Harmanjeet Singh Alias Harman v. State Of Punjab
Mr. Vinay Malhotra, DAG, Punjab.
!
"#$#%&'#&(&()%*+$,##%-(.#/,0&*#'#&(&()%#" $##1(%2 2"+%&)-+%&(3('+&)"0,+(.
(%3+$# )! /+&#/4!
5 6%/#"
#3&()%$
5 )-+%/$#3&()%5)-"7$3&()% )-+//#/.+&#")% #+".(#"$#3&()%$44 4 )- "#2($&#"#/ +& ).(3# &+&()% +&# +1(7+ ).(3# )77($$()%#"+&# 8($&"(3& 7"(&$+"!
!
)6%$#. -)" &*# '#&(&()%#" 3)%&#%/$ &*+& +$ '#" &*# +..#2+&()%$(%&*# )%"#3#('&)-$#3"#&(%-)"7+&()% (%&*#'"#$#%& 3+$#9+$"#2($&#"#/+2+(%$&&)&+.-(:#+336$#/ %+7#.0 ( 7"(&'+.(%2* +.(+$;+1+ (( +"7+%'#&(&()%#"*#"#(% ((( +*(.+&&6 (: +*(,(%2*+.(+$+,6+.(+$6"+<+%/: ;+"+%/##' (%2*+.(+$;+"+%!
$'#"&*#+..#2+&()%$ &*#0*+/-)"7#/+2+%2+%/9#"# +..#2#/.0'"#'+"(%2&)3)77(&"),,#"09*(.#,#(%2+"7#/9(&*/#+/.0 9#+')%$(%&*#+"#+-+..(%29(&*(%&*#<6"($/(3&()%)-).(3#&+&()%+&#
+1(7+! % &*# ,+$($ )- $+(/ (%-)"7+&()% 9*(3* 9+$ $&+&#/ &) ,# "#.(+,.# 9+$"#2($&#"#/#:#%'"()"&)3)%/63&(%2+%0"+(/! !
)6%$#.-)"&*#'#&(&()%#"$6,7(&$&*+&$6,$#=6#%&&)&*# "#2($&"+&()%)-&*# )%3)%/63&(%2+"+(/ &*"##)-&*#+336$#/ %+7#.0 +*(.+&&6 +"7+%'#&(&()%#"*#"#(% +%/ 7"(&'+.(%2*+.(+$;+1+ 9#"#+""#$&#/! )9#:#"
&9))-&*#+336$#/ 3)6./%)&,#+''"#*#%/#/!
>*(.#-(.(%2&*#-(%+."#')"& 3)+336$#/(&(1+.*)&"+9+$ -)6%/ (%%)3#%&! ')% *($ +''.(3+&()% -)" /($3*+"2# &*# $+7# 9+$ +..)9#/ +%/*#9+$)"/#"#/&),#"#.#+$#/-")7<+(.,0.#+"%#/
7"(&$+"
:(/#)"/#"/+&#/5!
5!
&($-6"&*#"$6,7(&&#/&*+&(&9+$)%.03)+336$#/(&(1 +.*)&"+ 9*) 9+$ &) ,# "#.#+$#/ '6"$6+%& &) &*# )"/#" /+&#/ 5!
5! )9#:#"
/6#&)+%(%+/:#"&#%&7($&+1#,0&*#+6&*)"(&(#$)- #%&"+.+(.
)(%/9+.+*(, +"%+"+% '#&(&()%#"9+$+.$)"#.#+$#/!
5!
)6%$#.-)"&*#'#&(&()%#"3)%&#%/$&*+&$6,$#=6#%&.0 )%#)- &*#+336$#/ %+7#.07"(&'+.(%2*+.(+$;+1+ *+$,##%2"+%&#/&*# 3)%3#$$()% )- (%&#"(7 "#26.+" ,+(. ,0 &*($ )6"& :(/# )"/#" /+&#/
4!
! '+$$#/(%5 4 5%%#?6"# *#"#-)"# '#&(&()%#"%##/%)&,#$#%&,#*(%/,+"$ )%3# +2+(%!(%3#*($$(7(.+".0$(&6+&#/3)+336$#/($#%<)0(%2&*#3)%3#$$()%
)-,+(.
*($'.#+-)",+(.7+0+.$),#3)%$(/#"#/!)"#):#" '#&(&()%#"($ "#+/0&)<)(%&*#(%:#$&(2+&()%+%/-6..03))'#"+&#(-'")&#/-")7+""#$& ,0&*($)6"&!*6$ 3)6%$#.'"+0$-)"2"+%&)-+%&(3('+&)"0,+(.&)&*# '#&(&()%#"(%&*#'"#$#%&3+$#!
"/#" /+&#/ 4!! 5 '+$$#/ ,0 .#+"%#/ //(&()%+.
#$$()%$6/2# 7"(&$+"
($"#'")/63#/,#.)9@ A*# "#')"& -")7 &*# +(. 6'#"(%&#%/#%&
#%&"+.+(.
)(%/9+.+*(, +"%+"+%"#3#(:#/ +$ '#" 9*(3* +"7+%<##& (%2* +.(+$ +"7+% (!#!
+''.(3+%&B+336$#/ +.)%29(&*3)+336$#/(&(19#"# .)/2#/ (% &*# +-)"#$+(/ (% #%&"+. +(. "( )(%/9+. +*(,! +&#" )% "#.#+$# )"/#" /+&#/ 5!
5 =6+ 3)+336$#/ (&(1 +.*)&"+ 9+$ "#3#(:#/-")7&*#)6"&)-8"!"+,*<)&;+6"
.#+"%#/ 7"(&$+"
:(/# .#&&#" ,#+"(%2 )!4 /+&#/ 5!
5! 6& 9*(.# "#.#+$(%2 3)+336$#/ (&(1 +.*)&"+ +"7+%9+$+.$) "#.#+$#/-")7&*#<+(./6#&)%#2.(2#%3#)-&*#<+(. )--(3(+.B #+/ >+"/#" +<#$* ;67+"
)!C! '"#.(7(%+"0 (%=6("0 9+$ 2)& 3)%/63&#/ -")7 +"'(%/#"(%2* 8#'6&06'#"(%&#%/#%& #%&"+.+(.
"()(%/9+.+*(, 9*#"#(% (&($$&+&#/&*+& #+/ >+"/#"B>+""+%& --(3#" +<#$* ;67+" 3)6./ %)& '")'#".06%/#"$&+%/&*#"#.#+$#)"/#")-+336$#/(&(1 +.*)&"+ +%/ )6& )- (%+/:#"&#%3# *# "#.#+$#/ &*#
+"7+%+.)%29(&*3)+336$#/ (&(1 +.*)&"+! .)%29(&* #+/ >+"/#" +<#$* ;67+"
&*#9+""+%&)--(3#"+"+,<(&(%2* $$($&+%& 6'#"(%&#%/#%& #%&"+.+(.
"()(%/9+.+*(, ($ +.$)"#$')%$(,.#+$&*#)"/#")-"#.#+$#)-+336$#/ (&(1 +.*)&"+ 9+$ +.$) '6& 6' ,#-)"# *(7! & ($ -6"&*#"$6,7(&&#/&*+&.#&&#"*+$+."#+/0,##%9"(&&#% &)//(&()%+.8("#3&)"#%#"+.)-).(3#+(. 6%<+,
*+%/(2+"* &)(%(&(+&#&*# /($3('.(%+"0'")3##/(%2$ +2+(%$&&*#$#<+(.)--(3(+.$!.)%29(&*&*#"#')"&)- 6'#"(%&#%/#%& &*#+-)"#$+(/.#&&#"+$9#..+$&*#3)'0 )-"#')"&)-'"#.(7(%+"0(%=6("0+"#+.$)+&&+3*#/! )(%&*#$#3("367$&+%3#$ (&($#:(/#%&&*+&&*#
+"7+%*+$%)&,##%"#.#+$#/ -")7&*#<+(.+$'#")"/#")-+%0)6"& "+&*#"*#*+$ ,##%"#.#+$#/+.)%29(&*3)+336$#/(&(1+.*)&"+ /6#&)&*#%#2.(2#%3#)-&*#<+(.)--(3(+.$+$$6,7(&&#/
(%&*#"#')"&)-&*#+(.6'#"(%&#%/#%&!*#"#-)"#
+"7+%<##& (%2* +.(+$ +"7+% 3+%%)& $##1 &*# 3)%3#$$()% )- +%&(3('+&)"0 ,+(. ,0 9+0 )- '"#$#%& +''.(3+&()% )%3#*#*+$,##%+""#$&#/+%/.)/2#/(% &*#<+(.
,6&3+7#)6&)-<+(./6#&)$#"()6$.+'$#$)% &*#'+"&)-&*#<+(.)--(3(+.$!*#'")'#"3)6"$#-)"
+"7+%($&)$6""#%/#",#-)"# &*#)6"&3)%3#"%#/+%/&*#"#+-&#"
&)$##1"#26.+"
,+(.!33)"/(%2.0 &*#'"#$#%&+''.(3+&()%($%)&.#2+..0 7+(%&+(%+,.# +%/ ($ *#"#,0 /($7($$#/! +'#"$ ,# 3)%$(2%#/&)&*##3)"/))7!D C!
*($)6"&*+$*#+"/&*#$6,7($$()%$+/:+%3#/,03)6%$#. -)"&*#'+"&(#$+%/'#"6$#/&*#"#3)"/+:+(.+,.#,#-)"#(& +%/-(%/$%) 7#"(&(%&*#3)%&#%&()%$"+($#/,0&*#'#&(&()%#" +$*#+''#+"$&)$##1&*# 3)%3#$$()%)-+%&(3('+&)"0,+(.(%)"/#"&)'#"'#&6+&#&*#(%+/:#"&#%& 7($&+1#)-&*#<+(.+6&*)"(&(#$!
)"#):#"
'"#$#%& '#&(&()% -)" +%&(3('+&)"0 ,+(. ($ %)& 7+(%&+(%+,.# +$ &*# '#&(&()%#"
*+:(%2 +."#+/0 ,##% +""#$&#/ (% &*# '"#$#%&3+$# +%/($(%3)%-(%#7#%&! 4!
*#"#-)"# &*($ )6"& /##7$ (& +''")'"(+&# &) /("#3& &*# '#&(&()%#"&)$6""#%/#",#-)"#&*#3)%3#"%#/<+(.+6&*)"(&(#$)"&*#&"(+. 3)6"&#?'#/(&()6$.0 '"#-#"+,.09(&*(%+'#"()/)-&*"##/+0$!
33)"/(%2.0 (%:(#9)-&*#/("#3&()%'+$$#/*#"#+,):#
'"#$#%&'#&(&()%$&+%/$/($')$#/)-!
!
!
!
8 +:($*+ >*#&*#"$'#+1(%2B"#+$)%#/
#$B) >*#&*#""#')"&+,.#
#$B)