← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/153/2001disposed of

Ramesh Chander Sikka v. Sunil Kumar Etc.

2015-02-18Mr. Justice Surinder Singh Grewal5 pages

                               







 !" "#$%$&' (  

 !" "#$%$&' (  

 !" "#$%$&' (  

 !" "#$%$&' (  

 )"%** &+",-$..

 //"00 &! 1-- -2&$032) , &+!*",%  4 "%/&+"&!%  '

'

'

' 5 6  -- - - 5 6  -- - - 5 6  -- - - 5 6  -- - -   ,"%"&!' ,  $&"%*,, 7+8# !"

,!*" //"00 &!

&" ,,"%/&+"&!%  &+ , - &+""/-2,$7+8# !" , ,"%/&+"&!%  &+  !$& 0&%2, &#")/ &96!+ , : +-$&;*7+8# !" ,,"%/&+"&! < === - - -7 - - -7 - - -7 - - -7 *" //"00 &! )"%** &+",-$..  ;;,$"8"+ ; $&%!!*" $& +">2 !"  #)/"&% !$&  ;, &!"+  ?9  !*"  0" ,&"+  !,  ##$+"&! 0 $)%,$?2& 07*! .5,$?2& 05 ,%*,!$& & ##$+"&!$&@*$#**"

%2

","+$&A2,$"%7* % $0"+!*"/,"%"&! //" 0 1 ,$2%/ %%"&;",%$&#02+$&;!*" //"00 &! )"%** &+", -$.. * +? ,+"+  2,@*""0",8"*$#0"@$!*,";$%!, !$& <B <B C&B C CC *"9@","!, 8"0$&; ,)#!,$%!7*! .! - )/0  ?"# 2%"  ?2%"%  @","  &!  /09$&;  +2"  !  *" 89  0+%  &+ 2&/,"#"+"&!"+, $&%  &?$,-$&;*,"%/&+"&! <@ %+,$8$&;!*"

 $00 !"+ 2,@*""0",8"*$#0" *"8"*$#0"," #*"+&" ,*20 & ,$& !*" ,"  *! .  !!* !!$)"7!*"

"&+$&;?2% <B( @&"+?9 9  &%, &%/,!/", !$8"-#$"!9,"%/&+"&!  &+ ?"$&; +,$8"& ?9  -2&$0  32) ,  ,"%/&+"&!    $&  , %* &+ &";0$;"&!) &&",# )" ,)?"*$&+ &+*$!!*" 2,@*""0", *" 2, @*""0",8",!2,&"+ &+ 00!*"##2/ &!%%2%! $&"+)20!$/0"$&A2,$"%

*2/-$&;*+$"+ !!*"%/! *"!*",$&A2,"+@","! ."&!-7 *! .  @*","  !*"9  @","  )"+$# 009  "D )$&"+  &+  !," !"+  -2+*$,

32) ,2/! 7 &!*",/ %%"&;",%2##2)?"+!*$%$&A2,$"%&!*"&"D! + 9 !*" ##$+"&!@*$0"-2?* %** &+",+$"+&  CC

*"0" ,&"+,$?2& 0*"0+!* !!*" ##$+"&!##2,,"++2"! !*", %* &+&";0$;"&!+,$8$&; ?2%@&"+?9 9  &%, &%/,!

/", !$8"  -#$"!9  ,"%/&+"&!     &+  +,$8"&  ?9  -2&$0  32) , ,"%/&+"&!  !@ %*"0+!* !?!*!*"+,$8",% !*"8"*$#0"% $&808"+$&!*" ##$+"&!@","*0+$&;8 0$++,$8$&;0$#"&#"% % ,"; ,+% #)/"&% !$&7 !*"   //"00 &! )"%** &+", -$.. * %?""& @ ,+"+#)/"&% !$& E 7F !@ %*"0+& !*"? %$% !*"+$% ?$0$!9,"/,!D   ;$8"&?9   ,+ !*,""

+#!,% -7*! .!* ! !9/",#"&!+$% ?$0$!9 !*" //"00 &!

@ %/,8$%$& 0  "%$+"%7?9! .$&;$&!#&%$+", !$&!*" ;" !*"

//"00 &!7*"@ % @ ,+"+EC7F %#)/"&% !$&  2,!*",%2)   E7F@ % @ ,+"+ %"D/"&%"%$&#2,,"+&!*"!," !)"&!7 ! .$&;+$"! &+/ $& &+ ;&9 % 0% !!"&+ &!#* ,;"% "@ % @ ,+"+E 7F$& 00 ,  $&"%*,, 7+8# !"70" ,&"+#2&%"0 //" ,$&; , !*" //"00 &!* %#&!"&+"+!* !$& #!!*"+$% ?$0$!9 !*" //"00 &!

 )"%** &+",-$.. $% !9/",#"&!/",) &"&!$&& !2,"7@*$#** % ?""&/,8"+8$+","/,!D C ?9 ,  - * +* GH  !$% %2?)$!!"+!* !)","09?"# 2%" ,  - * +* $% /,$8 !"+#!,$%

&," %&!&!,"09&*$%,"/,! %*"$% >2 0$ $"+,!*/ "+$#$ & *","

,"7!*","/,! ,  - * +* $%0$ ?0"!?" ##"/!"+ &+?9 ! .$&;*$%$&#)"!?"E

F/",)&!*7@*$#* &&2 009#)"%! (7F &++$%#2&!"+?9 !9/",#"&!7$%ECF/", &&2)   !*$%7 )20!$/0$", !*$,!""&$%!?" //0$"+.""/$&;$&8$"@!*" #!

!* !!*" ;" !*" //"00 &! !!*"!$)"  ##$+"&!@ %<H9" ,% *","

,"7!*" //"00 &!$%0$ ?0"!?" @ ,+"+E H7F7?"%$+"%7 *"$%0$ ?0"!?" @ ,+"+E 7F!@ ,+%/ $& &+%2

",$&; &+ 7F ,%/"#$ 0+$"!7 !!"&+ &! &+!, &%/,! !$& &,"%/&%"7, - &+""/-2,$7+8# !"70" ,&"+#2&%"0 , !*"   !$& 0  &%2, &#"  )/ &9  ,"%/&+"&!%    &+    * % %2?)$!!"+!* !),"!* &%2?%! &!$ 0#)/"&% !$&* %?""& @ ,+"+ !!*" //"00 &! !$%%2?)$!!"+!* !!*"0" ,&"+!,$ 02,!* %,$;*!09 ,"0$"+2/&!*","/,!D    !*"? ,+ +#!,% -7 *! .$&@*$#*$!* %?""&/$&"+!* !!*"+$% ?$0$!9$%/,8$%$& 0 &+ # &?"#2,"+?9%2,;$# 0/,#"+2," !$% 0%%2?)$!!"+!* !E7F * %?""& @ ,+"+!@ ,+%"D/"&%"%$&#2,,"+&!," !)"&!7! .$&; +$"!7/ $& &+ ;&9 *","

,"7&),"#)/"&% !$&$%0$ ?0"!?"

;, &!"+ ,  : +  -$&;*7  +8# !"7  0" ,&"+ #2&%"0  ,  ,"%/&+"&!

 <   &?$,  -$&;*  * %  %2?)$!!"+  !* !  !*"  20!  $&  ,"%/"#!    !*"

##$+"&!@ %!* ! !*"

"&+$&;?2%  "%$+"%7*"+"%&!+$%/2!"

!*"#)/"&% !$& @ ,+"+ * 8";$8"&)9!*2;*!

20#&%$+", !$&!!*"#&!"&!$&%  !*"0" ,&"+#2&%"0 ,!*"/ ,!$"%  !$%&!$&+$%/2!"!* !!*" ,"/,!  /,$8 !"+#!,$%&!!?"+$%# ,+"+,&!!?","0$"+2/& %*"$% /,$8 !"+#!, & #!*"$% /, "%%$& 0 &+!*","$%& ," %&  !  +$%# ,+  *$%  ,"/,!  )","09  ?"# 2%"  *"  $%  +$&;  /,$8 !" /, #!$#"  @"8",7$!) 9?"&!$#"+!* !!*"? ,+ +#!,%

< -7*! .* 8"/$&"+!* !!*"+$% ?$0$!9$%/,8$%$& 0$&& !2,"7 @*$#*# &?"#2,"+?9%2,;$# 0/,#"+2,"   ,  - * +* GH * %  )"&!$&"+  !*"  +$% ?$0$!9  $&  ,"%/"#!    !*"  //"00 &!  !  ?"

/",) &"&!$&& !2,"7*@"8",7$!$%&!%! !"+?9*$)@*"!*",$!# & ?"  $)/,8"+ ?9  %2,;$# 0  !," !)"&!   *"," ,"7  !*"  /$&$&    !*"

 ,+    +#!,%    -7  *! .  !* !  !*"  +$% ?$0$!9  $%  0$ ?0"  ! +"#," %" !",%2,;$# 0!," !)"&!$%$&+$# !$8" !*" #!!* !!*2;* !*"+$% ?$0$!9$% !9/",#"&!?2!!*"% )"$%&!/",) &"&!$&& !2," *"  //"00 &!  * %  &!  ?""&  ?0"  !  "%! ?0$%*  !* !  !*"  +$% ?$0$!9  $% /",) &"&!  $&  & !2,"7  @*$#*  # &&!  ?"  $)/,8"+  "8"&  ?9  %2,;$# 0 /,#"+2,",%2,;$# 0!," !)"&!  !$% ,!*"% $+," %&7$!$%!?"

! ."&!* !!*"+$% ?$0$!9$%&!/",) &"&!?2!/,8$%$& 0$&& !2," %$! # &+"#," %"?9%2,;$# 0/,#"+2,"7@*$#*$%&!%%! !"+?9 ,  - * +* GH *","

,"7$!$%! ."&!* !!*"+$% ?$0$!9$&,"%/"#! !*" //"00 &!$%/,8$%$& 0 %,"; ,+%!*"#)/"&% !$&/ 9 ?0"7$!$%!?"&!$#"+!* ! !*"  //"00 &! )"%** &+",-$.. @ %<H9" ,%  ;" &+*$% )&!*09$&#)"@ % %%"%%"+!?"E

F *","

,"7$ !*"+$% ?$0$!9 $%  !  ?"  ! ."&  %  /",) &"&!  $&  & !2,"7  *"  @20+  ?"  "&!$!0"+  ! #)/"&% !$&    E H7F  ?2!  %$&#"  $!  * %  ?""&  *"0+  !  ?" /,8$%$& 07!*" )2&! #)/"&% !$& EC7F7@*$#** %?""& @ ,+"+?9!*"0" ,&"+,$?2& 0$%A2%! &+%2

$#$"&!

%  ,"; ,+%  #)/"&% !$&  ,  %/"#$ 0  +$"!7  !!"&+ &!  &+ !, &%/,! !$&7!*" //"00 &!#0 $)%),"#)/"&% !$& E 7F7 @*"," %7E7F* % 0," +9?""&;, &!"+ *$%$&#02+"%/ $& &+ ;&9 %@"00 *","

,"7$&!*" #!% &+#$,#2)%! &#"%7$!@20+?"

A2%! &+"D/"+$"&!!* ! %2) E7F),"$% @ ,+"+!!*"

//"00 &!!@ ,+%%/"#$ 0+$"!7 !!"&+ &! &+!, &%/,! !$& % 0% / $& &+ ;&9@*$#*$&!*" #!% &+#$,#2)%! &#"%@20+?"A2%! &+

/,/", ##,+$&;097!*" //" 0$%+$%/%"+ @$!*!*")+$ $# !$& !*",+", !*"0" ,&"+,$?2& 0!* !!*" //"00 &! )"%** &+", -$.. %* 00?"/ $+ %2) E7F %),"#)/"&% !$& - - - - - - - - - - - -                 

(  

(  

(  

(  

      * ,+@ A !"'?","

",,"+!,"/,!",'"%