Mani Ram v. The Assistant Collector Grade I And ORS
!" "#$%$&'
&$ ( "!$!$&") *" %%$%! &!++"#!)%!) ,"-++"& . , &,!*")% "%/&,"&!% '0 1 23323 22 4 23
!"
# $ % &&&&& 23 22-) + !'
() !**+ , -) . /
0
.. # "* ('
!**) , -* . /
2 . 3 # - 2 4 #.
/ 5 67 8 !*9! 6
/567 8 !*9! () (+ "("!86 : !*9! ;8# < < =
0
2
.# ;. 2/ ) ( &#* 5 ! 6$++ 7" ( +/8)9% +:$&,")3$&7*- ; 3< =0 ..
> . = .# . .. > /
0
.
. # 7 !((((?-
. . /
"9 (4 !**+ . .
7 . !% (!
!**) /@A +9%(!**) .
. / "* (% !**) /
. > /
2 "* ('
!**) . !'
() !**+
. 5 . < #.@3
< #. @3 !*4( B A !49 ""
('
!*'". /
0
/ > . . !*4( 0 .
.
. 7 4 .
7 !9 (9 !*'" ;
. A.> 62 8 () !!
!*'" 7 "%*(4?- !)(((?- 7 9(((?- () !!
!*'"
3
%
. !*') .# ;. 2 / ) ( &#* 5 ! 9$++ 7" ( +/8)4%628 > . # .
7 $. #.@3. ; 7 !! .
. . !!%) !+ !"
!*44 !*9!
. #.@3. 2 / "* (9 !**+
= . . > / !%)9 > .
. #.@3 0 . . # . # 0 . < . # # .
5 !*9! . 6-8/ 686)82 " . <
2 () !!
!*'" . - (* (4 !*') 0 .
. 5 - .
< 0 . !*9! !**9 0 . @ .
0 < . !*'" .
0
< . . 0 .
2 "682 % !*9! - "68 C C - 6!8 . DE2
/F, . G 6"8 G 6%8 . .
G 6+8 .
. E 6 8 " 7# !**+ ,
!' 1 #. 6/ H 8 !*+'61 #. )(!*+'8 2
2 "%- G 6+8 . . G 6)8 5
..#<
G
. - 68 68 .
<- .
> G $$0 : %%* ($+ !,"*- .8! * % .""& ++!!", ! &5 /")%&.5!*""* .$+$! !$& "/ )!("&! !*"3! !" 6")&("&!- !")!*"#(("&#"("&! !*$% #!-.8! &)."
)"!*" !*, 5 8+5- ; ?@ 68 . . . . "9 $ !*)(G 68.<. "9 $ !*)( . . ,
- #. . G 68. .
G 68 . . . . GF 68
68 . - ., . "9 $ !*)(G 6,8 . G 698
!' 1 #. 6/ H 8 !*+'61 #. )(!*+'8 "%- I (/* %$% ,,", J< 2 &,% ! :*$#* !*$% #! //+$"%0 6!8 >
. 2 5
.
A 68 " 6"8 A .- 6!8 +- 68 . , .- 6-8 68 " . , 2 68 "
. . G
.
.
.
2 !( . ..G $$ :*")" &5+ &,* %6"%!",$& / &#* 5 !8&,")!*$%
#!- .8! %8#* + &, * % .""& "B#+8,", )( %* ($+ ! ,"* 8&,")%8.0#+ 8%"$$0 #+ 8%"7 %"#!$& - ++)$7*!%- !$!+" &, $&!")"%! !*" / &#* 5 ! $& %8#* + &,- )( !*" , !" ++!("&! %8#* + &, .5 !*" "* .$+$! !$&
"/ )!("&! !*" 3! !" 6")&("&!- %* ++ #" %" &, ++ %8#* )$7*!%- !$!+" &, $&!")"%! %* ++ 6"%! $& !*" /")%& ) /")%&%!:*(!*"+ &,%"B#+8,",* %.""& ++!!",.5 !*""* .$+$! !$& "/ )!("&! !*"3! !"6")&("&!& )."
)"!*" !*, 5 8+5- ; %8.C"#!!!*"#&,$!$& !* !0 &5 %8( (&"5 )" +$%", .5 !*" "* .$+$! !$&
"/ )!("&! !*" 3! !" 6")&("&! % )"%8+! ++!("&! %8#*+ &,?).:*")" & (&"5 : %
; )" +$% .+" .5 !*" "* .$+$! !$& "/ )!("&! !*" 3! !" 6")&("&! % )"%8+! ++!("&! %8#* + &,- !*" (8&! #(/"&% !$& $& )"%/"#! %8#* + &, % ,"!")($&", 8&,") %8.0%"#!$& <.5 !*" ++"#!) !*" ,$%!)$#!$&:*$#*%8#* + &,$%%$!8 !",-%* ++."/ $,.5!*" "* .$+$! !$& "/ )!("&! !*"3! !"6")&("&!!!*"
"6"+/("&! &, &#* 5 !% "/ )!("&! ) &: ), ,$%.8)%"("&!!!*"/ &#* 5 !!:*$#*%8#*%* ($+ !,"* ."+&7", 6%8 . #.
/567 8 !**9
/
.- 6.8 68.- 6"8 /
I (/* %$% ,,",
.
< # ;. 2 / ) ( &#* 5 ! 9$++ 7" ( +/8)68 > !*9! 682 "686)8 !**9 ..
2 > .. - ,
H
3 / / ) ( &#* 5 ! 6$++ 7"D8(0 D + & 9% 3! !" 8&C . &, !*")%-
<> $6$+ A=A- # 0 ) ( &#* 5 ! 6$++ 7"D8(0D + &68
.
!**)
- J68 !**) . 6.8 2 5
# ;.
2/
$ ; 68 . A '!**) 68 A '!**) 2 5 68 A '!**). 2 ' 1
!*)(6 !*)( 8 . I 0 - J%9 .
5 /
0 . . 5 000 / 0 67 07 !*49 2 / "")+8 . ;. 2/
!""#$ $ !
0 , . ;.
2/ > 2 # !*9! > . ;.
2/ - "9 2 5 .#
.
D
2 5
,
.# D D
@
. / 2 5 D . D + !*9! D.
D D, D D . # . .
!*'! D . .
. /
H 4 !% .
D D
"4 K/ 5 . D # # .
. # . . # . . 5 . 5 # # .
.
- "'
03*)$)$!*6$!!&$++%2!,6 ) #*
)87* 8&$#$/ +$!5 E @ 3 <;;- / 3 /
# 0 >, . 6 8 !*9% , .
. / C
/
. 6 8 68 ,#
, D . .
. %!
> . 5 # . .
# . # . , . . # . . 5 / I %4 0 - ;. 2/
# . # %'
L . . , . . . >
. L . .
. I
# !**) .
. # / ) ( &#* 5 !9% +.$)D 8) &,!*")%-
= $6$+= B . .
2 .
< . :2 ;
>.
, . 2 "686)86-8 A .
!'
() !**+ ,-) . /
0 1
. "* ('
!**) , -* . /
2 @
623 228
"#"(.") -
@ ? M?A @ .
M?A