Jaswant Singh v. State Of Punjab
! "## $ % '( ))** + &! ! ,+ - . ) !"# $%&'( )*+,-( !.,/01! "!
$%&'( )*+,-(! ,$2( 0,$310,21) , #( !$ # + $# */" !/
!( ))** ! & , & 0#
/#!# *" !1 */,+ - .
!.,/01! "!4 0(# )) *## !#!+! ' # !!(-+'2 ! .3&# $+'/2#! /# &# 4 /%(.3!( ""+$ % '(% "( '%#!( !# !(
" )+ #( .*+ &"!# 5, 6% " #"! ! "+ &"!# 5,!+ '*# #2)# 2 !) 3
/7 # +*! ) 32 /(% #"!! +!( + '#'+#2)# 2 #82 !( 0(" !()"+!# # +!(**#!( ! )*#") !3( .3&+.5 )"!2#9&# '(/&6:(29 /% ) !**# '+!3 &2! # : +,;4 ((+.
*.#&# '( 2!(#2 2 ! !2 !. (#2!( !(#!$'# : +% 2 # .+!!% !33 . "9%#!($ % '( 6#!( '#
.#!(! +'(!/ 2*3/:+*%# : + $ % '(+! <+ *%#!((#!!( !(( !'# .#!(! &( ( (+.
*.# &# '( + ! "+ * ""+ $ % ! &# '(
/ ! .+! , /&2! $'# : + $ % '(( "2!((+ &(! *9!!(2 0( +'(! !( ""+( ' !!((+ ( !(=#!&+9(%# : + > !
#** '? * &(##!!((+ $'# : + !
.+! 0(+! !((+ $ % '(% *"9 &( !!((+ 2!((+ (# '( &( % !( !(#!$'# : +% *3# ' # )* .* "!
#!(2 &( !#"# -+# (( / ( 2+!( ""# ' ! (/ $ % ! &# '( ( 2+ $'# : + @5/ A8 ,17% " 0(# <+!)!% )) 0(#!)* % )) *! # <+#*!% #B *! # )#" )#**% * '%#!(.*! # % *" 0(.3% )!2!28 2# 0( ""+% ! 6% !' ! 62 #"*+! !2 '!" %
*' !(( !(% )#" 2(#(+/%(#"( (9)!" " *+ !(
!#' !# % "2)*! "( **
% )+!+) !"2)*!# **!(" * 2 *#!# 0()"+!# 8 2# +2. %#!
# +))! !(" 0(! !2 !( ""+% *"+ &"!# , 6 #!(" !()"+!# 8 2# ;2#9 &# '(# " 6% " #"! ! "/ !#"(# . 6 "/!() ! )) *
C "+ * )) # ' .( * !( ))** (2 !*3 '+!( !!()"+!# ( #*!)#!" C "+ * )) # ' !(&! !(2 !*3 '+!( !!()"+!# ( )#!" .3 .*+.! +))!!(-+'2 * +!.*% ;( ( * "+ * !() !# ' !(+'( !(-+'2 "3" +**3 ,; &+9(%# '()!( !(" +"!!( )!2!28 2# !(.3 $'# : + 6 ( !#"!( **%# '# -+# !(.3 D * " !%+ 8 "2 "8! # '
2.!(!("(9 * ! **3 E *3# '. "+(# #'+# ' " *. %"+(
. 9+** "!+ # * " ! .+!
42* .*% ) !# !(" # *" #!3 * " !%+ 4 8 "2 #'(!#
( * " !%+ "28 4"2! /
+))) ! ( #"!# + *3# '. + # -+3 % "!+ ' ! . # * " !
* " !%+ 4"28 "2 #'(!# #.* "2 22#*# E *3# '2 #.* . % "!+ 4 * " !%+ 48 "2/"2* ! *!# -+3
#.*% "!+
" !+# 48 "2 #'(!# ".*%
* ! *!3 .2 /9# /)#!#+2/*#/)* /9# 3/'
' !# % 5 2+!(/ ( !/ ) * !
"!+ &!2 "( " ! # 3 2 ** <+ !#!3
+ #'! &2 **# !!# " ! # #'! C ' # !!# " ! # " * 2 !! * % 2)!3 F )!()# # ,; &+9(%# '(/!(" + !(% ("9 ( 2( '+!# -+3 / /%(#"(% +
#"# !!" + !(# !(# 3"+ !+ **!(# -+# % !2!2# !+ > ,;#(# 2/ !2 /,;66 .
&# '( ,;
6&+# :+2 !( 2 *%#!
,;4&2! # : +#!( *#! " $'# : + &(% 2 #!$ % '( &(( '!(2 # ' # '% ) 2 .+!!% !3 3 . "9 6#!( '#
.#!(! +'(! &(% 2:+*%# : + ""++! <+ *%#!((#%# .3! !# '!( !(( !'# .#!(! 0(3 +!"+ *(#2 $'# : + * '%#!(((+.
( "2!( (+ 0(# +'(!( * 3' !? * &(% !!!((+ (#! ! .+! 0((+% *"9 2+!# &( ( !( !!(#
!(2% *"9 &(% !!!((+ (#! 2!( (# '( #'(.+ 0( 2% ) ;( (2!(<+#*! 2!(./( ( #!*3# ' # )* .* 5 -+#% ((
" &( #(+ "3 ,)* 2 #'(.+("**"!!( 6(+.
* "( &(! !%)# ' 0()*#""( ! !2 !/A8 ,1 5 ("8 2# /(% "
!%#!(( )#+! !2 ! &( 2#!!!( !# (! !2 !. !()*#"/( ( !! !!( !(#! * '%#!(((+.
( "2!((+ &(( !2 ! !2 !. !()*#"!( !(( ##!!((+
4 (#! &( * 2#!!!( !(( !2 ! !2 !. !( )*#"!( !( !!((+ (#! 2!( (# &# '( &()!( !!( ""+( ! !! + !# '(#! !
'## '.#!(! 6(+.
( "(!()* " ""+ " .+!742# +! !( # * 0( .3% )! 2!28 2# .3!()*#" ! .+!7 , ,;
:+*%# : +#!( +'(! " !( ""+ ""# '!(/!( ""++!<+ *%#!((2!( "(## '(!( !(( !'# .#!(! 6+!!( ! ( 2!(!( !(%#**9#**( %#**2 3 0% 3)#!!( !( (2!(/( !(( !(!!((+ (##! !#** ' ? * &( #!(+''!# !( !(% !+! ,;
$ '#&# '(!# )! # 2!(23 6) !( !$'# : +% (# !(=.!(= +'(! &(% 2 #%#!( ""+$ % '( .+!3 . "9 /(( ' ! :(29 2) *%9 ! .+! / ""+$ % &# '(2!(#2 !(.+!
:(29 62 8! -+#"# * "
# . (#2!( !(( 2+(#%# .3+# '% *'
0( !/!( ""+ * % 3 5 (#"8 2# /( 2#!!!( !:(29 # ! #!
" 749#*2! 2(# #** ' 6( ' !#** '( #)+!2!&+. 6 .( -
&# '( 6 # ! ' ! )*#" #22# !*3 ! !( 8! -+#"# * "
# % 2 .3!( ""+. (#2 ,;> :+*% ! &# '( ) !( ! ))** ! ( "
. (#2!( !(( "22#!!!(2+ (#%#
,;&52#9&# '(!!# #!( !(( "! !2 # : +/A8 ,1 @5/A8 ,17/% ".36&+# : + 6 ( )) !( # <+! )"# ' # A8 , / * )) !(+'(#!)* /A8 ,: 6( **# !.*! # !(
2!()* " ""+ "#A8 ,:/.*! # <+#*! .* ! # )#**% @&C8 2# 6( !!( .3 )!2!28 2# 6( *"!(! !2 :+*% &# '( * '%#!(!() 0( ""+% !
0( ))** !( *)+";2#9&# '( ""# '
!(#2/!( ""++!*## 1++% ( #! &# '( !#** ' &#( *# !( 3 2+ ! .+! /(% !!!((+ !( ""+ !(.*! 2# # !# '!( .3 !(%# !( ""+/(+(!!((+ !(#! " / 2*3/ # : + # : + "(!()! * '
%#!( ( (+.
0( !/ ( ! (# ! #** ' &#( *#/ %(
2!( ""+ 0( ""+" 2%#!((# ! .+! (#"8 2# /( 2#!!!( !(#(+% ! #!
" .+!43 2!((+ !( ""+ "2)* # !% 2 !!(& #&+)# ! ,*#"' # '!( *#2)*#" !# ""+ 4 $'# : +( ## !((+ !( ))** ! 5!% !( ))** !!)+ %( !"#"+2!
"(#%# ## (#(+ )&"!# !(5 # A# ""! 6( ! 9 !()* *#.# 6( *#+) !(! !2 ;2#9&# '( ""# '! 2#9&# '(/(+!## 1++% ( #! &# '( !#** '
&#( *# ""# '!(#2/ !( 3 2+ ! .+! /(( ' !!((+ !( ""+ !( !((+.*!
2# # 6 !# '!( .3 !(%# !( ""+/% !!((+ !(#! !(" 6( "" # !##!!( (+ !( ))** ! 6#! !2 ! !# )#"
# " 0( ))** !( 2 8! -+#"# *"
# . ,;
$ '#&# '( ,;>:+*% '( ,;
$ '#&# '(# !# )! # 2!(23 6( 2#!3%#!(!( ""+
6+2 .*% !(8(#.#!" ! # # ) "*== " ! # '=
) "*= =" ! # ' # @&C)!/A8 ,G ?#@&C)!/A8 ,/!((+2 .*%
) "*==" ! # '/)#" <+#*!"8(#.#! /)#" <+#*!" * '%#!("!! 8(#.#! /)#" )#**%"8(#.#! /)#" "!! 2 !!! * #8(#.#! /)#" "*!( "!! 8(#.#! 4/ ) "* = = " ! # ' =#*=/ ) "* == " ! # ' =?
=/ ) "* == " ! # '8(#.#!/ *% 8(#.#! ( %*8(#.#!
,;4&2! # : +" !'#" **3)!( !(+! "+ *$ % '( &(( ' !!((+ !("
&(( # -+32 9 !(( " (#! ; ) # % *'% " !!(# !
" !( ))** ,;
:+*%# : + +'(! " ( +))!!(" )"+!# ""# '!(/!( ))** !+!"(#(2!(!( !
(( !)+" 0(# "" # !( +'(!! **3 #2)*#" !( !( &! !2 ! ,;4 # : + ,;
:+*%# : + +*3". !.3! !2 ,; &+9(%# '(
> 0(" + !(% ("9 ( 2( '+!# -+3 / /%(#"(%+
#"# !!" + !(# !(# 3"+ !+ ** !(# -+#% !2!2# !+ 0(). .*+ !# .!%
-+3 !(% # !
+ ,. .*+ !# .!% !( )!2!2% ! (+ 0(" #. "#"+2!
!# * # " 0("( # # !() !" #"2)*! > ""# '*3/!()"+!# ( )!(" ' # !!( ))** !.3 .*+.! 0(# 2#!# !( )) * 0( 2##2# -#&( 2 $+' 6 # '(&#(+ $+' ;(!() 9# '7 H7 ;(!()! .* H7