Joginder Pal Mehra And Another v. State Of Punjab And Others


 




 
 




 





"#"#"#


()*+(+
,-

% ".

#"#

 


 





   



 


 



  

$%
,/
#"#
 

 




   




 


   

  

&'


  

 




 
0 $
/ "
47% 1%
$0
6 +
%#$

 
+4

6
"&-0
4 44!

/&82
 
$"&4
!
"&-0 1%
&$
%

47%#$  
  


 !

















&+$&$
6 $"$"%&+
07

&
1"!

4
/&4

#$"%&
:(
%1



 

 !"

#$"%&
'(
) ) )*
+

,"&-
./+0"&-
%1
$0 !

!%3
$"!

" +$
&1% 5$"%&
 6% $
*
&4
!!
$0
#%&+ ./ &$"!
6 %#

4"& &-+
 "+"&-
$0

1 %5
%&
$0 +"+
%1
$0
#%56 %5"+
4

4+
4

  :
;
<'
&& =/
 @
;
@ *
#$ 4
2 $3

&
6 $"

+
 '



'
 

,

0( ()0*,- 2!
, *)(
00*,- *20 *)0 ""1% # "  #"1
$"3
$#"
#"

()0*, -
#$
,/
,-

,/
728+-
 -+9 8

44*5 0*,-
)0
-+
()0*, 
)0
#"$ 

"4
% 4
4$ 4
:::

:
$0
11 #$ 4
6 $"

+
3

4"

# #$ $%
66 1%
$0
!

"!
)%/ $> >!!.
-"+$ $ 
1%
- $$"&-
$0 "

+6 #$"7

+$$ &$+
#% 4 4
3"$0
- 4 4
$%
$0
#%56 %5"+



6% $
0+
+"&#

&
# "7

4
1 %5
!

4
/4"#"!
-"+$ +$
)!++
!&40
"&
6/ +/&#
$%
$0
4 4"

#$"%&+
%1
$0"+
)%/ $
30

"&
1#$/5
%1 1
$0
#%56 %5"+
 "7 4
$
2 $3

&
$0
6 $"

+
+$&4+
7 "1"

&4
#%&1" 5 4
+
6
$0 6% $ +*
#%56 %5"+
0+
"&4

4
2

&
# #$ $3

&
$
6 $"

+
&4
$0
+5
"+
3"$0% %/$
&?
6 ++/
%
#% #"%&
&4
%/$
%1
$0 "
1

3"!!
&4
$0
6 "7$ &$+
07
!+%
54
+$$ &$
$%
$"%&
"1
$0



$0
##/+

#$
$0 $
$0 ?
3%/!4
07
&%
%28 #$ + 4@

+
"+
./+0 4
'

$ "!
)%/ $
0+
&& = 4
$0
+$$ &$+
%1
$0
6 $"

+ +
"&
% "-"&!
!%&-
3"$0
"$+
6% $

!

7&$
6 $
%1
$0
+"4
6% $ $
"+

6 %4/#

4
0

@2 !%3


(2) *6 60*,-

,


,0
*- -  = :(
,/
),46 *--0<;*)0*4 2!

9(

09(
))82(+
-+
*--0
<
;*)0*42
(
6 0>
0,

,4*2(
?
2*5-(+
09(
24( -84:(
,/
6( 2,-2
/,8-+
;(+
2
))82(+
*-
09(
+*2680(< *;(
+8 *-5
*-78* >
))82(+
*;>
-+
 (29
C84
@( (
/,8-+
*-;, ;

--,)(-0A
09( (/0(
)9 -
@2
(2(-0(+
,- >
5*-20
09 ((
))82(+ -4( >
,8 ;
(9 
 *2
;

(9 
,5*-+( 6
(9 
-+
'(( =0*
 *2
'(( 
(9

-(
),46 *--0
?
,-(
;*)0*4 (2
+
;
#

84:


=9(09  ),46 ),46

-
)2 2(
->
//()0(+
6( 2,-
))82(+
46 *--0!
*2
(/0
,80
,
-,0
>(+
2
6 0>
*-
09(
7829*-5
 ,
,
),4

> 6(0*0*, @9( ( *2<9(

(), + +* ()0 6( 2,- 
=9(09 ,-
:(/, (
*59
,8 0
+(0*
(,/A
 (
200(4(-0
*2
20*
0,
:(
+(+
*-
),46 *-)(
0,
09(
0*,-
,/
09*2
,8 0
+(0* 2
,/
28)9
 
- 9(
->
))82(+
92
:((-

(+
2

6 ,) *4(+
+( <6( 2,-
,
->
28)9
-  + , "

   *-   , "

"

;

2(

0
,/
09(
,8 0
@9(09( 2
6(
09(
200(4(-02
,/
6 0*(2
- -+

;
@2
4(+
+()

,//(-+ ,)( *-*0*0 -;(20*50*-5
//*)( 
))82(+
,8

(9 D

;
(9 @ +() (+
2
,) *4 ,//(-+( <6( 2,-
;*+(
, +(
+0 "1 " #".
-+
;*+(
, +(
+0 1 "$ #"#
622(+
:>
09(
,8
,/
 -8
*-5 
09(
09(-
'+
  -+9 
9(
@2
(

(20(+
*-
0 (2(-0

-+
@2
B,*-(+
*-0,
0 (+*-52
5*-20
9*4<9(
9;(
:((-
0(+
,
6(-+*-5
+B8+*)0*,-
0(+
0(+
9 
09(
09(

-;(20*50*,-A
))82(+
,5*-+(
 *-59
(9 
-+
'(( 
=0*
D
'(( (9 
@( (
+() (+
2
6 ,) *4 ,//(-+( <6( 2,-
;*+(
, +(
+0 "1 " #".
-+
;*+(
, +(
+0 " " #"#
622(+
:>
,-E: (
8-B -+
>-
*59
,8 0

*-
 3""#"#$
, +(
+0(+
"1 " #"

;*+(
@9*)9
09(
))82(+
@( (
+()

2
6 ,) *4(+
,//(-+( 2<6( 2,-2
@ ( 
4(+
0(+
0(+
:
 ".

(+
@2
(0
2*+(
*-
09(
6 (2(-0


(2

(6,

 ),46

@*09, *-/ 8( %
->
,

,4*2(
*2
5(-8*-(
;, 8-0 >
-+
80
->
),( )*,-
,
8-+8(
(-)( ,09(
26()0
( (;-0
0,
09(
 ,
(2(- -0
)2(

:

 $$
#%/&+ !
$%%
+/25"$+
$0$
$0

&%
%$ ##/+ 4
% %$0
$0&
$0
6 +
&4
$0
6 "7$ &$+

$0
% %&!?
-- "

4
6 +%&
"&
$0

"&
./ +$"%&
A

&
7"

3
%1
$0 6% $
%1
$0
!

4
/4"#"!
-"+$ $

+$
)!++
!

&40 
&4
$0
6 "&#"6!

+
!"4
4 4%3&
2?
%&B2!

$0
6 =
)%/ $
"&

 

 

 

  

&4
!+% %
2?

/!!
  &#0
%1
$0"+
)%/ $
"&
"!#    

 

        !"#
$0
"&+$&$
6 &
"+
!!%3 4

1% +"4

&4
!!
#%&+

./ &$"!
6 %#

4"&-+
 "+"&-
%/$ $
%1
"$

./ +0 4
<

4!

++
$%
+?
$0$
$0
6 $"

"

+
+0!!
5"&
2%/&4
2?
$0
$ 5+
%1
#%56 % %5"+
&4
$0 "
+$$ &$+
#% 4 4
2 1%
$0
)%/ $
2 !%3
(

 $"$"%&
+$&4+
4"+6%+ 4
%1
0%$%#%6?
%1
$0"+
% 4
6!

!# 4
%&
$0
1"!

%1
%$0
#%&& #$ #+


 








 

 !

6$



<
: