High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/2104/1995disposed of

Jagtar Singh v. Rajbir Singh And ORS

2023-12-01Mr. Justice Aman Chaudhary7 pages

!"#$"

%"" ""&"

'()*+,-*./0/+122 3(4)(56/147 222288*99(1) :*50;0 <(=>/56/147(1-+)7*50 222<*08+1-*1)0

"?@ A#B?

D"?""

% 5*0*1)

02:/>7(E(4(5F-G+.()*,+5

525/)(H6/1476(/1/F-G+.()*,+5)7*(88*99(1)2

52'**8(I6;5/F-G+.()*,+55*08+1-*1)E+2J10;5(1.* +H8(1K2 LLLLL "?""

%M!C 2 J1=;5*-(88*99(1) 7(0 ,/9*- )7* 85*0*1) (88*(9 0**I/14 *17(1.*H*1) +, )7* .+H8*10()/+1 (H+;1) (N(5-*- >K )7* 9*(51*-

+)+5 ../-*1) 9(/H0 O5/>;1(9F H>(9(

,+5 07+5) P)7* O5/>;1(9Q G/-* (N(5- -()*- 2 2 F +1 (..+;1)+,)7*/1=;5/*05*.*/G*->K7/H/1(H+)+5G*7/.;9(5(../-*1)2 2 R*(51*- .+;10*9 .+1)*1-0 )7() )7* /1=;5*-(88*99(1) 7(- H*) N/)7 (1 (../-*1) +1 2 2 F N7*5*/1 7* 7(- 0;,,*5*- H;9)/89* /1=;5/*0 /1.9;-/14 ,5(.);5* +, 7/0 9*,) 9*4 (1- (5HF +1 (..+;1) +, N7/.7F 7* N(0 ;1(>9* )+ 8*5,+5H N+5I2 * 5*H(/1*- (-H/))*- /1 )7* 7+08/)(9 ,+5 (>+;) -(K02 ) )7* )/H* +, )7* 0(/- (../-*1)F 7* N(0 K*(50 +9- (1- *(51/14 <02F S 8*5 H+1)7 >K -+/14 (45/.;9);5* N+5I2 O7* (88*99(1) 7(- 0;,,*5*- T 8*5H(1*1) -/0(>/9/)K N7/.7 7(0 >**1 (00*00*- )+ >* UT +1 (..+;1) +, 07+5)*1/14 +, 9*4 (1- 7* /0 0)/99 )(I/14 )5*()H*1) ,+5 /)2 /0 H(55/(4* 85+08*.)0 7(G* (90+ 4+) (-G*50*9K (,,*.)*-2 O7*

! " !#$#%& '()*)

+ ,$ ' ' #$

) +# %# -# $ .#' + +#!-/

#--# - $ --

$ ! + /

$$" $ 1 # +#!- $#

/ $# -- $)

+ , # + ! $' ' -

# -#+ " %$ $# 1+$ !$$ ) $

# --# $ $# !2 % + $# 1"! $ 3 45678933 :;<33 =>5?@633 A>65833 A>;B78>C@33 DE<3 F?6<G3

H )

#I H- ! #$ # 0 $)J #$

!- $! " $ J1 +#!- $#K

# + ! $ $

# "# $# -+ 0+$! -# $#

) %# #++ + #% ++ $' L # !#$ #% !# / # #$ !$ +#!- $# + $!) -

%% " $ 0+$! "# %$

# ++ $)

# -+ #

#% #0 # ) !# $/ +#!- $# ! 2# $# )

#+ $/

#! ! #% $$$# $# #

00 ) 0+$!

0 $# %+ 0 'K $ )

# " -- +#!- $#

+ / $2" $# +# $#$ %## " J (' 0 + # +# +$ $ -- $

%% -- " $# ++ $' - " %#! #% -/ #% # #/' M$ $+$ 0 // #$ !# -$+/ - / + +$0$/ $#

-0$# #%

!- - ! $ #% % )

N #

#% " +-+$/)

#" $ !

+#/ +#!-+$# ," +#$# + ) ! + $ $! $

# -$O$#)

0 % " #%

) -

#) " )

) P $/) $+' M

#$) -- " !- - / +) ! $ - /+ ##"+

0 $$" !-+$ # #+%+ "#%$ 0+$!'

Q' M + #

) -- $

! "# $! !

%& ! '

(

( % '' %& !

(( ) ( % '

!" * * +

(

# % , % !

% & "( , # !) !

((

!" ,, * - & ./ 01 11 11 3452678897:;2<8=>?;@A>2 # B! B% ! !

(( * & )

! (!&,

%&) ! "

( (,

# B! B%

C# )D ! !

# B! ! (! ! "

'C#)D# #EF - &G"

( )! % H. ! (

( (,) * ' !

- ) +( " ! &

((

! ! !

I , "( (

& ! !

,%% H

' - &"

''/# $ !%&

C J ) *

( (,./ # E E% !" # -

F K) ! ! H #

! - '' %& !") ! ( (,

' !

(( L "

, %& , # !) !&

1"& % +# E

& , )

! '

( ) ! * %

% - & ! "

'# B!'

) !

) ! !

" %

I # E ! '

,," ,

! , ) * ' !

C +! !

(( '

( (,

- &" ''#/ 11 11 11 # E *

) *

C# ))D *

( (,# 3MN52O=>>2=P2QR;S9A9;>2 # B! B% ! !

C# )D !

"# B! ! (! !

C# )D

%& ! B% # B! , " '! (( *

"C# )D# 11 11 11 # B! ! ,

(( T U

( )

% HK# B! (,( , & '

* %& ! ,

!, , "( , ") ( , ! ,"

(

! "

% !

# !

$%# ' ( ) & $& * ! !

!* &! ' +, *! -!* *' . /! /0 !'"

234'5'67 3'/8'9'

)! 0$ &! :' / * % *

;0 !

# 0

! " * &* # )0

=" # %$

! " # # 0

%#$ % &=!

!& % 0!' >0 &&

! &# *

*! ? * ! !' <<<< @' 55A

$ ! 0 ) ! &

# %

$ & 0#

&# *

0 &0!) )"

000& !$ * 0 !"

0 &5''7 << << << ' B?%=0# >0&&

0$ "

)

,0? *!0! :/ $$

&# 0!

8' & ' * "

( 0&

!! % 0# 0!

! &

# C A

! #0

0 && $

#& &

* & !0

?0 % 0!' $ 8'9'

)!C

0$ "

&0! * %

& %

&="

" A &0!

! $&0 0

& %

&% $&%" ! "

0" '"

& %

&% # *

' ("

0& #$ & %

) &&

#$& &

& %

*<!

*!0

'7 ' / *

!" ! # 0

$$&& %

! " ! &

! )

?0 0 ! % #! < !& %'7 ' (

#$ !! % 0 0! ! !0! ' )!0

!& %8'@"@@"3D ' )

3# 8'4D '

! &<$ 8'"

!"" #"$%$&

! ! '

(" #"$$& % )( *! '

(" #" $& + )*""*, *!-.

#" $& / ! !",,!( #"$$&

( *" " #"$$& )*""*, !" #" $& 0*

#"$+/$&1 % *!23 0' 4 * !5 6789:55 ;<=>>?55 @A:55 B:C:55 ;DEFG5 4 !)! 4 +$ H'! ' !! "

3 . '

" * '

+ . * !$

" '" ('

3 '

3! '!(!( '" *3 . *-!( ,!

3 . "- .

!( '" !!(

! '

-!( * " *"'

#"/$+$&

!( #"$$& ,*

! ",,!($ #" & "

$ #"$$&

*"" *,

!" *,

, 3. *3"-!( '

" *"*! *,

H '

"" *, !! "

" 3.

!$ '

! " ! * !* I" ,

*"" *, !

*$ 3

"* , *" " J '

" 3! 3. '" * ! !" !

" '

KI"

* !"

*!1 " 3 ! ! "

" *

! ! ' "

*"*!

" ' " 3,* '

! **L

J!5 M<NA8O<P<55 Q7R9<55 S:T:55 @A:55 U?V>PW<X55 YPAZ?<P[>55 F7:55 MW9:5 4 !)! 4 +/%$

" *, + \ "

3 . *!

*! *, ' !I" "" !$ '

* !"

*! " !'

*!"!( ( *" " '

-!( 3 * L

! ' 3!(

*"" *, , !

" ' !I$

( $ " H*L!(

L!( ] -

! !!(

*! *, #"/& *!'$ H' "

" "** "3" ! 3. * !( '" "

" ]%$ *3"-!( '

' (' * '

! ! * !

*!"!( ' !

" #"& +

*-!(

L * ' "!

"$ ' " !* " H' ( *

! " #$ %$&' "(" $) $)) * (+

" ##++

))" ,+#+ -" " + *

"$ $

. & /

", $) ' ,

" $) 0 * #+'

++ + +! ) #$ "("'

"" $) $)) * (+' $ -$

("+ " $ "

' #" $ , $

++ * $ " ,

"" ! )"" 1, $ & 2 ##++ ", $ #+3 )$" $ !

& / #" $) "'

#)++! "$" 45 6"&76 8", #$ 9*" 8 * #$ "

"$* $ $ #+ & & 1, $ )$

))" * )"$, $# $ , "

-"! $) +) +* 0+

" 1#$ -$

" $# "

( +" , ""

, $ +* )$$ "

"$ *" $) +, *$ * $ * *" &

", '

"*+ +( 1"

+ )1$

$ ! , # ", , #$ && &

" $#"$

" $ +, $+

(& &&

9*" 8 * #$ "

* , &:& "* :&:& " * #"$'

" )$" )$ ;&

")"' #$ " 0# $, * $ , )$" )$++$ # ", & ;

9*" 8 * #$ "

( * ,+#$ $ $) +) 0+ -$

"$!

+,# #", +!

<&= 2 +! * 0 $( $ $) -"

))"'

" +

$" * $) +*'

$+ ( ))

$ +! "

* #!' "$ #")$", * $ $+ $" ( , * ,",$ +#"$ # &

!"#$%& '( ($!) $* !%!"+)$!) # '( $('%)$* *!"+ '( #$ , ) '"% (*) $ ('% *) '( -")! . $*/"$#& +, $+'" '( !'+)$' $%** $##$ *)% ) .$*) $!* ") 0'))'($% *"'*)$.#&11 2)3 $$*)"((% 2) ,4 0'))'($% ('%3+' ) 13 2) ,4 ""%+*!$#1)) 2) ,4

*$,%$)'%$',)!$#*!! $% )2) ,

$%%$ %')!) 2),,4

0'))'($+)'(#( 2) ,4 !!'%* #&, $!* $+'" '( !'+)$' '( 2),,4 '

% $* $.'

$+'" '( 2)3,4 $#%$*& $%** .& 5%."$#, $#'

%) 6 7 % $"+ ) $## . $* !#$+$$##$

%'* '(

+' ) (%'+ *$ '( %! '( !%(* !'& '( ) -"* +, ($#

! , $+'" ) $## $!!%" $ %) $ %$ $) $#%$*& $%**.& 5%."$#

'*(& $%* $('%)$* 1, %) $$# ) *)')*'( 9:;:<8=>:?@>:ABC8 D?@EF8 GHIHJIJGJK8

) 4L"% M %)$L 4%$)'* N)4O' M %%'%$.# N)4O'