Mr. Justice Sumeet Goel7 pages

$# %&7 6!*!%) $# %&7 6!*!%) $# %&7 6!*!%) $# %&7 6!*!%)'

'*#

'*# :

3 :

! " ?,

*'* $( #$# %&'$ ?, *5%7 ) ) ) )

#) 2+, 2+, 2+, 2+, + + + + *,.%# $7"'/78%6$# &%

,$4!7

! $/77!#!% $4'$(, <<<<< <<<<< <<<<< <<<<< + + + +/,0+3 /,0+3 /,0+3 /,0+3 ,

# #"!

7 5 #!#!% "$* (

&!4 7 '7

6#!% @A %& #"

"$ $#!-$ !. '

$.*"$ $"!#$/

0 0&% *"% # 1 23 &%

$# %&

($!4 # #% #"

! 6$*

7$# :,,

!*#

%&& *5'!*"$(4 '7

6#!%*A063/ :/ B/C$7A:

: 6%# #!6 *$7*-6"%# %5!6 '(*#$ $6 *6#/BA:0&% *"% #1 6#23/ $#%4!

!6 #$#!% 5 6!$4$*.% =! /!*# !6# / '$(,

$8$9 %&#"

$44

$#!%* $!*##"

!*#"$#"

!* $$66'* 7%& &( !8%48 7!$ 5

#$! ! #% 6#!8%48! :.

%5!'9$44

74-

6%8

7& %9#"

, + 76%'* 4&%

"$*!#

7#"$##"

!* ! 6'*#%7- *!

!6 :,,

, + 7 6%'* 4 &%

"$* &'

*'(9!## 7 #"

"$# #"

9$7$#% - 5 %8!*!%* %& #"

6# "$8 %# *6 '5'4%'*4-

6%954!

7>!#"/$7#"'*/#"

6'#!%6$* *'&&

*& %9 9

6#*,+ 76%'* 4&% #!# #!%

"$*!#

7#"$##"

!$4!* 4$- 7$7# 4!$(!4!#-#"

%&6$%#( &$*#

7'5%#"

,+ 6%'* 4 "$* & &'

7 #"$# #"

"$* *'&&

7 !6$

$#!% &%

#"$ - *,"'*/

($!4!*5 $-

@, + 7 #$# 6%'* 4"$*%55%*

7#"

#5 #!#!%(-$

#"$##"

$44

$#!%* $!* 7$ $!*##"

!%'*!$#'

$7/#"'*/ 7% *%#7

6%6 **!%%&#"

($!4,+ 7 #$# 6%'* "$*&'

'(9!## 7#"$##"

!*#$#($!454 !*($

7(-#"

*%& 6#!%

6#/$7#"'*/#"

*$9 %'

"##%( 7!*9!** 7,+ 7 #$#

6%'* 4*

.* *#%54$6 %

6% 76'*#%7-6

!&!6$# 7$# 7,A, :!%'

#/ >"!6"!*#$.

6% 7, :,

"$8 "

76%'* 4&% !8$ $45$ #!

*$7"$8 % $8$!4$(4

6% 7*%&#"

>$* $

*# % :,,

!$&#

!8 *#!

$#!% >$*6$

7%'#$76"$44$>$* *5

7% :,B,

,%#$4 @ 5 6'#!% % >!# ** * "$8

6!# 7/ % %'# %& #"

9/ %4- "$8

D$9! 7#!44 47$# ,"

!8$46%# #!%* $!* 7$#$ !8 !* #%7 ($#$(4

!**'

**"$44( $#!%6!$# 7'5%7'

6% %&# !$4,"!*%'

#7% *%#

9!#$55 %5 !$# #%7 7

5!#%#"

!8$46%# #!%*/$##"!**#$

/4 *# !# 9$- 5

'7!6 # !$4, %#"! #$ !(4

"$* (

( "# &% >$ 7 #% !7!6$# 4 !.

4!"%%7%&#"

$(*6% 7! & %9#"

%6 **%&'*#!6

>!#"#"

6'#!% 8!7 C,,

7'(!#$(4-/ #"

# 5 #!#!% % !* #"

#"!

7 $## 95# (- #"

#% 6'

($!4,"

4$*#($!4 454 $5

7(-#"

>$*7!*9!**

7% ,, @,%>

5! !8!

>&'

!6$

$#!% %& #"

#!#!% %

&% $ 5

!%7 %& 9%

#"$ B 9%#"* $7 % *'(*#$#!$4

**!#

!$4/#"!*%'

#!*!64! 7#%&$8% $(4-6%*!7

!*#$#54 &% ($!4,5

%&!#$(4

/!#"!*

7/6$( 9$7 #%$'7 #%& #"!*%'

#5$ $** 7!

#!#4

7$*$&!HK"$8

*'* #$# %& $&!HK"$8

*'* #$# %& &&&& $ -$$$7 $ -$$$7 $ -$$$7 $ -$$$7 7 $%#"

7 $%#"

8$#>"

$7*$ $*'7

) F, * $ 5!4% #% #"

!6!54

)

6%7G*'66 **!8 9$!#$!$(4 !4$>;"

*%4 4-%#"

%'7%&9$!#$

'6" 6%7G*'66 ** 9$!#$!$(4 >"

>!#"7 $>G7!*9!** 7$*%#5 4!

#!#!%>$*7!*9!**

% * 6%7G*'66 *'66

7/ #"

G$554!

H'!

7#%*"%>*'(*#$#!$46 %&$9

*'5

&!6!$4% %*# #$5"% !6

**!% %& *

"#%#( $(*# $6# 7!#%4 *'(*#$#!$4/ && 6#!8 $76%*

I D"$'*#!8 '!7 >"$#>%'476%*#!#'# *'(*#$ 6$* "$* !#* %> '!H'

&$ $## 95#!*%#"! ('#$'#% *#4 &##%#"

'7!6!$4>!*7%9 >!#"*'6"* 6%7G*'66 **!8

I 6$* $%'

#6"%%* ($!45 #!#!%0*3/6%

#$74'6

6% 7 &%

$#! *'

6%7G*'66 **!8 #!#!%0*3, "$8! *'66 **&'44- 6%7G*'66 **!8 #!#!%0*3 6!5"

$(4 & %9#"

*$!7% $(%8 7!*6'**!%/ #"

&%44%>!

($!4 #!#!%0*3 &!4 !* *'6"5 #!#!%%'

"#%##%(

6# #$!$(!4!#-#"

%&, *!8

($!4 #!#!%0*3 !*

#!#!% >$* 7!*9!** $*

** 7G7!*9!** %5 6'#!% 7%9

!#*, **!8

($!4 5 #!#!%0*3 #%

!6$# *"$44 ( ** #!$44-G5

#! #46"$

!6!

6'9*#$6 *$7*"%>!

*!(4 6"$

>%'47%#*'&&!6 ,"

.! * 6%7G*'66 **!8 ($!4 54 $0*3

3 4!#

$4!#

$#!%*%&5 #!#!%0*3>!#"%'# H'

#!$46"$

!6!

6'9*#$6 *, 4! *6$5%**!(4-( 4$!77%>$*#% #!$46"$

!6!

6'9*#$6 *$*

- &$6#*G6!

6'9*#$6 , $.! *'6" $ %5!$ 7 $8%'

%/#"!*!**'

9$77!*6

#!%%&#"

#7 $4!

($!45 #!#!%0*3, *#%

$#* 6%7G*'66 **!8

'6!7

$*%*$

#! #4-

H'!

7#%

'6" 54 $ 7 *5!# *'6" $ 54 $ (

%#"

>% 7*/#"

6$'* &% $%'

6%'# $6 7G

#$! *'6"

3 %'

"# #% (

$7!4- $7 64 4-

5$** 7,L C, , 5

'*$4%&#"

J!9!%

*5$ $** 7(-#"

!$4%'

#/( "# &% #"(-#"

/!7!6$# *#"$##"

!$4!* *!7

75 %6 $*#!$#! $7&%44-

%&6$% %#( *$774 7'5%#"

, ,*5

6'*#%7-6

#!&!6$# 7$#

@ @ ,A, : &

&!4 7 (- #"

4 7 #$# 6%' * 4/ #"

"$* $4

$7- *'&&

7!6$

$#!%&% $5

!%7%& - ; 7$-*/;!*%#*"%>#%(

!8%48 7!$ $-%#"

G , #"!*8!

> 9$##

/#"

!95%* '7

6#!% 6#*#$7*7!4 '# 7!4!

"#%&#"

#!64 %& %*#!#'#!

!%%& 7!$, C, , "!* %'

# ! $ '7 # #!#4 7 $* K'4>!7

*'* #$# %& K'4>!7

*'* #$# %& &&&& '$( '$( '$( '$( 5$**

7 ! C@@ C@@ C@@ C@@ @

@ 0

:)) CB:3E $&#

4-!

'5% #"

$#!

#!% 7 6!7 7!%& #"

'7 #* %& & #"

%2(4 '5

# ! '**$!$ $K K"$#%%8*,%9 6-,/ #$# %& &!"$ 0BA3 AE(7'4 "9$#'

'4$-8*, , $-$.0BB 3

:E$8 7'4$9 $(! "$!."

8*, #$# %& $"$ $*"# $ $7 $%#"

@0 3 0 !9!$43 @B@E %"7 '*4!9 M '**$! 8*, #$# 0 %& 4"

"!3

5% 7 $*

E E !9!$455 $4 %, @:G 7$# 7, ,

#!#4 7$*F"!##$!*>$*4!$* '("$* 8*, #$# %& = *# $4LE F !# #!*" 7"!.$ - M $5$ 8*, "

#$# %& = *# $4L/ 5 6!$4 + $8 #% 5 $4 0 4,3 %,::

7$#

,A,

# #!#4 7 $* F%"$99$7 $49$ $!& "$!." 8*, "

#$# %& '$ $#LE !9!$455 $4 %,CB%&

7$# 7:,A,

#!#4 7$*%5$4 K !*"$ $# $ M %5$4 '*9$ 8*, !% %&

7!$/ $7 .'

"$'7"$ - 8*, , #$# %&$7"

"-$ $7 *"/ @0@30 !9!

!$43 E"$*"

47/#"'*) F,A, "# #% $ *5

78!#$4*$&

'$ 7#%5

#'7'

$7 $D!

#-$76%6

$66%95$-! !95$!

#!#"

$(!4!#-%&$$66'* %8

6"! *%6!

#$4!#

*#5$8! >

74-$6#'$# 7!#"

$(%8

7#% '5

#2*'

6!*!%*%5 ! '5 >8!*#$*%& *5

7-# !$4!*$9$4 $9$# 7!#%#"

&'7$9 #$4 "##%4!& $74!(

#-/ %*#!#'#!%, "

"# #% *5

7- # - $7 7!#!%'* # !$4 !* %# %4- $ 7 %55

**!8 !6$

$#!%E#%9!#!

$66'*$#!%$*> 44$*#%6'

#$!4$- 7#%7 7"!9* 4&/('##"

!*$ >$-&% $*5

7-# !$4,"!* "#"$* #5$*#$7#"

$#!%7 6!7 7!%&#"

'7 #*"$8 4$!77%>$*

*%& & &'7$9 #$4 "#*,"

6%6 5#%&

#!64 $*$ ** #!$45$ #%&#"

'$ $#

7$75

7'7

!$4 (

!* >!#" #"

$6#'$4

*# $!#

: :

!95%* 7 $# #"

#!9 %& #"

!6$

$#!% >"!6" 6%#!'

* $# !8 *#!

$#!%/ !H'!

-/ # !$4/ $55 $4

'7!6 #"$#9$-

*'4#7'

#%!95 #!9 %& #"

6%99!**!% %& #"

% 6%*'99$# !#% $ &!$4!#-/ 6%'47 ( $7H'!6.7!*5%*$4$

*! H'

%>7 7%'

#7%6.

#*/#"

**'

%#"

6'#!%$7#"

!9!$4'

!*5 '7 #!$49 6"$!*9'

6$%#( $ D6'* &% .

$66'* $!7 &!!#

!%7%&#!9 !9!$4 '*#!6 *-*# 9/ $#"

!# 9

'$ $#

%& $ *5

7- # !$4 !* !# 7 4$- (- !95%*! % #"

# $ %6

7>!#"#"

!$4>!#"$

$*%$(

&%475'

5%* ,!

*#4-/!#5 %# 6#* !$4 !95 !*%9 #E * 6%74-/ !#

5'(4!6*'*5!6!%7'

#%'

*%48 76

$!*# #"

!*. #"$# 8!7 >!44 ( 5$**$

%& #!9 / #"'*/ !95$!

"!9* 4&, *>!#"%'#*$-! #"$##"

$8 , 66'* 7/ 5

*'9 7 ! *'( 6# 7 #% 5*-6"%4% !6$4 $7 5"-* '7

%'*6%7!#!%*,H'$44-!9 *'6"$$66'* 7&

#4-&$44*"

&$9!4-,

!* - # $%#"

$ 6%*!7

$#!% $# #"!* *#$

, "

$44

$66'* 7 ( !8%48 7 ! $ 6%# $($7'7

6#/BA !$6$* !8%48! 6%99

6!$4H'$#

7'7

6#!% #"$# %'

#* 6$

$# ($!4 #% $ $6 6'#% $7$&#

"$8! *$#!*&!

$*%$(4

%'7* &% 4!

8! %&& 6"$

7G$44

7$7#"$#/"

>"!4 %($!4,"

# *% 9'*# ( 9 #!6'4%'*4- *6 '#!!J &'7$9 #$4 "##%$*5

7-# !$4, 6$%#(

$#% -(-'>$ 5$ #!6'4$ 4->"

*'6"7 4$-0*3!* '*#!&!

7$##"

7%&#"

6'#!% 6$%# ( .

5# ( "!7 ($ * &% $

! *4$!77%>! 6#!%

!*4$#'

!!#*>!*7%9/!%

#% *'7

6#/"$*5 %8!7 '7

6#!% C%&#"

6#,%>

- #%#"

%# $6# 77 4$-*$7*-*#

!*4$#!8 5'

5%* ,%'

#%&4$> %#( 6%9 6%954!6!#!8!%4$#!%% %#>!#"*#$7! $-#"! 6%#$! 7!

#!#!%!$6$* %8

7(-#"

*# %& #"

$66'* 7 $7 6%* H'

$44 *#$

*/ $9 4-/ #"

*#$

%& 4 $7

8!*!% *% #"$# $- 5%**!(4

9!**!(4 $7$8%!7$(4 7 4$-*!6

%&& #!44 #"

6 !9!$4 5 %6

7! $8

7, "

7- # !$4/ 4H'$%%&6 !9!$4'

!*5 '7 ,"

$8-8%4'9 %&>% .$7#"

*'4#$#

%4!6 /!7'(!#$(4-.

5*#"

**$7*# $!,%>

/#"!*

*>% 7%&$9%64 *"$ %#"

#7% *%#*

$-6

7!##%#"

9$.

* &% $ *$7 *#$# %& $&&$!

*, "

7 #% $8%!7 %55

**!% $7 5

$7 #"

6'#!% $ %(4!

$#!% #% $(4 7!*5$#6","

'$ $#

*$ *#"

$66'* 7$ $!*#%55

**!8

* #"

$66'* 7 %& #"

$D!

#- $7 !9!$46"$

*$74$*#4-/!#5 %# 6#*

4%*# % 9 9% * 7!99 7 (- #"

$(!4!#- %& #"

$66'* 7 #% 7 7 6%* H'

*%&5

# !$47 #!% %6 #/ #!44 5 %8 %#"

>!* / $

*!6$4 7 !8$#!%* %& $!44!& / '*'$44- !95% #$#/#"

%&7 #!%%& $8!4-%#"

!%6 #9 9(

*%&"!* $*5 6# %& #"

9$##

>"!6" 7

$#!%* ! #"

# 6$*

4$# #%

4$#! #% 6%99

6!$4 H'$#!#- %&

BA:,="!4 6%*!7

$($!45 #!#-/#"

#"$*#%.

5!9!7#"

%& 6#/BA:>"!6"9$7$# 6

: 66'* 7 %4- $&#

5'(4!6 7!#* 4&%&#>!6%7!#!%*>"!6"$

"$# #"

$66'* 7 !* %# '!4#- %& #"

!*%#4!.

4-#%6%99!#$-%&&

%& 6#!% 6#/BA:

$!*# #"

($6.7 %5 %& $66'* 72* "##%4!& $75

*%$44!(

$# 77 4$-*!#"

'7!6!$45 %6 **/ !#"

$## !('#$(4 #%#"

$66'* 7%

!%(- 6%

$*%*,!7!8!7'$4 !% 7!$#

!%7 %& #!9 (- #$.!

!% 6#/BA:,"

7-$7#!9 4-7!*5%*$4%& 6%*#!#'#!%%&*5 6!$4%'

#* >

/#"!*%'

#6$%##'

4*%2* 9$#!6! &&!6!

6-#"$#& '*# #"!* >!*7'#-(%'7#% *'

#"$#!#7% %&$!7!8!7'$42*&'7$9 #$4 "#*/ !4 #/ !$*#$#'# ,="!4 7 $4! >!#"($!4

*%& 6#!% 6#/

BA:/ #"

# 9'*# *# !.

$ '7!6 !# ##%6'

(#"

9 $6 %&7 *$ #%$&$!

$7 7!#!%'*# !$4, %4% 6$'* !*.* # $*&% 9!

# !$4 7

$%'#6%9 $#!#"

#!6$4#%#"

!6!5

%/#"

' H'!8%6$4 &$!4 7 #% 6%64'7 >!#"! $

$*% !6$

$#!%/ !# 9!4!#$# * $ $!*# #"

$7 4!(

$# 7 '7

4$> %8

!7! *#$#'#% 9($

6#/BA:%'

"##%( 6%*!7

7$* >% 7*/

$#%&($!4!$6$*

#$!

%'7%&'7'

7 4$-!# !$4/6$% 6#/BA:,L 6!%'* ($4$6 #>

!*4$#!8

7#"

*$6 %*$6# "#%&#"

$66'*

7!6$

$#!%/>!#"%'#'*#!&!$(4

#!% !#% 5'!#!8 !95 !*%9 #/ %&'*#!6 $7 H'!#-,

#/ 4!&

!*#"$#>"

!$4"$* %$(4 #!9

*'4#! ! 5 %4%

6!%'* &'7$9 #$4 "#* %& 4!&

> $7/ $* *'6"/ 6%7!#!%$4 4!(

7'7

6#!% *5

&$6#*%&$ !8 6$* %#"

!! #%6%99

6!$4H'$#!#-/%#"

%#( *$!7#%( & ##

7(- 6#!%

'&&!6 #%*$-/&'

7 #!%%

$*$'7

!$4!* %#>$

$# 7!#"

&$6#*$76!

6'9*#$6 *%& &#"

> %& $(%8 / #"

# 5 #!#!% !* $44%> 7,

7#%(

$* 7%

($!4%"!*&'

!*"! ($!4G*'

#-(%7*#%#"

*$#!*&$6#!% % %& #"

+7, 6%6

7 # !$4 %'

#G'#- $ !*# , %>

/ ! $77!#!%#%6% %7!#!%*#"$#9$-( !95%* 7( (-#"

6%6

7# !$4%'

#G'#- $ !*# /#"

*"$44

9$!(%'7( (-#"

&%44%>! 6%7!#!%*) 0!3

*"$44%#9!

0!!3

*"$44%##$ 7%6'9 #$ -/7'

0!!!3 "

*"$44%#$( *'* 4!(

$# 7, $95

>!#"$- 8!7 /% $4%

!$4, (* #"!9* 4&%$-7$# ( &%

!$4, 0!83 "

*"$44%#6%9 083

*"$44 7 5%* !$4%'

#, 08!3

*"$44 !8

8 *#!

$#! &&!6

G *"$44 %# 6"$

"!* 6

9!**!%%&#"

!$4%'

08!!3 "

*"$44%#! 08!!!3 "

*"$44 *'(9 99!#$-%&& >"!4 %($!4, *!# "!* 5$**5% #/ !& $-/ >!#" #"

"!* 6 445"% '9(

#% #"

%&6%6

7%4!6 #$#!%$7

445"% '9(

>!#"%'# 5 !%

#G 44$H$$ !*#

$-9$

-#%7 4$-#"

!$4, 9!#/ % #"

*# >% .! 7$- %&

-9%#"/$$&&!7$8!#/ #%#"

&& 6##"$#"

"$*% $- %&& $&#

!*&%'7#%( !

7%($!4! &%

6%6

7# !$4%'

#/ #(

!8%48 7!6%99!**!%%&

$* 7 % ($!4, 6$*

!8%48 7!$-%&& $&#

"!*

# /%#"

($*!*%&

"!*$&&!7$8!#% %#"

>!* / &% #">!#"/ &% 6$6 44$#!% 6%'

/*"$44( $#!%6!$#

/#"

#$# !*9$7$# 7#%9%8 / %& "!* ($!4 >"!6" 54 $/ ('# %&

7'5%9

!#*#"

%&, A,

6$* %& (

$6" %& $- %& #"

$&%

*$!7 6%7!#!%* $7 #"%*

>"!6"9$-( !95%* 7(-6%6

7# !$4 #G'#-$ !*# $*7!

!$(%8 % '5%*"%>! $-%#"

*'&&!6 6!

#6$'* /#"

#$# G6%954$!$# *"$44( $#4!(

#-#%9%8 6$6 44$#!%%&($!4%

7$66% 7! 4-, ,

%#"! *$!7"

!$(%8 *"$44( 6%*# 7$*$

**!%%& %5!!%%#"

!#*%&#"

, !6 9$! 6$* "$* (

6!7 7/ 5 7! 9!*6 44$ %'* $554!6$#!%/!& &$-/*"$44$4*%*#$7*7!*5%* 7% %&&, '

'*#

9$"$8!

*5 $.

5% :

: 0 + + + +3

$*% 7) *G #$(4 ) *G