Banarsi Dass v. Virender And ORS
!"# $ #% &!'()*+)*,
!"-#&!& !.
&!)*/)*, 000 ))
11 2 0 2 0 ))) 0 0 ' 31 ) 0 1
! "
#$% & ' ((((
14) ! )
*' + ,!!"!--. *' &
)*
/
0)*
12+*'
*'
$
!33 +!4, !-.. 5 ,6,4!--# + )
)*
*'
" )
,6,4!--#+ +
+
$"$
7
* 89$ 6::3/ 0 2
+ + %+ + * *' !
) * /++*'
2+
' '
* ;%9+ *' )
* + * *
+ *'
' *< '
! "6- ##6%&)
!+ # 9 ! "+ ' *5
'
5
+
! ) + 9 #
!+
4 ;
+ +
$
!""#
$%$
&
'()** & + $ ,$
$#$
$$()** '
$ ()* -
$
( "
: ) )*
*' % !
$
+
3 % ,6,4!--#
+
' & 8
&
8
9 + + *' ,.,4!--#=*
9>9 !# ,-,4!--#+ 6
,.,4!--#
*'
$
* + + +
7 +
*+
+) & ? +
%
+
+ '+
8
+
8+
*
=*
9+ ;%9+
$4$ . )
!4,3!--#/& "#->!!--:2++ '*'@$ # * &
& 9 ?
% &
+
+
! - )
+*A
' * * !,
+*A
@$!
A
* & @$4
+ ' 8+ )*
* @$4
+ $A
) & +
1 + ,.,4!--#/* +
9+ 2 + * ' !! ) )*
'@$!+ +
' $ * *' ' )
)*
*' 9 !
9@$ " + 9@$! ? 9@$! 9@$"
' 9@$! * ' 9@$"/ !2
'
$:$ !" = *
)*
% !
+
! !# B
)*
5 +
'
8
7 !-,4!--#% '
+
9 +
* A ' &< '
"6- ##6 %&*& !4,3!--#
!4 % *
9
!: % 5
+*A @$! '
+ !8
* * + /
$! ,.,4!--#2* +
9 !# ,-,4!--#+
9+
$
' +
' ' +
$3$ + )
9
+
+
* ' + !3 )
' * + + * 89$6::3 * * 1
!6 % )*
5 '@$!9 ! " ' %
'
* $ ;%9 & *'
! "6->##6%&%
* '
! *
!. ) )*
'* ,.,4!--#
*'
* * +
9 !# ,-,4!--#+ !- ' +
+ )
5 + + *' * 89$
$6$ 6::3
*' + = ' @$!/5
2
+ !
*'
'@$4A = *
*' ! "+ 9@$! 9@$" ' ", )9@$! 9@$"+' ' * '+ +' '@$!) * $
' '
* ' !+ ' "! %
C * D ) 81* & 5"6&!57 !$ #5!. & -5!81"
)%)95 !
$:5#6 #$)","!/429&9/& 24-4 + + * *' ' ' 5
E * 5 +
%
+
+ +)*
*'
&
* *
$
< *' * "" % * < * %
+ 5 $
+
$.$
+ ,.,4!--#% 5 $
' **' + ' ) ,.,4!--# * +
+ ** ' *
' + 5 $
) + * * ,.,4!--# * ! " ' "# % ,6,4!--# 5 $
!-,4!--#
5 *'
5 '
+
A *< ' !4,3!--# 5 $
! ;%9 *
,.,4!--#
9 !# ,-,4!--#)
7 * ' '
5 $
%
!+
) '
9 ,.,4!--# ' *'5 $
$-$ )+
*
' !*'
+
'+ ! +
; ! "
+ '* '
*+
*
' 5 $
' ) & + A
8+
9 !# ,-,4!--# + '@$!/
2 !
+ 89$6::3 "4 ) )*
'@$ ! ' $A
) & = ' @$! * +' $A
* + ? 5 '$+@$!
+
' +
+
": %+ * '
)*
5 $
! ,6,4!--# ) @$! +
!@ * "3 ' )*
% !
$!,$ % !
% ,6,4!--# 89$6::3*' ! "6 %+ ! * 5 $
< + 5 '
5 $
". ' * 5 $
% *
' + 5 $
$
+
'
'* +
+ '
+
' ' ₹!,#:>$ <
+ '
+' !--#
+ *4:'
8++ @$!"!,#!--:
:,' % 5 + *+4::,' "-
'
5 $
:,F
'
@$: G ?
5 ' 5 $
' A :,F; A":F
!#+
5 + *
!" '
$!!$
+
++
4 ' 9 4,,,>$ #, % + 5 $
+
5
'< + *' ' :,F #! ' +
% 9!,#:>$ /
+ '
+2 9!,#:>$
' :,F!,#: 9:!6>$ ; ":F /:!6H!"-2 9343>$
!# !# B I '
'
9343A!#A!" 9!,,663>$ 9":,,,>$ B 94,,,>$
9!,,,,>$ B
9#,,,,>$ )
+ 9!3-663>$ #" Claimant-appellant shall also be entitled to interest @ 7.5% on the enhanced compensation from the date of filing of claim petition till realization. Liability of respondents to pay compensation shall be as per the award.
$!"$ Respondent Nos. 1 and 2 alone would be liable to pay compensation jointly and severally as respondent No. 1 was not having any driving license. ## Appeal is accordingly allowed in above terms. #4
/2 '
/2 ' "6,4","3 1
5 @ > J @ J>