High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/16270/2022disposed of

Vishal Gouri v. State Of Haryana And Another

2023-03-14Mr. Justice Harsh Bunger10 pages

"# $% &% &

"# "

# '( % ) ) & '$ '%( ) %*+' ,($ -.'/)# ) '0'' Mr. Vikas Bishnoi, Advocate for (*'12('

%('0) %*+' , $%" ) * % +,-.

Prayer in the instant petition filed under Section 482 Cr.P.C. is for quashing of FIR No.189 dated 29.03.2022 (Annexure P-1) registered under Sections 148, 149, 323, 379-B, 427 and 506 of Indian Penal Code, 1860 at Police Station Jagadhri City, District Yamuna Nagar along with all consequential proceedings therefrom on the basis of compromise/agreement dated 01.04.2022 (Annexure P-2) entered into between the parties. $

'+ , + ( +'

) $/0 3('/, , $%"4 '.'

,/%30.'0,',,%'*,'1%5 1') ) #$ 0

$%,/+)!'1 '"'6'788 '1 , +1$/'' '9'

( '/'

('90) 6'%6 +1$1 ) ('

3 $/'+%'

4).(+('% '

%&4

" !

$ % ! !

& ' ()*++ , *-*-+-..+/01 234

& 3 !

4& & ! ! & 5 & & ! & &

! ! & !

! !

$ 54 &

! & & 5 &

& $ & )$

54 &$ $

4 &

& $4

4 # ! 67 6 !3

2 86 9 !

Vide order dated 10.01.2023, the //';''6 '<'/2 was directed to record the statements of the parties with regard to the genuineness and validity of the compromise.

In compliance thereof, the Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate, Yamuna Nagar, District Jagadhri has submitted its report, vide letter dated 16.02.2023 which indicates that the parties appeared before the Magistrate and got recorded their respective statements with regard to the validity of the compromise. As per the report, the compromise arrived at between the parties is genuine and without any pressure or coercion from any corner. Relevant extract of the said report is reproduced as under:-

$( '1,+1$/'')(1'3. (+1$/''<'9'

(-(/''%'++

%('

3+1$1 % .( '0++) % ,/ +'%$

'%( /0 '++

%($ +'

'%+1$/'''%'++

%('*

6%('61'%(+1$/''('

3=+),(

;

(% '6' ( '++

% ( 1/' 1') ( '++

%'1/0 ('/('

6*( '1('(('

+1$1 %(1'.((+1$/'').( '0++)

% ,/ +'%$

1( '1 ,+1$/''

->- '%'++

%)'$$' ('(1'3.3(($' ('

3+1$1 %*/ '/0).( '0$

,'09%) ,1'0+'%+1$1 ,,+%3.(1 6

+) 1 ('( '1 ,$' ' ) (

/,'0,'

%1 $ ''% (

/, , ?// , ( $' '% '++

% '1/0 ('/ ('

+1$1 %(1'.((+1$/'''%+1$/'''%

'% '++

% ('* 6% ( '61<+1$1 %% '% (+)(+1$1 ,,+%3.(1 6 )*/ '0 '%.( '0++)$

% ,/ +'% *'/% ('3* '% )

('/ ,($ +'

'$$'%'%

,,%' '13,(2

'1) .'

/%6%'6' '/,*'++

%$ '1/0 ('/) 1/)># )'%. 9.$ '% ,( $ ('%=%* 6'//0 ( '6 ,($ +'

%* 6'",('++

% $ ('

3 %+/'% '

$+/'1% ,,%<$ ( $ +'

'%:+$($ +'

),('3* '% '++

%$ */*%'0(+'

$+% ( $ +'

)( /0+1$/''<*+1'1/0'9'

( -(/':

(

,/'%+ /,($(' $ FIR No.189 dated 29.03.2022, there are total five accused, however respondent No.2/complainant has entered into a compromise only with the petitioner in this case; accordingly, a prayer has been made that the abovesaid FIR may kindly be quashed only against the petitioner herein and the proceedings may go on against the other accused in the said FIR. '%+ /, $%"('

'6''%(' (1'('

3 /%'%+1$1 %/03.($ ( +'

'% $%"<+1$/'' '

36$'+'%'10 3.($' ++%6/0)

31%('$ FIR No.189 dated 29.03.20221'09%/03;

(%/0'6' ($(

-@- '%($+%6 1'03%+%6'6' (('++

% ( '% '% ' + / % ' '0

% $ 6'%6;

(6,', '% /0;

'$( +'

('* ('% ( /'% + / , ( $' '% ('* $

%(,/

(

6'%6;

(6, '6' ,., 1'0'++

%'%'//.6($+%6 + '6' ((+4 '++

%.'

3=+1'3,*'

2 %,,++'

'% + %6'/0,,'+ '%++ '+ )(2 ('*$1% ;

(6, ;

' 1,'++

%'%'( '11)($+%6

('* 3 '//.% + '6' ( +4'++

% 1 , ( %+ ( 6'%''

,//.

A B3/ $:2 ;

(%(

.((+1$1 .'

,,+%30,('++

% .((+1$/'')303 *6'

%& ; &

$( 4)& 44

!%&&

) $

%&&

) *

# ! !

&4 44

<%&&

)= $ $ &

( 4) 3

& &

& 4$ & -

> &

$( 4)& 44

<%&&

&& & !& &

4 44

> &

& & !

$ $6 !3

> &

! 4$ & -3 & $ & & 4 & # & 6$ <

=4$

& - > &

& $ 6 !3

& & $& &4 & $

4 &

$ $ > &

! 8

& & $

> &

4 &

$ *

! 4

& ( 4)3

! ! 544

<%&&

!4&44

! ! & 8

% & *-3 $&&4

<%&&

&& ** $ $#

! ' ( ) -0,** !

$ 2

& % & 4

-1.-1-.*-*/ 2 3

<%&&

&& 944

$> ;:

%& ).'

(/%'

%& 1 94

& 9 &

$$$ 4

9& 8& ' (

# # 4 4 . 95 ! &&

! $

-C-

& !

4 $

# 4 ' ( # 4 ?4 !

& 2

$ !

67 3

& @@%<

& & &

&&49

&# ' ()+- . & --1.-1-.**/ 2 32

& 2 8 "

&2&5

4 & !

! 54 !

& & # 4 + %&& !

' (

& !

! # # 4 $ 4 & !

! &&

& ;:

()(3'%$+$/ ,:+ 6($. %

+@D.

11'E%30( B3/

$12 (1' , '%(( ) * %(( + " ( ," -

$')( '1' :'+%'

16. 9 4

& $ & ! 4 &

$ !4 4

A *1*& -4 4$

6 ! 3

4 &

&94

& $ 4$

4 4$

$ &

6 !3

B *19 & 8

& 6 !3

# '

(4 &

4 & ! !

-7- &

& 4

4 & 4 !&C

& 4 !&4$ &

! 4

& 3 3

*+.94$ # & -

& &

& 4 *1

!4 $ &

4 & !

# > &

& -6 !3

$ 8

> &

4$ B *1-C

4$ 6 !3

$ 4 > &

B< = &

& <

4 &

B *10 9 &

$ & '

# !

& &

& && >

& &

B *11 > &

4$ & -$

!$ 4

6 ! 3

& 6

& !

4 &

4& & 44 4

# ! &

& &

45 !4

4& 4

& 9&

& $

! 4

& B *1. %

& &

& $ & $

! 4

& ! > &

4$ #

&& B *1 3

& ! & $ &

& & &

& $

44 4

-D-

# ! $ 4

B *1+

&& 6 !3

# &

& ! $&

& &

4 & !$

4 8 &B *1*9

>&4 4

& 4

*1*1+D&

&& !

& &

& $

& $ &

96 !3

!# $

& 5 & &

9& # & && 4 &

$ ! & Having appraised the afore-stated para-meters and weighing upon the peculiar facts and circumstances of the instant case, this court is inclined to invoke powers under Section 482 Cr.P.C. to quash the criminal proceedings for the following reasons:

( $ '% ( $% "4+1$/'' '

'%3/'* ('//6';

'$$1','+'$$' 3'

/,1

% '%63.($' > ($%

,,'0+1'/'+%

'% */*%'0(+'

@ ( ( +'

6 %F8>8'%( +1$1 .'

,,+%88@8'%( (6 +% (. (' ( 3, ', ( $ $% +1$1 ) '0 .'% +% ' $% 3. (

-F- $' ($' (.*/).( '0++ +1$ / ) .//6/0 '% */ '/0 ('* 3 % ( %,,+ '%. ('++%';

(% $ A C (+1$/'' /9/0

$$(+'

,( $ + '6' ($ 7 (3=+,/'. .// *%.(($' /*( %,,+ '% +( $'+, //0 +4: '% /* ('10 D (6*'+ ('*63 /*%) ,=

+ . /%3 *%30,+6($ %66 , +1'/$+%6 F (;

(6,+1'/$+%6 .//'%*'+$'+) ('10)'%,//.

($'16 ($' .(('*%+%% ,6'%,6*'0//4.// '% ('* *6'+ '6' '+((A'%+ ',($+%6 '6' ($ /9/0'%*'+'0 ,=

+ 8 ( +'

, '%1 ' , +1'/ =

+ 1 . /% 1' 4,,+% '++$'+ , ( '1+'3/

/13.($' ('

'%'3*, this petition is allowed and the criminal proceedings in the aforesaid No.189 dated 29.03.2022 (Annexure P-1) registered under Sections 148, 149, 323, 379-B, 427 and 506 of Indian Penal Code, 1860 at Police Station Jagadhri City, District Yamuna Nagar along with all consequential proceedings therefrom)'; '

(%/0 ;

'($ .*)( '1. /%3

3=+$'01,+

, 8)888<43%$ %30($.(( /

, "!0

-8- - ,

2"3* * 4"3 5,46 '%( '%'1 . /%3

$,('1,$$' .((9./%6, %+'/

$% "%/

'0('$' ('//1'3 %30(1 , +1$1 '%( '1 1'%(2 3/.

1'%+/'('($+%6 '6' ('++

% ('// + # $ %,(', '%1

//$%6'$$/+' ),'0) ('// '%% $ %, $% &% & +) .

1'%$ ?(( $'96<'

%& ! <" ?(($'3/& ! <"