High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/25752/2018dismissed

Jaswinder Singh Lotey v. State Of Punjab

2019-10-31Mr. Justice Amol Rattan Singh5 pages

! "!#$%$ &'(

) %*$&"!+,$&-./ !0

! $ $ &!+ 1!+%2% , ! 2&34&"& .!+

!%5 &"!& % '

6/ ,/,

+!%!& '

, $7,+ "1 # !7*$ . % ,25+$0+ +7"1 # !7

+ .!5! $ $ &!+ + , ,!*87""9 72&34 1&$%.$ 97"1 # !7

++!%5 &"!& &

/,7 :+9;

1$&-.!+"9!+&!"# 2&%!9 + .!5+ $!% 9!&- . 1!+ 5!+$ " ("0%7%+!-+"% .!" #2<!& 4!$&-+!9$!"25 &40+ $7 9!+&!",!&$ + 2&%!955!+$&- + .!5! $ $ &!+7:%. *&$& .!$&"!= 4! &&!=2+! (7 *$ . .! 1!+&#29+ 1!+%$ & .!+! %. *& 4!

&&!=2+!7 +2&&$&-5-!

( .!55!+4 8;7*.$#.$%% !" 4!

6%!9 "!#9+ $ &67 . $%1!+06" 24 29" #2<!& 6 ##!5 .$%% -!

9!% 7 + .! 52+5 %! -+& 4$97 $ 4!$&- %!!& . .! >%!9

"!#9+ $ &?$%& %$-&!"$<<!"$ !904!9 * .!<$&4 "0 *. $% # & $&!" .!+!$&7 &" !1!& % +!-+"% .! %$-& 2+! 5+!%!& !+ .!

1!+$ $# $ & %. *&7 $ $% & & 55+ 5+$ ! 59#! *.!+! &0 %2#. %$-& 2+! * 29" & +<990 4!7 # &%$"!+$&- !%5!#$990 .! # . .!

5! $ $ &!+$%9*0!+&"* 29" 41$ 2%908& *% . *"!#9+ $ &$%

4! %$-&!"@ &" # &%!A2!& 907 $ $ *% 4! - %$-&!" + < .!

# <59$&& 7$ * 29".1!4!!&55+ 5+$ !90%$-&!" .!+!9!1& 59#!%

$ .%7 # 2+%!7 1!+0 % +!&2 2%90 +-2!" . .! # <59$&& .%& "!&$!" .!%$-& 2+! & .!" #2<!& 7&" .!+! +! .$% 2+ ++$1! # &#92%$ & . $ $%& " #2<!& 4!+!9$!" 25 &7$%# &#92%$ & . %. 29"& 4!"+*&

$ 9755!+$&- + .!# <59$&& 7 & .! .!+.&"

%24<$ % . .! 5! $ $ &!+7 % .! # <59$&& %6 9*0!+7 ." 8!& .$% %$-& 2+!% &49&855!+%7&"%$&#!.!."4!!&.$%9*0!+ +% <! $<!

.!"$"& +!

2%! " % 7&"# &%!A2!& 907!1!&$ .!%$-& 2+!%+! 2&"

4! . .!# <59$&& 7 . " !%& 2 .!& $# ! .!" #2<!&

$.%%24<$ !" . & %2#.-+ 2&".%4!!& 8!&$& .! +!590 $9!" .!5! $ $ &7*$ . .!%$"-+ 2&"& 8!&!1!&$& .!5! $ $ &

$9!"40 .!# <59$&& %!!8$&- . $+$&1!% $- $ &4!# &"2# !"40& $&"!5!&"!& -!&#079$8! .!:

7*.$#.$%9% 9$% !" "0;

,!*87 9!+&!" ""9 7 2&347 $& +!%5 &%! .!

+!%$"# & !& $ & + $7. *!1!+7%24<$ % . !1!&$& .!# <59$&

$9!"40 .!# <59$&& .!,,7 9$#! $% +$# B.&&7.!."% !"

. .!5! $ $ &!+ 8.$%%$-& 2+!% &% <!49&855!+%

$% 2+ .!+ 4! -$& 4%!+1!" 40 .$% 2+ . & # &#92%$ & .% 4!!& +!#.!" 40 .$% 2+ % +!-+"% .! +!%$"

" #2<!& 7%.%9+!"04!!& 4%!+1!".!+!$&4 1!!+9$!+7*$ .$ &90 4!$&- 4%!+1!" . + .!52+5 %! -+& & $#$5 +04$9 .!

5! $ $ &!+7 .!" #2<!& 4!$&-+!9$!"25 &40.$<$%& 4!9$!149! .!

(

#! $ 7%243!# # 2+%! 2+ .!+$&1!% $- $ &$& . +!-+"40 .!

5 9$#!

.!+ .& . 7$ $%&!#!%%+0 -$&$& .$% +"!+ +! !+ .!% 2%+!5 + <&5+!! B2+C9$7 !52 0 $+!# + &# <!

=:&1 ; 7/2".$&7%.%4!!&&&!=!"*$ . .!% 2%+!5 + " !"

) $9!"40,.+$,2+3$ ,$&-.7 !52 0,25!+$& !&"!& 9$#!7097 . %5!+ .!!&A2$+0# &"2# !"40%2+1!0 !< . "!5+ <!& 7 .!

5+ "2#!"40 .!%%!%%!!7$ !

.!# <59$&& 7*!+! 2&" 4!

8!6

$ .% . *!1!+ 2+ .!+ %24<$ !" . *$ . .!

# <59$&& .1$&-99!-!" +2" 6 &906% D

98.%$& .!7 .!

< 2& %

#+ +!592%"!5 %$ !"40.$<$& .!4&8## 2& E% !90&"$& !#.:

*.$#. .!5! $ $ &!%6*$ !$% .!+ 5+$! +;7* 29"

>.1!& !=59& $ &?74!#2%!1!+0 41$ 2%90 .!5! $ $ &!+ .!+! !+9% "!5 %$ !" & < 2& %

D7 7FF E % = *$ . .! &# <! =

!5+ <!& $&&2+0

725 &+!A2!% . !

!# .1$&-4!!&<"!

40 .! # <59$&& 7 % $& # .! 5! $ $ &!+%6 *$ !%6 $+< *!" .!

# <59$&& . <2#.< &!0$&+!%5!# .!"!5 %$ %<"!$&.$%*$ !%6

$+<%6## 2&

! .2%%24<$ % . $ *%& .!"2 0 .!5! $ $ &!+ "!5 %$ .!$&# <! ="2!% .!# <59$&& 742 .!# <59$&& *% &90 50$&-

.$% *$ !%6 $+<%6 "!4 .! # <59$&& 40 *0

"!5 %$ $&- .! =%&"*.!&"$+!# !":!1!& . 2-. .! =$%% !" 4!

+ .!%%!%%<!& 0!+

D ;

&+!590 .!+! 7+ $ 95 $& % &&!=2+! *$ . .!

D 5! $ $ &7*.$#.$%%. *& 4!% !<!& .!5! $ $ &!+4!

+! .!

$&1!% $- $&-

$#!+7<"! &

7 .!!

!# . . 2-. .!*$ !

.!5! $ $ &!+$%&&-$&!!+$&--+"2 !7:42 $% .!+*$%!. 2%!*$ !;7 *. .%&## 2& $& .!&<! E%!90&"$& !#.7*$ . .!%$"

## 2& 5!&!"40 .!5! $ $ &!+:%*$&"!+,$&-./ !0;6 #$9$ !.$% #9$!& % "!5 %$ $&# <! =+! 2+&%6

1$&- # &%$"!+!" .! 4 1!7 $+% 907 $ * 29" 4! 1!+0 %2+5+$%$&- . &$&# <! =5+# $ $ &!+* 29"-! .$%*$ ! 5!&& ## 2& $&+!%5!# $+< *.$#.%.!$%% !" 4! .!5+ 5+$! + 7 "!5 %$ $&# <! ="2!% #9$!& % .!5+# $ $ &!+7 + .!< 4!

.!+!

!+ +&% !++!" .!&# <!= !5+ <!& @42 !1!& 8$&-$ .

.! +!%$" &&!=2+! $% & 2&%$-&!" % !<!& <"! 4!

+! .!

$&1!% $- $&-

$#!+2&"!+,!# $ & .!+ :%% !"409!+&!"

# 2&%!9;7*.$#. .!5! $ $ &!+#&"!&0 &0% -!7 .!*. 9!< !+ 41$ 2%90&!!"% 4!$&1!% $- !"1!+0 . + 2-.907% *.! .!+$ $% .! 5! $ $ &!+7.$%*$ !7 + .!# <59$&& 7$&"$1$"29907 +$&# 992%$ &*$ . .!+&"E +$&# 992%$ &*$ .&04 "0!9%!7 . ." !<5 !" 1 $" 50<!& $&# <! = $99 .!0*!+!$&"!!5* !+%&" .!&# <!=

!5+ <!& ." % + !" $%%2$&- & $#!% + & &"!5 %$ =!%7 *$ .

%. *$&-50<!& = 2&" 4! 4+$# !"" #2<!& %40 .!

&# <!= !5+ <!&

.2%7*$ . 2 <8$&-&0 2+ .!+# <<!& & .!# 29<!+$ %

.!#%!7 + .!+*$%!7*.$#.* 29"& 2+990% $994!%243!# < !+

$&1!% $- $ &7%!!& +!% & !& !+ $& .$%5! $ $ &7 + 9! .!5! $ $ &!+ # & $&2! +!<$& &$& !+$<4$9&0 2+ .!+

&%!A2!& 907 .!5! $ $ &$%"$%<$%%!"&" .!$& !+$< +"!+ " !"

$%1# !"

(

)

C.! .!+%5!8$&-E+!% &!"

!%E C.! .!+!5 + 49!

!%E