Sundeep Kumar v. The Board Of Directors, Dakshin Haryana Bijli Vitran Nigam And Others
!"#"$ %& !#""$
'( )*+'"
, +, ++ '* **** !
"# !
"# ,-! .' / 0&12 " %&'
(
( ) " * $+* +$ ++* #
$, # - +* " + $+ .//0 +
* $ $
+*2 #2*
3 %.'
+ ( #4$"
+ ..0)5 (
* ( 6 $ .7 /8 ././%"9 .:' (++ &.
/7 ./.& %"9 7/' ( 2* $( ( 2 $ ( ( ( 2 ( # $
$ ;
2*
+ < $ 6 $
$, /= /7 ./&=%"9 >' 6 /?
/8 ./&?%"9 ='
V VISHAL 2023.09.29 15:41
- 2 - %7'
( " -$ -+ +(
&& /= .//> +* ( 4$ " -9#-$
" ( #2* 2 (
$, ( /= /7 ./&= 2* $-$ ;$+ ++$$ $/& /0 ./&8, + $+ 6 /?
/8 ./&?%"9 ='
$
( # +( .7 /8 ././ %"9 .:' ( 2* )
, ,!
$$ ( 2* $( ( (
5 ( +2* )@
&.&=& ././ + + 2
+ +* # $ &.
/7 ./.& -;"
#*
$+ &8 /.
./.& A $( + ( BA $( + 3&45 /4 B ( %>'
!
+
+ 2 #2* +
*
$(
( 2
( 2* $ * .7 /8 ././ &.
/7 ./.&%"9 .: 7/ #+*'
+ 2+26 #( $+ 8%7' (.% '%2'
%' - +* " + $+ .//0 $# $ $+
" $
- 3 - ++ 2# ( # + ( 2* * $ ( , + 2*+
*(
* 1$ )
%:'
5 2 "
+ "
+ ) "&?:0+(
"
+7&&)5
+* C $ *D (
+
2 $-$ ;$+ ) " * #$ ( 1
$6 # *
$,++$ + 2*$
%0'
<
$ $ ( # $+ ; E 4+
(# +* &/ /:
./&? %"9 &7'
* # * ++$
5 (
F# +
;
%"9 &:7> 7:'( $ ++* #
*$ # 2+
1 +*+ 2 4 %8'
E
+ $
+6
)+ ,& )+ 55 ++
6 +
- 4 - E$ +
2
$ +$ +#$ + 22 E$ +
2
$ ! # $+ E 6
4+ ( $+* ,+$ ( $+ 6
F $
#( $ +++ #+ +=%=') .
* )#+ #%F
+' +./&0 67"
" 2
2 + ;
;
$ (( $G5+*G2*
2
H$
+
*
$ * $ * *
%?'
( .8 /> ./.& +* 2+2*
%&/'
!
"#
$ 2 +
2 #
+* &0 /?
./.& 2 $+ 8%7' .//0 $+
$, 2 2* +
* ( +6 21 2 E +$ (
!
$$
<
"
+>0%9' %9'"
+ " ++$ ( # + 2 !
$$
!
$$ ( +
*# (
$,
- 5 - %&&'
$
2*+
+
$+ .//0%"9 ./'( +
./&? $ * $
+ $ I $+ &?%&'%2'./&? $+ ++
+ $ ./&? $+
2
( ./&? $+ * 2
+ $ ( $ (./&? $+
+2
+ 2+ J ( ++ I $+ 8%"'%7' ./&? $+ *
$ #+#$
+*$ * %&.'
6 ,#$
$, 2* E$ +
+
+
2
+ $ ( +* $+ 2*
$+ .//0 + 2* $+ ./&?
$+
4 2 +
* $ * + E$ +
2
$,+6
%&7'
5
2 +
2#
2*$# 5 2
+* $+ ( + # + 2+ * +$+ # %&>'
2*+
+
- 6 - %&:'
+
+
$ $ %&0'
++$
$, 2 2* * #$ <
$, +$
$+#++
# $ * ++*+$ +
$ ( 2 # 2*
+ ( %&8'
H ) "
"$ " * I "
+ 7&& ) 5 +
*2 42*"$" *"
+" 1 (
( !
$$ %"
+>0' (
%"
+>.'
"
$"
+" (+(
+* $ * (
*
+
) "
$+ # + +4 )
!
$$ ,+$ *( $
* +
*
4 )
, ,!
$$ # + * ++ 2 $ * +
* ! $ 2* )! +
"
+>0%9' %9'!
$$
4
- 7 -
# + + !18/! -/45 &9-4& !2*
%&='
< $+ 8%7' ( $+ .% '%2' %' .//0 $+
$, 2 2* +
*(+621 -# .//0 $+ 26+*
./&? $+ *
$, #+#$
+* $ * C"9 "D ./&? $+ * (
-9# -$ % ' !
$$
2 +
$, ( 2* $ -$ + 4 1 $ 2+ $ -$ ( +* H ( ( +$
$, %&?'
" * ,+(+(
+( 4
+6
) 2+ +
$, 2
9$
$,($$ ( 42*!
$$ ;+
*" *2* #$
$,9 ++ 2
$, A
B $
$,+ +
$,( 4 # +2 !
$$ #
- 8 - %./'
5 !
"
# %
' (+ ++$ + +
* # +
$
$, 2
( 2* * +
* ) #+*+ ,
! "#
! $ ! "#%&'
(
! "# ! ")
$ ! "#%#'
*
*
+ *
* ,
- .
*
$
, &""%"'
/ $ -
, &""%0'
*
1 *
*
$ -
* $$ 2 $3
%.&'
@+ 1$ 2#2 + +$ ) + #H
$, 2
(2* * +
*(+ (++4(
9
% '
- 9 - %..'
+
A / &%&-1 &3 : ;&!& -4& %4& !B - +
4 %2 ' ++( ,
,
6
* *
/ 7
*
*
8
6 * 6
$3
%.7'
+ 2 2A ;&!& -4& *-3B $+$!$ + $2$ 2 % ' ": ++( ,
/ *
,
6
6
*
* $
6 *
* $
( 6
*
*
7 * *
6 ;
*
$3
%.>'
# $+ $
+
* #$1
+
+* +*
* *+*( ( 1 +* *#6# + * $ * 2 2 +* 2
2 + 6 +
- 10 - $
+* 6 2
+*2* * +* %.:'
$
2 + + # 2 2 1 $+* # 2
#+* +$ 5 %"9 &: 7> 7:' ( 2 +$ ( " ), 8=;F!;" %F 7=;+,5 7/ /0 ./&>%"9 &:'2* !
$ ( + +* (++2 ( 2
# +$ ( +$ + (++2 4
# 4 ++$
) +
&> &.
././ %"9 7:' +
+* + + 2 4
+ 2+2+ 5 ++ ( *# 2+ ++$
( 6
($;($ 2*( *+$ #;
(&: * 5
#$ # # *
2+$ + # # *$
+ +** $ A # + 2+ B
- 11 - %.0'
! # >%0' @+ +( " ./&&
G 7 *
*
* 7 *
*
G %.8'
2 +
* $ +2 *+ ( 9( #
(* #2 +$ #+
* + # ) +
%"9 &: 7> 7:' # +
* $ !
2 #
(
*2 2* + #
(
#2 21+2
++(2
( ++$
+
2
+ 5
+6 *2 + ( 2 #
$, 2 9 %.='
" ( ) (+ # *
#+#
D , $ $ /& /0 ./..
(# +* $( ++2*;$+ I( 2 ,+$ ( # $ 2* F, , ;$+ E 4+
! # ,+$ ( 2* $+ + =%=' ) .
* )#+ #%F
+' +./&0( #
3 6
- 12 - - ! *
< +
+ #(
*
$+ *; # ;( 4$
$+ ++ $ (+ ( F ( *+2+$ (
6
"+ + $+ H + E; ,+$ ( 2* E ( 6 2 + $ + #2
<
#
( ( ( A!
+ B F# 5 ! * +2+F # %.?'
5 2+ $ /& /0 ./&8(( #
# $
$ 6 6
$ ( + 6
!
;" +./&?+ 5 (+
$$ + -9#-$ + K$ 4L "-; %$+ ' $2 +
+ + * #
+
* 2+ * $
$ * +, $ $
+
+* 2*
$ * ( # $ $
+ +*
- 13 - ( +
2+ 9 ( 2$ 9 2*
($2 $ %7/'
< 2#( ++( .7 /8 ././%"9 .: 7/ #+*'
(++
$, ++ 6 + $
2*
$
++ #; +2 * +$( M?N
2
++ +H +$ *
./..
%7&'
+ ++ 2 (
*
%7.'
Ordered accordingly. .8 /?
./.7
6,-! .' / 0&17
/ 0
1. Whether speaking/reasoned?
Yes/No
2. Whether reportable?
Yes/No