(O&M) National Ins. Co. Ltd. v. Anita



 

      

       

 

 





      

 
 

  

  !"



   

  

 







  

 

  !



 

  

"

 





# $ % ##$%%&'(
')*+&',$,-.#&'/0&)12%$3(02)&##$&%,0&%%$'42'4 (0$&5&+33&($36  #&))$37/(0$-(-+,,23$'( %&2.)+27*'&% &%&'30&+50$+$7/(0$,%&2.#$(2(2-'12%$37/(0$523-5&'3(0$.2'-+,02%3 -1  3$,$&)$3
&+2'3$+  !*.&+  5&)  &%%-5$3  &'3  &  ,-.#$')&(2-'  -1
89
&%-'452(02'($+$)(:;#$+&''*.5&)&5&+3$3(-(0$.

+2$1%/(0$1&,()-1(0$,&)$&+$(0&(-'< 8&(&7-*(9 = # .

  &+2'3$+  !*.&+  &'3  02)  1+2$'3  &43$>  2'40  5$+$  4-2'4  1+-. 0-4#*+(->2%%&4$&11&-'& $)#&,--($+7$&+2'4- 
?

6

@0$'(0$/+$&,0$3(0$   -&3 0&%%-'4&(+*,A7$&+2'4- 

66?6 ,-.2'41+-.(0$-##-)2($)23$7$2'43+2>$'7/&+5&'!*.&+2'&+&)0&'3 '$4%24$'(.&''$+02((0$),--($+ -(0&+2'3$+!*.&+&'3&43$>2'40 +$,$2>$3  )$+2-*)  2'B*+2$)  0-5$>$+  &+2'3$+  !*.&+  )*,,*.7$3  (-  (0$



2'B*+2$)&((0$)#-(50$+$&)&43$>2'405&)(&A$'(-0-)#2(&%7*(0$&%)- 32$3 0$&,,23$'(5&)52('$))$37/&+3$>2'40+$.*((&'3&432)0 2'40 0$ ,%&2.&'()
+$)#-'3$'() 12%$3  &,%&2.#$(2(2-' ,%&2.2'4  )  %&A0)&),-.#$')&(2-'

0$,%&2.#$(2(2-'5&),-'($)($37/+$)#-'3$'()- &'3 (0$ 3+2>$+&'3-5'$+-1(0$(+*,A+$)#$,(2>$%/7/12%2'4&B-2'(5+2(($' )(&($.$'(&'33$'2$3(0$&,,23$'( 0$/1*+(0$+3$'2$3(0$2+%2&72%2(/(-#&/ ,-.#$')&(2-'&'3#+&/$31-+32).2))&%-1,%&2.#$(2(2-'

0$  +$)#-'3$'(  - =
2')*+&',$  ,-.#&'/  2'  (0$  5+2(($'

)(&($.$'(  #%$&3$3  (0&(  +$)#-'3$'(  - 
3+2>$+  5&)  '-(  0&>2'4  &  >&%23 3+2>2'4%2,$',$&((0$(2.$-1&%%$4$3&,,23$'(&'3&%)-(--A&)(&'3(0&('- )*,0&,,23$'((--A#%&,$ 0$-7B$,(2-'+$4&+32'4'-'B-2'3$+-1'$,$))&+/ #&+(2$)5&)+&2)$3&'3#+&/$3(0&((0$#$(2(2-'7$32).2))$3 

#-',-.#%$(2-'-1#%$&32'4)&'31+&.2'4-12))*$)(0$#&+(2$) &33*,$3(0$2++$)#$,(2>$$>23$',$ 1($+$C&.2'2'4(0$$>23$',$&>&2%&7%$ -'+$,-+3(0$+27*'&%&%%-5$3(0$,%&2.#$(2(2-'&'3&5&+3$3&(-(&% ,-.#$')&(2-'-1 
89
&%-'452(02'($+$)(:;#$+&''*.(-7$ #&237/+$)#-'3$'()- (-=B-2'(%/&'3)$>$+&%%/1+-.(0$3&($-1#$(2(2-' (2%%(0$#&/.$'(2).&3$(-(0$,%&2.&'()

$',$(0$#+$)$'(&##$&%7/(0$&##$%%&'(
')*+&',$ -.#&'/

#-'+$,$2>2'4'-(2,$-1(02)&##$&%(0$,%&2.&'()+$)#-'3$'()- &'3 12%$3(0$2+,+-))
-7B$,(2-')1-+$'0&',$.$'(-1,-.#$')&(2-'

$&+'$3,-*')$%1-+(0$&##$%%&'(0&)&+4*$3(0&((0$3+2>2'4 %2,$',$2'(0$'&.$-1(0$3+2>$+&+5&'!*.&+5&)'-(4$'*2'$&'32'(02)

=

+$4&+3)#$,212,-7B$,(2-'5&)+&2)$32'(0$5+2(($')(&($.$'(502,05&) #+->$37/$C&.2'2'4 @
&+22'40 %$+A1+-.(0$-112,$-1  -%&'

*(3$)#2($(0&(,-'>2',2'4$>23$',$(0$%2&72%2(/5&)1&)($'$3*#-' (0$2')*+&',$,-.#&'/  $)*7.2()(0&((0$12'32'4)-'(02)2))*$&+$ &4&2')((0$$>23$',$-'+$,-+3(0$+$1-+$(0$)&.$3$)$+>$)(-7$)$(&)23$

$&+'$3,-*')$%0&)1*+(0$+&+4*$3(0&()2.2%&+%/(0$+27*'&%0&)5+-'4%/ &))$))$3(0$.-'(0%/2',-.$-1(0$3$,$&)$3&)

(-+$&,0(0$&''*&% 3$#$'3$',/-1
9
0$+$1-+$(0$&.-*'(-1,-.#$')&(2-'&5&+3$3 (-(0$,%&2.&'()2)-'0240$+)23$ $#+&/)(0&((0$2.#*4'$3&5&+37$)$( &)23$

'  (0$  -(0$+  0&'3  %$&+'$3  ,-*')$%  1-+  (0$  ,%&2.&'()
+$)#-'3$'()0&))*7.2(($3(0&((0$2.#*4'$3&5&+32)7&)$3*#-',-++$,( &##+$,2&(2-'-1$>23$',$-'+$,-+3&'3(0$,-.#$')&(2-'&5&+3$32)-' %-5$+)23$ $)*7.2()(0&(7/5&/-1,+-))
-7B$,(2-')(0$,%&2.&'()0&>$ #+&/$31-+$'0&',$.$'(-1,-.#$')&(2-'

  $&+'$3,-*')$%0&)1*+(0$+ #-2'($3-*((0&(1+-.(0$&,,23$'((5-,%&2.#$(2(2-')0&3&+2)$'&'3(0$ ,-''$,($3    - ?69
  (2(%$3 
  

         

&%)-,&.$*#1-+0$&+2'47$1-+$(02) -*+(-'= ?

 50$'2(5&))$'(7&,A7$1-+$(0$+27*'&%1-+1+$)0&3B*32,&(2-'-'(0$2))*$ -11&A$3+2>2'4%2,$',$ *+2'4(0$,-*+)$-10$&+2'4%$&+'$3,-*')$%1-+(0$,%&2.&'() 0&)  #+-3*,$3  (0$  -+3$+  3&($3  =  9  (-  ,-'($'3  (0&(  (0$  12'32'4) #+$>2-*)%/+$(*+'$32'(0$2.#*4'$3&5&+33&($36  +$%&(2'4 (- 3+2>2'4%2,$',$5$+$'-(&%($+$3&'3,-.#%2&',$+$#-+(5&))$'((-(02)

<

-*+(

$&+'$3,-*')$%1-+(0$,%&2.&'()0&)1*+(0$+&+4*$3(0&((0$ 2',-.$  -1  (0$  3$,$&)$3  5&) 
8
 #$+  .-'(0  7*(  (0$ +27*'&%  0&) $++-'$-*)%/(&A$'2(&)

&'3-'(02))-%$4+-*'3(0$,-.#$')&(2-' 3$)$+>$)(-7$$'0&',$3

1($+0$&+2'4%$&+'$3,-*')$%1-+(0$#&+(2$)&'3,-')23$+2'4 (0$&7->$7&,A4+-*'3(02) -*+(12'3)(0&((0$12'32'4+$%&(2'4(-(0$ 3+2>2'4  %2,$',$  -1  3$,$&)$3  &+5&'  !*.&+  5&)  3$%2>$+$3  &4&2')(  (0$ 2')*+&',$,-.#&'/2'(0$2.#*4'$3&5&+3&'3#*+)*&'((-(0$-+3$+3&($3 = ?

  2'  (0$  ,-''$,($3    - ?69  -1    (02)  2))*$  5&)  +$
$C&.2'$37/(0$+27*'&%&'32(.&2'(&2'$3(0$%2&72%2(/-1&##$%%&'(>23$ 3$,2)2-'3&($3=  9 *+(0$+&#$+*)&%-1(0$-+3$+3&($3= ?

 )0-5)(0&(502%$)$'32'4(0$,&)$7&,A(-(0$+27*'&%(0$ - ?69-1   5&)  12'&%%/  32)#-)$3  -1  7*(  &1($+  (0$  3$,2)2-'  7/  +27*'&%  -' =  9'-&##$&%7/(0$2')*+&',$,-.#&'/5&)12%$3.*,0%$))(- ,0&%%$'4$(0$12'32'4+$%&(2'4(-3+2>2'4%2,$')$ 0*)2(2)&##&+$'((0&((0$ 2')*+&',$  ,-.#&'/  0&)  &,,$#($3  (0$2+  %2&72%2(/  2'  (0$  ,-''$,($3  ,&)$

-')$D*$'(%/(02) -*+(3-$)'-(12'3&'/.$+2(2'(0$&+4*.$'(-1%$&+'$3 ,-*')$%1-+(0$&##$%%&'(+$%&(2'4(-(0$&,,23$'(-+(0$3+2>2'4%2,$',$-1(0$ 3+2>$+-1-11$'32'4>$02,%$ @02%$&'&%/E2'4(0$D*&'(*.2(2)$>23$'((0&((0$,%&2.&'() +$%2$3*#-'(0$-+&%3$#-)2(2-'-1>2,(2.F)521$'&.$%/'2(&G@H50- )(&($3(0&(0$+0*)7&'35&)$&+'2'4
8
#$+.-'(07$2'4&'$.#%-/$$&( &#$(+-%#*.# -5$>$+'-$>23$',$+$4&+32'4$.#%-/.$'(-13$,$&)$3

8

.*,0%$))7/$C&.2'2'4(0$$.#%-/$+-+7/&33*,2'4&'/-(0$+$>23$',$ 5&)7+-*40((-#+->$02)2',-.$&)
8
0$+$1-+$(0$+27*'&%0&) +240(%/&))$))$302)2',-.$&)

#$+.-'(0 -')23$+2'4(0$'*.7$+ -13$#$'3$'()&'3(0$&4$-1(0$>2,(2.(0$+27*'&%0&)+240(%/&))$))$3(0$ 3$#$'3$',/  7/  3$3*,(2'4  =+3 -1  02)  2',-.$  &'3  +240(%/  &##%2$3  (0$ .*%(2#%2$+-1F9F

0*)  (02)  -*+(  3-$)  '-(  12'3  &'/  ,-'>2',2'4  4+-*'3  (- 2'($+1$+$  52(0  (0$  2.#*4'$3  &5&+3  &)  (0$  )&.$  2)  7&)$3  -'  ,-++$,( &##+$,2&(2-'-1$>23$',$-'+$,-+3

-')$D*$'(%/(0$&##$&%&)5$%%&)(0$,+-))
-7B$,(2-')&+$ 32).2))$3

$#($.7$+ $

% *%&(2

 &'

@0$(0$+ $#-+(&7%$  $)- @0$(0$+#$&A2'4 $&)-'$3  $)