Punjab State Power Corporation Ltd. v. M/S Sangrur Industrial Corporation Ltd. And Another
!"#" $%&'&
($) *+
, - -. -
" $/ 0
1#+ $2-(-$0(# -"
3 -. -
" $/ 0&$- % 4/ & + + + 4/ & +++ ++5&
!
"
#$#%%#%&
!' (
) " "
*++
*
, - ! ./ 0* &$$1 !' *2 " - %3#4%#&5 !' 6 * * " ! +
!
*2
+' "
+
-
-
+' -
!-
+ *
. * "
+ " "'+
+
"
'
- ! "
!- 7
!"# !
$ # % ! # &! & ! !"
!$' (!! " )! *+ *! , $& $- !
. !& )!! &$ "! !
./ ! !".0"
1# !& !& # ! #! 2'% ! # "! !"#8 "'+
-
+
9&&$&49&&$45'+- !+ - /5'
9&&4$#9&&$%3'+ - !+!'*2- .#' ! "
-
+ '+
*2- ! +&##:'+ - /5'
.#'
' -
+ ! 9- '+- +- .#;/5'
+' + - *2 !'
" ' '+- !-- 6 *2 + * + +' ;
+ +'
"' + !
+
6 * * " < * = "
- " + *2 >
?
> + 9&&$4#;@.43#;?
54$$%41; ! 9&&$&4;@.44&;?
%%.#/4;
9&&$%3;@.434;?
/%341#5; 9&&$45;@.4$3;?
$3/34; 7
+
;*+ +'
' '+- +* + +'
'+
'+- ' -
++ "'
+ ' + ;* +*+' ! "
%<&=<= - -
' + - +
' 3 + +' 8 +-
!' " " '
' ! * "
+* +*6 *
+ "
+ + "- %$#4%#&5 - -!'9 "*
+ - "$ $:#&"$ ;
;$5 ":"357< 6
+-
' + +'- ! ' "
, - ( ,
!A - * - "
&4</= ( +- !- + - !
! + -
-!"
'
! "
"
&1;&%;#33%/&&%&$45-
* + +' , 6 ' +'- + "
+ - '
"'-
&13&%55.; .#/%#&5 "-
+ ! <.B3%5:C%&35:= - +' - &5%#&5 D -
< ""
!' - *2 ./ + " " - - + ! +
!' + " "+#$#%%#%& = * *2 ' - + "
! -
+ +
(+ %##1 ,
"
;
+
+; +
%<=304 %##1 * *2
* + +' ( * + +' '
+ ' - +'-
' 304
! ' !'*
!-
!
"
+ !
!
!' +
+'
!+ !'*2!
!- +
"
E, +!
!
" !'+ " - " " ! ' , +
+ +'- - + ! - & % '
"- " !" ?9 &&$&4! 5.35.$.#.%#&% +- %3:!
- "'! %45#: 6 F * + " 7 E "
- ! B+ ./ * - 767& ..3"!
" $ - #
"$2 #"0 -*"
- 3 , -0 34 ( +"! .! )&+#$.#& $ .$ !! !" !& )& ! &)! . !354& . !34 354
.! )&#$. !&.$( $! 34 $#0!" !! ! 3!4 $) & #! !$+ 3!!4 .!!"#! !& & ) )! ! ./&!+!
!"$!&!! + & )!#.!"!6 3!!!4 $#0!" !!) "!
! !#.! .! &!" ) )! .
!
6 3!
4 .! )& & )! &!
# &.$
!")!!# .#! !
.!!+!! &! ! # .$& .#! !.!!7
!&&+!&! ! # .#!&.!! . &# .#!&+ $ .! )& )! ! &! ! #
.#!&.!!#$. !&6 4 # !!.! !.
.!
& ) !&)!"# ! + "#) ! !)! ! ! ! #)! ! &"+! !" "#+) !&)!! 63.4 ( !& 3!4 ./#&!
! .
#.$.!! & )!#.!"! + 3!!4 .! )&! ! !)! .
! !$8&! )
!&$& .+!! !!& )&! ! !)! .
! !$8&!+ $ !+ 3!4 #0!")&) !& &&.$ & !) ! ! ! !91 !:6 3!!4 ! ! ! ! )! &# !$ 8&! )6 3!!!4 !! ! !)!# . !! # !$ / !
!& & .+ )! !)! &# !$ 8&! )
!
!)#! &!
5
.! )&! !" .!! !! ##! .!! +#$ . !&.$ +!( !& )&! !!&.$ !
" !$ !")&7
!&&)&
. !&# $ " & !! ) .$ !! !& ' B+ + - -
! <%= ./ - !
'"
+
!
<=<!=
!
<%= "
! % ./
, *2 - + ' - " + "
,
" - -
!'
- 35 4&
&$$1 - - !
+ '
8 +
*2 ! + +
'
( %##1 -
"
+ + ;
+' +
+' - + , + " ( %##1 ;
+ +' "
"
"
>&1;&%;#33%/
! +,G - &4</= *
' < * "
+ ;
+'
'+ - -
+ " ''+,- "
! '
!'* !',(
= F !' * "
+ +'
'+- -
+ " ''+
- -!'9H!B*
1# (-* $!;
*3 # $0 $0(!
-# :
/ 0&:#&## 9+
3 !
-"!"
> -0 $0
$ ;
-+78+'!+- ! !$# ! !
&.$
! & + ! ! & !
!# $! & ! ! , & & $#.""!
!+ !! # $ "&!
! $ ! $& $& $# F +
! " !'*2 '
' ( +! " !
' + &1 ( ,- ! " - !'
9I! B *
+
) # ;
$ :#& (-"
99($"!
" $ 9.
$>/ 0 $0 $ ;
-==78+7<':"? :"?
;
#! .
"$
- - $!
*> (- #($0 -# !
" $67 ;
-*"
-
" $ !
7! *!$ & / ! ! .!!+
& ! !&!! !
$)! !$!&!"
!&)# #.$ .!! +&!" & &!" + *! )+)!.*! &.$
( !&!"+! ! &#.!
"!")&
& .!! 8% ! )! & .!
! &.!#
!+!!
" )&" & !
!) )! !.
!! ! #&+#! &+&! !)
& . 0 & .! !
& !& & # & #! &+!! !
+)&! !.
. 0&)! !)/ &!! &! !&!. && # !$ !# & # &#! &+!&!"#&.$
.!#$. &. & ) ##!& .$ .! .$ ! & ! #! & )!"!)! )&8 + - !
& &+;
;5+;
- #+ !@- @ -# / 06A -#(#&&&+ !(-"
"
# /"9"
0 7 ":"356=5+(.- (- $0"
" $ 3 "2;, ># ( ; -"
> $0"
:#& $
" $ $0"
/ ''+!
''7 - !
- !
!'
"
" - ! "' "
+ ./<%= 0* &$$1 , * - +
!+
+ ( >
+ ./<%=%
! !+ -
" - " " - "- " !' "
- " !- " ?9
&&$&4A ! 5.35.$
" - %3:
+ !
!' !
" ! "%3:, !
'
!-A
!
+ - -
- !'* - ! "'!
-
+ ' + " '+ , "
!+ !' * + +'-
!' ! !'*2-
- * + +' -
+ "! !'*2
- ,(
' - -
6 , - +
- !'9H!HB*
- + +
++ + + >5 '
"#$ #$%&$'
()%$& $* +$&),
"#$ #$%%$ % -$ +$&),