← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/2174/1997disposed of

Babu Ram v. The Collector,Land Acq.

2016-05-03Mr. Justice T.H.B. Chalapathi11 pages

    

 !"#$

%

% &&'()* + 



  ,-   

    

  

  "##

   

$





.'

/"0 .!

 .

1.02 %  

   & ' (  )    



& '

**    !  * ,  !   -.'%/0#%11/ *      !  ** + !    -.%/23#'33% *4  !    -.'012#'33% *5 , 

! # *4 . !    -. 6%766%78#'33% -.0027#'33% **    !    -.63%%63%2#'33% .   -. 62006202#%118

-. 076/ 0768#'3%% *9  

4 :) #       .

1.023 !  456 

 #'7

#+

0 - . 72372'#%111 6726#%111#

#:)  '% -. '%/0#%11/ 62006202# %118 %/23 '012 63%%63%2 6%766%78 0027 076/ 0768# '33%#







# 

  



#+ # ;+ 

#



# 

#

,#

#



 #-.'%/0#%11/! 

 

 

"##

  $  

#,    #  

,  # 

   #  

 

  #  #:) 

  %6'

2< %1

# 





= , 

( $

   : 

>

#



#

 # $ ?   

, 



0#  

 %810@ A# +

''%%113

 #+

,



%0%%11%

2#

  



@B# 

 + .%

%1%%116 #





 '% /3723

 # #!

  :   %1 /23C

# #!

 ( $ 4 *<  #   +

 %2 333C 



 + #

)

%8# 

  !

 +

 '%%'%112

   

.6/#08%116 

@! 





A

, 

+

'%%'%112 

 A

+

#+

 %7

( 

 



+

%/%'33% 

+ 

A

 + #+

:< 

 #    

 



+

2%%'333;+

#*C +

;

*C 

;

*C D  :, D 

+ +

## 

+

'77%118 ,



#   +  +

#+

+

'77%118



 +

'2/%111D

#



! # %733C E '

333C  

# 

 

+

'77%118 '2/%111  #:) #

#

<  

       #    

   +

 +    +  !

 #

 

<   #



        #     #  

  

 

,    + !



 +

!



<



 #  #



+ 



  ;!





# 





 # #  #

 #

  !  

   #

, 

!

, +

#+   #  ,#



   #

 < ) !  + 

@B#  + <  ,  

  $?  

+   

5 ,,









 





 +   ,  >

        

 #

  

!



 ,!

 

4 < +  





> ,#

 

!

 

+  



 

;!



#



  



   !



 , 

 

    

 +

'%%'%112

B

 



/# 

+ 

   #!

  : F>0+

82%11'

F>7+

%86%11% F>2+

0'%182 #



0# + %1%%113D!

+#



#

 , !

F>2

0'%182

  8<  # 03 333C   #  03 333C ;+  

 

#  , 

 

#

!  

#!# D# 

 

#

F>2+ , !

#

  !



, 

#

 

) ;+

#

   #  D

+#  #



 /# 

+

 

D

#:)



,

>





+ 

F!

#



,   

>



!

>

 



 !





D

#

+







 

!

+# + 

+, ;B   0578 & & 73** 4 )6 +

;B    6'# )   G  



                     

 

      

       



   

!     " 

    

  #           

 

$ :

 #

F>% ' 6

,



#*C +

;

-.6202# %118 + ++    ,#





#



 ,+

 !

 - 

  , 



 

 

!

+ !

 , 

  



+< ,

 

# 

!  ;A   9-&5%85::&8 -;73* 

+ 6   F>

  

 !

   +    

!  

 !

 #!#

 #:)D!

+# !  ,#,  !

#

F>2

0'%182

, !

#

  # , 

#

#

D





  +

+,

;A       .7<5  27<=&  -  4>&63 &;78  -=?734* 6) (3



 

<

 

 



H



,  ##, +

F>2 



0# D!

+#

+

+, ;B   75.>3 &5#-5:&087?7&!&8?7& 5# 73**@4 6

)  7;2-78

93* )4(65 3 + 

 %'I

  

 ##, 4 #%'I

  

## ,

03 333C



F>2  

 2'

103//





## 2'

173C 

,





#    2'

173C

# #



0#       , +, 



+

+  , 



#

+  , + +



  D 

 

 



     +  

 !





 

F!

, #

    

D 

 >    , #,



# +  ,#,





!

#  

+< ,

  ,

#

#  #+ ) 

;A

  

G

& &,& 5&>773 **)4 6)+ 

7%, 93* *4 6) A ( 7 &7, 973 * (4)6)  

   



!"

  #  $#""%#&' ()$$ * ")

+ ,

#-.

 /0" 

$ $ * "+

( 1 '  # 2 &%3    $#""%# #44$$ * "



 

56

    #-     #44$$ * "

 '7 /*  #  #- 8 

@   #44$$ * "

4 9":

 #- 8 44+)$ $ * "(

 '



 # 2 &%3    ;  "2   .'!#*' ;#     #44+2&+

 9

 #   .'!#*' ;;  "<"  # 44($$ * "

) 0' #  #- 8    #44)$$ * "(

 #

#





  + 

 ##

#



    



-.%/23#'33% :<  !

 

 

"##

      :<    833 , 



 #







, %18'





8,  #

#  

    

> + 

(')     -

"##

# #:)



 



#  , 

+

 %333C %'33C

 + 

  



# 

>  



#  

 %%# 

+ 



,

 !



,

 , ;+

 

,   

# , 

 233C 

 

 ,  #



  



> 

 ,      -

  "##

  #      #  :) 

#    

 !



 

> 

!



 D

+# 

<   !  #     ,  

 +

 ,    :<   

  

 

       #   % 333C    

   .   #

, 

833

  

 

#  

#    !





#      #  :)     ,     

       #  



,   :<  





   #     ,  

       #   % 333C  

, 

        

  -  .6202  #  %118 *C +

;

!H #D

  

  # !  F>:'

!   '7# 

+   #(6)   %6#  + <  ,    

 

# ! # 

>  

#  %6 62'73

#

   , D

  #

 

, ,

 

#



,  

+

  

* +   8 733C  #

, 

 



,+

+  



!



D  ,##

 

   # %'

+ 



#)



,

+ +,)



,    





# %'



 

>

#+

  #

  

    #*C 

;

-.6200#%118*C 

;

!H #D

   !  F>:'

%81%110!   '7#  + #  

+

 6 '33C;+



# , 

 



 %6 62'73

# # 

-.6202#%118*C +

;

! H #D

 



, ,

 + )    # 6

#   

+ 

#



 ,

+  +, )

,   -.6207#%118 *C D  :, D 

!H #D

  

# /3 333C#   

  !   F>:'!   '6#;+





# 03 333C+ 

,  

 



#

   !



  



#:)

+ # 23 333C+ )    "

,    

,

  

)







!

,  +



 ##

# 





 #

 



!



 #

#

+  #

#;, 

!

,



 , +

 > 

  



 #

# 2'

173C #

#



0#    



#  +





  

 

  

 , !    

!!

 

,  

! 

 





# #

 

+  

 ()* + 4.

1.026 ; %