High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/1916/2003allowed

Gur Harjinder Singh v. State Of Pb.

2018-07-05Lok Adalat Bench - 217 pages

!"#$!%&'&"()*+,+- .//0&($!/&(12 3+44!55( 6!/'.'

!"# .(07 3+ !'4"($!( ) 89

+ ++

!"##$$ %"& &'"& "( ) (*+ ,,,, ++ :+ -"&##$"+#! '&"*( '.!

& & ! /

# +0"(!

&&$&1( ' " .& 2"& "

( )(3*& &'"2 & !$$2

($!/!% &"( !( !(%!;/$!$

/ 4 &'(&.#&.!0 #0 !&!

5 & !($"!

!(" ( '&'(&.#&.!2." 6" " (

.$0 7& &'"

.&#$&'"8+" 9&'"8!" (*&9(8."

:& 9( *&9(8&&$2!)(3*& &'"

" + ;(& !" "'!. '&".

-" ( & )( 3*& &'"

2" & ##$$ +! "& ( #0 " " ##$ + #

" &.#(' *( '.! & & ! +&

"+ ;(& !" "'!. '&"&. &!$0

"# (&0&"" &.&$ . "&0&"& 2&.&+0 .#$&&'" !-*&'"

& ! ( $ $& &1 &$)((

' +( 0 '& ($(&+0 & 2"&"&. . "#$& <

""& ('":& *&9( 2.& 2&")(3*& &'"+(0#&"& &

#&%"$&'&(& "&."" '& 20#"& !& &$#&& "$& !." 0+'&&':& *& 9(2+&'" +0:& 9(2&!!=$2& &'"8 "(+ > $ +"> 2&! 7& &'" 8

"(+ $ +" *& 9( 2&! ! 7& &'"

.&#$&'"8 "(+ >0('+"+& (*& 9(."&$2?""2" ( +0".! +&'&'$ 20?""02 . &' !.".+(" 2&#&&." . ?" " +'& & 20

" .#$&!(" ""& ('" :& *&9(" +&!.&'"&. "&2&!9($2& 9( ' &'".$.+0"&&$2!+&'&' &

20?"" "&2&!" #$ 2&"" ( +("0 .& . #& &"&.$. (&'!

:& *&9(!+&'&'$ 20?" <

+(@

.&".&'

)(3*& &'". $#"& $$"&.

!. &$$'9"#9"&&'":& *&9(2.&&'& $&'" ( "

" .#$& "&2&!$'2&"2&!>+" 9&$&'"

& !A 2"" .".

&$$'9"#9"&?""0+ " + 0!:& *& 9(2!$&'&# !" &$$'""(!9 &'"?"" .#$&" $!"&2&!" + 0 2 # &'#$& &#"."2 "20 "(&'!".$$

" . "#$& " +0 453(%"2& &'" "&!! "4 &'&'

!!& 54 '"&. -"4 &'&'!!& ## "& .+$2( ". (;" $& &""" .& "+&!2"& "!.$B4 2'& -"! " #$& #0 .#& +0 " .#$& 2 " #$ ! ( & ( # &# &-"4 &'&'!!& ## ('"&#$!" "(! ( "# -" + 0!:& *&9( 2"& "

2 !$&' & " # 2 % ( -" 4 &'&' !!& ## &;(#2&"' &-" + 0!:& *& 9( 2 & &!& +0 &'" " &'" -" 4 &'&'!!& " #( 3=".#$ +$ $% &'"%" + 0!:& *&9(& &$3#&$!" #(#!'&'"#.. ( " ""#$& !!& &$'" !($ "! + 0!:& *&9( 2 " " .#$& &'"

!" ! "

2" $"!" " "#$&

/ !!& &$ +0 " ! #.. C.&& " + # ( +0".+!"4 &'&'!!& 2"& "2% &#&+0"4 &'&'!!& -"4 &'&'!!& " " .!2&=(&'"#&# & "4 &'&'!!& " (.. *9(. "'#" "#$ !& & "%#"'#"!"!$&' + 0 !" + 02%(!"# &2'&'##

!.""'#"(+;($0 ""'#"" "#"'#"$'2&""'& "4 &'&'!!& =(&'"& &'&'!" & !" 2 "!!& !".& $DC.& &$"('"+$ $% &'" <

&$! $#"!.2 &

" #& 2 !( & " =(&' " ( ! & &'& " .#$& &'" . (##$.0 .+!"4 &'&'!!& /

"!! " )(3*& &'"!9&'"

"(+ !:& *&9( 9&'"!-*&'"

!"&$2!:& *&9("

$+"&'" 2#&+$!" "-" (

2 &"& -" 20& $2 !." "(!" (

2"& "2%&#$& #& ! .#$& ! & &'& " !.$&&

"$$'&" ( 2## !&$ &"(!

&&$"&!1( & &$'& .& #& ! "$$ & " ( ! $

&&$"&!1( & &$'& .& "(##$& #&!

(.$& (#&" "$$" ( !!

E # ( &

@-"!& &'""!! ( &

/ 4&C $(& $0&+$+0(!& $

&&$ "&! 1( & &$ '& .&

..& " "(!$ &1( '

.&!.2"&2( "(!$

&&$ &1( ' .& &#! &"( $

&&$& 1( ' .& + &'"#&.! & "'!!! ( &

/ 42 & $ '&$$" (

"02 "'" &'$0-" ( #$ '(&$0 $&.

&$ =(&'" (!& "# (&C.&

.0 2&# &$+$2 6 +$ $% &'"

2" <

2"&$ # $& &"""" %$ # $ &&'

& !" '& "&.+03(%"9(.!%&'

& " !!& ! ".& $ DC.& &$ #&&' & "

# &"' &'" (&'"#& "# $.&

& "& ( 0 &" " .# 2&" " . " $$2

0+ 0$ 6 &'"8 .#$& !"!" 6 9($2& 9( ." ! " # & 2&""# (&0 6 =)(.*& & F ( B& & &

& $$$' .&# ". & $ &'"

2"&$ # F ( & B& & &

-C& $'0 =#. & $ $$' .& " $' 2&"

=)( "." ( #..C.&&"

+ 0!:& *&9(2&!!)(3*& &'"

/ E0!.$

& ! &$$'9"#9"& "" + 0" + +('"+03 $%&'" +$=".$ 2"&2 &!& +0.&'" "&'"3# #0!"# ..#&'""2.%!C$&*(0"

+ 0 !" & &$&"#..

#DC "" ! "&#&&' &' (! "&$$ " &#!#!.".& $DC.&3 "# # & !.".& $DC.& #&2!( &" !!(# $! & !" "3#&

":& *&9(" & ($!#"0C& 2"& "2 (

+0 2&' "!2.&(" $# +2 2&'

" !("#..2 ( 2&"& /"( !." " 6/ $%&'" ""%26&'"

2" ('":& *&9(2.& 2&")(3*& &'"

" &'" " '& (!!& & 20 " &. !

.&'? " @5 <

:& *& 9( " & & &$$' 9"# 9"&? " . 2 # " #$& (&'

& &'& "*& "#$& 0#0" +0+*&&'"'&'

" "( ! ( 20 & $ 2 & "& # 2"& "2&G +0"#$& !!& 0..

+0"&. "&2& &'"

."&'"

+$'&'"

@ 6E*9(. "'#" # ' &'%&'!

#"'#"!" + 0"#$ ! ( 6@(%"2& &'"

(+4# 2""

& (& &'&!"& &&&$$0 .*C

# &"' .! ( 2 ( &

&2"& "$$"& &.&&' & (. ##&''& ".2#(".+("0 & "$$'& &'" "0& " +!$$0& $ &"& B(" ( )(3*& &'" 9&'"

%(#"#$" . ! 202 . B(" ( 7& &'" .&#$&'"% (#"#$""0" +!$$0& $ +&'..+!" !.&$0 B(" ( :& 9( (*&9( *&9( %(#"#$" . ! 202 & :& *& 9(2 .$ ( !+&'&'& ;( 20 4 ! " ( C.& .0 "2&# &$+$2 =6 2 9(. = $#. '&

"0 0 ). "0 &$$'9"#9"&" +('" # &'+%!"). "0!" &$$'!.!. # " # ( ". =6 $+&&'"

.+ "0!). "0

&$$'9"#9"&& "0< ""%2" ( +&' &$$' !& "($&&+2"&"(

< "! ( )&'!("" " ( )(3*& &'"" #& !." ( ?"&E .&#$ &'"

7& &'"

9 &'" )( 3*& &'" "

#&& "&$ 2&""& &! &$$' "0&"& # "&. 2&&'2 &"# &'+% !" &$$' "03# "2&&' E@E+&'

"&&'(&"# &'+%# ( +0=629(. 2$$ $"## &'& #0DC=D =6 =2& &'" 2'$0 (.+ =6 """ !.=7$$' 1$ " " +2%&' & $!!& : #:(&'3. """ & " 0 E 3 " " " +('" " '& .&& &"&"#&$" &'&2&"' .&&!

#& #'&+('"+0"&.

:& *&9( 2&!!)(3*& &'"

& ! &$$'9"#9"&2 .& & "& "#&$ 2&" "&0! #& "0& $ +" &( ($&?"".& "#&$&G &$$@

""2 & "' !" &' 3 "" " :& *&9( (&'"!& #& 3# " 0&"'&2&"' .&&!:& *&9( DC= 6&"" ! ! ( 2 $ !"&''(. $ &$( &

( )(3*& &'".& + 2"& "$! "&.''& ""!&$ "###$ 6" ( 7& &'"

.&#$ &'" 8

+" 9&'"8!" (*&9(8." :& 9(

*&9(8&&$2!)(3*& &'"" + ;(& !

" "'!. '&". 4" " $ ($!"##$$8 ( & $ &

)$!"!(*+ +& '&'"('"" F ($!"##$$"'( "&"B4 ' +0" .#$& "". "###$$ "& !" 9 &'" ( " $ $$ 0 $$'&!".2&"' . ! 20!."

&2!/E 0""02. ($#&+0 .%&'(##$.0."#$& 2"& "'"2" &2 !"('"#(&';(&.% " ("& &0!( "$$'&$ $$ '&"##$$ & "& !" !(". 9 &'"

!" ! " ##$$5 & "+ ;(& +0"&$("+&!" . -" (+.&&. +0 ($!"##$$ 2""# &!& $$'&2&"' . !

20 ($0 ".2&"# "##$$5 (

"$$'&;(&'$$ %&'.&$ &$3"!(" " " ( +0 C.&&' =6 =2& &'"

2'$0(.+ =6 "# " 2 (!!&'!."0& $+" &( #& ($& ! 2"& "".& "#&$&G !" 0 ""

..& (& & +0 *(.#&' & " # "& 2

2'$0 &+$& +0"&$(2"&$ & &'" ( 6"&$ !&' " . ! " .#$& &'"

$ ($!"##$$"'( ""& #&& '# ""##$$" + (& & !:& *&9(

' " #&&!6 9($2& 9( "" . .&$&.# .!.".. "#$& ( &"2 ($0 ! 2&"" ( ".( "

$& +#$ (#"&.0 &'"$

($!"##$$ "# (&"!&$ # & "' '&"##$$5 ( +0 " 2!+$ (+

0&' &!"!! ( &

/ 42 !($!&$$ +( #&""&$(2'$0 &

"##$$5 ( 3#0""##$+ # " ##$$5 ( + ;(& !" "'!. '&"&. " " "

$ ($ 2"&$ ($0

! &' " *( '. # +0 " &$ ( !(&' " (+.&& #( !2 +0 $ ($ ! " ##$$ " ""# (&" ( !($$0+('"".'(&$" ##$$5 ( ! " !! ( &

/ 4 +0 +&'&' ' & &'

$&+$ ($2$$ (.0 -"*( '.# +0"(+$2 (!!!.

0&$$'$&0 &!&.&0 ( "

&"($ +(#"$ "##$ +&'2&"(.&"($ + &.& 4"& "##$$"+ & !"!! ( &

/ 4& 20 "-" 0&' &!

"!! (

! !" #"$ % &

' !

( $

!" ! " % ! $ % ) "

"$ % "

$ 4! &2 & C ! " # " !& 2 &' & !&&$0"& :& *&9( " &

(($ "+020! 2&'2&"& 0!" .&' 32 " .&&' &' & &$0 +$&" -"&"&'!&$"2"" 2 (+* ($0 ". +0 " ##$$5 (

"## +""(+ 0!"&$& "& & 2&" . ! 20+!" ".!! &" . ' +0 .#$& &'"

!" ! "

2&""#$& <

"" . "##$$ ($#&42$0!+(/E 0""&& " ' "& (##$.0 . 2&" " #$& .&' " ##$$ ( "&!"+&'$#&+$! "!"&

('"3&"+& " &+&$&0!#.##&'

!& & &(&' '&G+$!! "#$& + ( &. & "# ( #( &!

"& & 2&""#'!&."$.!("'

&$( " ! $( &+&'& ( ! (

$&+& ($& .(+"-"! #.# $ '&'!B4& &+$4"& (C#$& $0!." / 0&.&'"##$$5 ( ($#&#(+&';(& .% &+&$&0!"# (&0+ (&!"2& $

&"& & "" .#$&2($ " . "&.$'2&"

"" ( &"&&&&$."#$& ' +0 "&. <

2"& "!. +&!'&&!"!.$B4 B(". "# (&"++$+&' '

& &' "2"0 . ! 202& +0 ##$$5 ( !. " .( " $ $$'&' " " ##$$5 ( " +(&'"&'" .#$"+&'. 20& $!."#: &$!

" 20 ($$0'& "&.!.&' " &$!$$'

. ! 20 +0 ##$$5 ( !. " " # &$!( " . " &'$$' $0+. "

&$!$$' ".(! "" !

##$$5 ( "4"20 "$$'&;(& '( !'$0#-"

( +0"# (&&" ' &+4!2" # ( +0"# (&

6&'"

.#$& !"!" " " $"('"(!!& & 20& $& $( &'" " +'& & 20+( ( 2&!& 2&"". & 2 . +0". "&&+&$&0# (

"0 .$&' (&':& *&9(-"&

$ %.&$#& ($:# &!& & !$$' . !

20" +'& .!! "& '

& &' "2"0 20" &! +'& "&.!.&'4"& C.&& 6&'"" "2"&$ &'"&.( & DC "" % "4 &'&'!!& .!)( 3*& &'" 9 &'"

2"& " ## + & &'& &"&C.&&& "&!&$! "" "" ' "& . DC 2&" 453 (%"2& &'"

"2 2 "&. "&&'(2 +& 2""##2+$% (""&"&' "2""4 &'&'!!& 2! (+$0& $&

2 " ( 2( .$&"" !# (&! 0 ($& .& 3 & + " " .#$& 2($

!&&$0" $ ' .#$&'&( "#$& !!& " "&'" ("&& +( .& $0 " -"! "& &"$"('""" . ##$$5 ( )(3*& &'" 9 &'" +( 453 (%"2& &'" & # "& . "& &'( 2 +& +$% ## ##$$'& 6 9($2& 9( "('" & " . $ $$

$$'&! . ! 20'&" ( !("

&'" "0" +.$&'" +(2" ! 2&"" &'&$.( & .!( "0#!

$$'&2!( +""2&'""" . .&$&.# .&". #(&'+&';(&.%

" &+&$&0-"# (&"C.& 0"2& &2"# " ( .&'"" & 0 . ! 20 " .$ ( " 4 +.&" "6@(%"2& &'"

4 &"& C.&&

""" .! .#$&2&"(0$&

&&"&#!2"2( +0" .#$&&.&$$0 "# .!9($2& 9( ( & &'""" ".2 "&.

+0" -"# (&"$ 0 +0C.&&'0 #$& !!& 2&"' &'!(##$.0.!

.#$&.&'##$$5 ( "&!" ($#&" 2&" ' . ! 20 ". +0 ##$$5 ( !." ""."&" " (& $$0$ %&'$$" 0&' &! &

/ 42!($!&$$ +("&$(2'$0 & " ##$$5 ( "('" ;(&&'".&&' ( ". ! &#&!."

:& *&9("

..& (& & -" ( &$;(&+&2"" ( )(3*& &'"" + "(& & !:& *&9( - .&"2" 2"+. ($$0. & @!"4 &$ $2&"+.B ! "# &&&# ( ( H @+.!"&'I#+ " &'!"&'

2"I

B&I 4&' 0 # "

E "&'?

$0ID'' 2&" . "##&0 #& 0! " &'!""&'

&! &$$'$ .&& % #$ & #(( ! " #& 0 & " &'!" "&'?

-"& $0I4&$$0& +00 &$$'$.&& " &'!""&' DC#$& I # 2"

+0 2&$!($ .&#& +02&$!($ $. ! .&$ ! 2"& " " & +(

& $ $(&$0 ( # ( .# (# ( "&'+

&& &&'" &'!" "&' 4$$(& #(+$& !!& & ("&G +0 2 !. ( !

1(& ##" J %2&'"! $"&J 2&$!($$0# "&J "+0&&$$0 ( ##" 3 ++0&&'& "##"&! DC#$& I6" &"#& "&.!" ..&&! 0"&'& ! &$&" ..&& ! " "+0 ! &$& "

..&&"!

&& & " &'!

" K -"&;(!+.&&&'& 2"& ". '

(' !2 # % & &(' (' -"$$' ( "#!"##$$5 ( &"& .2&"&".& "&!!+.-"! " +"$ '(&$0!+.!(& & !" $"('"( & !"4 &D

"&#(.#&+.!(& & +0.& 2.+( "" ( &$&' &"""(+ ( "$& !"(+

" (+* " ($0". ( & $&' #(.#& 20 " " !! " ( "

".2""& &2&" . ! 20& $$0.&&'&"& -" ( &"& ! " $

+0C.&&'=6 =2& &'" 2'$0(.+ =6 " " 2 .& & : # :(&' 3.

""" ! #& "0& $+" &(+& ($&6!"!" " .& &"& C.&&" 2"#&$&G .&"('""

"&2! 0-"&#&+&$&0!" ..&&'

(& & !"B.".!=6 $+&&'"

& +$&" ""##$$5 ( "&+"" + #&"&& -"# (&&"& " !&$ # & "' '&"##$$5 ( +0 " 2!+$ (++( "&$(+0.&##&$! .&&#&!$2

@ 2'$0 & "##$$5 ( !"& !! 4"$&'"!+ & (& "##$ # -"&.#(' *( '.! & & ! ( ##$($"!& -"##$$8 ( & ;(& !" "'!2"& """ +"$ '(&$0 &

"&.#(' *( '.-"##$$&+&$ ( ""

"&(0$ & "' !."&$&+&$&0!+&$+

(0+ : 0&&.&+";( ++

*+,+- /&0 6""#%&'5

L5:

6""#+$ L5: