Shakuntla Devi, Etc. v. Dilbagh Singh & ORS.

   

      

!"# $#%&'&()
*
 +,"+-!./("0!#1&!($"-#2'

33#00!("'  4#2'/'

&05!6-+&(6-!($"-#2'

#'3($#("'

)  78  + 9 8+  2#'#("):

2+92&3!"-&;$1%!"#; 2;

2!&4&2!$!1;$1%!"#; 2"-#!33#00!("' 2 /3"!;$1%!"#; 22#'3($#("  <-#"-#2"-##32"#2' 0%!0(#='3!3#2,!>5#!00=#$"'## "-#?/$6,#("@
 5#2# #22#$""-##32"#22("  <-#"-#2"-#?/$6,#("'-/0$5#2#32"#$&("-#$&6#'"@ ::

::

8+ ;

8 ,3/6(#$  &(  "-#  32#'#("  !33#!0  &'  "-#  !=!2$  $!"#$ 
;3!''#$5>"-#"2%%&$#(" 0!&,'2&5/(!0; /26!(

&('-2"7"-#2&5/(!07  2&# !%"'    "-&'  %!'#  !2#  "-!"  ( 
;  !& !2.!'-;!6#$!5/"
*>#!2';=!'6&(6(!,"2%>%0#5#!2&(6 2#6&'"2!"&(8::**!($=-#(2#!%-#$(#!2!'!("9/(?; #0-&;-#=!'-&"5>"2/%.5#!2&(62#6&'"2!"&( :A
-# 2&5/(!0"."-#1&#="-!"'&(%#"-#2#=!'(#1&$#(%#"-!""-# $#%#!'#$=!''#00&(6,&0.;"-#2# 2#&"!''#''#$"-#&(%,# "-# $#%#!'#$!",&(&,/,=!6#'!""-!""&,#&#'
; :3#2,("-

:
:

!($!330&#$"-#,/0"&30&#2 *!($!

"#2$#$/%"&(6 2$!'3#2'(!0 #B3#('#'%!0%/0!"#$"-#$#3#($#(%> "-#%0!&,!("'!'';A :

3#2,("--#2# 2#;"-#!,/(" %,3#('!"&((!%%/("

0'' $#3#($#(%>%,#'"';A :B
C*D';
;A : '  ; :(!%%/("  /(#2!0 #B3#('#' !($ '
; : ( !%%/(" "2!('32"!"&(%-!26#'=#2#!0'!00=#$ 8#!2(#$%/('#0 2"-#!33#00!("'-!'%("#($#$"-!"

"-#&(%,# "-#$#%#!'#$=!'!''#''#$("-#0=#2'&$## -!'2# #22#$""-#2#%2$5. '!0# ,&0. B
=#1#2;"-# !00#6#$'!&$2#%2$5. '!0# ,&0.&'(0> 2"-#>#!2'A !($    !($  &(  5#"=##(;  "-#2#  &'  (  2#%2$    >#!2   -#2# 2#;"-#'!&$$&!2> B
=!'2&6-"0>("2#0&#$/3(5>"-# 2&5/(!0 ("-&'%!'#;"-#$#%#!'#$=!' /($"5#
>#!2'

!6#!($,/0"&30&#2 *=!'!330&#$;=-&%-&'("-#-&6-#2'&$# =#1#2;  '&(%#  "-#2#  &'  (  %2''  !33#!0;  "-&'  /2"  $#'  ("

&("#2 #2#&("-#'!&$ &($&(6' -#  0#!2(#$  %/('#0  2  "-#  !33#00!("'  -!'  /2"-#2 !26/#$"-!" /(#2!0#B3#('#'!2#(0=#2'&$#%,3#('!"&( ( !%%/("    0''    %('2"&/,  "  =& #  !($  0''    01#  !($ !

#%"&(""-#%-&0$2#(=!'!=!2$#$ 9##3&(6 &( 1&#= "-# !%"'  !($ %&2%/,'"!(%#';  /(#2!0 #B3#('#'!2##(-!(%#$5>'
; :9##3&(6&(1&#="-# !%"

"-!""-#!%%&$#("=!' ;'; :(!%%/(" 0''

::

%('2"&/,""-#=& #!($!("-#2'/, ';; : 20''

01#!($!

#%"&(!($6/&$!(%#"%-&0$2#(!2#!00=#$-#""!0 %,3#('!"&(&'#(-!(%#$5>';E; :-#""!0#(-!(%#$ %,3#('!"&('-!005#3!&$5>"-#&('/2!(%#%,3!(>=&"-&("#2#'" FEG3#2!((/, 2,"-#$!"# &0&(6 "-#%0!&,3#"&"&("&00&"'

2#!0&H!"&( %%2$&(60>;  "-#  32#'#("  !33#!0  &'  !00=#$  &(  !51# "#2,'

8+   

*
 '?.'