Meena Devi And ORS v. Satvir Singh And ORS

1 102






IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT CHANDIGARH







































FAO8181999








Date of decision: 29.01.2026 





 



  




 

CORAM:

HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE YASHVIR SINGH RATHOR 

 



!" #
 



 
!"
$ %&
'(
 
!


!"
# 
)* 
%"
'+ ,,,,, YASHVIR SINGH RATHOR , J. (Oral) -




 "
& 
 
.

-/-0-112 

'

'
3/
#
-114
5+

"" 
'

5%
6 77


 
%
" 
-44
#



"
" -122
!


.


%
#
) 28 ///9*
.
.

" 
 
" 

""%
#

#
7

.


.
%5
# " 
-

!

# 
#
" 
0
%!


# " 
)
7
!



.

 5

+
 %
#
" 
7 +

!+ 0


+
%
:% 

5
 

 



#
" 

""%
#

# 7


 #
 
 
#"
#
 
"
.

&

 
#
""




:% 

5
%"

#
 
 
#

2 5!

+

5%

"

 
""% 
%
%
-
  ""



:% 

 
"

""%
#


& &  &

 

#

-
.


 &
 
## &
%"

5 &


*-)*0)88
% &


#
7

.

. .
5+

0

%
.


)

 
 #  &


5
 
5+
 ) 
!


"%
#
 
 

!
% 
 
"

"


 

 
 
 
"
# 


.

 5%

&
5%


# 
"


5"


 



 
5
"




#  &
 !
 5+
 5% 8 ;
 
 &
#
 
#.

&
%
. #<*   

  

 

  



        



    !

     

  #$%%&

 ' $ ()

 



   * +

,   -



 !

 +

 , .

  +  

 )

    

. /011     +        

 

   2 

3

   +.

  /011

 4 + 

2 

2  3    

   

  2 +2/011 

 5


!
 
"
 
" 
!
= 
 !


>-

 #
" 
"
!

"
.


+

3 %
 
"+
#
;
=



=?
"+
#  "% 
" # "
#
7

='
+
 
=
%&
  

"
#
 
"
#
"


=
!


+
"
=



 
 & 
=-

=) 4 
 

 

= 
>*-
6' '

%&

## "
#
 
%"
'+

>*0

@ 


%9&

 #
 

"
 
!

"
.

 + &
%
 
"+
#
 
 &
 ""
#
5 
= -
"+
# &  
" # "
= 0
%"
"!

= )
 
"! 
#
%"
= )9-

=
)91

= 8


 
 "+ = A 

! 
#
" 
"
7 

. .

&
.



 "

'5

.
& &
) ///9*
 

+

!



#"
" 

!


 >-


 
 
 
.

#
#
 
"
7

" 
0



.


" 
)

 
 
#
 "

 +

.

%




+
 
# "
.


!

"

=
"" &

.


. & &

%
#
) ///9*



+
B
5%



 "

5
) ///9*

 
-9)
#
 "
. %"
.




 &
=

 + "+
.
 

0///9*

 

"
"
.
0A +
#
&


 "% 
" # "
='

* 
=?
% 
#
-4
.
 


%
#
₹) 28 ///9* . .

" 

4 2

.!
"
.
0A
+
#
&

.
 
+


'5
.



 "
"" &+
 
&%  
 
.

0/-A
'6
0A//
'National Insurance Co.

Ltd Vs. Pranay Sethi and Others', 
.

0//1$4(
''
-0-

 

 

        

   3/C
#
 
%


5




 " .
#%%
"
#
 &
 

 
 " "

83//9*
(₹ )///9*
D
-3//9*( 1 "

#
5


 



%"

-9) #
 
%


5
%"
.


 &
=
 .
#
.
 
.



 



#
%" 

 
"+
"
%

)///9*



 %
"+
"
%

)4 ///9*
$ )///9*
=
-0(
" .
0A
+
#
&



&%  
 
.



 

 
% 
#
-A


5
 

#
+ &
 
 
" 
+5
"

4 -0 ///9*
$ )4///9*
=
-A( -/ 
 






&%  
 
.

    

 
-

!



 

 %
#
8/ ///9*
.

#
" %
-3 ///9*
.

# 

-3 ///9*
.
#%
=


.
 
.
 0/-2
$8(
' 
$'

(
)))
'!" #

 $   %  & '

(    ( )  
 


 
 
#
 "



 


%
#
8/ ///9*
"

.
#  

" %



" 
+5
 %
"
% 
5
A 40 ///9*

 

" 
+5

 


5 "" &+


%<* S. No. Under Head Compensation awarded by the Tribunal Compensation awarded by High Court -  " ₹) //// ₹) ////
0 ;%%
"%  3/C$ )///9*
D
-3//9*

E
83//9*( ) %" 
.

= -9)
$ - ////) -9)
$ -3//9*( 8 %
"+ ₹08 //// ₹)4 ///9* %  -4 -A 4 B
#
"+ ₹) 28 //// ₹4 -0 ///9* A

%
" %
B
#

;%
=  ₹A/ ///9* 2 ' %

  ₹8/ ///9* 1 ' %

   ₹8/ ///9*  



₹3,84,000/ ₹7,62,000/ --

%+
 




""
.

"
 


 


%
#
₹3,78,000/ ₹ ( 7,62,000 − ₹3,84,000) 
 "
" 
!

5!
 
"  .
5+
 5%
&
.



 

#
1C

% #
 

#
# &
#
" 
 

/0/3-114
 
 F  +5
5+

-

)
7 +

!+
%
#
 # 
%

%
#
A3 ///9*
"

5
 
&
.

 


 

0

)

5"
% &
.

 

5
 


-


  %
5
 

 


"

5
 

5

""% -0

& +

 "

 
 
%  "
"+
#
 .

 

%"
'+


#
 " 
% 5+
 G5
%
'%

> 
 
$'

(
3)8
#
0/0/

6 
Bajaj Allianz General Insurance Company Versus Union of India and others,
"



-4/)0/0-

%"
'+
  "+
.

 
 " 

%
%
'%
$;(
#
 
 7%& -)  &
"
 " 
$(
#
+
 

 
# (YASHVIR SINGH RATHOR) 29.01.2026 JUDGE  + 

 % >  


&9
< H
 >  
5
< H