Transport Commissioner Rajasthan State v. Shanti Devi Etc.






      
   



 !"#  $%!&%  ''!%  ()!

*  +   (  $%!&%  %&% , -..%()!

*

&&//

0%!1!

+'

+*  2 *%! (!&    



 

3%! "4 %/51'%-*/6 ,2 

%  %1)5*,2 

% %!!47) %!%!& # 
 

  $*!%%!*//!&! *'&&/


!6//! %!!47) !  /7*/

%!& #

  

  !"

$*!!&&/ /78 ** -%/.%()!

* (68!.!

6% 9

&!!78 * % 

/'!$%71/,(* :*%

%% %% !#$%&'()*+,;

% 5!***%

%% %% ! #$%-%.%+/%-;

' % 2* /  :&/    < =7% , ! * !% ,   *% 6*/%>(# 4 9?

7.%278+ 2%+.*@3&&1!

%

2//.//  # '6 *&!!.%!/7%+.*,+*23%:!*, (7%,+1/,(.*1 *,*!*'+1/  71  #?'() +.*,  8/,('*),()%,.% /7%/!7%

*! *%6*/% %'2//.5*%+* $* '&6!7.

%278+ 2%+.*,%2% */

! *%6*

% * 4<://!* >1'% 6%!2//.5*%6%, 71! ()!

*(68!(+($ 7%.(<434

<#7.%2 %!*/8./. /878('+%1&,%!& ?*%, '

/*! %'&&! % $*71!!* '&

71

'$*!*44 //1! 1%%1 %!*./.

%2. *71!78 !%2%,%!1/ . )1%!  1& !

'&+ 2%,+1/ ,()+.*,  8/5!**! %!1/ *   *% 1& ! '&/!!1

%)1%! $*%!& #*% /!&%  /'&  #

 ,6* *6!//678 *$%71/ # $*/%$%71/,

%&&%  . *2 % % 6% '&!  
#, ,

4 ! ? A% 1!/ % *!!!/ *6% .%1  !5!** *%&!!.%!6% %2//.

 '&>(# 4 9?

6* ;!1!(<434

<# ' %' /*!&&! % *44 //1! :

&/  *'%,!!1 *,  /% *  :&/ 1 %!*./. %2. 7 * *2* /! '&! 6! 7 &&% !?

"?

= !/!   . *$%71/ !!1! !1!

7/,! *$%71/  !% '8

< (B('+.*,%2% ;!71!  * *%*,/% 1!/ %%!& # %.1! .! *$%71/!!1%6//%! !'  // %8 % % 

=*2*%/% 1!/ %7 * *!!,&% &%1!. *% % 9 $*$%71/,6*/ .!!1.!

*%,%/1& *!

' 3B /7%+.*,6*6!84 6 !!/!. /. *
=(CD3 +/7%+.*6!

'.!

*  /' !,  !  !1 *,  *  6!    &  6 !!   > !1&&% *2%! ! *71!E1!

6!7.

%2 %!*/8   ./. /8, 6*%!  *  '& 6! 7. %2  

'% !&6!&% /8
7%'/

!>!

*71!!* '&,%!1/ .  * * !&%!!

)1%! * *%&!!.%!%2%,)1%+*23%:!*3B , .% 3B<  ()%+.* 3B#*2  /!'  *  !'/% ' ! *71!6!7.%2%!*/8./. /8!*  *71!$*   1%%1 1/ 71!%2%('+%1&, %!& $*$%71//! : (B('

+%1&%2% *

.71!

'

 %'/ !%.%.   E1!

6!&..!

*'$*$%71/ ' */

!/ %8!

' (B('+%1&! !1

  %71 . 2 2/7/% %.!

*' $*$%71/ 1% *% 7!%2 (B('+%1&2 !

'&6!7.

%2  %!*/8    ./. /8  $*  $%71/  *!  /!  !% 

# %.1' ! %! 78 /%  1!/  %  * &&//  %.%.  ..8 '%.2%/. '&,*62%, 8 % 7* *!'  =26 *72, .!% %78 *$%71/ !!1,!  // %8 % % 78 *! 1%  0  

1"

= *! !, %!!47) !*27 /78 ! *  * '&!   A% 1!/ % %!!47) %!%!& !!17' !

'

/8 * !,6*6!#8%! .,6!'&/8  %/  + /  B/ %  %,  6  /*    6!  %6.  !/%8 

?

4&%' * = !!17'

 %! 1 1% &%!& !*! 7

%26 *)1.' *+1&%'

1%  +#'

*+,
*/)&+*.% 34+*5'3'#%-6/&+*+5 %#$'+*-

#$%&/"

789  7':',9 2 = ! 1% *%!17'

'1/ &/% <6!%E1% 7&&/!

!2&&/78 $%71/= !/!   *$%71/*! 6%8 %!

 *'1  '&!  $*%!!&1 %.%. *. * !5!* *#8%! '   $*%! 1% *%!&1

%.%. ' * !
?

<<4&%' *!!!!!78 /%  $%71/  >62%,   %!     '     1   1% &%!& ! *% # F!%E1% 7% :,:&.26 )1.' *+1&%'1% +#'

*+,
*/)&+*.% 34+*5'3'#%- 7/)4&+9 $*% %, '&! &87/ * %!!47) %!% %4

?

6%: 71/ !1%"4
  

  

' * ! 5!** 

 





. * ! #8%!

2

 */8 ' * !
?

<<4 2

# F    2  !    7    6%!

1%&%!& 
?

<<G

<
9

4&%' 2

# * 2 721 6%!

&%!/D&!!


9

4

H


4&%' 2 '&!  / 1/ 

%&&/8.

*'1/ &/% < 

 < H
,<, 4 2
1%/D&!!

?

D

'&!  %/!!  !% 1'

#

D

'&!  %/!! !

?


 2 "; < !!E1/ '8! 1!!72, *'&&/


 !!'!!>62%, * %!!47) !*2'% 

*!'%&% /8 & $*6% *$%71/!' 

/ '&! &87/ !!*//7
,

, 4 '1 D !!2%6* 6!6%6///!

%  %!

@ ?F

%' * *&   // * &8' $* /' !6// !*% *'1  '&! !&% *6% *$%71/ 7
 

8""

   B* *%!&:.%! I!

B* *%%&% 7/