← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/24796/2014allowed

Rakesh Kumar & ORS. v. State Of Punjab & ANR

2020-01-06Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan13 pages

  



           

 !"#$%$ &'( (

)%*+,- . &" *.% ((( $ $ &.% /.%,%

 !,&0 1 &" & *.

((( %2 &"& %  '

 34 (

 /  5

      !   $ %  &'

()  ( # %*

  ! #  +  /  56(    

,  # "

- % "./+  



    !   0 1 2    0 102  "    () # 3

,% ! 4 



   %  )-# !

% !

% )3  ! 0  *

""! "!   #  + 5! 3#  $

6%   ""

! "

 "

() ) & #3 

,  



  )3 ! 3# "

 "./ % 3 (  %

8 9

 893

' )! %  

$ %  %  ( % $ % 

 %   ./   "     " %+  :

 *   &

!  3

0) %,) , , !  

; !  ,   #

 "

!  0 1 2 0 102 "  ! #

 

3

%  3    

 -  ,

  !   )  !   



 5 

#   % <# 3  <  ! 3#

,1 7&2   ) %  !!"

3 ! 3#

,/ "  ./# '; +  !  0

  ), ()'  3=   7 )& #3&# 3 

 "

7&  

;  ! 0>1 2 "  %  ! "

# ! /./ "  #  -

, 3 

"  "



#      "          !

%    

   #       % 3 # 3    ) % !!"

! 3#

,  ,  #

 "

!   01  41 2    2  "     "  ),  !  1 212 4 >1 2 "  ,! 33 ""!# ) ! 0 1 2 0 102 " / "  ./ )  " -

, !  ! ), $

6% 

  ! 33   ./ % "



#  ,  % 3  "

 ?

5# -,

 # 1  #

), 2



% 3 @! , 

# "

@!  "  "

@ 0 4

# % 3      #  ),   1#    2    )

0  "

3 5  5"



#  ,3,    %#  3# / "   #  ),   1# 2       !

%    #      !  ! 3# ,3 1  2  8 %##  3 7&  ,! 33  ""!# ) ##

 "  : 3#% ./  

 "

#  ## "

 )   "

# #  8 - % "./ ! #

% !

 7#   ! #  # )"

), "

() #  + 5! 3# $

6% 

7&  A   

       !       #     @  

 % 1#    2

 #   # ),  "

 8#!! #   %,  %  ,   #

%

 # , %"

!

 "# 3 (! "

%    

3  /  )  #  +  5! 3#    -  "

%   -

,    "

3   / % %A""

! "

%  "! "

 

!    "

    #!

!  ""

  )     ,   ! !

%  

 %  "./#!

, %

% -3 ), 7&"

)3  % -

,

  !

-  "!  /     !

% %    

>  

- " # ( %3

4



# ),

 

3  % "

),

   %! 3  %   #  !-

  #   "

! 33  ""!   !   0 1 2    0 102  "    : "

   # #!   !

 )3  ! 0  B  % #  "

./ 0       %    % ,  % 3  # 1# ), 2  ! ! % 3 # !   % #  3#  ,) 3  !!  

) %, "  "  "   "3 B  !   "

   #   "   %      #

%3 ?

5# -,

  

 "

# 3 (! %  !

3   #  "3  ) ," @#

, " #

  3  )  , "

#!

!# 3! 3  ) ! "

),# "

   # "   "# 1# ), 2 !   ""! 3   ! 0 1 2 0 102 "  B !  "

 #    " % 



 %   @   !  ! 0 #  % 3  %,  ,#   3  !! ), #  + 5! 3#  B  !   "

   #  "   %  

#  + 5! 3#  %   -

, @ 

4    3 ./  8 "

"

 %     %   -  3  B  !   "

    %          #   "

# , 

% "#  %   @! # ! % 3   , #  #  3  ,@#

,)!8 0 4

  "

#!

!# 3! "

),#  B  "

 ! 0  "

  !    C7( !!&#% &"2& $%( 2,#   # 3   %  !    )! "  ! 3#, 

!  #

 "! 0 4 

4      !  !  )  #    

3#

 3  "

   3 33   3  "     ,  !3,@  ,  3 33  " # !

!3,@   #"

! 12@@@ @@@ @@@ 102,# 3  %    ) @! "  ! 3#,  !   ,  #

 " !  ", 3  

 #,#, 3#  #  3), ! 3#  

,   "      #,  @# ,#

"

 ""! )#    !  !  3#

 3"

 3  , !3,@   ,  33  "

  "  #        !  3, @   # ! 12@@@ @@@ @@@

  142@@@ @@@ @@@ 1 2@@@ @@@ @@@D B " )3 # ! 1,2 <# 3  <3#       "

   !!  ,   # )  !  ! ! !  !# 3 <!   ; <   # !  , <# ,  < <%<  ""  # 3 #   )" " ) !   ; <#  < ! 3 )! %   "#   " ,"

3   "    !)

!  ! !  ,   # , % 3"

  # ),,  3 B " )3    3#,# ),  " ,  "

 "

 "<# 3  <,  #   " ,    "  <# 3  <    ! 3#

, ,   # ,!  ,

"

! )# ! 3 , %   "@ ! "!  % 3 # ! 

#  % #  ),!

% 3#  B " )3    !  ,  # #  %  ./  3    !  !

! "!, !

!

 "(  )3 ),/ % %A""

! + ) :

# ! 

 

 B !  "

 " "

  # 

#! 

 ! #,!  ""



 @ 05:

 + ):

*   % =A ! ! 

=-  #    3 "  

 C:

,   %   /#!  '

#   %   = A""

! *   )/#! B8

 %

     =   A""

!  *     %  #  !# , 9 # %.

 9% *  

:  ! % 

=-*     ! # "

 + 4 54*  

#

  +     "  

  "

 ),  8  93 )"

  = <)  ()    = ,  = %    

% "

! , "

3 ! #  "

%+  %  #!  !!

% $3)

 "

   ,  

0     #!  "

959  >50>  3>3

* %*    #

9 + >

>4  >  >  >>  45>   5>  

 5

 >5

5

   0

5 5  4 5  5

5  0 5 4>45> 4> 5> 



  5

5

 4

0  45 0 5 0

>5 0 5

 

 0  4



4 3

0* %*   "   !    3

%    * %    *   ! ) !!

% # %



  ! =

!

#)   !!

#

  "

, %

%  "  

3

* %0*  '

38   !6@)

'

38 

 8#   3   

; !  ,   ! @ %# ) %#  + 



  5+ ):

*  D

> B   %  

 !

    3 "

%  

  !% "9 '



%

 , "#  "   "# #   "  !

!      ! "

!

 #  #!  * !

# !  

 ) %, ) ,! )

  3 ) %,  0) , %

338  )

!  

;

!  , @ %#  B " )3 



# 3 %

! 

  !  ! %

!

#   3 8 ",#%#  B !   %   ""



   ""! ! 4 "  3  

#   # !  , B  !   "

   #   "   %     !  "% 3  ! ) 

 !  )8 ""!# !   "  ##  # 3 

  )  "% 3      # !  , !    "!   " B ! " )3 % 3   # !  "

   8),# # 3  ),,

    8##

 "!  4 "  B  !   "

   #     " "

  ""

 "=A *   &

!    

 # 

"" ./%  1  @  

 % # ./2 ! 0   "/  ! %)"

3

%   , "!

%

 / #,  !   )  "./ ""

"&



!+) &

!  



 %  #  " #  + 5! 3#  

; !  , !  ),# " 

 % 3 # !  "

3     3       #  B !   #  -

, 1@  5:2 @ ""

 "&



!+)

 !   @  ), )

%, 3  ,

  8 , %)    "# ! 1# 2 %

%!  !  "3# ,    ) ! ,## "

3 7&B !   )3  #    ! 8%      3  !! B    !       )   "    ""

 

 

 "  " )3  !!  " ,

8 %! # 3! )8%  / "

  #  !  # 3     

!         ! 3#  

 % 33

, B !   

 "#  #!



 !   

#"!=A + ) : "   ,!  , @ %# 



   # #    "

"   "#     ! %

#        !

#  B    !   "  )3   ! %  ), 7& ! 0>1 2 " "

"

3 4



>  # !# "

 ! 0 # #  



>   )3

)"

/-%  B #  + 5! 3#   ) " #,  4

   %  ./

 % # ! 1 2 "  !

!  ,  8 %! ,#   !   "

"

3! 3#

,/  ""



%   -

,    >



4       !  ),  7&

"

 # 3   )  !  "

 # ! % # 5!! #    B #  + 5! 3#    )  "  ""

 



>"

 )" ": %

$

 6%  5! 3#     "   %      !    %  % #     #   / #,   %  

# "!#    3 "  "./ #  ,!  ,   #   "

# %

!  !   #   "  B " %  "!#   ! 3 ),#  % 



 )!   

  % 3  #  8%3 , 3 ,     ! 

)@!   "  !  !!  % 

"" ./%   " 

% #  /"

3

 # # "

"     12 /  ! "# ),, "% 3   , 

 3 ./

#  

  # % 3 # ), 1# 2!    %#  ),!

% 3#   

 "! ,  @! "  "#    ,#  "   ,

#  ),!

 %

# ,

%   ,    ),!

% 3#  6    % 3           

"

 #   ) % # 3 

  

 #

 "! 0 4  4 "  1)2 : %   !

 % 3  #    "               #

 

 ) #      "! 

),=A + ):

*  

#  #!



 !,!!

% # %





#  !    

  !

# ! ), /

#  ! ,    

; !  , 

!   @ % 1!2 :#    # 

"" 

# ),

$ % +)   4



 ! "

# 3 (! "

),# # , %"

 % "

3  %

# 

#   

3   )  ! # "

@!  "  @#

0 4

  "

(!  3  )

  #       3 ,    "

       "

 #!

!

3! ! "

),#      !               : "

    !-

   #  " ,3

  !#) "!

% , !  ,#    # ! % 3 #  " 0

 ! 1&2   @    ),38 %  ) ,  8  %)    "

# ! # , !  !3# ,   8  "

3 7& ! 33

% 8%! %     #         #  ), "!, !

!"

 !   !  )  )"

# ! ",

;

!  ,  #  

   ! )  7&

 0  !%   @  %       !5     !   0      )3 % , " !   ""! 3  % #    3#,#

),   !-

  #   "  !!

%, # #   ./+ 



  ! 0 1 2 0 102 " () # 3

,% ! 4 % )- # !

% !

% )3  ! 0   ),- -#   ( ( 9 /  5:









   

 

  ! "  

   ! "